HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nobody9999

6,767 karma · joined July 8, 2020

submissionscomments
nobody9999··on ICE using Palantir tool that feeds on Medicaid data
>If a state bureaucracy doesn't explicitly check for legal immigration status then yes the policymakers in that state are trying to blur the line between legal and illegal immigration.

When it comes to healthcare, many states don't care if you're a tourist or a resident or a one-eyed, one-eared, horned purple-people eater. They (because their constituents -- you know, the folks who pay for this -- believe people shouldn't be dying in the streets because they can't afford basic care, regardless of who they are/where they came from) provide healthcare to anyone who needs it because it's the compassionate, humane thing to do.

That some states do not do so says a lot about the folks who run and live in those states -- partly that they have little empathy for their fellow human beings. Which seems weird, given that many of those states have "leaders" and vocal residents who claim to be Christian, yet they are unwilling to engage in the very things that Jesus Christ prescribes[0][1][2] that they do.

I'm glad I'm not a Christian. If I were, I don't think I could abide such evil, selfishness and hypocrisy.

[0] https://www.borgenmagazine.com/9-quotes-from-jesus-on-why-we...

[1] https://jesusleadershiptraining.com/charity-what-did-jesus-s...

[2] https://christ.org/blogs/questions-answers/what-did-jesus-te...

nobody9999··on ICE using Palantir tool that feeds on Medicaid data
>An easy win that should get widespread approval is bolstering the immigration court system. I have dark worries, but I'm still not entirely sure why this administration is whittling away at immigration courts. You'd think they'd want to process asylum applications faster, so invalid claimants could be deported sooner.

Absolutely. Especially since upwards of 80% of asylum claims are denied[0] when they actually get adjudicated. Which usually takes years to happen because there aren't enough immigration "courts."

Provide enough immigration "judges" and "courts" and we could clear up the backlog within a couple years. I'd also point out that while asylum seekers aren't (yet) legal immigrants, they are (based on Federal law[1]) legally in the United States until their case has been adjudicated -- once again arguing for increasing the number of immigration "courts" and "judges." It certainly doesn't argue for hundreds of billions of dollars for a bunch of jackbooted thugs to terrorize citizens and immigrants alike, all to deport fewer people than other administrations who didn't need to shoot citizens to do so. Funny that.

[0] https://www.factcheck.org/2021/04/factchecking-claims-about-...

[1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/8/1158

nobody9999··on IPv6 is not insecure because it lacks a NAT
>How exactly would a regular NAT implementation, such as s consumer router's NAT, remove security compared to a direct connection? Assuming there is no port forwarding configured, the NAT will drop (or NACK) any packets addressed to the router's IP on any port that doesn't correspond to a currently open connection.

No one (at least not me) said anything about a "direct connection" (which I assume means using globally routable IPv4 addresses on your internal systems).

Nor did anyone say anything about not forwarding any ports. In fact, much of the discussion has been about how "secure" NAT is when forwarding ports, with some folks claiming that doing so is all you need. Or did you miss those 80-100 comments?

>This statement makes no sense. If you are not using NAT of some kind, and your machines only have RFC1918 addresses, then your machines can't access the Internet at all.

Exactly. That was my point. And if you add NAT without stateful firewall rules to limit access, your internal systems are exposed.

I tell you what: post the IP address/range of your home network, turn off the firewall you're using and just leave NAT enabled as it is right now and we can see for ourselves just how "secure" bare NAT is. What do you say?

Unsecured NAT (i.e., without, at a minimum, firewall rules limiting connectivity -- a default deny rule at least) is not secure at all.

I've said (now twice) what I had to say. Feel free to disagree (again) and/or downmod my post, but my decades of experience professionally implementing networks, the security infrastructure which attempts to secure them, at the perimeter as well as at the LAN, server and endpoint informs my opinion.

Don't agree? That's fine with me. It's no skin off my nose. I have no axe to grind with you or anyone else around this or anything else.

Have a good day.

Edit: Clarified the "Globally routable" addresses as IPv4.

nobody9999··on IPv6 is not insecure because it lacks a NAT
>NAT provides security because normally it disallows external actors on the outside from accessing resources on the inside side.

No. NAT enables internal, non-routable (cf. rfc1918[0]) actors on the inside to access external resources on the Internet. Generally, that's done via NAT masquerade[1] (one-to-many NAT), but can also be done with one-to-one NAT.

>A firewall is not required for NAT to work, although many firewalls have NAT built-in. And indeed, if a firewall is off NAT can still function (if NAT is separate).

No. It isn't. And if you enable NAT without firewall rules, it will happily expose your internal network to external actors. In fact, that's the whole point of NAT.

In fact, not using IPv4 NAT is enormously more secure than using IPv4 NAT, assuming you're using RFC1918 addresses internally. Primarily because non-NATted RFC1918 addresses won't be forwarded by routers on the Internet (CGNAT notwithstanding).

>Here's the end point: NAT effectively reduces the attack surface for a home network to the router. That is security, practically speaking.

Again, no. Enabling NAT increases the attack surface for all networks, regardless of type. Without NAT, external actors need to compromise your router first, then get it to accept spoofed packets.

Yes, there's detail that I've ignored, as it's irrelevant to the statements made. Most of that is related to "I want to access Internet resources, but my ISP won't give me anything but a single, ephemeral, routable IPv4 address, so I need to use NAT to share that one address."

That's not an argument for the "security" of NAT, it's an argument for being mad at your ISP, especially if they won't give you a /56 block of IPv6 addresses.

[0] https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc1918

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Network_address_translation#On...

nobody9999··on American importers and consumers bear the cost of 2025 tariffs: analysis
There have been peaceful protests all over the country for months. Have you not been paying attention?

And there will be more, and soon (tomorrow -- 20-Jan-2026 -- in fact)[0]

[0] https://www.freeameri.ca/

nobody9999··on American importers and consumers bear the cost of 2025 tariffs: analysis
>From https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/11/democrats-...

You conveniently left out that the author (Ruy Teixeira[0]) of the piece you quoted is a senior fellow at the right-wing think tank that authored the Project 2025 roadmap.

Should we ask Stalin to critique US Cold War policies? Or maybe ask Xi Xinping to publicly assess the relative strengths and weaknesses of Taiwan's defense posture too?

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ruy_Teixeira

nobody9999··on American importers and consumers bear the cost of 2025 tariffs: analysis
In the US, the far-right party elects many fewer women than the center-right party[0]

[0] https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2025/02/21/women-acc...

nobody9999··on American importers and consumers bear the cost of 2025 tariffs: analysis
>To be absolutely frank, I don't consider the Democrat party as "Left" in any (traditional?) sense at all, even though it may include Left and Left-leaning elements.

The Democratic (not "Democrat", a member of that party is a Democrat, but the party is the "Democratic" Party), and calling it the "Democrat" party has its roots in Republicans deliberately misnaming the party as one of many attempts to devalue and dismiss the Democratic Party. If that's your goal, then please continue. Otherwise, it's like calling an Englishman a Limey or a Pommie just because you've heard others do so.

Otherwise, you're quite correct, in that the US Democratic Party is mostly a center-right party, with it's most progressive/left-wing elements being firmly center-left.

nobody9999··on Around 1,500 soldiers on standby for deployment to Minneapolis
>The politics of fear stoked by two sets of extremists egging eachother on is the core reason we're in this mess, the failure to reject both simultaneously and the desire to rule with feelings instead of facts caused it all.

Pol Pot[0] was a leftist extremist. Chairman Mao[1] was a leftist extremist. As were the Red Brigades[2] and the Symbionese Liberation Army[3], etc., etc., ,etc. Who in the US Democratic Party advocates for the same things as those guys? Let's see. No one.

In fact, the only ones in the US who've shown an interest in nationalizing the means of production (c.f. Intel) or putting down the Intelligentsia and normalizing violence against those who criticize the regime are just one set of extremists. Because extremists end up going full circle -- because for them it's about power and not ideology.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pol_Pot

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mao_Zedong

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Brigades

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Symbionese_Liberation_Army

nobody9999··on Texas police invested in phone-tracking software and won’t say how it’s used
>Tracking the population without cause is never the right use case for anything.

Agreed. Which is why I submitted this in the first place. But AFAICT, it's orthogonal to GP's comment. Or not. Which is why I asked for clarification.

nobody9999··on Texas police invested in phone-tracking software and won’t say how it’s used
>I hate the concept. But this is not the right case to test the tool against.

To which case are you referring? TFA doesn't appear to refer to any ongoing litigation associated with the "Tangles" software.

Or are you referring to warrantless geo-fence tracking as a poor use case for the software?

nobody9999··on Texas police invested in phone-tracking software and won’t say how it’s used
Title too long for submission. Original title:

Texas Police Invested Millions in a Shadowy Phone-Tracking Software. They Won’t Say How They’ve Used It.

nobody9999··on US freezes visas for 75 nations
>How on EARTH are we going to host the World Cup this year?

Good question. Which is likely another reason for more ticket cancellations[0].

[0] https://www.financialexpress.com/sports/fifa-calls-for-emerg...

nobody9999··on US freezes visas for 75 nations
>Flagging on the other hand to me on a post as such and other attempts genuinely sadden me because I was only able to discover this flagged post because people wrote about this article in the post I built which has also promptly got flagged.

I find that annoying myself. However, at the suggestion of another user, I began looking at https://news.ycombinator.com/active instead of the front page.

The "active" page (as its name implies) includes the most active discussions regardless of whether or not they've been flagged.

I find it to be a much better place to find stuff to discuss.

nobody9999··on FBI raids Washington Post reporter's home
>It's like you didn't see where I agree that current enforcement is too aggressive. Why are you writing in a tone that implies we disagree when we agree? This is the sort of thing that confuses me.

I combined my response to your comment[0] and its parent[1], as I mentioned:

   I'm not pushing any "broader political narrative" either. Just pointing out a 
   few things not mentioned in your or GP's comments.
Rather than disagreeing with you, I was attempting to add nuance and additional substance. As the site guidelines[2] recommend:

   Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone 
   says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith. 
You appear to have assumed bad faith on my part. Why is that? Was I not clear enough? What could I have added to the above to be clearer?

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46620707

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46618048

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

nobody9999··on FBI raids Washington Post reporter's home
>It is the most commented on and has the highest points today. See: https://hckrnews.com/

Also see https://news.ycombinator.com/active

nobody9999··on FBI raids Washington Post reporter's home
>Strongly worded letters to one's Congressperson are the equivalent to "thoughts and prayers". It doesn't matter how just (you think) your cause is; it will never achieve anything.

Your assertion isn't supported by, well, anything. The problem is that constituents think they can't affect their representatives' positions. They can.[0][1] Especially if there's a concerted effort to do so.

For every constituent who writes/calls/emails, there are at least a half-dozen more who feel the same way.

The problem isn't that contacting your representatives isn't effective, it's that by not doing so, you're ceding power to those that do.

[0] https://act.represent.us/sign/does-calling-congress-really-w...

[1] https://americansofconscience.com/calling-congress-still-mat...

nobody9999··on FBI raids Washington Post reporter's home
>It saddens me that your rather innocuous comment has been down-voted so aggressively.

Despite the ridiculous narrative that Obama and Biden were "bringing in illegals en masse to vote for Democrats," if you look at the actual numbers, it's not surprising that folks are down-voting that comment.

Mostly because those previous administrations (Obama and Biden) managed to deport many more undocumented folks than either this or the previous Trump administration, without the thuggery, violence and murder we're seeing now.

I'd note that even without the gratuitous violence and intimidation, folks were also protesting Obama's and Biden's ICE activities.

Because the real issue around immigration in the US is that our system is broken and we haven't constructively addressed those problems for nearly 40 years.

So no. I'm not surprised by the down-votes because there's nuance that's being glossed over and, while doing so, giving violent thugs a pass by claiming that they're "enforcing the law," even though they're doing a crap job while harming our citizens, legal residents and helping to destroy what's left of our civil society.

I'm not pushing any "broader political narrative" either. Just pointing out a few things not mentioned in your or GP's comments.

nobody9999··on FBI raids Washington Post reporter's home
>It feels like all of the "patriots" joined ICE.

That's certainly possible. Maybe even likely. Fortunately, we now have more information[0] to correlate whether or not that's true.

Perhaps soon we'll see a "Show HN" with a searchable database of those folks with links to known "patriot" groups. That would be interesting.

[0] https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/whistleblower-leaks-person...

nobody9999··on Scott Adams has died
Less than half. 49.8%, in fact.[0]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_United_States_presidentia...

nobody9999··on Scott Adams has died
>The best we can do for the dead is remember them as they were, good and bad, not demonize them nor write hagiographies for them

I agree with your conclusion, but not with your premise.

We can't "do" anything for the dead. They're dead. What's more, since they're dead they don't care what we do or say because they're, you know, dead.

Anything we might do or say in reference to dead folks is for the benefit of the living and has nothing to do with the dead.

That said, you're absolutely right. We should remember folks for who they were -- warts and all -- to give the living perspective both on the dead and the dead past.

nobody9999··on Scott Adams has died
>As others pointed, the story of human civilization is one long arc of going against our base animal instincts in order to build a society that benefits everyone.

I'd add that it's cooperation and the ability to moderate impulsive behavior that, over the long term, differentiates us from our closest primate relatives, the chimpanzee.

If we were just our base instincts and nothing more, we wouldn't be having this conversation as we'd likely have died out, because our ability to accept and work together with each other allowed us to flourish despite the threats of predation, climate change, natural disasters and other challenges.

As such, making the argument that we're "hardwired" to hate and fear our fellow humans doesn't make sense, whether that argument is an intellectual one or an evolutionary one.

I feel sorry for folks who feel so isolated that they can't understand just how closely related we all are. It must be quite lonely.

nobody9999··on Scott Adams has died
>...When he was diagnosed with inoperable lung cancer, he went to every dubious healer my grandmother could find...He was never right wing.

Desperation isn't partisan, friend.

My father was diagnosed with metastatic lung cancer and died from its ravages too. He participated in clinical trials and did everything medically reasonable to save himself. None of it worked, and when the treatments came to an end, he faced his death with grace and dignity. I've often thought that if I was in a similar situation, I'd be happy to be half as courageous as he was.

Other folks I've seen have been more along the "freak out" axis and have fallen apart, sought out any treatment regardless of efficacy (or sanity), or both, in order to stave off their fear.

None of that is partisan. All of that is sad.

If Scott Adams died from his cancer's advance, he died a slow, painful (opioids notwithstanding) death which included numerous indignities and, at the end, a lack of awareness that, had he been conscious of it, would likely have driven him mad.

That's what's sad. No one, not even Scott Adams, should suffer and die that way. How folks meet death, especially one as grueling and painful as cancer eating your central nervous system, isn't a partisan thing.

And while I'm not a fan of his later incarnations, his brief cameo here[0] was quite amusing.

[0] https://babylon5.fandom.com/wiki/Moments_of_Transition

nobody9999··on CLI agents make self-hosting on a home server easier and fun
>It's the way the internet was meant to work but it doesn't make it any easier. Even when everything is in containers/VMs/users, if you don't put a decent amount of additional effort into automatic updates and keeping that context hardened as you tinker with it it's quite annoying when it gets pwned.

As someone who spent decades implementing and securing networks and internet-facing services for corporations large and small as well as self-hosting my own services for much of that time, the primary lesson I've learned and tried to pass on to clients, colleagues and family is:

   If you expose it to the Internet, assume it will be pwned at some point.
No, that's not universally true. But it's a smart assumption to make for several reasons:

1. No software is completely bug free and those bugs can expose your service(s) to compromise;

2. Humans (and their creations) are imperfect and will make mistakes -- possibly exposing your service(s) to compromise;

3. Bad actors, ranging from marginally competent script kiddies to master crackers with big salaries and big budgets from governments and criminal organizations are out there 24x7 trying to break into whatever systems they can reach.

The above applies just as much to tailscale or wireguard as it does to ssh/http(s)/imap/smtp/etc.

I'll say it again as it's possibly the most important concept related to exposing anything:

   If you expose it to the Internet, assume that, at some point, it will be 
   compromised and plan accordingly.
If you're lucky (and good), it may not happen while you're responsible for it, but assuming it will and having a plan to mitigate/control an "inevitable" compromise will save your bacon much better than just relying on someone else's code to never break or have bugs which put you at risk.

Want to expose ports? Use Wireguard? Tailscale? HAProxy? Go for it.

And do so in ways that meet your requirements/use cases. But don't forget to at least think (better yet script/document) about what you will do if your services are compromised.

Because odds are that one day they will.

nobody9999··on I replaced Windows with Linux and everything's going great
>Windows reads the drive fine whereas Linux gives an error that has no obvious solution. And it can't be solved by right clicking the drive in the explorer and selecting "take ownership and mount" or something like that, it requires using an unfamiliar command into the terminal to fix the problem. And that's basically the case with most file-permission errors that I encounter on Linux systems.

That definitely seems like a feature that could/should be added to some (most? all?) linux file managers. In fact, it doesn't even sound like that difficult to implement with standard system calls[0].

It's not really an issue for me (I prefer the command line -- heck, I still use octal when setting permissions instead of 'rwx'), but it sounds like it bugs you a lot.

You don't mention which Desktop Environment (DE) you're using, but I imagine the file manager in your DE is open source. As such, I'm sure you could make yourself and the (I'm sure) many others who'd like to be able to modify file/dir/filesystem permissions/ownership via their GUI file manager much happier.

Try doing that with Windows Explorer or Finder. I think not.

Good luck!

[0] https://www.tutorialpedia.org/blog/how-to-change-show-permis...

Edit: Clarified prose.

nobody9999··on Fighting back against biometric surveillance at Wegmans
That depends on relevant state laws. Perhaps Alabama wasn't the best example.

Regardless, as I said, organized shoplifting rings are mostly addressed by other laws (related to criminal conspiracy and other criminal enterprise laws) which do carry felony penalties.

If someone goes into Walmart three times a week and steals bread milk or eggs they should be charged with a felony and be sent to prison? Really? Shall we imprison those who sleep on the street too? How about speeders? Litterbugs? Jaywalkers? But we don't have enough prisons for that do we? Which leaves what? Summary execution?

As Anatole France[0] observed[1]:

“The law, in its majestic equality, forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to steal their bread.”

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anatole_France

[1] https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/361132-the-law-in-its-majes...

nobody9999··on Ask HN: Is it time for HN to implement a form of captcha?
>Captchas are not effective. You can pay 2captcha less than a penny per captcha and humans solve them for you.

I'd expect that if we took Randall Munroe's advice[0], that price would go up significantly, perhaps prohibitively so.

[0] https://xkcd.com/810/

nobody9999··on Minneapolis driver shot and killed by ICE
I'd add that since, as ICE claims, Ms. Good had already been non-violently interacting with them, they had the opportunity to note the license plate and, if they felt criminal charges for obstructing their operations were appropriate, they could just go to her (nearby) house and arrest her later.

There was absolutely no reason for the attempt to pull her out of her car, and even less for escalation to use deadly force and, IIUC, DOJ guidelines and DHS policies[1] back that up.

This was an execution, not a law enforcement officer "defending" himself. That the decision was made in the heat of the moment doesn't make it any less an execution.

What's more, shooting peaceful protestors (cf. First Amendment[0]) is illegal on its face:

"Congress shall make no law...prohibiting...the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.*"

[0] https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/first_amendment

[1] https://apnews.com/article/ice-minneapolis-police-rules-shoo...

nobody9999··on Fighting back against biometric surveillance at Wegmans
>It makes a whole lot of sense, otherwise there is a loophole for unlimited stealing as Police/DAs do not want to waste time on misdemeanor theft.

Actually, this was already addressed (n.b., aggregation laws only exist in nine states, see GP's link here[1]) in most places by an increase in the severity of the crime charged for folks being convicted multiple times. cf. Alabama's law[0] as an example:

   Enhanced Penalties for Theft Convictions in Alabama

   Alabama law increases the penalties for habitual (repeat) felony offenders. 
   The length of the enhanced penalty depends on the number of past convictions 
   and the felony offense level for the current offense.

   Second felony. For a second felony conviction, the sentence is raised one 
   level—for instance, a class B felony increases to a class A felony. This 
   penalty increase applies only to current offenses classified as class A, B, 
   or C felonies.

   Third felony. A person with two prior felony offenses faces the following 
   minimum prison terms: 10 years for a class C felony, 15 years for a class B 
   felony, and 99 years for a class A felony.

   Fourth felony. A fourth felony offense results in minimum prison terms of 15 
   years for a class C felony, 20 years for a class B felony, and life for a 
   class A felony.

   Class D felony with prior convictions. When the current offense is a class D 
   felony and the person has two or more class A or B felony convictions or 
   three or more felonies in general, the penalty increases to a Class C felony.

   (Ala. Code § 13A-5-9 (2024).)

Whatever information a "Loss Prevention" team has might be useful to a DA, but unless there's authentication and verified chain of custody of such evidence, the ability to fake such "video surveillance" makes such "evidence" not worth a damn.

[0] https://www.criminaldefenselawyer.com/resources/criminal-def...

[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2023/08/11/organized-retail-crime-nine-...

nobody9999··on Fighting back against biometric surveillance at Wegmans
Thanks!
← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →