HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nobody9999

6,767 karma · joined July 8, 2020

submissionscomments
nobody9999··on ICE Will Use AI to Surveil Social Media
>... I mean it absolutely does. What on earth are you _supposed_ to do? Give the unaccountable secret police the benefit of the doubt?

Exactly. Even if this guy holds beliefs that aren't aligned with those of the US government, so what? That is not a reason to detain or refuse entry to a place that's supposed to embrace freedom of expression and of the press.

This is blatantly anti-democratic (small 'd'), capricious and just one more example of the current administration's attempts to destroy a free and open society.

Yet here you guys (@ajroos, @dlubarov, etc.) arguing about why the US government is abandoning the rule of law and trying to normalize authoritarianism and bad-faith governance. It doesn't matter why. It's wrong and evil on its face.

nobody9999··on What if tariffs?
>Also, Bernie should have one, but the DNC leadership absolutely cheats... this was incredibly apparent in 2016 and 2024. Talk about an oligarchy/autocracy...

How, exactly? Clinton received 12% (55.2%-43.1%[0])/three million-plus more primary election votes than Sanders.

And he only received that many because Clinton wasn't a great candidate, and more importantly, the decades-long campaign to smear her and her husband.

What's that? 'Muh "superdelegates!"' Those actually didn't matter -- the actual votes by actual Democratic voters is what did it.

What's more, even if Sanders had not lost by 12% and had become the Democratic nominee, the ads just write themselves:

   Pan in on Bernie Sanders saying "I am a proud Socialist!" 
   with shimmering backgrounds of the Soviet and CCP flags 
   and portraits of Stalin and Mao smiling down on him. "I'm 
   Joe Stalin, and I approve this message!"

   Then video of Soviet/Chinese armies parading with tanks 
   and all sorts of other "socialist" imagery.
and on and on just like that, over and over. As such, Sanders would never have won the general election and it wouldn't have been nearly as close as the actual one.

Go ahead. Call me a liar. But actual vote counts from actual elections have nothing to do with "superdelegates" or any of that.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_Democratic_Party_presiden...

Edit: Added more detail to the imagined "campaign ad"; Fixed prose.

nobody9999··on FBI Agents Visit Anti-ICE Protester: "Your name was brought up."
>When federal agents, such as the FBI, attempt to question you, it is strongly advised that you do not talk to them without a lawyer present.

Yes. This. James Duane lays out[0] why this is so important. I strongly encourage everyone resident in the US to view this video as it makes (IMHO) a very strong case for never talking to the police -- they are not (at least in their official capacities) your friends.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-7o9xYp7eE

nobody9999··on Trump pardons convicted Binance founder
>I suppose, however, that the majority of low-population states were also frontier states, seems like a fairly compelling distinction.

Not so much, unless you consider Massachusetts, New Jersey, Rhode Island, New Hampshire and Vermont to be "frontier" states in 1787. Actual frontier states like Georgia were in favor of the Virginia Plan as they figured their population would grow soon enough and they could take advantage of their eventual large population (with slaves being counted as 3/5 of a person) in a "Virginia Plan" world.

The Connecticut Compromise[0][3] ended up in the Constitution as a reconciliation of the Virginia Plan[1][4] and the New Jersey Plan[2][5], with the larger states supporting the Virginia Plan and smaller states supported the New Jersey Plan.

The above is incredibly abridged and ignores much context. As such, I strongly recommend you read Article I, Sections 2 and 3 of the US Constitution[7] (the result of the Connecticut Compromise) as well as the original Virginia and New Jersey plans, or at least the wikipedia pages I linked for a much better discourse on the topic.

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Connecticut_Compromise

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virginia_Plan

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Jersey_Plan

[3] The current system. Which differs from the original only in direct election of Senators, rather than them being appointed by state legislatures[6].

[4] Proposed a bicameral legislature with both houses apportioned by population.

[5] Proposed a unicameral legislature with one vote per state.

[6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seventeenth_Amendment_to_the_U...

[7] https://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/

Edit: Added the missing link.

nobody9999··on Trump pardons convicted Binance founder
>In many parts of Europe a couple of strikes would have taken place. Usans are numb or has no social conscience and muscle.

Americans are not numb. And we have both of those things, or at least most of us do. What we don't have are strong unions. Less than 10% of American workers are union members.

What's more, for as long as there have been unionization efforts in the US (150+ years), the forces of corporations, aided by the government -- to this day -- have suppressed those efforts -- for a long time, brutally and fatally -- and such suppression (although generally not with clubs and guns these days) continues, often with government support.

As such, even a "general strike" would have minimal effect, as many union members are forbidden by law to strike (in various jurisdictions, police, fire departments and others).

The vast majority of US workers are "at will" workers whose employment can be terminated at any time, for any (or no) reason. Workers can do so just the same as employers, so it's definitely fair!

More than half of Americans can't afford an unexpected $USD600 expense. As such, how many do you expect to essentially quit their jobs (possibly multiple jobs) to join a "general strike"?

Labor and unions don't work in the US the same way they do in say, Iceland, Sweden, Denmark and other countries with high levels of unionization[0]

As much as I'd love to see repeated "general strikes" in the US, protesting the anti-democratic (small 'd') assaults on the rule of law, freedom of expression and due process, given the state of organized labor in the US, that's just not going to happen.

As such, we organize where we can and mobilize widely. As the pain comes, more and more of folks will begin to see the problem. I hope it won't come too late.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_comparisons_of_t...

nobody9999··on Trump pardons convicted Binance founder
>From the 7 millions that did show up, very close to zero of them will be deciding the next election due to the way the election system works in the US.

That's not really true. Check the margins of victory in so-called "swing" states (Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin, Georgia, Arizona, Nevada and North Carolina) for Trump and compare that with each state's turnout at last weekend's protests.

So no. Many more than "close to zero" of those folks will be deciding the next presidential election.

Edit: Corrected prose.

nobody9999··on Trump pardons convicted Binance founder
>What if some criminal blatantly says "I'll give you $1bn if you pardon me" and Trump does it? Is that enough for something to happen? Because it seems like that's the only place we can go from here...

According to SCOTUS[0], as long as it's a "gratuity," it's not a bribe and not illegal. No. Seriously.

https://www.scotusblog.com/2024/06/supreme-court-limits-scop...

nobody9999··on With deadline looming 4 of 9 universities reject Trumps pact to remake higher ed
>When executive demands something of private citizens and private entities, it means they are bossing over said people/entities. Nobody elected the executive to boss over people. When Congress attempts to set these same regulations, these entities get a chance to reach out to their reps and ask for changes. When Congress sets regulations, power is dispersed among 400+ reps.

IMHO it's much simpler than that. Congress has the power of the purse -- that is to say that Congress decides what funds are disbursed by the Federal government.

While there is a small measure of flexibility for the Executive on when and/or how those funds are disbursed, the Constitution vests budgetary power (i.e., who gets funded, how much to they get, and for what purpose) in Congress and not the Executive.

The same goes for tariffs too.

Congress is not doing their job. Not only in the sense that they've abandoned the "power of the purse" to the Executive, but also in that legislators, for the most part, represent their big donors rather than their constituents.

Which isn't new, although it's pretty stark right now. With the dysfunction so high that the government is currently unfunded.

Even more, the House won't even gavel into session, as they'd then have to swear in a newly elected member of Congress which would give members just enough votes to passing a motion to publish information (The so-called "Epstein Files") widely believed to be bad news for the President as well as others in the power structure.

The Senate isn't negotiating, nor is the House drafting actual budget bill(s) which is one of their primary responsibilities.

So yes. If there's an issue with Federal research funding, it's Congress that needs to fix it. What the Executive is trying to do is not part of the powers given to them by the Constitution (you know, the *supreme law of the land) and, as such, isn't lawful.

nobody9999··on With deadline looming 4 of 9 universities reject Trumps pact to remake higher ed
>Having casually attended one of these schools, I'm so confused about why they are even in this group. What is making this group of schools best suited for this sort of blackmail?

That's a great question.

I wonder, shouldn't Oral Roberts University, Brigham Young University and other, similar institutions be required to be less biased in their ways too?

If not, why not?

nobody9999··on TiVo exiting legacy DVR business
>and not being able to transfer the recordings was a huge pain.

Except you can[0], and I have for decades.

[0] https://github.com/lart2150/kmttg

nobody9999··on TiVo exiting legacy DVR business
>But YouTubeTV is excellent too. The only thing I miss is the ability to save recordings for as long as I want or record anything I want. There were some I kept for years and YT only lets you keep them for a few months.

cf yt=dlp[0]

[0] https://github.com/yt-dlp/yt-dlp

nobody9999··on Retiring Windows 10 and Microsoft's move towards a surveillance state
>you seem to be up on GPL2 , what happens when someone packages distros on disk or stick, and sells them for profit ? thats something to be aware of as well.

Assuming that someone has customers, they have a viable business model, that's what happens.

That was, in fact, the business model of most Linux distros before we were all terminally online.

Don't be shy. Tell us what you're concerned about and why you think that's an issue.

Are you implying some sort of illegality or breach of license?

nobody9999··on Opinion: Why I'm handing in my Pentagon press pass
>I never said that I'd heard any officer state that they'd lied to a reporter. I said that I believe that access is/was choreographed (to present a certain narrative to the reporter), and that I don't think the reporters get the 'real dirt' from Pentagon access that they think they do (because most officers doing a desk tour there know they are walking a political tightrope). >[...] >I don't take notes on the podcasts I listen to, so I don't have episode-specific citations for you.

Fair enough and thank you for the references.

Like I said, this wasn't some kind of "gotcha" exercise.

nobody9999··on Opinion: Why I'm handing in my Pentagon press pass
And these podcasts prominently feature ex-military officers saying they lied to reporters on a regular basis?

Can you be just slightly more specific? The two podcasts you actually named have ~650 episodes between them. Heaven knows how many are in the podcasts you didn't name.

nobody9999··on Opinion: Why I'm handing in my Pentagon press pass
>My suspicions are based on listening to many podcasts with ex-military officer guests, and what they’ve said about serving ‘pentagon tours’, being publicity/public affairs/media officers for their units, and speaking with the press in general.

Which podcasts? Which ex-military officers?

That's not a "gotcha," I want to listen to those myself.

nobody9999··on New York Times, AP, Newsmax and others say they won't sign new Pentagon rules
>Because American ballots are massive?

>They vote for everything including the president and local school district board members and everything in between at the same time.

What's more, elections are managed/run at the county level, not at the state or Federal levels. As such, there isn't just one election in the US on election day. Rather, there are 3500+ elections, each with different ballots, different folks managing the elections and different sets of interested parties monitoring each of those 3500+ elections.

While many offices are up for election every two or four or six years, not all of them fall on even-numbered years like the Federal elections.

My state has state elections that happen in concert with Federal elections, but my local government does not. In fact, we're voting for mayor, City Council and every other elective city office in a few weeks, even though the federal and state elections aren't this year.

Since elections are managed and run at the county level, there is little uniformity -- and less opportunity for widespread fraud.

nobody9999··on New York Times, AP, Newsmax and others say they won't sign new Pentagon rules
>So I think it's reasonable to say that, to paraphrase the earlier comment, putting an X in a box on a piece of paper is how it's done in most of the world.

>It's true that the ballots aren't always counted by hand.

I can't speak for other jurisdictions (although I understand that this is pretty common in the US), but where I live (NY) we do exactly that. Well, instead of marking an 'X', we fill in an oval for each item on the ballot and that paper ballot is then scanned and counted.

If there are issues or the vote is very close, as with most places, a recount is done, first by machine and, if necessary, by hand.

How is this different from the rest of the world?

nobody9999··on Opinion: Why I'm handing in my Pentagon press pass
>I suspect that the officers they were talking to were actually walking a highly political tightrope in hopes of advancing their own careers.

Upon what evidence do you base your suspicions?

I'd note that Tom Bowman (the author of TFA) has been publishing stories based upon such details for nearly three decades.

Can you point to any stories that he published, based on such information from Pentagon-based military personnel, that turned out not to be factual?

If so, please share that information. We'd all like to know.

nobody9999··on Opinion: Why I'm handing in my Pentagon press pass
From TFA:

>I've held my Pentagon press pass for 28 years. For most of that time, when I wasn't overseas in combat zones embedding with troops, I walked the halls, talking to and getting to know officers from all over the globe, at times visiting them in their offices.

Without press credentials, the above becomes impossible.

You seem to be under the impression that these folks sit in waiting areas until a "press conference" is announced, then copy down whatever some talking head says and publishes that and only that.

There may well be some who do so, but that's not journalism, friend.

nobody9999··on Tennessee man arrested, accused of threatening a shooting, after posting meme
>That's a pretty big assumption that also happens to be wrong. I specifically said "if at all possible" because I'm well aware that plenty of people can't put everything on hold for 30-60 days and have to potentially start over after that's done.

Okay. I've been wrong before, am wrong with this and will certainly be wrong again. My apologies. As such, I hope you never end up in a position where you'll need to consider taking your own advice.

But that doesn't change the overall point -- that sitting in jail for weeks or months, perhaps even years pre-trial will likely destroy most folks' life and livelihood.

nobody9999··on Tennessee man arrested, accused of threatening a shooting, after posting meme
>Regardless of bail, IMO you are almost always better off staying in jail if at all possible and forcing the state to a speedy trial.

I'm guessing that you have the means to pay your bills for years before having to worry about losing your income and your home. Most folks don't.

If you're in jail, you can't work. If you don't go to work, you'll lose your job. If you lose your job and you're like most people in the US, within a few months, you can't pay your mortgage or rent, so you'll lose your home as well as any belongings in that home.

Which are the biggest reasons why high/no bail forces folks to accept plea deals. "Speedy Trial" laws generally don't even enter into it.

nobody9999··on The fight between doctors and insurance companies over 'downcoding'
>Here are the magic words in US Health Care: "What is the cash price?"

I'm not so sure about that. Especially in a hospital setting.

Many years ago, I was admitted to the hospital for several days as it was suspected (wrongly, but that's another issue with the perverse incentives in US "healthcare") that I had MRSA and the doctor wanted me on IV antibiotics while testing proceeded.

I spent three days in the hospital, getting discharged when the tests came back negative for MRSA.

Shortly thereafter, I received a detailed "explanation of benefits" (EOB) from my insurer, which put the cost of my hospital stay at ~USD$12,000 which included stays in two hospital rooms simultaneously as well as a pap smear (despite the fact that I do not have a cervix). When I complained about this, the insurer tried to make it seem unimportant, but I pressed the issue as both the hospital and the insurer seemed to be involved in some sort of fraud WRT billing.

I was told I shouldn't care because I wasn't actually paying, but I persisted as I was concerned that there was something hinky going on. That culminated in a conference call with my insurance company, the hospital's accounts receivable group and me.

The two other parties talked in insurance billing jargon for a while, but when pressed, they stated that the charges on the "explanation of benefits" was a fiction and that the insurance company and hospital group's contract set a USD$1,500/day flat rate for patients admitted to the hospital's facilities -- roughly 1/3 of the "costs" cited in the EOB.

The made up stuff (which they didn't even try to hide that it was made up) was there as "protection" for the hospital group as the "cash price" of such services, even though I couldn't have received such services (two rooms at the same time? A pap smear[0] despite the fact that I don't have a female reproductive system, nor do/did I present as anything other than a cis male?).

I imagine that there may be some cases where a "cash price" actually does reflect costs and might even be less than insurance costs (although that seems unlikely given my experience), but insurers and healthcare providers do and have for decades gamed the "cash price" to justify the insane overcharging of healthcare services. YMMV.

[0] https://www.mayoclinic.org/tests-procedures/pap-smear/about/...

nobody9999··on Police Said They Surveilled Woman Who Had an Abortion for Her 'Safety.'
>I don't think this is weird at all. Corporations may be more "malicious" (or at least self centered), but governments have more power. So even if you believe they are good and have good intentions it still has the potential to do far more harm. Google can manipulate you but the government can manipulate you, throw you in jail, and rewrite the rules so you have no recourse. Even if the government can get the data from those companies there's at least a speed bump. Even if a speed bump isn't hard to get over are we going to pretend that some friction is no different from no friction?

That's all as may be, but you're ignoring the fact that governments are buying[0][1][2][3] the data being collected by those corporations. That's not "friction" in my book, rather it's a commercial transaction.

As such, giving corporations a pass seems kind of silly, as they're profiting from selling that data to those with a monopoly on violence.

So, by all means, give the corporations the "benefit of the doubt" on this, as they certainly have no idea that they're selling this information to governments (well, to pretty much anyone willing to pay -- including domestic abusers and stalkers too), they're only acting as agents maximizing corporate profits for their shareholders. Which is the only important thing, right? Anything else is antithetical to free-market orthodoxy.

People suffer and/or die? Just the cost of doing business right?

[0] https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/security/us-government-buys-dat...

[1] https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/when-the-government-buy...

[2] https://www.congress.gov/118/meeting/house/116192/documents/...

[3] https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2024/02/28/government...

nobody9999··on Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listening for human voices
That's all as may be.

And discussions of ALPRs and the issues around them are absolutely important.

My point was that the City of Evanston required their contractor (Flock) to remove their equipment from city infrastructure. Flock did so and then promptly reinstalled that equipment on city-owned infrastructure, flouting the will of the legitimate civil authority -- because they wanted to get paid by another government agency, against the express orders of said civil authority.

I don't know where you come from, but that sort of behavior just reeks of bad faith to me.

Feel free to disagree. And if you do, given your significant policy experience why Flock acted in good faith in Evanston. I'd be quite interested in your thoughts.

>I really don't think the "rhetorical" thing is going to work with me.

Huh? a rhetorical question[0] is (often) one that isn't actually trying to elicit information. My question, on the other hand, was specifically attempting to ascertain whether or not you think Flock is acting in good faith given their history.

So no, I wasn't trying to "gotcha" you (as in "when did you stop beating your wife" kind of thing), I genuinely wanted your take. But that doesn't seem to be forthcoming, so I'll back off. Have a good day.

I hope it's worth it.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhetorical_question

nobody9999··on California needs to learn from Houston and Dallas about homelessness
>It does, though, and the article I linked explains what actually happens:

And I disagree with your analysis. That's not an attack on you or The Guardian for that matter.

While there certainly are programs as you mention, there are (and have been for decades) others that do not seek to reunite people with support systems -- rather they just want those pesky homeless people gone.

Out of sight, out of mind and all that.

nobody9999··on Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listening for human voices
>Because the question was whether I'm commenting in good faith.

Perhaps others have asked that question. I have not. Rather, I'm asking a different question:

Why should we believe that Flock is operating in good faith?

Especially given the anti-democratic (small 'd') and likely illegal stuff they pulled in Evanston[0].

That's not a rhetorical question.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45382434

nobody9999··on California needs to learn from Houston and Dallas about homelessness
>The reality is a lot more complicated

Reality is always more complicated than a one-liner. Surprise, surprise.

But that doesn't make it a "myth." Rather it's more municipalities and more disposable people being "disposed" of.

That doesn't make it right and certainly shouldn't normalize such practices -- that said, it's a little late now.

nobody9999··on Apple takes down ICE tracking apps after pressure from DOJ
>Maybe in our (very near?) cyber punk future, it's not only goverments that we should be concerned about. After all, we have some measure of input regarding the goverment.

Why shouldn't we already be concerned about the corporations? They've been slurping our data and selling it for a profit for my whole life[0].

Sure, that sort of behavior started with banks and other financial institutions, but has extended, over the decades, to consumer products companies (P&G, General Mills, etc.) and to retailers (Walmart, Target, etc.), then into internet search (Google, Bing), "social" media (the Meta conglomerate, etc.), hardware and software companies (Apple, Google, Microsoft, etc.), communication devices (Apple, Google, Samsung, etc.), consumer electronics (LG, Samsung, GE, Maytag), Automobiles (GM, Chrysler, Nissan, Toyota, etc., etc., etc.) and "IoT" devices (Amazon, Google and a host of others) are all hoovering up as much information as they can to both sell (and governments as well as other corporations are buying and paying through the nose) and use for "targeted" ads.

Isn't your refrigerator showing you ads, your TV recording what you're doing while you use it, your phone reporting pretty much everywhere you go, everything you do and everyone with whom you communicate, social media apps recording every key stroke, even if it doesn't end up in a post, your car tracking both your movements and your driving behavior, your internet searches used to create detailed shadow profiles of your interests and purchasing habits. I could go on and on and on. Corporations are collecting levels of private data on people that would have been beyond the Stasi's[1] wildest dreams.

And so I'll ask again, when, exactly, should we "start" to be concerned about corporate surveillance?

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_Credit_Reporting_Act#Hist...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stasi

nobody9999··on California needs to learn from Houston and Dallas about homelessness
>SF tried, didn't work. The homeless population increased, not offset by the people who got housed.

IIRC, For decades, the homeless "relief" programs run by states like Florida, Georgia, South Carolina and others pretty much ended at bus tickets to San Francisco for the homeless (whether they wanted to go or not) and that's it.

Is it any wonder the population of homeless in SF grew?

nobody9999··on YouTube says it'll bring back creators banned for Covid and election content
>> How is that not the case now?

>The protocol allows servers, rather than users, to ban other servers. Servers should be only the dumbest of pipes.

A fair point. A good fix for this is to have individual clients that can federate/post/receive/moderate/store content. IIUC, there is at least one client/server hybrid that does this. It's problematic for those who don't have the computing power and/or network bandwidth to run such a platform. But it's certainly something to work towards.

>> Are you suggesting that since ActivityPub isn't perfect, it should be discarded?

>I'm saying that by the time something like this has billions of users the protocol is going to be a lot harder to change, so you should fix the problems without delay instead of waiting until after that happens and getting deja vu all over again.

I'm still not seeing the "problems" with server usage you're referencing. Federation obviates the need for users to be on the same server and there's little, if any, monetary value in trying to create mega servers. Discoverability is definitely an issue, but (as you correctly point out) should be addressed. It is, however, a hard problem if we want to maintain decentralization.

>The thing that should be in your threat model is Gmail and Chrome and old school Microsoft EEE. Somebody sets up a big service that initially doesn't try to screw everyone, so it becomes popular. Then once they've captured a majority of users, they start locking out smaller competitors.

Given the landscape of the Fediverse, that seems incredibly unlikely. Perhaps I'm just pie in the sky on this, but those moving to ActivityPub platforms do so to get away from such folks.

Adding to that the ability to manage one's own content on one's own hardware with one's own tools, it seems to be a really unlikely issue.

Then again, I could absolutely be wrong. I hope not. That said, I'm sure that suggestions for changes along the lines you suggest to the ActivityPub protocol[0][1][2] as a hedge against making it fall into a series of corporate hell holes, as you put it, "impossible," would be appreciated.

[0] https://github.com/w3c/activitypub

[1] https://activitypub.rocks/

[2] https://w3c.github.io/activitypub/

Edit: Clarified my thoughts WRT updates to the ActivityPub protocol.

← PreviousPage 11 of 34Next →