HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nobody9999

6,767 karma · joined July 8, 2020

submissionscomments
nobody9999··on Arizona Bill Requires Age Verification for All Apps
>I agree regarding listserv and NNTP. It's questionable whether IRC and IM would be treated as "publishers" without sec 230.

Firstly, the concept of "publisher" is irrelevant to Section 230, then and now. IRC and IM (at least chat rooms) require servers to host the back and forth. As such, the issues were exactly the same as with email or usenet. Section 230 protects the hosts of any platform that allows third-party content. Full stop. This whole "publisher vs. platform" thing is a canard and a malicious attempt to muddy the waters. The law itself does not make such a distinction, nor does the case law surrounding it.

>Perhaps your coming up was a little earlier than mine? My perspective included things like gnutella and edonkey. There was a general feeling of building new application protocols to support new types of applications. Hard problems that needed to be figured out, for sure. But also background baseline values of people running software they choose on their own computers.

Sure, I was aware of gnutella and edonkey and other peer to peer file sharing tools. And yes, you're correct that there was much discussion of peer to peer applications for, well, almost everything. And even before that, there was KA9Q[0] which I ran on my PC/XT back in 1990. But none of that really went anywhere once NCSA-Mosaic[1] was released and the web (as you mention below) was born.

>For protocols, there was also websites themselves. Someone with something to say would host their own. And some rough solutions for distributed discovery there like webrings.

Right, and Section 230 protected (and still does!) the hosts of those sites too, while Mark Zuckerberg was in middle school.

>Yes. All of the high-cost productization/advertising work to make software palatable to normies doesn't get done, because investment money heads towards technical architectures that are more capable of exfiltrating value from end users. So any software still based around representing the interests of its users gets relegated to developers scratching their own itch.

On that I kind of disagree. It's not so much that the normies aren't interested. They certainly would be if the could click to download and then follow an install script to set it up, and it just works.

Going all the way back to Diaspora[2], to pixelfed, mastodon and it's offshoots, etc., I've set up a variety of open source platforms that tried to fulfill that dream of personal ownership/possession of one's content.

As a technical person, most of them were installable with significant complexities, but none were simple to install for the non-technical user.

And that is/was because the developers didn't make it that way, not any sort of malicious conspiracy. In fact, I recall some discussion around Diaspora, with the developers saying they preferred to focus on functionality rather than ease of installation.

The developers of Fediverse projects have continued in that vein.

tl;dr, I think we're mostly in agreement here, but you seem to be a little confused about how Section 230 works/worked. No matter. It's all good. I certainly appreciate the discussion and your perspective. Thanks!

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KA9Q

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NCSA_Mosaic

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diaspora_(social_network)

nobody9999··on Wikipedia deprecates Archive.today, starts removing archive links
Thanks for the correction. I can't type the letter 'a'[0].

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ewY8CnFae0&t=56s

nobody9999··on Wikipedia deprecates Archive.today, starts removing archive links
I just quoted the very next paragraph after the sentence you quoted and asked for clarification.

I did so. You're welcome.

As for the rest, take it up with Jimmy Wiles, not me.

nobody9999··on Wikipedia deprecates Archive.today, starts removing archive links
>> an analysis of existing links has shown that most of its uses can be replaced.

>Oh? Do tell!

They do. In the very next paragraph in fact:

   The guidance says editors can remove Archive.today links when the original 
   source is still online and has identical content; replace the archive link so 
   it points to a different archive site, like the Internet Archive, 
   Ghostarchive, or Megalodon; or “change the original source to something that 
   doesn’t need an archive (e.g., a source that was printed on paper)
nobody9999··on Facebook is cooked
>Is there a problem with my name being green?

Not as such, no. However, new accounts (which show up as green) tend to get less attention and more downvotes. When I first joined that annoyed and confused me, but after a while (when my name was no longer green), folks seemed more accepting of my comments and submissions.

As the eminent philosopher opined, "It Ain't Easy Being Green"[0]. Although I believe their ruminations predate HN.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rRZ-IxZ46ng

nobody9999··on Arizona Bill Requires Age Verification for All Apps
>There was the better part of the decade after the CDA passed that the tech community was still focused on protocols that worked this way.

Which protocols? I was designing and implementing networks throughout the 90s and aughts and I really don't know what you're talking about. Perhaps I wasn't in the right place at the right time?

Email mailing lists? IRC? Instant Messaging? NNTP? Those all would have been vulnerable to frivolous and malicious lawsuits without Section 230.

Honestly, I'm at a loss here. Please do enlighten me as to which protocols you're referring.

>I then want all of these messages stitched together to form a cohesive presentation on each person's computer, by software that represents their interests.

Sounds like you want personal ActivityPub platforms. I'm all for that. But nothing even approximating that existed in the 1990s. In fact, there's nothing like that now that a non-technical person can host for themselves.

nobody9999··on DOGE Track
>And. I'd like to see something similar for Project 2025.

https://www.project2025.observer/en

https://progressivereform.org/tracking-trump-2/project-2025-...

nobody9999··on DOGE Track
>This sort of deranged rhetoric doesn't win anybody over to your side. It's more likely to do the opposite.

That's odd. The Federal government is specifically using that data to (incompetently, at least for now) inappropriately disenfranchise people[0]

So no. Not deranged, actually happening[0] right now.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47003975

nobody9999··on Arizona Bill Requires Age Verification for All Apps
>My point was that if we never had section 230 to begin with, then we would have kept the strong incentive against setting up sites revolving around centralizing speech in the first place.

Where did you get that idea? Section 230 never provided any preference or privilege to large organizations over small ones.

In fact, it did exactly the opposite for reasons I discussed. You say that without Section 230:

   ...lots of small sites that would find themselves in an uncomfortable 
   position.
That doesn't even come close to covering it. Without Section 230, your aunt would take down her knitting pattern discussion website/chat room/mailing list/whatever within half a day, with whoever it was posting something objectionable (or just off topic) and when your aunt deletes it, file a lawsuit claiming censorship.

How long is your aunt going to keep the completely free and volunteer site up when she has to pay lawyers $5-10K every week? And if she doesn't delete it, continue to flood the site with garbage until it's unusable, turning a knitting discussion site into 4/8chan.

All while doing nothing to stop the big boys from creating a dystopian hellhole because they have legions of lawyers on staff.

In fact, without Section 230, $BigCorp and/or other bad actors wouldn't even need to buy out their competition or wage costly efforts to destroy them, just post oceans of objectionable/off topic stuff, sue if it's taken down or wait for it to go under because its awash in garbage they posted there to make it unusable.

If we never had, or got rid of Section 230, your preferred candidate or issue advocacy group could trivially be taken down through these tactics, stifling free expression. Think fake DMCA take downs, but without recourse except through $500/hour lawyers and the courts.

Not sure where you got the idea that Section 230 ever was some sort of "giveaway" to big companies to encourage centralization. It was not, and even today it primarily protects the little guy, just as it did 30 years ago.

Do you have your mind made up and no amount of actual evidence will change it?

If not, feel free to check out the following:

https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/R46751#_Toc155275791

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratton_Oakmont,_Inc._v._Prod....

https://www.techdirt.com/2020/06/23/hello-youve-been-referre...

https://www.propublica.org/article/nsu-section-230

https://theconversation.com/law-that-built-the-internet-turn...

There's lots more of that to be found, but don't believe me. Check it out for yourself. Thanks to Section 230, among other things, you can.

nobody9999··on Arizona Bill Requires Age Verification for All Apps
>Serious question: why can't Meta, Google, and friends just decide not to serve Arizona?

I'll answer your serious question with one of my own. What incentive would Meta, Google and friends have to "decide not to serve Arizona"?

What is the business model of these companies? To make you view ads and charge advertisers more for "targeted" ads. Having age (which ends up being ID) verification gives them more tools to "target" ads and thus can charge more for the ad space they sell.

I'd say that these folks would be among the last to fight against something like this.

And so I'll reiterate my question: What incentives do these corporations have for opposing such legislation?

I'd say zero. In fact, I'd argue that their business models incentivize them to support such legislation.

nobody9999··on Arizona Bill Requires Age Verification for All Apps
>Not sure how common it is now, but based on repair manuals my TV's wifi is provided by a standard m.2 wifi module and can be trivially removed

Or just do egress filtering[0] on your router and block the device from communicating with the Internet. No disassembly required.

I block all access to/from my "smart" TV at my firewall/router and it works just fine.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egress_filtering

nobody9999··on Arizona Bill Requires Age Verification for All Apps
>The point is that the moral hazard created by sec 230 is precisely what has allowed the centralized social media industry to grow to the point it has.

That's exactly the opposite of what Section 230 has done.

Section 230 doesn't stop anyone from suing folks who defame or otherwise break the law. Rather, it specifies that those who say such things are the proper target, not the platforms that host such third-party speech.

And that's the important point. Section 230 covers third-party speech. Because litigation is expensive. As such, it mostly protects the little guy who doesn't have the resources to fight tens, hundreds or thousands of lawsuits because some folks don't like the restaurant/movie reviews or opinions about the quality of book plots or political speech or the Epstein Files or a myriad of other things that folks don't like and wish people would shut up about.

Nothing stops an aggrieved part from suing an individual for the things that individual says. But Section 230 says you can't sue the platform (say the website, Matrix or XMPP server you personally host) for the speech of a third-party who uses that platform.

In the absence of Section 230, huge, deep-pocketed companies like Facebook, Google, Twitter, et. al can pay for legions of lawyers to fight such lawsuits.

Do you have such deep pockets? Not all Internet content exists on those huge, deep-pocketed platforms. Many useful and interesting sites hosted by individuals or small businesses exist, but would be put out of business in a week if Section 230 didn't exist.

Getting rid of Section 230 would only cement the huge platforms' dominance and make them more unaccountable and powerful. Is that your goal? Not saying it is, but it's important to think through the impact of Section 230 beyond the (false and misleading) pronouncements of those who want to control you, your speech and the means of disseminating that speech.

nobody9999··on America's pensions can't beat Vanguard but they can close a hospital
>The act of maintaining a central database of funds so that individuals can transfer money to one another is a relatively simple and cheap problem, one perfectly suited to be provided by the government. It should be infrastructure, just like printing money is infrastructure under the purview of the government.

You mean like FedNow[0], which many banks are eschewing in favor of services life Zelle[1]?

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FedNow

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zelle

nobody9999··on Long-term unemployment is becoming 'a status quo' in today's job market
>Employers pay variable UI premiums and state UI funds now use Experience Ratings to increase insurance premiums on those companies where employees are not being fired for-cause

That's as may be, but we're specifically talking about firing people for cause, which makes the terminated employee ineligible for UI benefits.

And even if it was as you say, unemployment insurance is just another cost of doing business and, as such, is tax deductible as a business expense.

The wall of text notwithstanding, your "argument" is sorely lacking in relevance to the topic at hand.

I tried reading your diatribe as if it were in good faith, but the best I could do WRT that was assume you were uninformed.

Have a good day and I wish you nothing but happiness and success.

nobody9999··on Long-term unemployment is becoming 'a status quo' in today's job market
>It's much riskier to hire the wrong employee now. If a bad hire is made, it takes around 2 quarters to build the paper trail needed to be litigation-proof when firing.

Now? That's been the case since at least the 1980s, at least in non-union jobs.

What makes you think things were different before the "now" you reference?

nobody9999··on Amazon's Ring and Google's Nest reveal the severity of U.S. surveillance state
Thank you for your expert opinion. Unlike yourself and your colleague[0], I am not an expert on voting systems and infrastructure.

I am just a consumer of such things and have exactly zero say in my town's approach to voting.

I do know that RCV is better than FPTP, even more so if we don't, at least, require a majority, and am glad my town is at least making a start at such things.

That said, I'd love to make it even better.

As I suggested[1] to your colleague, it would be terrific if your expertise could be used to improve the voting system where I live.

I'd expect that the folks[2] who make such decisions could be convinced to re-frame things in another referendum based upon the recommendations of you and your organization. I know I'd certainly appreciate it!

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47035812

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47036908

[2] https://www.vote.nyc/page/contact-us

nobody9999··on Amazon's Ring and Google's Nest reveal the severity of U.S. surveillance state
>It sounds like the local ranked-choice implementation is unnecessarily complex and constrained. A simple "rank all candidates from 1 (most preferred) to n (least preferred)" for n candidates seems like the better solution.

I'm sure you're right. Unfortunately, I'm not the person you'd need to convince.

Here's contact information[0] for the relevant folks, and thanks for taking an interest. I'm sure my fellow townspeople will be grateful for your guidance. You have my thanks for stepping up to help us improve our voting systems!

For your reference, here's some background on the how the process came to be[1][2][3][4]

[0] https://www.vote.nyc/page/contact-us

[1] https://ballotpedia.org/New_York_City_Ballot_Question_1,_Ele...

[2] https://apnews.com/article/nyc-ranked-choice-voting-explaine...

[3] https://rankthevotenyc.org/history-of-rcv-in-nyc/

[4] https://rankthevotenyc.org/what-we-learned-from-new-york-cit...

nobody9999··on Amazon's Ring and Google's Nest reveal the severity of U.S. surveillance state
>A ranked choice ballot at least requires you to assign a unique value to every candidate on the ballot: you can honestly rank your second choice without being concerned that doing so undermines your first.

That's highly implementation dependent. Where I live we have ranked-choice ballots for local primary elections, while the local general elections are FPTP. State and Federal elections are all FPTP for primary and general elections.

While I am free to rank up to five candidates when filling out my ballot, I am not required to use all five choices.

I can just ignore all that if I choose and just rank one candidate first and leave the rest of the ballot blank. Or I can rank multiple candidates, but I'm not required to "assign a unique value to every candidate on the ballot."

In fact, if there are more than five candidates for a particular office, I can only rank five of them.

All that said, I'm absolutely in favor of RCV and wish we had it for all elections, not just local primary elections.

nobody9999··on Binance fires investigators found evidence of Iranian sanctions violations
https://archive.ph/3MSoe

Original Title:

Exclusive: Binance fires top investigators who claim to have uncovered evidence of Iranian sanctions violations

nobody9999··on Babylon 5 is now free to watch on YouTube
>I liked B5 far more, it tended to show people as real people.

Absolutely. I just rewatched S02E05 ("The Long Dark") that had Dwight Schultz[0] as a guest star.

While watching it (and not for the first time), it occurred to me that in that one single episode on Babylon 5, Schultz showed us more humanity than in all the dozen or so Star Trek: TNG/Voyager episodes he was in as Lieutenant Barclay.

In both roles, Shultz's character is emotionally damaged, which causes problems for them, but in the Star Trek roles it's mostly played for comedy and the issues around his dysfunction aren't addressed at all.

As the B5 character, his PTSD (based on serious trauma as a soldier) made him a homeless substance abuser. The plot pushed him to examine and face the source of his trauma. While I wouldn't call it a "powerful" performance, the B5 character was much more believable and human than the ST character.

Same actor, incredibly different on-screen results.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dwight_Schultz

nobody9999··on Babylon 5 is now free to watch on YouTube
That's the pilot (The Gathering), not S01E01.

S01E01 is "Midnight on the Firing Line"[0]

[0] https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x8h1hey

nobody9999··on Babylon 5 is now free to watch on YouTube
>The Vorlons are really a_____!

If you believe the actors on the DVD alternate commentary tracks, a Wurlitzer!

nobody9999··on Babylon 5 is now free to watch on YouTube
>Isn't the linked YouTube video title literally "Season 1, Episode 1"?

Yes and no It's the pilot (and consequently the first[2]) episode "The Gathering", which actually doesn't have an episode number.[0]

The first aired episode was S1E1 "Midnight on the Firing Line".

The former was released as a "TV Movie" even though it was the pilot episode.

[0] http://www.midwinter.com/lurk/countries/us/eplist.html for the episode listings.[1]

[1] Be careful, a wrong click can end up giving you spoilers. :(

[2] I'd note that the pilot episode has significant personnel, prop and make-up differences from the rest of the series.

nobody9999··on Babylon 5 is now free to watch on YouTube
>I would give my left kidney for either a continuation or a reboot of Babylon 5 under the helm of J. Michael Straczynski with full creative freedom. Or hell, even an entirely different show.

There has been discussion about a reboot over the years, with JMS throwing some cold water[0] (at least for now) on the possibility in January 2026.

There's sort of a "continuation" with Babylon 5: The Road Home[1] from 2023.

There's also Crusade[2] which only ended up with a dozen or so episodes, although JMS had a multi-year story arc planned.

[0] https://www.ign.com/articles/j-michael-straczynski-is-being-...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Babylon_5:_The_Road_Home

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusade_%28TV_series%29

nobody9999··on Babylon 5 is now free to watch on YouTube
>I hear this a lot about B5, and I get a _sense_ of it myself,

The series creator and chief writer, J. Michael Straczynski was explicit about that: The Earth Government story arc is lifted straight from the fascist regimes of the 1930s and 1940s.

A significant amount of which we're seeing rebranded as MAGA in the US and other far-right movements elsewhere.

A good example would be the "anti-alien" frenzy in Babylon 5 as compared with the far-right's ridiculous tropes about the undocumented in the US.

There are a bunch more like Trump's obsession with personal loyalty and lack of any empathy is quite similar to Babylon 5's President Clarke.

As I mentioned, that story arc is based upon the fascist regimes of the '30s and '40s, they even have a "Neville Chamberlain"[0] analog[1] who loudly proclaims "Finally, we will at last know 'peace in our time'."

The biggest difference is that in the Babylon 5 universe, the fascist scum are much more competent than those IRL today.

There's lots more, and I'll echo the plaints of others here that Season 1 is uneven and appears meandering, but many of the plot points brought up in Season 1 end up paying off much later in the series.

I heartily recommend watching the series, not just for the parallels with some of our current circumstance, but because it's a good story with the entire five season story arc fleshed out from the beginning, with good character development and character driven story lines.

It was also the first live-action Sci-Fi series that made use of CGI for the space scenes, which was both very cool, but was also limited compared to today's SFX given that 30 second segments could take hours to render on the Unix workstations of the mid 1990s.

Is it perfect, no. But it's worth the effort to watch it IMNSHO.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neville_Chamberlain

[1] https://babylon5.fandom.com/wiki/Frederick_Lantze

nobody9999··on Skip the Tips: A game to select "No Tip" but dark patterns try to stop you
>The bad faith interpretation is claiming that tipping is racist,

That's not a bad faith interpretation, the origins of tipping in the US are absolutely based in bigotry.

>claiming that OP knows that it is racist and supports it for that reason.

A fair point. GP certainly did not assume good faith or give the comment to which they responded the most charitable reading.

My apologies for being somewhat knee-jerk about it, but I have a really big problem with bigotry (I am absolutely not claiming that you or the poster to whom GP replied are bigoted) and believe that decent people should call attention to bigotry, especially when it's embedded in society as the tipping culture is in the US.

Bigotry is ethically wrong and harms the societies which it infests. As I mentioned, I feel strongly about that.

If I was less than charitable with your response to calling out bigotry (GP's attempt to do so was rather ham-handed), my apologies.

nobody9999··on Skip the Tips: A game to select "No Tip" but dark patterns try to stop you
>If you have something to add to the conversation then just do that. Don't make bad faith interpretations and unsubstantiated accusations against people.

You mean like you just did?

Tipping culture in the US is absolutely rooted in bigotry[0][1][2][3][4][5][6][7]. That's not a "bad faith interpretation," it's well-documented history.

[0] https://www.epi.org/publication/rooted-racism-tipping/

[1] https://www.povertylaw.org/article/the-racist-history-behind...

[2] https://stop-tipping.org/history-of-tipping/

[3] https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2019/07/17/william-b...

[4] https://inequality.org/article/tipping-is-racist-and-harms-u...

[5] https://www.historynewsnetwork.org/article/the-racist-histor...

[6] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/tipping-jobs-history-slave-wage...

[7] https://time.com/5404475/history-tipping-american-restaurant...

nobody9999··on A Federal Tool to Check Voter Citizenship Keeps Making Mistakes
Original Title too long:

“Not Ready for Prime Time.” A Federal Tool to Check Voter Citizenship Keeps Making Mistakes.

nobody9999··on US businesses and consumers pay 90% of tariff costs, New York Fed says
>This was a huge part of the platform that the US overwhelmingly voted for in the last election. People wanted this.

Please define "overwhelmingly" in this context.

A plurality (Not a majority), with a a small margin of victory (1.5%) at that of voters voted for the eventual winner.

In fact, more people didn't vote at all[0] than voted for the winner. As such, I don't understand your use of that adverb.

It's entirely possible that I'm missing something important. Perhaps you could enlighten me?

[0] https://www.usnews.com/news/national-news/articles/2024-11-1...

nobody9999··on Carl Sagan's Baloney Detection Kit: Tools for Thinking Critically (2025)
>We still use Newtonian physics plenty, despite bits of it not working due to relativity.

Absolutely. And since no one else has trotted this bit out yet, I guess it will be me:

All of our science is based on imperfect models of how the universe works. Every single one is wrong.

However, the models we use today are less wrong than those we used in the past. We know this because we (as you pointed out about Newtonian physics) can more accurately describe the universe than we were able to do previously.

That doesn't mean we've found "the truth." Nor does it mean that we have all the answers.

This is an important concept for baloney detection as those who are peddling baloney will (often, but not always) purport to know "the truth."

Anyone who makes such claims is either knowingly attempting to mislead or is lying to themselves and others.

Which, IMHO, is a pretty big red flag in baloney detection.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →