1,076 karma · joined August 16, 2024
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artificial_general_intelligenc...
Software engineering never had any strict standards or requirements (beyond borrowing abstractions from computer science) unlike other types of engineering. You never needed any license to be a software engineer, which showed up the in the “quality” of candidates or employees. The closest you get to ensuring even quality is education or training, but even that is a wash because of the varying quality (hah) of programs. Many programs also fudge up rankings, so you have shit-tier schools (and faculty) pretending they’re top-20 or whatever, meanwhile they are global zeros.
Now it doesn’t matter at all, you can’t put into place standards and requirements you never had to begin with just because your employment is on the line. People have been shipping broken, terrible shit for years because parts of it worked, or you got customer lock in for whatever reason. Microsoft Teams is a great example of this.
Software engineering, and computer science by extension, don’t require any formal degree or licensure anymore specifically because of AI. Thank God for that, actually, because a lot of terrible-at-their-field people got ahead because of sheer luck and we are stuck with them as though they’re the “experts”. In that sense, we should celebrate AI as an equalizer. It’s a digital gun, people should learn to use it, and responsibly.
Societal collapse doesn’t necessarily mean all-out nuclear catastrophe, and can also mean transitioning from one set of norms or rules establishing the status quo to another. People shouldn’t labor under the false impression that they will have guaranteed success when such transitions happen. What are they modeling this on, exactly? Countries where mafias are de facto rulers, or there’s some level of dictatorship, are only held up due to external pressures put on by democratic world orders. As mentioned, guns and bombs can guarantee protection up to a point, and the rest of that necessary work is done by ideas and ideals.
Secondly, I am afraid a lot of the people who believe they’ll have some sort of success in scenarios with lesser law and order than they grew up with will find out it wasn’t their winning personalities which guaranteed them anything. There will always be someone more brutal ready to just take yours and dispose of you. To put it more plainly, if all they like is your money then you’re just standing in the way of that.
> return to tribalism . counter to globalization. amazing new alliances. you and I both agreed zero interest rates were too high, as i said in your office. finding things on their way to collapse , was much easier than finding the next bargain
> This is a perfect example of what Naomi Klein calls "disaster capitalism."
Disaster capitalism only works if there’s enough law and order to preserve capital for those who acquire or control it. People who believe in ideas like the two mentioned in the email have experienced nothing but post-WW2 America-enforced global security, albeit relative amounts of it depending on how you are.
That security is not a constant guarantee, it is not a natural element of the world, it is not a force of physics that exists by itself. In a way, the post-WW2 order was crafted by centuries of both physical and mental toil. Undoing it will not bring the selective prosperity or success these people hope it will.
If you decide to be “enlightened”, you force your enemies to assume the same posture. If you decide otherwise, then what they do in return is fair game. Then very soon afterwards you find out there’s no such thing as sheltering from the aftermath of such events. Look at any societal collapse example in history, recent or otherwise.
Besides that, anyone who tells you creativity is just some form of randomness seriously needs better education in the arts and media.
AI is not a magic bullet that will resolve questions about the human condition.
Yes, all generations have their unique references and fixations. But what’s different for generations growing up with the internet is that ads/marketing optimization has made it easier to create the same signals across different cultural mediums, so everything roughly becomes, looks and sounds the same. Gen AI is only going to make this worse, especially for music.
Nothing makes this more obvious than the fact that even the “alternative” culture is cookie cutter down to a set of ingredients and shapes. For example, black lipstick if you’re {type 1} {goth}, {makeup item} on men, etc. It’s not “alternative” if it’s an identity uniform.
The other disappointing thing is that even crossing international borders doesn’t change what you see and experience because there’s a checklist of experience optimization that filters out anything unique, different, or weird that may not be immediately accessible.
Maybe do an empirical analysis (a small one?), or point out people who have, as it will at least tell us the underlying theoretical frameworks and assumptions. May make for more interesting discussion.
The problem being that AI can scale faster, and compound problems exponentially, than any human can review or oversee things. There need to be better control mechanisms.
If these systems can produce something, and that thing is reproducible and usable, then what’s the problem? Seems like an interesting project.
Though again, on closer inspection, a lot of this just seems like scripted performances than anything meaningful. Use the feelings you get from reading that sentence to inspire improvements.
If I cannot guarantee outcomes (people usually get demoted or fired when they don’t exactly do what the boss says), then I need something in the loop which I can hold accountable to ensure I get the outcomes I want.
If an agent keeps giving me bad information or code, how do I demote or fire that agent if I am subjected to vendor lock-in? Everyone is using the same models and APIs across the board.
We need people for quality assurance even beyond AI developing cognitive flexibility on par with humans. I can hold a person, or group of people, accountable for their mistakes. I cannot hold AI agents or APIs accountable for shit.
Let’s also not forget that some mistakes have very little fault tolerance, and software we write has never been able meet that demand. See all the recent plane crashes, for example.
If human capabilities are the bottleneck, then those capabilities need to augmented.
The only real test is AI agents that independently learn to self-correct and self-regulate. Memory constraints are not the bottleneck here because tiny multi-cellular/animal brains do this all the time.
Absent validation and success in AI self-correction and AI self-regulation, the only thing we can say here is there is a mass delusion between humans that their AI agents are sentient or conscious.