HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ngneer

634 karma · joined June 8, 2015

submissionscomments
ngneer··on Intel Announces Retirement of CEO Pat Gelsinger
I see a lot more speculation on this thread than data.
ngneer··on Ryugu asteroid sample colonized by terrestrial life despite strict control
Not sure why this was downvoted. First, it could have been written tongue in cheek. Second, this is a perfectly legitimate and admissible explanation, that must be ruled out. Maybe it is very easy or trivial to rule out, as attempted in another comment, but it is important to keep all options open for scientific rigor. I believe the fact that the first scan did not reveal such life is a strong indicator that these organisms were introduced later.
ngneer··on Rapid colonization of a space-returned Ryugu sample by terrestrial microorganism
I suppose we need a one-way valve, such that information about the sample can flow to us while nothing can affect the sample. Conceptually like a Heimlich valve. Or, as a wild alternative, we could amplify the signal in some way, perhaps using sterile equipment in space, such that any Earth life would drown out in alien life and contamination would no longer pose as big an issue.
ngneer··on Rapid colonization of a space-returned Ryugu sample by terrestrial microorganism
That's really too bad. I liked the notion that RNA found on Ryugu was brought back by Hayabusa. It feels a smidge lonelier down here on planet Earth. I imagine contamination prevention protocols will be revised.
ngneer··on NASA: Mystery of Life's Handedness Deepens
This can easily be solved by calling left right and right left. Voila. Mystery solved :).
ngneer··on NASA: Mystery of Life's Handedness Deepens
Can someone please explain the big mystery in simple terms? The article sure doesn't. Why does RNA being ambi-valent deepen the mystery? As others have noted, it could have been a toss up early on that persisted. If a coin comes up heads, no one is looking to explain why the coin "favors" heads or is "predisposed" to come out heads. Neither is true. The coin just came up heads. Is the mystery why homochirality persisted?
ngneer··on Apple Confirms Zero-Day Attacks Hitting macOS Systems
I came to ask this very question. Could be an Intel hardware bug, but then we would see an advisory from Intel. So, it must be a different issue. Apple probably did not realize that their advisory implicates Intel components rather than Apple components.
ngneer··on Even Microsoft Notepad is getting AI text editing now
Well, they already lost me as a user when they transitioned to an MDI interface. My only use for notepad.exe these days is to demonstrate exploits.
ngneer··on The inventor of the automatic rice cooker
I do have both and still prefer the rice cooker for rice cooking. The lighter weight helps me move it around the kitchen as needed. I also like that it is easier to put in the dishwasher and that I never have to futz with the rubber seal or the hard to clean yet easy to lose pin and other small parts in the instant pot. It is always a chore for me to clean. The steps needed remind me of (not unhappy) times in the army having to assemble and disassemble an assault rifle.
ngneer··on The inventor of the automatic rice cooker
This reads like an ad.
ngneer··on The inventor of the automatic rice cooker
Being a single use device has its benefits. Rice cookers are lighter weight than an instant pot and have a single button, making them extremely easy to operate. I find this is very helpful to me when cooking.
ngneer··on The inventor of the automatic rice cooker
This is known as bang-bang control, a very basic form of negative feedback.

The key insight, which may not be emphasized enough in the article, is that the vessel can only rise to above 100C once all the water has changed phase (boiled).

I think this is the same principle explaining why beach popsicle vendors can carry many items on a hot summer day without them all melting right away. There is insulation, for sure, but in addition the temperature of what is effectively a large volume ice cube block must rise above 0C before the popsicles can begin to change phase (melt).

In the rice cooker, this property is harnessed while a "bimetallic switch measured the temperature in the external pot". The bimetallic component means that one metal heats and expands faster than the other, eventually breaking the circuit.

If memory serves, this same trick is used in older car model turn signal lights, to produce the periodic on/off switching.

I am not asian but enjoy my rice cooker every day. I love simple robust engineering.

ngneer··on Using Large Language Models to Catch Vulnerabilities
I agree it is a pessimistic view. I did not mean to make a disparaging comment, though. I agree that all research starts out small. And, naturally, for any influential idea, you can point back to when it was small.

I did not intend to conflate separate issues. I agree assisted coding and assisted bug hunting can coexist. I was merely trying to weigh the net effect LLMs have on security.

ngneer··on Using Large Language Models to Catch Vulnerabilities
Thanks for highlighting a key aspect.

It may be informative to see all the ways in which the LLM got it wrong along the way, before arriving at the cherrypicked example. For instance, was this the only pattern flagged as a potential bug in the process?

That said, I am surprised at how far pattern matching can get you. Certain exploitation requires arithmetic. If LLMs struggle with simple arithmetic, then it is unclear why we would expect them to do well with these. In the GPZ example, it does not appear that the assistant can do the arithmetic or realize the negative offset and its implication. Rather, it looks like pattern matching that mimics static dataflow analysis in order to arrive at the assertion failure.

"To cause the assertion failure, we need a constraint on a column with index greater than 3 or smaller than 1."

ngneer··on Using Large Language Models to Catch Vulnerabilities
Sounds like they had some fun, but what is missing from the analysis is the effort spent, or even a rough indication of said effort. The epilog lists about sixteen non-security contributors that were needed to achieve the feat, and probably many more security personnel were needed from GPZ. Yet the outcome is one bug that could have been found with manual code review or a custom fuzzer. I am not sold on the premise that LLMs can increase code security or lower costs. At the moment, LLMs are producing and introducing more insecure code than they are finding.
ngneer··on Security research on Private Cloud Compute
How is this different than a bug bounty?
ngneer··on Fearless SSH: Short-lived certificates bring Zero Trust to infrastructure
With you there. The marketing term makes Zero Sense to me.
ngneer··on Congress fights to keep AM radio in cars
Great analysis. This must be the crux of it, meaning the engineering tradeoff between good EMI mitigation and lower cost. Shielding is one way to go. I do not know the details here for cars, but in digital systems people tend to use spread spectrum clocking (SSC) to lessen the interference. Others on the thread seem to suggest the culprit is not the electronics, though, so that technique probably is not applicable.
ngneer··on Linux from Scratch
This brings back memories. I built LFS on a Pentium based machine a few times and it was quite fun. I took a similar approach to building a custom bare metal system for a client that needed extra security. I sometimes wish that there was a well maintained bare bones distribution inspired by the LFS philosophy, that might help with managing complexity on the cloud. Scanning the thread, NixOS came up. I used to love Slack, too. Any other recommendations? Something with minimal dependencies yet capable of being a LAMP-like server?
ngneer··on Chipmaker Qualcomm Is Said to Explore Takeover of Intel
Is this the same Bloomberg that alerted the world to the existence of hardware trojans in server platforms (e.g., Supermicro), only then it turned out that none of it could be evidenced? This is looking like a rumor mill...
ngneer··on How to succeed in MrBeast production (Leaked PDF)
There is a natural tension between these equally important roles, especially when folks choose to view competing objectives as a zero sum game. I think your point of view is one-sided.
ngneer··on How to succeed in MrBeast production (Leaked PDF)
I do not view these as counterpoints. You are making the same point, which is that the metric one optimizes for is extremely important. MrBeast is solely focused on maximizing revenue on the YouTube platform. The examples you cite also demonstrate the same exact metric (i.e., profit) in other domains. I know HP was in the habit of crippling its printers to extract more money, to add to your other examples.

Out of curiosity, what's wrong with Intel? Are you referring to their selling more capable parts for more money? If so, that does not strike me as a shady practice to maximize profits. More like how the best fruit goes for export, where it can fetch the most return.

ngneer··on DEF Con 32 – AMD Sinkclose Universal Ring-2 Privilege Escalation (Not Redacted) [pdf]
Likewise. Engineers do not idle well.
ngneer··on DEF Con 32 – AMD Sinkclose Universal Ring-2 Privilege Escalation (Not Redacted) [pdf]
Just terminology. Whenever a new higher-privileged entity is created, it is sometimes described as a negative ring.

There was a time when people thought if we could put the secure code in a lower ring, then with it we could protect the rest of the system. With virtualization, the hypervisor is in ring -1, which is technically not a ring, but rather a mode called VMX root operation, post-VMXON. This enables things like the blue pill attack, where the hypervisor is itself presented with a false image of the underlying physical hardware, by a malicious layer. You can find the same pattern in ARM TrustZone, where the secure code is repeatedly broken.

"if only we had ring -N"

ngneer··on Deploying Rust in existing firmware codebases
Too bad they do not go deeper into impacts on binary image size.
ngneer··on NASA is about to make its most important safety decision in nearly a generation
In God we trust. All others must bring data.
ngneer··on CrowdStrike Update: Windows Bluescreen and Boot Loops
Not remotely. I am aware of the state space explosion and the difficulty with brute forcing the testing. I am suggesting that the damage a broken antivirus update can do should be restricted.
ngneer··on CrowdStrike Update: Windows Bluescreen and Boot Loops
Allow me to give a different, information-theoretic, perspective. How much damage can flipping a single bit cause? How much damage can altering two bits cause?

The fanout is a robustness measure on systems. If we can control the fanout we increase reliability. If all it takes is a handful of bits in a 3rd party update to kill IT infrastructure, we are doing it wrong.

ngneer··on CrowdStrike Update: Windows Bluescreen and Boot Loops
This. The 1970s design of the operating system and the few companies that deliver us the monoculture are simply not adequate or robust given the world of today.
ngneer··on CrowdStrike Update: Windows Bluescreen and Boot Loops
Have we failed as an industry?
← PreviousPage 4 of 16Next →