HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nickelpro

2,445 karma · joined December 21, 2019

https://vito.nyc
submissionscomments
nickelpro··on What Luddites can teach us about resisting an automated future
Replacing manual labor with automation is good, actually. Sewing machines put the weavers out of business yes, but more people get to wear shirts. I'm pro-shirts, anti-weavers.

Preventing such replacement is definitionally anti-progress

nickelpro··on What Luddites can teach us about resisting an automated future
I can't believe this is a full-throated, illustrated, pop-culture defense of luddism. Luddism is a caricature of an ideology, a thing you throw at opponents in debate and they are forced to deny.

You're not supposed to adopt it as your real, actual ideology lol. Is this a joke?

Guess I'll need to find some clogs, sign me up General Ludd.

nickelpro··on Launch HN: SiLogy (YC W24) – Chip design and verification in the cloud
The functionality on offer here is equivalent to about 30 lines of Github Actions YAML to install verilator, run the tests, and upload the coverage information. [1]

Generating waveforms is free, Verilator already does that if you pass it the appropriate argument, either --trace or --trace-fst. We usually control that with a single CMake option.

Complex workflows can get nutty, but what's illustrated here is not a complex workflow.

[1]: https://github.com/NYU-Processor-Design/component-template/b...

nickelpro··on Launch HN: SiLogy (YC W24) – Chip design and verification in the cloud
Ya and I've seen similarly basic support in small IP houses that support Verilator alongside whichever proprietary suite the house uses.

Is there a need here? Are there IP design houses that are so bad at CI infrastructure that "we run Verilator for you" is a value add?

I don't mean to denigrate the OP, just wondering what the market is. Undergrads build this stuff and let me tell you my undergrads are not a particularly talented group.

nickelpro··on Launch HN: SiLogy (YC W24) – Chip design and verification in the cloud
This is my feeling too, it's pretty trivial to do this stuff in any CI infrastructure.

At NYU we have this entire process built into very trivial CMake and Github Actions stuff.

Here's an example: https://github.com/NYU-Processor-Design/PurdNyUart

You can see we have 100% test coverage, illustrated by CodeCov, and our CI runs the test suite on each PR. This is very normal in the software world and I guess I don't understand why the hardware world would need a specialized provider just to run Verilator for you.

nickelpro··on U.S. seeks to revive idled shipyards with help of Japan, South Korea
> Modern ships didn't pop into existence from nothing. Nothing does.

They didn't evolve from some minor capital investment. The problem is not one of ideas it is one of scale. In that sense, yes, they popped into existence from nothing.

The Panama canal is the result of centuries of technological development in the technology of canal construction generally, but fundamentally it is not the result of a startup or even a hundred startups building tiny canals until they had enough capital and expertise doing so to build a big canal.

It is a result of governments (plural, the first attempt failed), in a one-off immense expenditure of capital and manpower unable to be mustered by the entirety of the global shipping industry (for everyone with eyes and a map could see the potential), constructing something that was not there before. "From nothing".

nickelpro··on U.S. seeks to revive idled shipyards with help of Japan, South Korea
Norfolk, Portsmouth, Puget Sound, and Pearl Harbor, are the four entirely domestic military naval shipyards. Newport News, the General Dynamics yard in Groton, and Ingalls Shipbuilding are effectively domestic-military-only shipbuilders.

Some commercial shipbuilders, notably NASSCO, do business with the US Navy for smaller classes of ship as well as auxiliary vessels, and potentially could take orders from foreign militaries.

But yes, there is a massive domestic shipyard and shipbuilding industry in the US that is military-only. There are almost 300 active ships and another 170 in the reserve fleet, almost all with far more complex maintenance requirements than the typical civilian vessel.

Like many government operations, the US government doesn't try to oversee day-to-day operations, and awards those by contract. Same with the operation of national labs, for example.

nickelpro··on U.S. seeks to revive idled shipyards with help of Japan, South Korea
They are run by contractors because the US government does not have riveting or hull welding in its core competencies.

They are operated by those contractors for a profit, profiting from the US government. The US government does not choose to establish and/or invest in yards, and grant operating contracts to those contractors, for the purpose of making a profit.

The US government does so in order to have a reliable source of naval construction and repair services in case of a military conflict.

nickelpro··on U.S. seeks to revive idled shipyards with help of Japan, South Korea
> Right, but I wonder if developments in the rest of weaponry have changed the calculus around that. It's pretty likely that a fleet carrier or other purpose-built warship also has zero survivability in the face of a barrage of anti-ship cruise missiles too

This is incorrect.

> been born out by Russian experience in Ukraine

Defending your assumption with the Russian fleet is certainly a thing you are doing right now

nickelpro··on U.S. seeks to revive idled shipyards with help of Japan, South Korea
> You're putting words in my mouth because that is probably not how people would start out.

I'm making concrete your vague handwaving, feel free to provide a more complete explanation of how you think this goes.

> But the literal incorrectness of that statement is so wrong it is puzzling. The shipbuilding industry, which builds nuclear submarines, started with some extremely modest boats. The path we followed to get to where we are was precisely starting with little fishing boats and evolving to where we are now. There is obviously a path from small boats to large boats. To suggest otherwise is absurd.

No it didn't. And certainly not the military shipyards discussed in this article. While a couple (Newport News, Brooklyn Navy Yard) have origins as more modest shipbuilding sites, the vast majority were purpose-built sites for military construction built with US government dollars. Like the Manhattan Project or the Hoover Dam, there wasn't a smaller initiative that gradually developed into a massive industry. Massive industry was the go word.

These types of projects, continental railroads, interstate highways systems, and military naval shipyards, they can have private-public partnerships but they do not grow organically from more modest roots without public dollars.

> You might be about to make the argument that government funding is necessary or something, but the big problem here is unusually simple - the US is not globally competitive at manufacturing, a startup would be expected to fail if left to compete in the market and that is why nobody is going to try (or succeed).

This is irrelevant, pick your foreign military shipyard and you will find that the story is the same. Bohai, Zelenodolsk, Cherbourg, any of them. The government recognized a need for a new, larger, more powerful class of ships and either built or expanded the logistics necessary to construct the vessels.

nickelpro··on U.S. seeks to revive idled shipyards with help of Japan, South Korea
Similar ideas have been tried in the past, they always end the same way. The converted civilian ship has zero survivability and is sunk by the first passing warship to the embarrassment of all the planners involved.

Today such vessels are so susceptible to anti-ship missiles and submarines that they're laughed out of any serious military planning meeting where the participants aren't already desperate for tonnage.

nickelpro··on U.S. seeks to revive idled shipyards with help of Japan, South Korea
There's no path from point A to point B.

Building crab fishing boats doesn't have an evolution that leads to building nuclear submarines anymore than manufacturing charm bracelets or ready-to-eat delivery meals. The requisite materials, logistics, and labor expertise are effectively unrelated to one another and separated by mountains in terms of capital and material resources.

As was said before, the only way in is basically to buy into an existing operation, at which point where you got the money from originally is irrelevant.

nickelpro··on U.S. seeks to revive idled shipyards with help of Japan, South Korea
These are military shipyards, their establishment is not primarily profit-motivated
nickelpro··on U.S. seeks to revive idled shipyards with help of Japan, South Korea
There's no such thing as a blue water autonomous torpedo, there will always need to be a human-occupied platform to project power and manage military naval operations from.

This is without getting into the obvious problems of "lol how do you plan to control your USV? Pacific ocean spanning tether?"

As long as there are blue water navies, there will be military shipyards servicing them.

nickelpro··on Life Aboard a Nuclear Submarine
These articles come up every so often and they're always a little strange as a former submariner.

Firstly, they're always aboard US boomers, which are immensely spacious by submarine standards (lol'd at "The ship seemed cramped, with narrow passageways."). You can walk two-abreast in some US boomer passageways, a completely unheard of feat on any other class of sub. They also have relatively relaxed, predictable schedules, with deployments rarely lasting more than 3 months. It's easy to say you've got good food when you're not rationing beans because the 4 month deployment became a 5 1/2 month deployment.

Secondly, one of the core social divides in the US submarine force is between members of the engineering department ("nukes", also A-gangers, though they exist in a sort of limbo) and everyone else on the boat ("coners"). These pieces only ever interview and report on coners (not in small part due to the intense security concerns surrounding nuclear propulsion technology). The lives of the submariners on either side of the watertight door are different in many significant respects, there's no nuke in the fleet that appreciates being represented in the public eye by sonar techs and torpedomen, but nukes only get talked about when they're killing themselves [1].

This is the nature of the secrecy surrounding US subs of course, and I'm not complaining, but it's weird. These articles show the best possible life aboard a US submarine, likely the best possible life aboard any submarine. It's the US Navy putting its best foot forward for the benefit of reporters. Note they talk about the integration of US boomers, but don't mention that US fast attacks remain male-only with no plans to change in the near future. It is, without attaching any sentiment to the word positive or negative, propaganda.

[1]: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/nuclear-trained-sailors...

nickelpro··on Microsoft is driving users away
What stranglehold do you imagine MS had in 1980, prior to shipping a single DOS install?

Android Linux and iOS are what killed MS's stranglehold on consumer electronics. GNU is a footnote in the history of MS's rise and fall in the space.

nickelpro··on Microsoft is driving users away
> I think you're overestimating the importance of the revenue generated

It is literally impossible to do this. Revenue is the only thing that matters when measuring markets. If it doesn't affect the bottom line, it does not matter.

Passion does not sell OEM installs or license keys. Creators and hackers didn't buy MS products in appreciable numbers to begin with (compared to consumer and enterprise markets), so to the degree MS can be said to be losing them, MS does not care. If moms and humanities majors stopped buying laptops entirely and that $750M/Q dropped to the ~$1M/Q the power users drive, MS would probably pull out of the OEM license market.

This is a very different mindset about how businesses operate than you seem to share, which is fine, I'm explaining it not trying to convert you to it.

nickelpro··on Microsoft is driving users away
You haven't worked in IT with "truly" non-technical people if you're asking this question (yes, No True Scotsman fallacy, I know).

They never opened such panels, they don't read error messages, they just say "the printer doesn't work". If the "Add Printer" button doesn't work it's all over for them. The only thing you can do is make the "Add Printer" button as good as possible.

The least common denominator is so much lower than you think it is. It's why Jobs and Timmy Apple worked so hard to eliminate the concept of the "file system" and make everything built around the concept of the "app". These abstractions that seem intuitive to power users and technical people are nonsense to the much larger market of push-button users, and that's where all the money is outside B2B enterprise.

nickelpro··on Microsoft is driving users away
As explained above this is irrelevant to enterprise users, corpo installs don't play with per-station configuration like this or care about consumer-facing UIs, the needs of that market revolve around things like image management, deployment, and active directory administration.

You're right that the home market is shrinking though, the OEM install market is down billions in revenue and has been dropping by double digit percentages each fiscal year, but you're wrong in your assumption that the power user market is worth anything. Power users, represented by direct license installs, are a rounding error of Windows revenue. There's nothing worth fighting for there.

Convincing Mom that she should buy a Windows laptop instead of an Apple laptop is still worth ~$750M/Q, and Mom doesn't ever want to see the old Windows panels, she loves the "Add Printer" button. Convincing Timmy Q Hacker that he should buy a Windows license key instead of installing Arch Linux is worth squat.

nickelpro··on Microsoft is driving users away
You're a power user unable to understand the needs of non-power users.

We all go through that stage, it's natural.

I once installed Linux on all my siblings' desktops because I had convinced my parents it would lead to "less viruses" (Fedora 13, I think, GNOME 2, those were the days). The nightmare of providing support for that over the rest of my high school years provided me with a powerful and important lesson.

You have few reasons to stick with Windows, you are a very, very tiny droplet in an ocean of users with different needs than you. Judging what such markets will do based on your personal needs is unwise.

nickelpro··on Microsoft is driving users away
I did enterprise administration of Windows boxes, ~400 seats.

We did not manually muck with control panels per station. I could not care less what the settings UIs for home installs of Windows are.

And that's the real truth, power users and these small fry IT install bases are not major markets. The most prominent markets are OEM installs for non-technical home users (who hate complex panels and love the push-button UIs), and large 3/4/5 digit enterprise installs that do not give a damn about this stuff because they're using MDT (or whatever) to deploy images to all their stations and not playing with this per-station configuration stuff.

nickelpro··on Microsoft is driving users away
The article doesn't specify what the issue was, neither you or I can say what the best way to fix the problem would be, if it required something specific of the old panel unable to be accessed via more appropriate or modern tooling.

I suspect this is on purpose.

nickelpro··on Microsoft is driving users away
This is basically an article by a guy angry that the UI for printers changed and predicting the end of the Windows empire based on that.
nickelpro··on The Average New Yorker Spends $10,454 in Upfront Costs for a Rental
Ya that's a silly explanation, the only relevant point is this:

The price charged by brokers to landlords is less than the perceived value of the labor required for the landlord to list the property, receive calls from interested renters, and show the property.

This isn't surprising because brokers charge next to nothing to the landlords because they make their money on the fees from renters.

Renters are forced to abide this situation because of the aforementioned mismatch in supply and demand.

Why does this market crop up in some cities but not others? It's hard to say, some claim it's rent control but buildings without rent control still have exorbitant broker's fees in NYC. However, this is hardly the only market niche that is cultural rather than dictated purely by market forces. Americans don't buy bidets, the Japanese still frequently prefer cash transactions to electronic payment, and San Franciscans don't charge brokers fees.

nickelpro··on Think Python, 3rd Edition
I mean, the docs? And the source code?

At a certain point of expertise, everything after basic journeyman familiarity, there's nothing left but to read code and write code.

nickelpro··on Cool URIs can be ugly (2023)
Nope, unless you're bankrupt you're supposed to host forever:

> Pretty much the only good reason for a document to disappear from the Web is that the company which owned the domain name went out of business or can no longer afford to keep the server running.

nickelpro··on Cool URIs can be ugly (2023)
Nah, it craps all over site operators for their lack of "forethought".

Oh, you didn't perfectly lay out your URIs in the initial design? Too bad, you're saddled with the unending burden of maintaining redirects forever or you're not "cool". Should have known the company was going to move to Markdown static site generation five years before Markdown was invented.

Miss me with that shit. Link rot is the burden of the link author, not the target.

nickelpro··on Cool URIs can be ugly (2023)
"Cool URIs Don't Change" was always such a pretentious page to begin with.

No, just because I hosted something for awhile does not mean I am obligated to host that resource in the exact same way for eternity. There is no contract, implicit, social, or otherwise that I will continue to provide that free thing for you in a way that is convenient to you personally in perpetuity.

nickelpro··on Vcc – The Vulkan Clang Compiler
LLVM is a library for building compilers, GCC is not.

It's pretty much that simple.

nickelpro··on The Crypt of Civilization (2006)
An equivalent period of time in the past would pre-date decipherable writing, possibly the invention of writing altogether.

In other words, this is silly. Might as well throw away the key and just say "never open it", the effect would be the same. Such an insane period of time is isomorphic to making the thing a tomb or an archaeological site.

← PreviousPage 8 of 21Next →