HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nnvvhh

112 karma · joined April 9, 2015

submissionscomments
nnvvhh··on Ask HN: Is discrimination to promote diversity okay?
The problem with this view, to me, is that it takes a really narrow view of discrimination. Why are you only concerned with the hiring process of software engineers? To me, bad-faith alarm bells go off when concern about discrimination only rears its head when the speaker's corner of the world is impacted. There are much more pernicious problems that need addressing than the quality of engineers at your job. How is the need for meritocratic software hiring more urgent and pressing than rectifying major societal problems? Are you OK with permanently setting in place the underclass, subjugated status of entire minority communities so your page loads are quicker?
nnvvhh··on Ask HN: Is discrimination to promote diversity okay?
The argument you point out, about treating well-off groups equally as bad as those less well-off, is a bad argument and not what you should be thinking about. The practices you point out have nothing to do treating everyone equally bad. You are focusing on the unfortunate consequence of attempting to make right past injustices, rather than the effort to right past injustices. The goal is not to discriminate against young graduates. Rather, biasing hiring in favor of historically oppressed groups is an attempt to, in some small way, achieve a society we would have been in without things like racism and sexism. I understand this type of thing is frustrating for a qualified candidate who personally has a minuscule impact on society, yet is feeling the full brunt of a rejection. But I would encourage you to focus on the much more widespread similar feeling felt by those being helped up by such efforts.
nnvvhh··on Ask HN: Any indications Copilot scans your local files?
Ya, I'd be curious to hear how orgs are thinking about it. It could be that the risk of a copyright judgment against the org is outweighed by the efficiency gains from Copilot. The risk involved has an element of discoverability – how the heck is the OSS developer whose small snippet of code gets sucked into a closed-source project going to learn of the infringement?

Other stuff within copyright makes infringement of a small Copilot snippet less likely too, and the recent Google v. Oracle decision reinforced the fact that copyright is an awkward fit within copyright and may sometimes get less protection than things like fictional books. Fair use also comes in here, too; remember something as "egregious" as Google copying 37 Java packages worth of package / class / method declarations into Android was held a fair use. Declaring code is sort of special because it's more like an interface, but the Court really reinforced the notion that it likes cool new technology stuff that opens new markets, makes new products, etc., and a fair use finding for small snippets of code is in line with that as adapting copyright doctrine in the face of tech changes like AI / ML.

nnvvhh··on Ask HN: Any indications Copilot scans your local files?
It's unclear whether MS would be directly liable for copyright infringement; the Aereo case[0] perhaps expanded a device-maker's direct liability for user actions. MS would likely escape secondary copyright liability because the verbatim suggestions are really rare, and the standard under the Sony VCR case[1] is whether the device is "capable of substantial non-infringing uses."

EDIT: The user would perhaps be the direct infringer as the person who made a copy of the code, even unwittingly.

Source: current law student taking copyright and writing a paper about Copilot.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Broadcasting_Cos.,_In....

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_Corp._of_America_v._Unive....

nnvvhh··on Former college professor accused of serial arson is denied bail in California
What in the world does this have to do with Bolshevism?
nnvvhh··on Universities have formed a company that looks a lot like a patent troll
How can you sue an NPE for infringement when they are not practicing the invention?
nnvvhh··on Pentagon surveilling Americans without a warrant, Senator Wyden reveals
Although to distinguish the 2nd Amendment, its the language specifically mentions firearm ownership in connection with a "well regulated militia." There are disagreements about the effect of that part of the text, but it's worth mentioning.
nnvvhh··on Amazon workers vote against unionizing in Alabama
The comment you responded to gave a response to multiple points, it's far from "nuh uh." Your characterization is inaccurate.
nnvvhh··on Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time
No substance? Come on now, I thought it clearly communicated my opinion that you were being pedantic in focusing so narrowly on the denotations of English words. Words like "worship" often define fuzzy concepts and do not define things as precise as a function signature. The response to the original quote is so silly to me that I am compelled to continue replying. To ignore the quote's thrust and have your reading be short circuited by its "redefining" of words, especially given that it is a snippet of a wider work, making the initial criticism all the sillier, is too fun to ignore.
nnvvhh··on Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time
Since you are so hung up on denotations, may I suggest a couple of official, sanctioned, orthodox definitions (right up your alley) of words the dwelling upon of which might wrench you from your obstinance: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/connotation and https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/pedantic.
nnvvhh··on Learning about the navigational feats of animals
This happens to my cat in Brooklyn. We walk with him up or down a flight of stairs to an identical-looking floor, and if any disturbance occurs on the other floor he runs to "our" door. We get a real kick out of his mistake.
nnvvhh··on Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time
"Just playing word games," he's a writer! Not everything written is documentation.
nnvvhh··on Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time
You must be fun at parties.
nnvvhh··on GitHub, fuck your name change
The word "pursue" is doing a hell of a lot of work in your idea of the American right "pursuing voting rights." They're pursuing them like a hunting dog pursues a kill.
nnvvhh··on Magic Mushrooms Are Decriminalized in DC as of Today
I disagree that the alcohol comparison is not useful. I think many people in the US take lots of their social world as axiomatic and correct and natural. Two such "axioms" are the legality of alcohol and the illegality of "other drugs." The comparison with alcohol helps those who have not considered drug laws in good faith break out of their stupor and realize the "axioms" are created socially. The hope is that they will realize that the supposedly natural distinction between alcohol and other drugs is illusory.
nnvvhh··on Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust lawsuits against Google
But it literally is whataboutism. If a friend of yours expresses concern about big tech firms, and then you say, "But what about this other industry?" you have not engaged at all with the original statement and attempted to shift the conversation to something else entirely.
nnvvhh··on Small business rescue earned banks $10B in fees
The article mentions that a law firm is currently pursuing this.
nnvvhh··on What Armenians should know about life in America (2014)
To me car haters are pro-development. Have you really encountered people holding both of the views you described?
nnvvhh··on How a preventable disaster killed six marines
Donate to ProPublica!
nnvvhh··on The Real Class War
From Zinn's A People's History of the United States: "One percent of the nation owns a third of the wealth. The rest of the wealth is distributed in such a way as to turn those in the 99 percent against one another: small property owners against the propertyless, black against white, native-born against foreign-born, intellectuals and professionals against the uneducated and unskilled. These groups have resented one another and warred against one another with such vehemence and violence as to obscure their common position as sharers of leftovers in a very wealthy country."
nnvvhh··on Who Owns Your Wireless Service? Crooks Do
I think you're overreacting. The Sohn quote is referring specifically to oversight by relevant government agencies. Lawsuits are not relevant to the statement. The article implies that the FCC investigation into location data sharing was, at best, proceeding slowly.
nnvvhh··on Things You Notice When You Quit the News
+1 for the Economist. You get much more value than what you pay for an annual subscription. This week's edition has a letter to the editor from the president of Peru... It's that kind of publication.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2