HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nimonian

332 karma · joined October 9, 2018

submissionscomments
nimonian··on Malus – Clean Room as a Service
I consider this a form of performance art. To really expose the absurdity of the system, you can't just point at the cracks; you need to actually stick your fingers in.
nimonian··on LLM Writing Tropes.md
I completely agree. This is a good list, but a poor prompt.

Also, I sometimes find a sort of Streisand effect: when you tell the LLM to avoid something is starts doing it more. Like, if you say "don't use delve" it contains the words "use delve" which, amongst a larger context, seems to get picked up.

I have more success telling the LLM to write in the style of a particular author I like. It seems to activate different linguistic patterns and feel less generic.

Then, I make an "editor agent" comb through, looking for tropes and rewording them. Their sole focus is eliminating the tropes, which seems to work better.

nimonian··on “It turns out” (2010)
I hope the irony of this comment isn't lost on the author of the article
nimonian··on My spicy take on vibe coding for PMs
This seems crazy to me. I am a PM and I am busier than ever. People are waking up to the idea that code is cheap and things can change faster now, so deciding _what_ to make and prioritise in the deluge of ideas coming to prod is becoming completely essential.

One thing LLMs don't have is taste. That's on me.

nimonian··on How to talk to anyone and why you should
> I asked his thoughts on the matter because I assumed

Kindly, I think this is where you went wrong

nimonian··on I am directing the Department of War to designate Anthropic a supply-chain risk
I've been on hn for years and I see this kind of sentiment raised all the time. It is not my understanding of the guidelines.

Politics and ideology are not off topic, provided the subject matter is of interest, or "gratifying", to colleagues in the tech/start-up space.

What's important is that we don't use rhetoric, bad faith or argumentation to force our views on others. But expressing our opinions about how policy affects technology and vice versa has always been welcome, in my observation.

So, what do you think about the US government's decision, and why?

nimonian··on Layoffs at Block
> 40%

More to your point, to get from 6,000 back up to 10,000 requires a 67% increase in productivity on the remaining 6,000!

nimonian··on Google API keys weren't secrets, but then Gemini changed the rules
I completely agree with you. There's something conspicuous about this particular use of the "group of three" device. It's trying but it's goofy and conspicuous. I think it's not human, it's 52 trillion parameters in a trenchcoat.
nimonian··on Fastest Front End Tooling for Humans and AI
I really liked biome but it kept murdering my .vue files
nimonian··on Claude Sonnet 4.6
Moore's law lives on!
nimonian··on SkillsBench: Benchmarking how well agent skills work across diverse tasks
It's like those sequences of images where we ask the LLM to reproduce the same image exactly, and we just get some kind of grotesque collapse after a few dozen iterations. The same happens with text and code. I call this "semantic collapse".

I conjecture that after some years of LLMs reading a SharePoint site, producing summaries, then summaries of those summaries, etc... We will end up with a grotesque slurry.

At some point, fresh human input is needed to inject something meaningful into the process.

nimonian··on Show HN: Maths, CS and AI Compendium
Hey I wouldn't argue with this guy maybe he has a degree in Physic
nimonian··on Show HN: Maths, CS and AI Compendium
For speakers of the King's English, we wouldn't say "econ 101" either. We would say economics.

101 is an interesting number! Winston was taken there in 1984 by a fascist group whose tactics included the rigorous standardisation and abolition of all variation and redundancy in the English language. Nice.

nimonian··on Show HN: Data Engineering Book – An open source, community-driven guide
I think it was. It's a wall of information, lots of summary tables, fake warmth, and has that LLM smell to it. I'd be very surprised if this wasn't generated text.

Whether it's GPT or not, it needs rewriting.

nimonian··on GPT-5 outperforms federal judges in legal reasoning experiment
They have no evidence of such contamination, not evidence of no such contamination
nimonian··on I started programming when I was 7. I'm 50 now and the thing I loved has changed
> this post could have been written by me (if I could write)

This post was written by AI

nimonian··on Learning from context is harder than we thought
Wittgenstein famously said "The limits of my language mean the limits of my world."

Alan Watts suggests people like Wittgenstein should occasionally try to let go of this way of thinking. Apologies if it is sentimental but I hope you'll give him a chance, it's quite short: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=heksROdDgEk

In reflection of all of this, I think that the quote you're responding to only meant to say that experiencing the world through language means building an abstraction over its richness. (I somewhat agree with you, though, that the quote seems a little dramatic. Maybe that's just my taste.)

One more thought.

I think there's a reason why various forms of meditation teach us to stop thinking. Maybe they are telling us to sometimes stop dealing with our abstractions, powerful though they might be, and experience the real thing once in a while.

nimonian··on Vitamin D and Omega-3 have a larger effect on depression than antidepressants
Next time I get sunburn I'm calling it a vitamin D overdose
nimonian··on Over 36,500 killed in Iran's deadliest massacre, documents reveal
From Hacker News guidelines:

> That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity.

There is a long history of major world events like this being discussed on Hacker News and it is accepted as on topic. There is also a long history of people who haven't read the guidelines asking what they have to do with tech.

nimonian··on Space Math Academy
Mathematics is concerned with a lot more than arithmetic and computation. Beyond the most basic levels, a mathematician will profit greatly from being aware of this type of epistemological vocabulary and a strong sense of their underlying meaning. Whether reading or writing mathematics, we're constantly dealing with propositions, and correctly taxonomising those propositions can really help keep your mental workspace clean.

I do question the effectiveness (and accuracy) of this exercise, but its learning objectives I think are quite apt.

nimonian··on Pi in Pascal's Triangle (2014)
There's a typo in the final line of math. I think 1/7C2 should be positive rather than negative.
nimonian··on Pi in Pascal's Triangle (2014)
I like the argument that every number in the row below is formed by summing two numbers from above. So each number above appears twice below. Hence the sum doubles.
nimonian··on George Orwell and me: Richard Blair on life with his extraordinary father
Thicker walked ceramic mugs are definitely common in the UK, and probably more common now than anything else, but me and my gran both agree that a proper cup of tea needs serving in a thin-walled, fine-china cup, like this: https://fegghayespottery.co.uk/product/plain-270ml-bone-chin...
nimonian··on Ten Digit Problems (2011) [pdf]
Fantastic. I used to set a competition in my school maths dept to compute as many digits of pi as possible in under one minute. Was always a highlight of the year, a kind of mathematical drag race.

The five coins problem is enticing...

nimonian··on Web apps built with Ruby on Rails
You could probably dockerize it and stick it on render.com
nimonian··on Fans quitting Spotify to save their love of music (2022)
I get where you're coming from with that last sentence - people do sometimes go against the grain because it's not cool to follow the crowd.

But I am one of those people who have felt a definite shift in their relationship to music because of streaming. I don't feel special and I don't want to hate Spotify - I still have an account and use it daily.

But I am less mindful. I don't build relationships with albums any more. I sometimes don't even know the name and artists of songs I listen to and enjoy dozens of times. I definitely feel like I have lost parts of my relationship to music (I've gained things, too, but I'm still not sure if I'm happy with the trade). It's a quiet loss that I've only started to appreciate in the previous year or two, and not yet salient enough to take the radical step of cancelling, but I really do get where the cancellers are coming from (even if there are some edgelords among them!).

nimonian··on Things I learned from teaching
> “I want to learn something just to learn something” isn’t the best reason,

Why?

nimonian··on Understanding Automatic Differentiation in 30 lines of Python
OC's point is that the chain rule for partial derivatives shouldn't be assumed because the ordinary chain rule holds, there's more depth to it than that, and the proof is harder than you might instinctively expect based on the ordinary chain rule.

It's epistemically acceptable to understand these both as "the chain rule" once we're satisfied they've both been proved, and apply liberal amounts of synecdoche from there (and I don't think OC disagrees with you on that).

nimonian··on A room-temperature superconductor? New developments
The reply you replied to was a parody of how Chat GPT responds when you correct it. They were alluding that its grandparent could be AI generated, explaining its slight vapidness.
nimonian··on The AI revolution already transforming education
Long addition is similar to calligraphy in the sense that its deprecation would have little effect on our civilisation's ability to continue functioning as is. They also both require patience to learn. The analogy is tempting.

However, contained within the process of learning long addition is a microcosm of our mathematical praxis: useful parables about logic, pattern, deduction, notation, communication, quantity, and more. There is a great deal to be derived from its study which, by scaffolding young minds, leads to more mathematical scientists, and hence value for society. I would have great difficulty arguing the same for calligraphy.

I don't always go out walking because I have somewhere to go!

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →