HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nobody9999

6,767 karma · joined July 8, 2020

submissionscomments
nobody9999··on Carl Sagan's Baloney Detection Kit: Tools for Thinking Critically (2025)
>It IS relevant to me and to most scientists. And you sound like someone who stops giving up at the first obstacle.

QFT posits that the graviton (as a particle-like excitation in a "gravity field") exists.

We do not currently (although there are some potential future experiments that might be able to confirm the existence of the graviton) have the means to detect gravitons.

Does the graviton exist? I don't know and neither do you. And we won't, unless and until we have the ability to detect gravitons. While we have a theoretical basis for gravitons, we have no experimental or observational evidence. Does that mean we should stop looking? No.

How about dark matter. What exactly is dark matter? We have a bunch of evidence that something that doesn't interact via the photon (the particle-like excitation of the EM field), but does interact gravitationally with itself and other fermions and bosons.

We don't know what that "dark matter" might be, but we continue looking for it, as there is both theoretical and observational evidence of its existence.

As for the "garage dragon," there is no theoretical, experimental or observational evidence for it.

There is also none of that for my claim of the absolute existence of a gremlin living inside your skull chowing down on your brain. But we should definitely saw open your skull to prove it, right? I'm partial to circular saws, but we can go with a chainsaw if you like.

>you sound like someone who stops giving up at the first obstacle.

It's not clear what ad-hominem attack you're making against me here as the words, as strung together don't make sense, but who I am or what I will or won't do is irrelevant to the discussion at hand.

Are you unable to make a better argument and so attack me personally instead?

>> I'd also point out that the guidelines[0] say:

>I had already removed it by the time you commented, so that's on you.

Did you? Thanks for finally following the site guidelines. Perhaps next time you won't need to be reminded.

nobody9999··on Carl Sagan's Baloney Detection Kit: Tools for Thinking Critically (2025)
>Not sure why this comment got downvoted, but after all this is HN: very pro-tech while at the same time anti-science. Computers do everything so knowledge doesn't matter.

As Dr. Sagan (quite correctly) pointed out:

   Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
Whether there's any particular method right now, next week or next year for such "detection" isn't relevant in this context for several reasons:

1. Sagan's example was a metaphor for an unfalsifiable hypothesis;

2. Dragons (okay, kimodo dragons do, but that's orthogonal to the discussion) don't actually exist;

3. Even if dragons with the properties posited by Sagan actually do exist, Evidence must be provided to confirm the "garage dragon" hypothesis or it's irrelevant. If it cannot be detected, it may as well not exist.

While it's true that "Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence," not being able to verify the non-existence of something doesn't confirm its existence.

I suggest you use the rest of the tools provided in Sagan's "Baloney Detection Kit" (helpfully linked above) to help you get the point.

I'd also point out that the guidelines[0] say:

   Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, 
   and it makes boring reading. 
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
nobody9999··on Carl Sagan's Baloney Detection Kit: Tools for Thinking Critically (2025)
>If someone claims to have a dragon that is invisible, silent, intangible, and undetectable by any means, there is no practical difference between the dragon’s existence and non-existence.

“Everyone knows that dragons don’t exist. But while this simplistic formulation may satisfy the layman, it does not suffice for the scientific mind. The School of Higher Neantical Nillity is in fact wholly unconcerned with what does exist. Indeed, the banality of existence has been so amply demonstrated, there is no need for us to discuss it any further here. The brilliant Cerebron, attacking the problem analytically, discovered three distinct kinds of dragon: the mythical, the chimerical, and the purely hypothetical. They were all, one might say, nonexistent, but each non-existed in an entirely different way.” ― Stanisław Lem, The Cyberiad

nobody9999··on Amazon Ring's lost dog ad sparks backlash amid fears of mass surveillance
Touche!

I will say that we don't use those limey flavoured spellings over here across the pond, nor do we allow such things in our adverts either, even if we're filling our caravans up with petrol.

It's an honour to be singled out for this, especially as I was whinging about it. ;)

https://ahdictionary.com/word/search.html?q=labor

nobody9999··on Amazon Ring's lost dog ad sparks backlash amid fears of mass surveillance
>So, implement surveillance of all, not only for the fracture of a percent of dogs returned but also because there are no functioning labour laws. Right. Got it. (/s)

Why stop there? People actually lie once in a while and say they never received a package that was supposedly delivered. We need to put those cameras inside peoples' homes, especially in the bathrooms and bedrooms where they hide the packages that were "never delivered." And why stop there? if we find that folks are lying about that, they should be tased, beaten and sent to prison (or just shot dead on the spot) for many years because they tried to defraud the powers-that-be ^H^H^H megacorps, and we can't allow that now can we? /s[0]

On a more serious note, there actually are labor (but without that extraneous 'u', friend!) laws in the US. But those generally only apply to "employees" and not subcontractors. Here's a page from Amazon about how to become a "delivery service partner"[1] (read: subcontractor so Amazon can avoid pesky things like labor laws, minimum wages, health care coverage, etc.), so you too can spend thousands and finally be allowed to urinate in plastic bottles. Good times!

[0] My '/s' is much broader and more absurd than yours. Please get ready for round two of the /s-waving contest :)

[1] https://logistics.amazon.com/

nobody9999··on Amazon Ring's lost dog ad sparks backlash amid fears of mass surveillance
>No, they live somewhere with a working postal law like Germany. Hand it directly to the addressed or a person authorised by the addressed (in which case inform the recipient via card or sms) or deposit it in a postbox, post office. This way it is secure that you receive your stuff even if you are not at home: https://www.bundesnetzagentur.de/DE/Fachthemen/Post/Regelung...

Sure. And that's great. But we're not talking about Deutsche Post, or even the US Postal Service.

We're talking about Amazon Logistics subcontractors who are so over-scheduled that they routinely need to urinate in bottles[0] rather than stop to use a restroom or they won't be able to fulfill their delivery quota for the day.

Those folks are assuredly not going to do anything more than the bare minimum (and not necessarily because they don't want to) because their delivery quotas don't allow for anything more than dumping a package on a porch (or in an unattended apartment building lobby) and maybe ringing the doorbell/intercom.

[0] https://www.msn.com/en-gb/money/other/amazon-depot-s-huge-pi...

nobody9999··on Carl Sagan's Baloney Detection Kit: Tools for Thinking Critically (2025)
Original Title:

Carl Sagan’s Baloney Detection Kit: Tools for Thinking Critically & Knowing Pseudoscience When You See It

nobody9999··on Google Fulfilled ICE Subpoena Demanding Student Journalist Credit Card Number
Yep. Ignorance is bliss, ain't it?
nobody9999··on Vouch
Sorry for the late reply.

You're correct, as far as it goes.

However, we weren't talking about using cryptocurrency in general, but in a very specific way: Making micropayments to devs as a mechanism to limit AI slop PRs to open source projects.

Doing that effectively would require broad implementation of some sort of payment scheme.

Given the current (as I documented) hoops one needs to jump through to obtain cryptocurrency if one doesn't have any, especially just for a random user to get crypto to send $1 to a github repo with their PR makes exactly zero sense.

Yes. Buying drugs and other stuff outside of the mainstream economy is definitely worth the effort. To send $1/PR for escrow to limit spam? Not so much.

nobody9999··on Google Fulfilled ICE Subpoena Demanding Student Journalist Credit Card Number
>What do you think is going to happen when DDG or Fastmail gets a FISA warrant? You think they will stand their ground and go to prison to protect your info?

I don't know about Fastmail, but according to DuckDuckGo[0]:

   Does DuckDuckGo share my search and browsing history with governments?

   No. Per our strict Privacy Policy[1]:

   "Critically, it's not possible for us to provide search or browsing histories 
   linked to you in response to legal requests because we don't have them."

   "We don’t save or share your search or browsing history when you search on 
   DuckDuckGo or use our apps and extensions."
[0] https://duckduckgo.com/duckduckgo-help-pages/misconceptions/...

[1] https://duckduckgo.com/privacy

nobody9999··on Google Fulfilled ICE Subpoena Demanding Student Journalist Credit Card Number
>We don't know this is mistreatment. It's not wrong for the government to subpoena data to investigate a crime.

To which specific "crime" are you referring?

From TFA[0]:

   Amandla Thomas-Johnson had attended a protest targeting companies that 
   supplied weapons to Israel at a Cornell University job fair in 2024 for all 
   of five minutes, but the action got him banned from campus. 
I didn't realize that attending a protest was now a crime. When, exactly, did that happen?

[0] https://theintercept.com/2026/02/10/google-ice-subpoena-stud...

nobody9999··on Is particle physics dead, dying, or just hard?
>> Yes, but we had hopes that it would lead to more. And had lead to more, something only known to be false in hindsight, who knows where that would have ended us up? What if it upended the standard model instead of reinforcing it?

>Sure, but it didn't. Which is knowledge that really should factor into the decision to build the next, bigger one.

Not this week, no. And if, next week (or next year or next decade) we resolve some of the most significant problems in modern physics, any expenditures in those fields were a waste?

You've repeatedly bashed particle physics based on your perception of a lack of progress vis-a-vis the costs, and claimed that other fields should be prioritized. Which fields? What would you hope to gain from those fields?

Is there no room for basic research that attempts to validate the bases (Standard Model, Quantum Field Theory, the marriage of the former with General Relativity, etc.) of modern physics? If not why not? Our models are definitely wrong, but they're measurably less wrong than previous models.

Should we not continue to hone/probe those models to find the cracks in the theories underpinning those models? If we don't, how will we solve these extant issues?

nobody9999··on Vouch
>First you have to make it low-friction. If I want Joe Average to send me $1 in cryptocurrency, how is he getting $1 in cryptocurrency to send me?

Absolutely. You're 1000% correct. Cryptocurrency is way too high friction for stuff like that. When I wish to spend crypto, I need to:

[If you don't have an exchange account already, you'll need the 0.x steps too!]

0.0 Create an account on an exchange which is legally allowed to operate in your state/country;

0.1 Provide all sorts of KYC/AML info including photos of yourself and your government ID;

0.2 Wait hours/days/weeks for the exchange to "validate" your KYC/AML info and allow you to purchase crypto;

1. Log in to an exchange which is actually allowed to operate in the place where one resides;

2. Purchase Bitcoin or other coin the exchange deems appropriate (leaving aside the hefty fee charged for using fiat currency/traditional credit card);

3. Wait days/weeks until the exchange allows you to transfer the purchased cryptocurrency out of your exchange-hosted wallet;

4. Transfer crypto to a wallet you actually control;

5. Convert the crypto purchased on the exchange to the crypto coin required for whatever your purpose may be;

6. Transmit the crypto to the destination wallet.

Total time (not including setting up the exchange account, which can take anywhere from 1-10 days): 3-10 days.

Much too high friction for small payments, IMHO.

nobody9999··on How Jeff Bezos Brought Down the Washington Post
>I have an even simpler step one: increase the IRS budget significantly so that they actually have enough resources to go after the big guys.

>It's on a downward spiral consistently, and it was further cut by 9% this year.

Has it been on a downward spiral?

The Inflation Reduction Act of 2022[0] added $80 billion over ten years to the IRS budget[1] (a good step in the right direction, IMHO), but which has now been withdrawn. Gee, I wonder why?

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation_Reduction_Act

[1] https://www.irs.gov/statistics/irs-budget-and-workforce

Edit: Added index [0] for link.

nobody9999··on How Jeff Bezos Brought Down the Washington Post
>It is much easier to get by not paying for NYT by using stuff like https://periscope.corsfix.com/ for sure. But it is a big inconvenience. WSJ is much more aggressive with it.

While not made specifically for that purpose, this extension[0][1] does a nice job without a lot of hassle, and it makes such pages accessible to others with a URL you can share. The downside is that dynamic content isn't supported.

[0] https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/archive-page/

[1[ https://github.com/JNavas2/Archive-Page

nobody9999··on The TSA's New $45 Fee to Fly Without ID Is Illegal
>You're not going to believe it, but if you already have a passport - you don't need Real ID (in ideal world). I only got Real ID because I want to have zero questions about my immigration status.

DHS says they don't consider RealID to be reliable "proof" of immigration status[0][1], so you might consider rethinking that strategy.

[0] https://www.biometricupdate.com/202601/dhs-agent-tells-court...

[1] https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.alsd.76...

nobody9999··on The TSA's New $45 Fee to Fly Without ID Is Illegal
As I mentioned[0] a few months ago after the TSA announced the $45 "fee":

   ...The courts have repeatedly struck down limits on domestic travel over the 
   past couple hundred years.

   In fact, the $45 "fee" is an acknowledgment that you aren't required to have 
   special documents to travel within the US. Otherwise, they just wouldn't let 
   you travel.

   So instead, they're making more security theater and punishing you if you 
   don't comply with their demands...
And now the birds are coming home to roost. No real surprise there, IMHO.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46128346

nobody9999··on Red Dwarfs Are Too Dim to Generate Complex Life
Underlying paper[0]:

Dearth of Photosynthetically Active Radiation Suggests No Complex Life on Late M-Star Exoplanets

[0] https://arxiv.org/abs/2601.02548

nobody9999··on County pays $600k to pentesters it arrested for assessing courthouse security
>Everyone should support the ability of even a person with a conviction to continue working and contributing to society. It's kind of a civil death that leads to bad outcomes for those targeted.

And not just those targeted either. The communities where those people live are deprived of the higher economic activity of someone with a middle/upper-middle-class income/lifestyle than someone who can only get a job mopping floors or washing cars.

That has a definite downward drag on the economic health of the communities where folks aren't given the opportunity to contribute because of past transgressions or, as we're discussing here, unwarranted criminal charges and investigations.

It's not just sad, it's a disgusting waste of human potential. More's the pity.

nobody9999··on FBI is investigating Minnesota Signal chats tracking ICE
>Citizen children have rights, illegal immigrants have rights.

Finally, progress! Thank you. Just to clarify, does that mean you believe that all citizens, regardless of whether they're born in the US, the children of US citizen(s), as well as those who are naturalized all have the same rights?

What about non-citizens present (leaving aside diplomats here) in the US? Do you believe that they are under the authority of the US Constitution, US code and the laws of the state/local area where they are?

If so, do the First, Fourth, Fifth, Sixth and Seventh Amendments, as well as 8USC12[1] apply to those folks?

>Be angry somewhere else.

Who's angry? Not me. I wasn't angry before and I'm not angry now. What would give you that idea?

Or is that just more projection (straw man indeed!) from you?

>Nobody was talking about your rights or rights at all.

That's not really true. I was talking about my rights, as well as the rights of others.

If you don't wish to have this conversation, you're under no obligation to engage with me. I won't be insulted or "angry" either way. I'm sorry that my thought processes seem to get your hackles up. That certainly wasn't my intent.

Enjoy your day!

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_the_United_Sta...

[1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/8/chapter-12

nobody9999··on FBI is investigating Minnesota Signal chats tracking ICE
>I am not talking about your rights: this is a strawman argument.

Whose rights should I be talking/concerned about? Are my rights unimportant? Shall we just go ahead and strip me of my citizenship because I'm not talking about what you want me to talk about?

It's literally the question I asked and your position on that specific question I wanted to understand. I did not misrepresent your belief/argument, rather I asked you to elucidate your thoughts on a specific question.[1]

That's not a strawman argument, that's being curious about your beliefs and understanding of the laws of the United States.

In fact, your initial reply to my comment was, in fact, a straw man as you argued against a claim that I never made -- that somehow asking about the rights of the children, their age is irrelevant, as everyone is someone's child, of immigrants only related to the minor children of undocumented immigrants -- I made no such claim, except in the straw man you set up.

If you didn't want to answer that question, you were under no obligation to reply to me at all. Yet you chose to do so and argue against a claim I never made.

So it was you, not me who engaged in "refuting an argument different from the one actually under discussion, while not recognizing or acknowledging the distinction."[0]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man

[1] I suppose that my question could (as you apparently did) be considered a non-sequitur. Definitely not a straw man, as I didn't argue for or against anything. Rather,I asked for your beliefs/understanding of US law and the US Constitution.

Edit: Clarified the difference between a straw man and a non-sequitur -- in case GP's first language isn't English.

nobody9999··on ICE using Palantir tool that feeds on Medicaid data
I'm glad you're trying to expand your horizons. Here's a link to get you started:

https://duckduckgo.com/?t=ftsa&q=deaths+and+bankruptcies+fro...

nobody9999··on FBI is investigating Minnesota Signal chats tracking ICE
>Do the children of immigrants have fewer rights than other citizens?

Your response doesn't even approach answering it.

Why is that? Are you unwilling to answer such a question? Did you misunderstand?

Your comment was completely unrelated to the question I asked. Especially since my parents are long dead (51 years and 28 years) and I haven't relied on parental support in 35+ years.

As I mentioned, I'm the child of a non-citizen immigrant. Do you claim that I have fewer rights than other citizens? If so, which rights, and what justification do you use to make such a claim?

That's not a rhetorical question.

nobody9999··on Apple to soon take up to 30% cut from all Patreon creators in iOS app
>Which banks do you use? I’m looking to switch away from Chase (which does this).

Do you mean SMS codes or a Chase Bank App?

I have to deal with the former because I auto-delete cookies when I close tabs and use Multi-account containers on Firefox.

I've never been required to install any application (Chase branded or otherwise) on my phone in order to use the Chase website. I'll note that I've been a Chase customer since they acquired Chemical Bank in 1996.

Am I missing something important here? If so, I'd love to hear about it.

nobody9999··on FBI is investigating Minnesota Signal chats tracking ICE
>think this is mostly because they don't care about false-negatives. They have forgotten the idea that our justice system was supposed to hold true to: "better a hundred guilty go free than one innocent person suffer" (attributed to Benjamin Franklin).

Putting on my pedant's hat here. Franklin may well have said something similar, but the maxim you mention is broadly known as Blackstone's Formulation (or ratio)[0] after William Blackstone[1], another Englishman.

Many sayings are ascribed to Benjamin Franklin. And some of them, he actually said.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Blackstone

nobody9999··on FBI is investigating Minnesota Signal chats tracking ICE
>What better alternatives do we have?

Set up your own XMPP or Matrix server and only expose it via Tor.

nobody9999··on FBI is investigating Minnesota Signal chats tracking ICE
>Invariably someone will shoot back with "citizen children of illegal immigrants."

Do the children of immigrants have fewer rights than other citizens?

I'm the child of an immigrant. Do I not deserve the same rights as any other citizen or resident of the US? If not, why not?

nobody9999··on FBI is investigating Minnesota Signal chats tracking ICE
>Because the whole point of tracking ICE is to help people dodge them. It's absurd that people cry foul when the government goes after people actively opposing the rule of law.

By your logic, combined with the actions of the ICE folks in Minneapolis, anyone who submits the location of a DUI checkpoint into Waze[0] should be summarily executed?

Is that your argument? ICE has murdered people for documenting their locations and actions which, by your statement was to allow others to "dodge" law enforcement.

Documenting a DUI checkpoint does exactly the same thing. So. If your position is that law "enforcement" is allowed to summarily shoot to death folks who document their actions and locations in one context, then they should be allowed to do so in other, more serious contexts like DUI checkpoints.

Is that your claim? If not, please do provide some nuance around what you said, because that's how I understood your statements.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waze

nobody9999··on FBI is investigating Minnesota Signal chats tracking ICE
>comments like that just make me thing people on the left are just good at violence

That's as may be, but it's not for a lack of trying by the right. In fact, the overwhelming majority of political violence comes from the right[0]:

"There were about 300 acts of political violence in the United States from the January 6 attack to the 2024 election.[46][45] According to the research, that was the largest surge since the 1970s.[45] Political violence during the 2024 election was also at its highest since the 1970s, and most recent violence came from right-wing assailants.[46][2]

As of 2023, political violence comes "overwhelmingly from the right", according to the Global Terrorism Database, FBI statistics, and other research.[3][41][48] The Anti-Defamation League found that all of the 61 political killings in the U.S. from 2022 through 2024 were committed by right-wing extremists.[49] A Princeton University study reported that the number of cases involving harassment and threats against local public officials had increased 74% in 2024 compared with 2022, totalling 600 cases.[50] Serious threats against federal judges doubled from 2021 to 2023 according to the U.S. Marshals Service.[25]"

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_violence_in_the_Unit...

nobody9999··on Celebrities say they are being censored by TikTok after speaking out against ICE
https://archive.ph/l4qni
← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →