HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nknighthb

4,726 karma · joined April 5, 2013

submissionscomments
nknighthb··on Evidence for nuclear explosions on Mars [pdf]
Did you read the article on natural fission reactors? Completely? If not, do so. It answers your question. No enrichment was necessary at the time, natural quantities were sufficient.
nknighthb··on The GNU Manifesto Turns Thirty
> government requests with the AWS terms that would apply to EC2

Are you talking about search warrants? I think any interpretation that makes one liable for copyright infringement for the government forcibly making a copy is likely to be laughed out of court.

> a service of the general type of Drive/Dropbox is still problematic

There is an exceedingly easy workaround if it is a problem: Encrypt it. That way you do not "enable" them to make copies (in any sense a court would care about).

nknighthb··on The GNU Manifesto Turns Thirty
How low do you think it needs to be?

I'd estimate no more than 1/3rd of the ESA's estimate could possibly be developers[0]. I would certainly consider less than 50,000 out of 1.4 million to be "almost nobody" for the purposes of this conversation.

[0] And I think that's a very, very high estimate, it's probably closer to 1/5th, or even lower. There are a lot of art, QA, and support people involved in the industry, before you even make it to usual corporate overhead of management, HR, payroll, etc..

nknighthb··on The GNU Manifesto Turns Thirty
You're right, that would be propagating, since it's making a copy. In fact, it's also conveyance.

But you forgot to keep reading GPLv3.

2. Basic Permissions.

[...]

You may make, run and propagate covered works that you do not convey, without conditions so long as your license otherwise remains in force. You may convey covered works to others for the sole purpose of having them make modifications exclusively for you, or provide you with facilities for running those works, provided that you comply with the terms of this License in conveying all material for which you do not control copyright. Those thus making or running the covered works for you must do so exclusively on your behalf, under your direction and control, on terms that prohibit them from making any copies of your copyrighted material outside their relationship with you.

You might still argue about dropbox, since it's neither modifying nor running the works, but certainly using the work on EC2 falls under this provision.

nknighthb··on The GNU Manifesto Turns Thirty
Your caveat is wrong.

The ESA, which has an incentive to play up the importance of the video game industry, puts the total number of people (not just developers) employed "directly or indirectly" in the US by the video game industry at 146,000[1].

There are around 1.4 million people actually writing code professionally in the US[2][3], even if you limit yourself to the BLS's "computer programmer" and "software developer" categories.

[1] http://www.theesa.com/article/u-s-video-game-industrys-econo...

[2] http://www.bls.gov/ooh/computer-and-information-technology/c...

[3] http://www.bls.gov/ooh/computer-and-information-technology/s...

nknighthb··on The GNU Manifesto Turns Thirty
What you're missing is that the copies aren't being sent to Amazon, Dropbox, or Google. They're being sent to space you are renting from those companies. You are no more propagating (another important term defined in GPLv3, which conveying is defined in terms of) a work to those companies than you would be if you put a copy of the work in a storage locker, apartment, rented office space, or even a rented car.

The copy is not Amazon's, Dropbox's, or Google's, it is yours. It never legally left your control.

nknighthb··on MuJS: an embeddable JavaScript interpreter
If your problem is one of semantics, please be honest about that up-front, instead of instigating drawn-out arguments.
nknighthb··on MuJS: an embeddable JavaScript interpreter
> My point is about the clause in the GPL that enforces developers to enclose the source of their entire software, not just the library.

I'm well aware of it. Everybody is. It's a term of the license. Just like "You must pay us $5000 to use this library" would be.

> And lets not nitpick here, the GPL isn't exactly subtle about these things.

Nitpick about what? Subtle about what? What are you talking about?

> No. It's their right to choose whatever license they wish, but it's also my right to not choose their software.

It certainly is.

But you said it's "bad". But it wouldn't be "bad" if they hadn't made it available under a free license at all.

This seems like a hypocritical and extremely entitled attitude. Under what moral code is it bad to offer alternative prices for alternative terms?

nknighthb··on MuJS: an embeddable JavaScript interpreter
> And what if those companies wish to provide their software to customers?

They can abide by the free license, or pay for a different license. Or, yes, switch to a different library. They are not entitled to use this library, nor any other library.

> No, the GPL, especially the AGPL is inherently bad for libraries.

If this library were not available under any sort of open-source license, would you be making the same post, insisting it's "bad" for them not to give you free stuff?

nknighthb··on FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to commercial regulations
Fair market value.

http://www.irs.gov/Businesses/Small-Businesses-&-Self-Employ...

nknighthb··on Open source USB Type-C to HDMI Adapter
The key word in my comment was "internal".
nknighthb··on Open source USB Type-C to HDMI Adapter
Ease of routing.

I know optical on-chip networks have been the subject of research for many years, and I've heard rumblings of optical interconnects between chips. I don't know their current status, nor whether they look to be useful in practice. Hence my question.

nknighthb··on Open source USB Type-C to HDMI Adapter
At what point do consumer devices start using internal optical interconnects?
nknighthb··on Apple App Store STATUS_CODE_ERROR causes service problems
I just installed AdBlock in Chrome, via the Chrome web store, on a Windows 7 box, that has never had a Google account logged in on it. So at the moment, I see no evidence that you need one to install extensions. Even if you did need one to install from the Chrome Web Store, you can also side-load.

With regard to the others, there are crucial distinctions:

* Chrome synchronization is entirely optional. You can use Chrome without ever logging into Google's servers. That's not the case with Authy.

* The malware blocklist feature uses data stored on your local machine that is frequently updated from Google's servers. It does not send the URLs to Google. Even aside from privacy implications, that would be annoyingly slow. And the block can be bypassed (last time I saw it, anyway) with a single click.

nknighthb··on Google balloons, “cell towers in the sky,” can serve 4G to a whole state
Unfortunately, that's already reality in some areas with usable (though not great) LTE coverage. Having a more direct LOS to the balloon is a significant mitigating factor.

There's also a factor not being noted here. The population at which a cell tower is feasible may drop substantially if the uplink consists of pointing an antenna at these balloons, increasing the number of relatively tiny villages that can have semi-conventional LTE service.

nknighthb··on Apple App Store STATUS_CODE_ERROR causes service problems
Authy uses a modified form of TOTP. CloudFlare requires Authy, not a standard TOTP implementation. They make this very clear when you try to activate 2FA.

Authy works as a third-party authentication provider. Their servers are in the loop on every login. They aren't just a TOTP app + synchronization, they actually do the code validation themselves.

The correct analogy would be if every time you went to a website in Firefox, it asked Mozilla's servers if it was OK to go there. Also if, when installing Firefox, it demanded you create an account and give your cell phone number to Mozilla. (Or better yet, Google.)

nknighthb··on Apple App Store STATUS_CODE_ERROR causes service problems
Authy necessarily has the keys on its servers in cleartext. When you integrate them into your application, you send the code the user inputs to Authy's servers for verification.

Authy is a third-party authentication provider, it is not simply a synchronization service.

nknighthb··on Apple App Store STATUS_CODE_ERROR causes service problems
> What exactly is wrong with Authy that makes it completely unacceptable for you to use?

This exact scenario is sufficient on its own. Also individually sufficient are the unnecessary revelation of personal information to Authy, and an aversion to perpetuating an authentication method that unsophisticated users can easily confuse with more secure methods that don't rely on third parties.

nknighthb··on Apple App Store STATUS_CODE_ERROR causes service problems
It's about being tied to a third-party service. Currently, the one causing you a problem is Apple's. It could just as well be Authy's.

With standard TOTP, you could pull out a paper backup and use it to make any TOTP app on any platform work. But with Authy, you're screwed if they're down.

And it sounds like you're screwed right now because Apple is down. Again, this wouldn't be an issue if you were using standard TOTP.

Meanwhile, if I'd given in and setup 2FA on my company's CloudFlare account, I wouldn't be able to access it right now.

So yes, I have an axe to grind -- with CloudFlare. We pay you $200/month, and the only reason we can still access our account is because I've refused to setup 2FA on it with Authy.

nknighthb··on Apple App Store STATUS_CODE_ERROR causes service problems
A lesson, perhaps, in why it's a bad idea to lock yourself (and your customers paying you hundreds to thousands of dollars every month) into third-party services (say, Authy) in order to get basic security features for which widely-adopted, standard alternatives exist.
nknighthb··on Goodbye MongoDB, Hello PostgreSQL
> The psuedocode in question happens to be syntactically valid Ruby.

So is everything else anyone types, code-like or not. He even said "Note how I deliberately shuffled the order and didn't bother with escaping.".

The response was flippant, intelligence-insulting, and obviously the result of failing to read thoroughly.

And speaking of intelligence-insulting, we all know you can run raw SQL through Sequel.

You're not having a useful dialogue, you're being combative, like the person I initially replied to.

nknighthb··on Goodbye MongoDB, Hello PostgreSQL
It's pseudocode for an implementation that doesn't exist. There is nothing in his proposal that requires this hypothetical implementation to copy the value of the price_range variable into the string at all, much less unescaped.

The strings don't even have to be sent to the DB at all. You've utterly missed his point. He wants the language to be intelligent about what the SQL means and do the right thing.

It's not raw SQL, it's an abstraction.

nknighthb··on Goodbye MongoDB, Hello PostgreSQL
His proposal is not string concatenation, and it is not vulnerable to injection.
nknighthb··on Sexism in Tech: Don’t Ask Me Unless You’re Ready to Call Someone a Whistleblower
Incorrect. The paragraph I quoted is 261(b). The paragraph you are talking about is 261(a)(7), part of 261(a). Note that 261(a)(7) never even uses the word "duress".

Furthermore, 261(b) says "this section". The "section" is 261, not 261(a)(7). Note also that 261(a)(7) calls itself "this paragraph", not "this section".

261.7 is a completely different section concerning the evidentiary value of birth control methods: http://codes.lp.findlaw.com/cacode/PEN/3/1/9/1/s261.7

nknighthb··on Sexism in Tech: Don’t Ask Me Unless You’re Ready to Call Someone a Whistleblower
Keep reading your own link. Duress includes "retribution" not limited to physical violence.

" (b) As used in this section, "duress" means a direct or implied threat of force, violence, danger, or retribution sufficient to coerce a reasonable person of ordinary susceptibilities to perform an act which otherwise would not have been performed, or acquiesce in an act to which one otherwise would not have submitted. The total circumstances, including the age of the victim, and his or her relationship to the defendant, are factors to consider in appraising the existence of duress."

nknighthb··on Sexism in Tech: Don’t Ask Me Unless You’re Ready to Call Someone a Whistleblower
Not according to the California penal code. Duress suffices, and duress is not limited to physical force.

http://codes.lp.findlaw.com/cacode/PEN/3/1/9/1/s261

"(b) As used in this section, "duress" means a direct or implied threat of force, violence, danger, or retribution sufficient to coerce a reasonable person of ordinary susceptibilities to perform an act which otherwise would not have been performed, or acquiesce in an act to which one otherwise would not have submitted. The total circumstances, including the age of the victim, and his or her relationship to the defendant, are factors to consider in appraising the existence of duress."

nknighthb··on Anonymous Login
As a user, I immediately quit apps that present a login with Facebook screen because, like 29% of users, I do not use Facebook.
nknighthb··on Blink - Intent to deprecate: Insecure usage of powerful features
> and my "OS" taskbar/menubar, that, is not possible today

Please articulate why you do not believe that is possible.

> Yes, and not connecting to those site on an open WiFi hotspot is still a good practice. Again, HTTPS or not.

Please articulate why you believe that is good practice.

Don't say "common sense". State the underlying basis of your belief.

And finally, please explain why, even if everything you believe is accurate, it is somehow a negative thing to prevent attacks from being carried out on users who do not share your beliefs and paranoia. Social darwinism?

Actually, one more: Even if no one did any of these things on open wifi, they would still be vulnerable to these attacks, since every internet connection is vulnerable, so please explain why protecting people who do share your beliefs is a bad idea.

Nope, still got another: I travel for work with some frequency, including internationally. When doing so, frequently my only available option is open wifi. Please explain why my livelihood should be destroyed because you, an admitted non-expert, believe using open wifi is a bad idea?

Oh, hey, yet another: Please explain why, even if doing these things were unsafe now, you oppose efforts to make them safe!

nknighthb··on Blink - Intent to deprecate: Insecure usage of powerful features
> You log into your bank website connected to an open WiFi hotspot ? I never would do that.

Many people do that, and it's quite safe to do so with a modern browser. Were it not, it would not be safe to do so in any context, because man-in-the-middle attacks are possible on any connection, just extra easy on wifi.

> I think there is a point where you have to apply common sense.

As you are demonstrating quite well here, "common" sense is not good sense. It is stopping you from doing things which are safe, and making you advocate for things which are unsafe.

> I access my through HTTPS explicitly typing the URL.

You would be typing the URL into the equivalent of a remote desktop session. That is what you're not understanding.

> My bank ask confirmation out of band for every dangerous action (by SMS).

1) Most banks do not do that.

2) SMS is not a secure channel.

3) Banks are not the only target (again, google/gmail accounts are another good example).

4) Even if they could not transfer funds, they would now have a great deal of information about your finances right on their screen.

> In Europe, banks have to cover frauds

They mostly do in the US, too. This makes consumers less likely to care about security.

> I am against HTTPS everywhere as the only security measure.

No one has advocated that. If you think they have, you have become very confused.

nknighthb··on Blink - Intent to deprecate: Insecure usage of powerful features
> Do you really need to secure Youtube viewing on a public WiFi hotspots ?

This suggests you did not, in fact, see the problem. The attacker in this scenario is not limited to replacing YouTube videos. They can make anything they want appear on the user's screen, including things like a Google login page, or even a bank login page.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →