HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nobody9999

6,767 karma · joined July 8, 2020

submissionscomments
nobody9999··on Fighting back against biometric surveillance at Wegmans
>This is their purpose, they're used to build cases over time, instead of single instances of petty theft, until shoplifters can be charged with felonies when the cumulative amount that they stole reaches felony levels.

I've heard the idea of combining multiple misdemeanor thefts to make a felony. Which doesn't make a whole lot of sense to me.

Wouldn't that require an ongoing criminal conspiracy/enterprise to "combine" such disparate acts into a single, chargeable crime?

Some state laws do "upgrade" crimes, both misdemeanor --> felony and felony --> more serious felony based on prior convictions, but not (AFAIK) with multiple separate acts whose aggregate value is greater than the cutoff between petty theft and grand theft.

What's more, it's the local prosecutor who decides what charges to bring against someone accused of shoplifting, not the "Loss Prevention" team at a store or its corporate parent.

The idea just seems unlike how local/state laws and justice systems work in the US.

I could be (and likely am) wrong about this, but I've been unable to find state laws[0] which specify that multiple, separate acts of shoplifting can be combined into a single grand theft felony.

Would you share which states have such laws? It would be much appreciated!

[0] https://www.criminaldefenselawyer.com/crime-penalties/federa... [1]

[1] See the bottom of the page for links to most US state laws.

nobody9999··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
>President Trump was elected democratically by the people of the US, by majority in both the electoral and popular vote.

It was a plurality of the popular vote, not a majority[0]. A majority is >50%. Trump received 49.8%.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_United_States_presidentia...

nobody9999··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
>Obviously I was not asking someone to link to my profile.

That's true. I misread your comment. My apologies.

Unfortunately, I can't delete my comment any more, but it should be (and deservedly so) pretty well grayed out by now.

Although I'm a bit confused since your profile as well as every other users' profile is linked by HN in each and every comment you (or I, or any other user) make.

If it's poor etiquette to "link to my profile," why does HN do that on every single comment?

Edit: Added context.

nobody9999··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
>My post history?

I'd venture to guess that GP is referring to this[0]. Or are you just incredulous that your past comments are being used to inform current ones?

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=EnPissant[1]

[1] Not making any value judgement as to the content as I haven't reviewed your post history.

nobody9999··on The universe may be lopsided
https://archive.ph/73ZxQ

Underlying Paper: Colloquium: The cosmic dipole anomaly

https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.23526

nobody9999··on Amatuer codebreaker may have solved Zodiac killer identity
https://archive.ph/pJ9eK
nobody9999··on Some Epstein file redactions are being undone
>Sure you can. Search and somehow mark the text (underline or similar) to make keywords hard to miss. Then proceed with the manual print, expunge, scan process.

I suppose a global search/replace to mark text for redaction as an initial step might not be a bad idea, but if one needs to make sure it's correct, that's not enough.

Don't bother with soft copy at all. Print a copy and have multiple individuals manually make redactions to the same copy with different color inks.

Once that initial phase is complete, partner up persons who didn't do the initial redactions review the paper text with the extant redactions and go through the documents together (each with their own copy of the same redactions), verbally and in ink noting redactions as well as text that should be redacted but isn't.

That process could then be repeated with different people to ensure nothing was missed.

We used to call this "proofreading" in the context of reports and other documents provided as work product to clients. It looks really bad when the product for which you're charging five to six figures isn't correct.

The use case was different, but the efficacy of such a process is perfect for something like redactions as well.

And yes, we had word processing and layout software which included search and replace. But if correctness is required, that's not good enough -- a word could be misspelled and missed by the search/replace, and/or a half dozen other ways an automated process could go wrong and either miss a redaction or redact something that shouldn't be.

As for the time and attention required, I suppose that depends upon how important it is to get right.

Is such a process necessary for all documents? No.

That said, if correctness is a priority, four (or more) text processing engines (human brains, in this case) with a set of engines working in tandem and other sets of engines working serially and independently to verify/correct any errors or omissions is an excellent process for ensuring the correctness of text.

I'd point out that the above process is one that's proven reliable over decades, even centuries -- and doesn't require exact strings or regular expressions.

Edit: Fixed prose ("other documents be provided" --> "other documents provided").

nobody9999··on Over 40% of deceased drivers in vehicle crashes test positive for THC: Study
>How did these people lose their license in the first place? The most common reason is DUIs. Followed by multiple instances of reckless driving. People are less likely to lose their license to begin with if they know there will be real consequences.

When I was in college in Ohio, one of my suite mates had several DUI arrests. After the first, his license was suspended -- yet he was allowed to drive to/from work/school because public transportation was minimal. After the third DUI, he was sentenced to 30 days in jail -- served on the weekends so he could continue going to school without interruption -- and still drive his car to/from work/school.

I was flabbergasted by that. But I guess that's how things are often handled in places without public transportation. And more's the pity.

nobody9999··on Over 40% of deceased drivers in vehicle crashes test positive for THC: Study
>But if you're going to bring that up anyway, how are people supposed to get their car home from the bar in a place where the government hates public transport?

An anecdote related to me by a former (Florida) county sheriff's deputy answers that question:

Many police will stake out bars around closing time, awaiting the intoxicated to get behind the wheel so they can be stopped, breathalyzed and arrested.

However, patrons were aware of this and the deputy saw a patron leave, stumbling, drop their car keys several times, then get into their car and drive away.

When stopping said individual, the breathalyzer and field sobriety test showed the driver to be stone cold sober. As such, the deputy sent the driver on their way.

Returning to the bar parking lot, he found that all the other patrons had departed while he was wasting his time on the one sober person -- dubbed the "designated decoy."

I'm sure other variations are and have been in use in the US for a long time -- since most places don't have public transportation or reliable taxis.

The "cars first, public transit last, if at all" culture in most of the US makes the likelihood of DUI/DWI and crashes/injuries/fatalities much, much worse.

nobody9999··on Over 40% of deceased drivers in vehicle crashes test positive for THC: Study
>This kind of test seems silly. It's going to be far too hard to remove the confounding variables. Much easier just to give people different levels of weed and have them do driving tests. Directly measure their driving skill instead of doing it by shitty proxy like this.

Given that differing levels of THC impact people differently both because of potential "tolerance" in frequent users as compared with occasional users and individual responses to cannabis (and even different cannabis strains with varied chemical profiles). There may well be other confounding factors as well.

Cannabis does not affect everyone the same way. It doesn't even affect the same people in the same way every time.

As such, while the testing you suggest may well be useful over the long term, it will require large populations and repeated testing at varying levels of both subjective intoxication and THC levels in the blood over extended periods to get good data about how THC use (both in temporal proximity and overall usage patterns) causes impairment.

As anecdata, I can absolutely say that lower levels of THC consumption results in much more impairment if cannabis hasn't been used recently and higher levels result in less impairment if there has been recent use.

That's not to say that driving (or any high-risk activity) is appropriate while actually high. It is not. Driving while impaired (by anything) is a terrible idea.

nobody9999··on Over 40% of deceased drivers in vehicle crashes test positive for THC: Study
>That's evidence of increased public/open-air consumption, which is to be expected with legalization

>Don't need to hide it anymore, especially if the local police don't have much to do otherwise

Yep. At least in New York City before legalization, using cannabis in public earned you an arrest and a night in jail despite the fact that it wasn't even a misdemeanor, just a local code violation with a $50 fine.

That was done consistently (I know several folks who were caught up in such chicanery) for decades to deter folks from using in public.

But enforcement was spotty and, as usual, melanin content played an outsized role in determining who would be "enforced."

Thank goodness that's not happening anymore.

Edit: Fixed prose ('we' --> 'were')>

nobody9999··on Over 40% of deceased drivers in vehicle crashes test positive for THC: Study
As the old saw about driving in NYC goes:

Green means 'Go!'

Yellow means 'Go faster!'

Red means 'The next six cars may go through the intersection.'

Okay, the third part is a little hyperbolic.

The above is from the 1980s and AFAICT (I've lived here nearly 60 years) not much has changed.

nobody9999··on Children with cancer scammed out of millions fundraised for their treatment
>I have trouble believing empowering people who have no risk of losing their job and no one knows they exist is the best model for making decisions for other people.

You mean like the (non-medical doctors) third-parties contracted by my private insurance provider who routinely deny important care[0] and even reject pre-approvals for antibiotics for MRSA infections even after multiple interactions with several medical doctors confirming both the diagnosis (with accompanying pathology) and the appropriate course of treatment.

Yeah, you keep that rolled up newspaper handy so you can "Gub'mint bad! Bad Gub'mint!"

I hope you never have to deal with a life-threatening situation where your insurer flatly refuses to cover treatment until after you're dead or have body parts amputated.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46291740

nobody9999··on Children with cancer scammed out of millions fundraised for their treatment
>Ok but urgency is a different kettle of fish. Life threatening cases get urgency everywhere and immediate care everywhere.

Except it doesn't. At least not in the United States. I have Peripheral Artery Disease.

I had two completely occluded arteries in my left leg and a third that was mostly occluded and had an aneurysm to boot.

One day, that third artery collapsed and I was left with zero blood flow to my left foot.

The doctor had me go to the Emergency Room to get testing and imaging to have surgery the following week.

He did not simply schedule surgery, as that would have required pre-approval from my insurance company and, in fact, the insurance company denied the claim and did not approve the procedure (which saved my foot) until six weeks later -- at which time I'd have had to have my foot amputated without the angioplasty and arterial bypass.

In fact, after surgery the insurance company continued to deny my claims and refused to authorize pain meds (they sliced my left leg open from my hip to my ankle and rooted around to use an existing vein to bypass the blockage on one of my arteries) for those same six weeks.

Oh yeah, US healthcare is so much better. /rolls eyes. My insurer would have forced me to wait until I required amputation if I hadn't just gone ahead on an emergency basis as suggested (because it's not unusual for that to happen) by the surgeon.

And in case you were wondering, yes I have private insurance and pay nearly $1200/month just for me. In fact, my deductible for next year just went up 20% and my annual out of pocket doubled, yet I'm still paying essentially the same premium.

No. The US healthcare system is completely fucked and I hope you don't die or lose important body parts learning that.

nobody9999··on Kids Rarely Read Whole Books Anymore. Even in English Class
>Let the market solve it. If the market requires educated adults the market will create that environment or something, answer is probably private schools. I assume they’d say something like that.

I don't pretend to speak for anyone else, but I am more than my economic inputs and outputs, and while it was in a somewhat different context, Heinlein's prose applies in spades WRT your assertion:

“I had to perform an act of faith. I had to prove to myself that I was a man. Not just a producing-consuming economic animal…but a man.” ― Robert A. Heinlein[0][1]

[0] https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/11588525-i-had-to-perform-a...

[1] From Starship Troopers[2]

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starship_Troopers

nobody9999··on Epic celebrates "the end of the Apple Tax" after court win in iOS payments case
>Are these the same thing?

Both articles appear to point at the same 9th circuit appeals court ruling:

The Ars piece points at:

https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/US-Co...

Which appears to be the same ruling as the Reuters piece links to:

https://fingfx.thomsonreuters.com/gfx/legaldocs/lgvdqxweopo/...

As such, I believe that, yes, this is the same ruling reported by both Ars and Reuters.

nobody9999··on Epic celebrates "the end of the Apple Tax" after court win in iOS payments case
Original Title (too long for title box):

Epic celebrates “the end of the Apple Tax” after appeals court win in iOS payments case

nobody9999··on Ask HN: Should "I asked $AI, and it said" replies be forbidden in HN guidelines?
>Would your prompt have been identical and produced identical results, today, tomorrow, which version of AI would you have used, were there bugs present that made the post or comment interesting that would have been absent in your response because the bug had been fixed already?

Why is that relevant to GP's point?

I can't speak for anyone else, but I come to HN to discuss stuff with other humans. If I wanted an LLM's (it's not AI, it's a predictive text algorithm) regurgitations, I can generate those myself and don't need "helpful" HNers to do it for me unasked.

When I come here I want to have a discussion with other sentient beings, not the gestalt of training data regurgitated by a bot.

Perhaps that makes me old-fashioned and/or bigoted against interacting with large language models, but that's what I want.

In discussion, I want to know what other sentient beings think, not an aggregation of text tokens based on their probability of being used in a particular sequence determined by the data fed to model.

The former can (but may well not be) a creative, intellectual act by a sentient being. The latter will never be so, as it's an aggregation of existing data/information as a sequence of tokens cobbled together based on the frequency with which such tokens are used in a particular order in the model's corpus.

That's not to say that LLM are useless. They are not. But their place is not in "curious conversation," IMNSHO.

nobody9999··on Congress warned that NASA's current plan for Artemis "cannot work"
I want to do Apollo again[0]. It was the beginning of a great age of human space exploration.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A4J9uvhJQM0

nobody9999··on Fighting the age-gated internet
>I was exposed to porn several ways pre-Internet. Older siblings, news stands, late night cable. If I wanted more, I could get it. It was simply not a problem.

Yup. Me too.

And it goes back much further. Cf. "Pictures of Lily"[0] for a pop culture exposition from nearly sixty years ago. The point being that "porn" isn't anything new, nor was it difficult to obtain (hence a popular song about "porn") even before computer networks.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g-PHDR2yhxE&list=RDg-PHDR2yh...

Edit: For those who would cite the current ubiquity of "hardcore" porn on the 'net, I'd say that's a difference in degree, not in kind. Something to consider.

nobody9999··on US air travelers without REAL IDs will be charged a $45 fee
>It’s actually gracious of them to offer an alternative.

I strongly disagree. The courts have repeatedly struck down limits on domestic travel over the past couple hundred years.

In fact, the $45 "fee" is an acknowledgment that you aren't required to have special documents to travel within the US. Otherwise, they just wouldn't let you travel.

So instead, they're making more security theater and punishing you if you don't comply with their demands.

That's not "gracious," that's coercive.

Edit: Fixed incorrect usage ("they'd" vs. "they").

nobody9999··on US air travelers without REAL IDs will be charged a $45 fee
>And yes, I agree. On multiple occasions in my adult life, I've "proved" my citizenship under threat of perjury, but that is only to say: I've made a statement on a form with my signature on it. My word alone was ~enough.

Sorry for the late reply.

You're absolutely right. As I said, that wasn't a "gotcha", but rather an acknowledgement that "proving" legal status to the Federal government, while gamed by those without such status, still carries criminal penalties if you're caught lying. And the same is true for RealID as well.

>But element 3, legal presence, is a bit tougher. There's a number of documents that are accepted, but only one of them is applicable to a plain-Jane native-born-Ohioan who does not have a passport.

>That document is an original birth certificate, or a certified copy of one.

A fair point. Weirdly, I had my original birth certificate for many years but it disintegrated. So when I needed it get a RealID (although I already have a passport which I also renewed around the same time) I was able to go online to the County Clerk in New York County, New York (better known as Manhattan) and get a certified copy of my birth certificate for a nominal fee (I'd note that a third-party fulfilled the order for a certified copy, with an additional credit card usage fee).

Which made things much easier as I was concerned I'd need to go to the County Clerk's at least once, possibly more to obtain a certified copy.

Not sure if Ohio County Clerks will do the same. If not, that sucks.

In any case, while it's more than mostly security theater, it wasn't (especially given that I needed a new driver's license anyway) all that big a deal for me. That could be radically different (and more difficult) for others, both those from other counties and who may not have been (mostly much older folks) included in registered births.

So yeah, it's basically yanking our chains for no good reason other than Congress posturing that they're "tough" on terrorism and co-opting the states to do all the hard work. Sigh.

nobody9999··on US air travelers without REAL IDs will be charged a $45 fee
>So, for example: As a native-born US citizen, that's a new requirement for me -- nothing else I've ever done in life has required me to prove my citizenship.

Unless you're really young (under 16 or so) and/or never had a job that paid wages, you've "proved" your citizenship (well, more specifically your right to work in the US which, in your case, adds up to the same thing) by filling out an IRS W9 form[0], which is required for any jobs which pays wages (whether that be hourly wages or a straight salary) by certifying -- under penalty of perjury if you lie -- that you're either a citizen or otherwise allowed to work in the US.[1]

I'm guessing you've "proven" your citizenship (or at least your legal presence/right to work in the US) at least once and likely (depending on how many employers you've had) more often.[3]

[0] https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/fw9.pdf

[1] No, this isn't specifically a test of citizenship, especially since non-citizen legal residents are also eligible to obtain RealID documents[2].

[2] https://www.pa.gov/agencies/dmv/driver-services/real-id/real...

[3] Please note that I'm absolutely not playing "gotcha" here. Rather, I'm pointing out that although we don't have Federal ID cards (although a passport certainly is that, and you Taxpayer ID Number -- usually your Social Security number -- are, in fact, Federal IDs) and RealID isn't a "Federal" ID. It's an "enhanced" (i.e., specific and often additional information specified by the Federal government is required to be submitted to your state of residence's licensing authority (usually the state Department of Motor Vehicles). As such, it's not actually a Federal ID, but a state ID with standardized requirements for verification across the US.

nobody9999··on HashJack Indirect Prompt Injection Weaponizes Websites
https://archive.ph/FkLc2
nobody9999··on Americans no longer see four-year college degrees as worth the cost
>You're agreeing with them. Keep reading their comment to understand why that didn't matter.

That's as may be, but my point was orthogonal to theirs and not meant as agreement or disagreement.

nobody9999··on Americans no longer see four-year college degrees as worth the cost
>The problem is that any hiring test that blacks and whites pass at different rates, is presumed racist. Never mind that the real issue might be that the blacks went to worse schools and received a worse education.

Your first sentence is the result of bigotry against those with "enhanced" melanin content, not the cause.

The cause is laid out in your second sentence.

Resolve the systemic bigotry (not just against those with enhanced melanin content, but against those with the least resources as, at least in the US, most schools are paid for by local property taxes, making the poorest areas the ones with the worst schools) and put us all on a level playing field and we'll be a much fairer society IMNSHO.

nobody9999··on Bringing Sexy Back. Internet surveillance has killed eroticism
>30 years ago it was rather normal that a manager would touch the behind of a coworker, which is clearly a bad thing. Nowadays looking in their direction a bit too long seems to be labeled 'not done'.

I was in the workforce 30 years ago and, no, it was absolutely not normal.

It was what we called an "HR violation" and a "Career limiting move."

Not sure where you were 30 years ago, but except in bordellos and strip clubs that wasn't "normal." Not even close.

nobody9999··on Plex's crackdown on free remote streaming access starts this week
I saw this and was confused.

But it actually seems to be true. Plex is charging you (and anyone you wish to share your media library with) to access your own media library remotely.

Huh? That should be a death sentence for Plex, right?

I can (and do) share my media library with jellyfin and other streaming servers. No one has tried to charge me for doing so.

One of the reasons I didn't use Plex back in 2019 when I was setting up my self-hosted streaming solution was that it required a log in on Plex's servers to play my locally hosted media. Which I thought was a bridge too far.

Now they're trying charge for accessing your own content? WTF?

Edit: I was unaware that Plex also provides "external" (e.g., not your local library) streams as well as locally hosted ones. As such, there's other stuff provided by the "Plex Pass" as well. Not sure if this makes a difference for users, but it certainly doesn't change my mind. That said, I wasn't going to use Plex anyway.

I hope those who do aren't too inconvenienced by the new charges/subscription requirements to play their own media.

nobody9999··on Doge 'doesn't exist' with eight months left on its charter
>No, it wasn't clear. I know several Trump voters who either didn't know Project 2025 existed or believed the lies that it was a liberal hoax.

>To anyone paying an ounce of attention, yeah it might have been clear.

Many, many folks were out there long before the election saying (both as promises -- from the Trumpers and warnings -- from pretty much everyone else) that Project 2025 would be the blueprint for a new Trump administration.

That some folks either ignored or disbelieved it doesn't make it "unclear." Rather, it means that a lot of people believed the lies. Which says more about those who believed such lies than it does about everyone else.

And to put a fine point on it, what more could others have done to disabuse those folks of the lies told them by the Trump campaign? Seriously.

nobody9999··on Iowa City made its buses free. Traffic cleared, and so did the air
>Homeless people have higher rates of substance and mental-health issues, and, unsurprisingly, less access to showers and laundry facilities.

As someone who was homeless (for less than a year, thankfully!), my experience was that many people with nowhere to go (myself included) become incredibly despondent that they have no roof, no shower, no place to keep (let alone wash) their clothes and turn to drugs as a way of (temporarily) ameliorating their suffering.

Those with mental health issues often can't hold a job as they're suffering from debilitating mental illness (duh!) and those with no place to shower or keep clean clothes have a hard time getting, keeping jobs too.

The latter group mostly just needs the opportunity to present themselves for job inquiries bathed, reasonably well rested and in clean clothes.

The former group needs the same plus mental health services including supervision and treatment.

Don't forget that more than half of Americans are an unexpected $600 emergency away from being unable to pay for food, rent, utilities, etc.

But most folks ignore that and instead just want them gone. They don't care where -- in jail -- in another city -- just as long as they don't have to look at them. It's disgusting.

← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →