HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nobody9999

6,767 karma · joined July 8, 2020

submissionscomments
nobody9999··on The story of DOGE, as told by federal workers
>What do you expect happens if you take literally trillions of dollars out of capital markets?

What a ridiculous trope.

Where do you think those fairer taxes will go? They don't just disappear from existence as you imply. Rather they get plowed right back into the economy. Into the hands of Social Security recipients (so people like your grandmother may not have to go without eating or eat cat food to survive) who will spend most of it almost immediately, and for medical/healthcare products and services.

In that scenario, will such moneys be a net positive for you personally? Probably, as millions of folks won't be starving in the streets and dying of preventable causes because their only means of sustaining themselves has been co-opted so you can have your "number go up."

More economic activity from fairly collecting existing taxes (that's what buying groceries and shoes and prescriptions is) will increase the velocity of money and grow the economy faster than the hoarding you're advocating. And "number go up" will continue.

Don't care about anyone else but you? Enjoy seeing people suffer and die for your marginal benefit? If so, come out and say it. It's at least a defensible, if evil and selfish, argument -- unlike the ridiculous one you made.

nobody9999··on Ask HN: Would you try a crossword that changes around your answers?
>Would you try such a crossword?

As a long time cruciverbalist (40+ years), I would hate it.

Not because it's interactive, but because it adapts to the solver. Which kind of defeats the purpose of doing a crossword.

Which is to stretch your understanding of language and vocabulary. Adapting to "your solving speed and skill," is dumbing down the crossword -- which is the opposite of that.

Yuck!

nobody9999··on The story of DOGE, as told by federal workers
>That is not actually a simple fix. You're proposing a 15.3% tax increase -- on top of all existing taxes -- on everyone who makes more than that amount of money

No. Not even close. It's not increasing anyone's taxes. It's just making them fairer. Most folks have to pay those taxes on all their income. Why should it be any different for the folks with the highest incomes?

What's more, I can say from experience that not paying SS/Medicare taxes over the arbitrary limit makes exactly zero material difference in my quality of life.

Whereas keeping SS/Medicare solvent while we figure out a better way will have a significant positive impact on my life and the lives of millions of others.

nobody9999··on The story of DOGE, as told by federal workers
>People like to criticize DOGE for going after smaller amounts (like hundreds of millions instead of tens of billions) but those are still hundreds of millions that could be put elsewhere, or even returned to the taxpayer or put towards federal debt. The biggest concern with DOGE is that much of the spending is just going to come right back during the next election cycle

Right. And those hundreds of millions went to tax cuts/benefits for the wealthiest (top 10%) among us, and less benefit to the bottom 10%, as well as trillions (3.8, in fact[0]) more in debt to actually pay for those cuts.

Yeah. We need more of that, right?

[0] https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-05/61422-Reconciliatio...

nobody9999··on The story of DOGE, as told by federal workers
>And we're talking about doing so before we ask the rich to pay (as Warren Buffet says) the same tax rates as their secretaries, and before we trim the military budget back to the levels requested by the military.

Yes, there are issues with Social Security and Medicare. Not least of which is that, at least for the next thirty years or so (at least until the baby boomers are mostly all dead -- not because I wish them ill, but because later generations are smaller, constraining the pool of contributors to SS/Medicare).

A simple fix (that would give us ~50 years to figure out how to do this better) would be to remove the income cap on SS/Medicare contributions. Currently, that's $176,100[0]. Doing so would keep SS/Medicare solvent long enough to figure out how to structure the safety net appropriately, without jeopardizing the health/well being of those who paid in expecting it to work for them too.

[0] https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc751

nobody9999··on US airlines are pushing to remove protections for passengers and add more fees
>Cutting "burdensome" and "costly" regulations

Reread my comment. I expect that at least one of the three (and maybe more, I pointed out three) groups you lumped together don't consider "consumer protections" to be burdensome or costly.

Did I not make that clear? Or are you deliberately missing my point?

>What a weird thing to be offended by.

Who said I was offended? I said I thought you were painting folks with too broad a brush. And the "folks:" to whom I referred didn't include me.

As such, I'm not offended by you. Or at least not WRT the broad brush you used. I can't say for sure, but your patronizing tone appears as to assume I'm not so bright. Which might offend me, except the source is some rando on the inter tubes (that'd be you in case you were confused).

So no. You haven't offended me. In fact, you gave me a chuckle. Thanks!

nobody9999··on YouTube says it'll bring back creators banned for Covid and election content
>but you need it to be architectured in such a way that no organization can capture the network effect in order to set up a choke point.

How is that not the case now?

>You need all moderation to be applied on the client, or you'll have large servers doing things like banning everyone from new/small independent servers by default so that people have to sign up with them instead.

I suppose. There are ActivityPub "clients" which act as interfaces that allow the former and act as agents for a single user interacting with other ActivityPub instances. which, I'd expect can take us most of the way you say we should go.

I haven't seen the latter, as there's really no incentive to do so. Meta tried doing so by federating (one-way) with threads, but that failed miserably as the incentives are exactly the opposite in the Fediverse.

I suppose that incentives can change, although money is usually the driver for that and monetization isn't prioritized there.

>The protocol needs to make that impossible or the long-term consequences are predictable.

Impossible? Are you suggesting that since ActivityPub isn't perfect, it should be discarded?

ActivityPub is easily 75% of where you say we should go. Much farther along that line than anything else. But since it's not 100% it should be abandoned/ignored?

I'm not so sure about your "long-term consequences" being predictable. Threads tried to do so and failed miserably. In fact, the distributed model made sure that it would, even though the largest instances did acquiesce.

ActivityPub is the best you're going to get right now. and the best current option for distributed social media.

Don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good.

Edit: I want to clarify that I'm not trying to dunk on anyone here. Rather, I'm not understanding (whether that's my own obtuseness or something else) the argument being made against ActivityPub in the comment to which I'm replying. Is there some overarching principle or actual data which supports the idea that all social media is doomed to create dystopian landscapes? Or am I missing something else here?

nobody9999··on US airlines are pushing to remove protections for passengers and add more fees
You mean this platform[0]? Not sure where it says they're going to "gut regulations and consumer protection." Perhaps you could point that part out to me?

I understood that to actually be the case, even though that wasn't actually included in the platform. Which is one of reasons I didn't vote for the current administration.

That said, I imagine that among those who did so, some folks are fine with it, some folks didn't care one way or another and some folks were unaware that this would happen.

As such, I think you're painting folks with far too broad a brush. Which is, I imagine, quite satisfying. I hope you got what you wanted out of that.

[0] https://rncplatform.donaldjtrump.com/

nobody9999··on YouTube says it'll bring back creators banned for Covid and election content
>We could have social media that no central entity controls, i.e. it works like the web and RSS instead of like Facebook. There are a billion feeds, every single account is a feed, but you subscribe to thousands of them at most. And then, most importantly, those feeds you subscribe to get sorted on the client.

The Fediverse[1] with ActivityPub[0]?

[0] https://activitypub.rocks/

[1] https://fediverse.party/

nobody9999··on In Maine, prisoners are thriving in remote jobs
Of course they do. Criminals are everywhere.

Anyone driving more than 30m/h over the speed limit is guilty of reckless driving. That's a criminal.

Anyone using controlled substances (including cannabis) is a criminal.

Anyone driving under the influence of drugs or alcohol is a criminal.

Anyone watching their kids while drunk/high -- a criminal.

And dozens of other things folks do every single day. Makes them criminals.

In fact, GP is almost certainly a criminal. Throw them in prison!

nobody9999··on They Thought They Were Free (1955)
>But it is also disingenuous to say it's just about a group of people who want to be left alone as in the original comment I responded to.

That's true. They want to be treated like everyone else, not discriminated against and berated (cf. pretty much all of this user's posting history[0]), beaten and murdered. Are those the "special rights" you meant?

>Your elaboration of the stages as I stated them has some pithy truth in it but really just confirms its accuracy. You can read all you want into how I describe the stages but description is not advocacy. I'm not advocating anything really.

Mayhap you are and mayhap you ain't. But you certainly did uncritically include bigoted stereotypes and lies/tropes that have been used pretty much forever. I guess I'll have to keep waiting for you to prove me wrong. And more's the pity.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=bobalob

nobody9999··on They Thought They Were Free (1955)
Yes. Go away you bigoted troll.
nobody9999··on Disney+ cancellation page crashes as customers rush to quit
>I was focused on that one specific argument. I agree that he shouldn't have been taken off the air by the FCC regardless of what he said (unless he explicitly encourages violent action against an individual or group of people be taken, ie illegal speech).

I get that. I wasn't attacking you even a little. Yours was a reasonable and cogent argument.

I'm just pointing out that care should be taken with those who aren't operating in good faith. Because such folks will throw your words back in your face without regard for context or nuance.

Because they care nothing for the truth, just for their own feeling of rightness and will to power whether that be political power or just "pwning the libs."

nobody9999··on They Thought They Were Free (1955)
>I'm not attacking anyone. I am describing what I observed as a relative outsider of the social process that has occurred in the last ten years or so.

You said:

>I think the reality of what has gone on has several faces which are all worth thinking about:

And then listed a bunch of innocuous stuff, as well as lies/tropes that bigots have used as an excuse to demonize minorities the world over, well, forever. Let's turn the clock back sixty years or so and change the focus from "transgender folks" to "African Americans." Perhaps then you'll see what got my dander up.

1. A group of people that want to be different without harming anyone and be left alone

(check!)

2. A group of people demanding certain specific and new legal rights with respect to how they are different

(yeah, those n*****s want to eat in our restaurants and swim in our public pools, have decent schools and even be allowed to buy houses near us! Why should they get special rights like that?)

3. A group of people advocating for new social and linguistic norms around said difference

(Yeah, we've called them darkies n****r for hundreds of years! What's wrong with these uppity pieces of shit? Black? African American? What a bunch of crap!)

3. A group of people socially shaming people who failed to respect said norms

(Yeah, what's wrong with these "language" police? I call a spade a spade -- or a n****r a n****r. What the hell is wrong with that? It's freedom of speech! Those fuckin' n*****s making demands? WTF?)

4. A group of people socially shaming those who opposed new specific legal rights

(Yeah! What's wrong with all those folks telling me I have to allow these n*****s into my store/restaurant and not beat them half to death for trying and that I'm a bad person to boot if I don't! What's with these new and "special" rights for them? Why should I be blamed for not wanting to allow them to live like us white people -- they certainly don't deserve it!)

5. A group of people vocally opposing said legal and social changes

(Breaking out of the historical context here: What legal changes are you talking about? Extending the idea that we should all be treated equally under the law? Which laws. Be specific here please.)

6. A group of people advocating legal restrictions to prevent or punish said different life choices

( Okay, back to 1965 -- Yeah! those n*****s choose to be poor and uneducated! Look at Dr. King! He can even read and write -- who allowed that to happen?)*

7. A group of people fighting said restrictions

(And a good thing too. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965 were good things, although they're under more threat now than they were sixty years ago)*

>Broadly I would like people to be able to live as they want and identify themselves as they like. I don't really understand your comment.

Perhaps, perhaps not. I don't know you.

I added (with the 8.) that the trans population is incredibly tiny -- yet folks spend an inordinate amount of time (including you making the assertion that trans folks are advocating for "new and special rights" that no one else gets -- what rights might those be? And be specific here) claiming they're trying to destroy our culture and corrupt our children with their Marxist beliefs.

Ridiculous tropes on their face. And you uncritically portrayed those tropes as truth, when in fact they're lies designed to demonize other folks.

As such, I have difficulty with your claim that you just want to live and let live.

Prove me wrong. At least as far as you and I are concerned, nothing would make me happier.

nobody9999··on They Thought They Were Free (1955)
8. A tiny (less than 1% of the population) group of people who you are (somehow) imbuing with enormous power and clout in our society, even those these are people who have been loudly derided, shamed, beaten and even killed by a sizable group of folks in our society.

Leave those folks alone, for heaven's sake. If you don't like them, stay away from them. If you don't want to give them simple human respect, it's legal to be an asshole.

All this anger/hatred focused on a tiny group. What gives you (or me or anyone else, for that matter) the right to tell other people how they should live -- especially when it doesn't affect you in the slightest.

People don't just "choose" to be transgender. And they certainly don't choose to do so because of the much higher risk of discrimination, abuse, violence and murder.

Did I mention that trans folks are an incredibly tiny sliver of the population (<1%)?

nobody9999··on They Thought They Were Free (1955)
>There are always enough likeminded people that you can't end a horrible reign just by killing the leader.

An excellent point. Just look at the line of succession to the Presidency right now[0]:

No. Office Incumbent Party

1 Vice President JD Vance Republican

2 Speaker of the House of Representatives Mike Johnson Republican

3 President pro tempore of the Senate Chuck Grassley Republican

4 Secretary of State Marco Rubio Republican

5 Secretary of the Treasury Scott Bessent Republican

6 Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth Republican

7 Attorney General Pam Bondi Republican

8 Secretary of the Interior Doug Burgum Republican

9 Secretary of Agriculture Brooke Rollins Republican

10 Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick Republican

11 Secretary of Labor Lori Chavez-DeRemer Republican

12 Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Independent

13 Secretary of Housing and Urban Development Scott Turner Republican

14 Secretary of Transportation Sean Duffy Republican

15 Secretary of Energy Chris Wright Republican

16 Secretary of Education Linda McMahon Republican

17 Secretary of Veterans Affairs Doug Collins Republican

18 Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem Republican

Now which one is dedicated to the Constitution/rule of law?

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_presidential_lin...

nobody9999··on Disney+ cancellation page crashes as customers rush to quit
>They asked what was controversial about what he said, not whether the FCC's actions were constitutional.

The former is (for some at least) interesting. The latter is actually consequential. I'm concerned about the latter.

The former, whether I agree or not, is about legal, protected political speech.

nobody9999··on Disney+ cancellation page crashes as customers rush to quit
>You're ignoring the part of the quote where he implied the killer was MAGA or MAGA affiliated. For reference the full quote is:

He did not. But even if he did, so what?

Does either interpretation make his comment somehow illegal and deserving of government threats to retaliate against folks unless Kimmel was punished?

That's not a rhetorical question.

IMNSHO, you're focusing on the wrong thing here. What difference does it make what legal speech was used? The problem is that the government is trying to silence the critics of those currently in power. And at least in the US, the government isn't allowed to do that -- whether they're critics of the current administration or not.

If you don't decry that, it could be you and yours next. You've been warned.

nobody9999··on Disney+ cancellation page crashes as customers rush to quit
>Mafia threats work precisely because of perception. The perception of the power is the power. If everyone caves, and can't fight back, the mafia gets stronger.

The US government is constrained by the Constitution. It is legally barred from acting like a mafia.

Don't try to normalize that. While you may think you're safe, Mr. Niemoller would like a word.

nobody9999··on Disney+ cancellation page crashes as customers rush to quit
>That isn't the same and you know it. Kimmel made no direct comment about what the shooter was aligned with, only about what the right wing sphere was attempting to frame them as being. Anyone with a moderate grasp of English should be able to tell the difference.

You're falling into the "trap." Which is that even though you're correct, the way it's being framed is having you defend Kimmel WRT what he did say rather than his right to say all kinds of stuff -- including the stuff they claim he said, but didn't.

Even if Kimmel had said that Robinson was absolutely a MAGAt with ties to literal neo-nazis (the groypers), that's still protected speech.

He didn't go that far (and it may or may not be true), but his right to free expression is what needs to be protected.

While you don't see it that way, the folks with whom you're arguing can come back later and say, "well, scheeseman486 agreed that if Kimmel had called Robinson a MAGA and/or a Nazi, that was a bridge too far. So now that Fallon/whoever said something similar, off to prison for him, because even those baby molesting/eating librul freaks agree!"

Don't fall into that trap. The Federal (and through the 14th Amendment, state and local) government is forbidden from taking action against legal speech, full stop.

Fight against that -- don't let yourself be hemmed in to a corner by those who don't want or care about freedom of expression unless it's theirs.

nobody9999··on ABC yanks Jimmy Kimmel’s show ‘indefinitely’ after threat from FCC chair
Amazing how my defense of the First Amendment (in a sibling comment) earned flagging and death.

Is that the death rattle for the First Amendment? I hope not

nobody9999··on ABC yanks Jimmy Kimmel’s show ‘indefinitely’ after threat from FCC chair
>I, too, remember when Obama has the FCC commissioner threaten to revoke broadcast licenses for the coverage of his tan suit.

I can't find any specific references to that. Is there a statement from an FCC commissioner or from Obama when he was president?

I'd really like to see such statements.

nobody9999··on ABC yanks Jimmy Kimmel’s show ‘indefinitely’ after threat from FCC chair
>I think people wouldn't have wanted to work with me or listen to my opinions.

If I was your co-worker, I wouldn't want to know your non-work related opinions, especially your political opinions. That assumes we're not working on someone's political campaign.

Your opinions that don't relate to your job are irrelevant -- at work. And as such, why would anyone, whether they agree with you or not, want to hear you (or anyone else) pontificate about how you "Like Ike" and that his Vice President would make a much better President than that (gasp!) Catholic, rum-runner/gangster's son from Massachusetts.

Yes, I'm deliberately using examples from 65+ years ago. Because it doesn't matter what the content of those opinions are. Unless you work for the RNCC or the DNC, etc. those opinions have no value or meaning in the workplace.

I'm not afraid to express my opinions, but I choose not to do so while I'm actively on the job. That you do it out of fear is, on the one hand, unfortunate but, on the other hand, a good thing as no one really wants to hear them anyway.

Keep up the good work!

>And I never voice any political opinions at work because I don't want to say anything my peers would perceive as "abhorrent".

Good. I'm sure that, regardless of how you think your peers would perceive your opinions, they are much less interested in those opinions than they are about the quality and quantity of your work, your opinions of the work and work environment, and how you interact on a personal level with others.

Edit: Fixed typo.

nobody9999··on ABC yanks Jimmy Kimmel’s show ‘indefinitely’ after threat from FCC chair
It was implied, but apparently, not clearly enough.

The issue is emphatically not that "Kimmel dissed our boy. He needs to be raked over the coals!" Nor is it "Kimmel had it just right! Fuck those MAGAts!"

The current controversy, while relevant to the above, is not the problem. What people think and believe and most[0] of what they say is, at least under current law in the US, not punishable by the state.

A government official (Brendan Carr) publicly threatened legal action, using the weight and resources of the Federal Government (don't believe me, listen to him say it yourself) against ABC/Disney[1] in retaliation for the legal (however you may feel about it) speech of Jimmy Kimmel.

Now you might think, "well so what? that jackass is always harassing the President and his most patriotic team. And now he's doing so about our beloved cultural ambassador, gunned down by some tranny loving freak just a few days ago. That sack of crap deserves whatever he gets!"

And you have every right to think that. And to speak it or write it or take out web/TV/print/billboard/etc. ads.

And you think, "Damn straight! I got rights. The First Amendment says the government can't punish me for what I say or think! And it's not a coincidence that it's the First one, is it?" And you're right.

If all that is true, especially the First Amendment[2] bit:

   Congress shall make no law [...] abridging the freedom of speech, or 
   of the press; [...]
  
Which, as centuries of jurisprudence have confirmed, aside from a few (none of which apply in this particular context) exceptions[0], the government may not punish folks for what they say.

Which is exactly what Brendan Carr threatened to do with the resources of the FCC if ABC/Disney didn't take action against Kimmel.

Which is facially a violation of the Constitution (of which the First Amendment is an integral part), which is the supreme law of the land.

And so whether you think Kimmel was out of line or not, something we all should be able to get behind is that the government has no place telling us what we can or cannot say.

A right that Charlie Kirk took advantage of and was proud to extol. And good for him -- whether you agree with him or not. And if we (want to) live in a nation of laws, then Jimmy Kimmel (or you or me) should have the same rights and latitude.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_free_speech_exce...

[1] https://www.foxnews.com/media/fcc-chair-levels-threat-agains...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Amendment_to_the_United_...

nobody9999··on Stephen Miller's Quota Likely Drove Korean Arrests in Immigration Raid
Actually, it was ~30% of the voting population.

According to Wikipedia[0]:

Trump/Vance received 77,302,580 votes (49.8% of votes cast)

Harris/Walz received 75,017,613 votes (48.3% of votes cast)

Total votes cast: 152,320,193.

Those in the US eligible to vote[1]: ~250-260 million.

77,302,580/250,000,000 == ~0.3 or 30%.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_United_States_presidentia...

[1] https://www2.census.gov/library/publications/decennial/2020/... [PDF]

nobody9999··on ABC yanks Jimmy Kimmel’s show ‘indefinitely’ after threat from FCC chair
The link you referenced[0] also includes this:

   A 2017 report by The Nation Institute and the Center for Investigative 
   Reporting analyzed a list of the terrorist incidents which occurred in the US 
   between 2008 and 2016.[27] It found:[28]

   115 far-right inspired terrorist incidents. 35% of these incidents were 
   foiled (this number means that no terrorist attacks occurred) and 29% of them 
   resulted in fatalities. These incidents caused 79 deaths.
   
   63 Islamist inspired terrorist incidents. 76% of these terrorist incidents 
   were foiled (this number means that no terrorist attacks occurred) and 13% of 
   them resulted in fatalities. These incidents caused 90 deaths.

   19 far-left inspired terrorist incidents. 20% of these terrorist incidents 
   were foiled (this number means that no terrorist attacks occurred) and 10% of 
   them resulted in fatalities. Two of these incidents were described as 
   "plausibly" attributed to a perpetrator with left-wing sympathies and caused 
   7 deaths. These are not included in the official government database.[15]
So out of 197 incidents reported between 2008 and 2016, 58% were "Far Right" inspired, 32% were "Islamist" inspired and 10% were "Far left" inspired.

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terrorism_in_the_United_Stat...

nobody9999··on ABC yanks Jimmy Kimmel’s show ‘indefinitely’ after threat from FCC chair
>So yes, ABC/Nexstar are within their editorial rights to make this decision, but that decision came at an awfully conspicuous time. So what, nothing to see here?

{Paraphrasing for those who don't get it]

Brendan Carr: That Kimmel guy sure is a pill. Will no one rid me of this meddlesome comic?

Hey ABC, It would be a shame if something bad happened to you guys, wouldn't it? In fact, let's do some investigating to make sure everything is on the up and up, yeah?[0]

ABC: How High?

[0] Right out of the authoritarians' playbook: "For my friends, everything. For my enemies, the law."

nobody9999··on Top UN legal investigators conclude Israel is guilty of genocide in Gaza
https://ny1.com/nyc/all-boroughs/news/2025/09/10/mamdani-hol...
nobody9999··on Robert Redford has died
Don't forget Three Days of the Condor[0] in which he's supported by a fabulous cast as well.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Days_of_the_Condor

nobody9999··on Man jailed for parole violations after refusing to decrypt his Tor node
>Pretty sure the questions start and end with “was it illegal”.

Disclaimer: I don't have any skin in this game or association with any government, any law enforcement agency, nor do I know the person discussed or (at least as far as I know) anyone who knows that person. And IANAL.

IIUC (and I may not), the guy was on probation[0], which is release from or in lieu of prison.

If someone is on probation, they are still under the authority of the (in this case Federal) judicial/prison authority which sentenced them.

It is (whether you think it's right or not) normal for restrictions to be placed upon those on probation, including random drug tests, restrictions on certain types of behavior (this is often related to the crime(s) for which they've been convicted).

Often, this also provides for warrantless searches and other privacy-invading stuff as part of the probation agreement. I'd note that (again, IIUC) that the convicted person must agree to the terms of probation or they will have to go to (or not be released from) prison to serve their (remaining) sentence.

Violation of the terms of probation (as is clearly defined in probation agreements) may result in imprisonment to complete the sentence imposed by the court after trial or (as it was in this case) a plea bargain.

I am unfamiliar with the case at hand, but sending someone to (or back to) prison for violating probation is the stick which (presumably) keeps people from re-offending and/or violating the terms of their probation, at least until they complete the term of probation.

[0] https://www.uscourts.gov/about-federal-courts/probation-and-...

← PreviousPage 12 of 34Next →