HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

noelherrick

278 karma · joined January 15, 2013

I write software. hireme@noelherrick.com noelherrick.com
submissionscomments
noelherrick··on So what was that? Was Starship’s launch a failure or a success?
What SpaceX is doing is amazing, and it is a fun show. Reusable rockets are beginning to be as cool as the space shuttle was. However, it could very well be the case the Shotwell and the engineers are actively trying to prevent Musk from making bad calls while promoting good calls (I'm not saying this was a bad call). It's perfectly reasonable, if you have a company controlled by two actors, one of them bad and one of them good, to always praise the good actor when things go right and blame the bad actor when things go wrong (caveat: I am not calling Elon a bad actor, just saying that it's not hypocritical to always blame the bad actor and praise the good actor).

But this leads to a bigger problem. SpaceX's attitude of experiment vs. drawn-out design is working (perhaps not too dissimilar to agile vs. waterfall design). Even with all that careful planning, the Space Race did kill people, we almost lost Apollo 13, and there were two distinct shuttle disasters that killed everyone on board. Even with very careful progress, we still had disasters. But, as I think this launch shows, SpaceX is going to experience similar events unless there's a incentives and structures to actually empower people with safety concerns (meaning the engineers and technicians on the ground).

Both post-mortems on the shuttle disasters are filled with something like "a higher-up decided it wasn't that big of a deal and dismissed concerns because previous red flags turned out to be nothing." Single humans can be singularly stupid. Single humans that are busy running a company, incentivized by profit margins, isolated from on-the-ground operations, equipped with a golden parachute, and wealthier than god, are even more prone to detachment from reality.

I also feel a bit bad for the astronauts that have to gamble whether these rockets are safe. Did this actually pass safety checks or is my life a sacrifice Elon Musk is willing to make? I suppose this has been part of the calculus of all astronauts since the post-Space Race era started to defund NASA, but it still sucks even if it's de rigueur at this point.

noelherrick··on Tech bosses are letting dictators censor what Americans see
Something I've been chewing on is legitimacy by process vs. outcome (means vs. end). We have far too long said if the means are done fairly (Musk bought Twitter legitimately, Zuck founded and unilaterally controls Facebook mostly legally), then we have to accept the outcome, even if that outcome is detrimental to the wider society. We just have to stop accepting that. Corporate law, money, etc. are all made up and are sold to the wider population as net boons to society. Why can't we dissolve and/or nationalize companies when they cease to be beneficial or have distinct negatives?

Copyright, patents, LLCs, publicly-traded companies, etc., all nominally exist to benefit society at large. They're not supposed to be this game of "I called shotgun so suck it!"

noelherrick··on Most of my skills are now worth nothing, but 10% are worth 1000x
"Poverty exists not because we cannot feed the poor, but because we cannot satisfy the rich." - Anon.

I first began to encounter this when I as an idealistic teenager looked into why poverty/hunger still existed when we had enough food/money to wipe it out. Aid to low income countries often wouldn't get to the intended recipient. Their leaders would live like kings while kids would die from malnutrition. It just baffled me (still does) how someone could be so selfish.

Then I realized we in the US have it just around the corner. I knew someone who worked at a "remedial" high school where the kids struggled with hunger, homelessness, and addiction. All the schools in the area would shuffle any kid in danger of flunking to make sure their numbers looked good. They lived in neighborhoods I as a middle-class person would never venture into. We just do a good job sweeping massive poverty in the US under the rug.

This was a middle of the road state - then you look at states such as Mississippi and you wonder how we can live with ourselves.

noelherrick··on Most of my skills are now worth nothing, but 10% are worth 1000x
If you really think that, then shouldn't you abolish economics? If a system doesn't value humans, and in fact in its history has proven it will turn babies into profit (lookin' at you Nestle), it's anti-human and as a human, it's immoral to support that system.
noelherrick··on Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten survival
Sales/VAT are regressive, so if by politics you mean "not hosing the already hosed (the poor)", and by most economists you mean folks from the Austrian school of economics, then sure.
noelherrick··on I worked at Google for -10 days
Google is profitable. They are not losing money, and they are in no danger of becoming unprofitable because of payroll. If we lived in world where folks measured things in a normal light, Google would not have frozen hiring, rescinded offers, and laid-off thousands. We live in the upside down world. We have to stop accepting the crazy, upside-down values of the modern world. The world would be better if Google just wanted to be an awesome search engine that made money by being great, instead of trying to grow quarter after quarter (unsustainable in the long run).
noelherrick··on The biggest EV battery recycling plant in the US is open for business
I find this comment strange since TFA talks about investment from the US government. I guess if by supply and demand, you mean the government demands clean energy and then the market supplies it, that could work, but this decade has been all about the private sector whistling past the graveyard of climate change.
noelherrick··on I wish GPT4 had never happened
We are talking past each other: I'm saying there are lots of ways that the wealthy avoid taxes, such as borrowing against equities for expenses (https://www.wsj.com/articles/buy-borrow-die-how-rich-america...). Trump had a private jet but paid $750.00 in income tax for a couple of years. Additionally, capital gains taxes are lower than many income brackets (cf. Buffet's famous quote about being taxed more than his assistant). Finally, carried interest loophole allows private equity managers to classify services as capital gains.

Basically, if you have enough equity, a bank will loan you the money you need, while you can leave those stocks untouched. You don't have to pay any tax, let alone the extremely preferential capital gains tax.

The Whitehouse in 2021 estimated that the 400 wealthiest families paid around an 8% income tax (https://www.whitehouse.gov/cea/written-materials/2021/09/23/...).

US has a tax gap of perhaps $1 trillion, and much of that is wealthy Americans who are too hard to pursue: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/13/business/irs-tax-gap.html. That could be 50% of the bill if we were able to cut healthcare expenses by dropping insurance companies, removing pharma control of prices, etc., to try to attain similar OECD healthcare costs.

The US is in a unique situation. We have to both reduce the amount of rent-seekers within the healthcare system while increasing the taxes we levy on the wealthy. Universal care might mean an increase in taxes on the middle-class, but universal care will ultimately reduce their expenses since it's more efficient.

PS. Please don't attack people personally: it's much better to say, "This comment does not account for X," than "You seem very uniformed [sic]?"

PPS. If you need a poignant example of the failure of the US healthcare system, look no further than maternal mortality rates. What a disgrace.

noelherrick··on I wish GPT4 had never happened
The American Medical Association restricts med student slots. You could say it’s government but it’s regulatory capture rather than government regulation. Remove Citizen’s United, close the revolving door, and fund congressional research offices so that legislators don’t have to depend on lobbyists for research and writing legislation.
noelherrick··on I wish GPT4 had never happened
Having a single payer healthcare system would increase taxes but could decrease overall costs by 50% (since US pays 2x what other equivalent countries pay).

Beyond that, we have an issue where corporations and high-net worth individuals aren’t paying taxes, which could prevent onerous taxes on the middle class. No nation really taxes the rich (cf. the Panama Papers).

noelherrick··on The average American has the same life expectancy as the worst part of England
I chose my words carefully (though clearly not my spelling):

- CEOs/wealthy folks are more likely to be psychopaths vs. the average population (https://www.cnbc.com/2019/04/08/the-science-behind-why-so-ma...) - Power disables empathy (https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/social-empathy/20190...) - Normal Americans have basically zero power - all decisions are made by the elites/special interest groups (https://scholar.princeton.edu/sites/default/files/mgilens/fi...)

Add in a personal attack, and the common right-wing trope of "I wanted to agree with you but you said it wrong so now I must punish you," and, baby, you got a conservative stew going.

noelherrick··on Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities
Pretty sure that was just racism: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight#United_States
noelherrick··on Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities
If in your city, cars are faster than public transportation, I would say that's most likely due to poor implementation of it. In my experience in NYC, London, Tokyo, Bangkok, even the Bay Area (TBF, haven't visited in years), metros are much faster and much more pleasant.

Unfortunately, in the US, we let a bunch of politicians who claim the government is bad at everything run the government. They have a vested interest in making sure it's not well run. For goodness sake, we had a president who said, "The nine most terrifying words in the English language are: I'm from the government, and I'm here to help." A sitting US president, who according to Wikipedia, is part of the government. We should have demanded his resignation then and there, and got someone who wasn't terrified of the organization he was a head of.

The most immediate solution to this is stop relying on contractors and let the government at every level build up public planning departments and a construction workforce that doesn't get let go when the project is finished.

noelherrick··on Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities
If you've only traveled in the US, you think public transportation is for poor people. I haven't used all US metros, but even NYC is pretty shabby in comparison to London or Tokyo. Most folks probably also haven't lived in a walkable city (which implies denser, smaller housing).

I don't want to force a lifestyle on anyone, but for me it is glorious just popping on a skytrain or a subway, listening to my music, and watching the world go by. I don't have to buy a car, pay for insurance, get gas every week, change the oil, repair it when it inevitably breaks down or things wear out, thus easily doubling the initial cost, find parking, and wash and clean it. I don't like dealing with different vehicle sizes, pedestrians on their phone, and drivers who think their time is worth my safety.

noelherrick··on The average American has the same life expectancy as the worst part of England
The solution to this is known by everyone, including those who will fain ignorance. Implement universal healthcare (including mental health), regulate guns (insurance, registration, training, buybacks, red flag laws) including banning weapons of war, build public transportation and transition away from car-mandatory living in all but the most rural areas, and push for democratically-controlled unions and worker co-ops. The second tier would be around children, namely we should reinstate the child tax credit, make university free, and provide childcare. We need to have a conversation around maternal mortality as well, because that is too darn high in the US (one theory is that we are too doctor-controlled and they will be more likely to induce or perform a c-section).

This may seem like a grabbag of policies, but it's because (as it is mentioned in the Twitter thread), there are a grabbag of failures: lack of healthcare, forced dependency on cars, and deaths of despair, which are very closely tied to our crushing work culture (especially for blue collar folks). The neoliberal capitalism alienates people from their labor and their fellow worker, and makes widely available drugs, alcohol, and ultra-processed foods to numb the pain after a long shift. We've created a machine that's very good at crushing people up to turn them into money for people who will never be able to spend what they have already (cf. the Sacklers and the opioid epidemic or Bezos and workers urinating in bottles).

America has so much potential. I still have great hope we can come together. Right now, it's like the Onion wrote: "'No Way to Prevent This', Says Only Nation Where This Regularly Happens". We have to stop pretending we don't know the solution. The jig is up. I feel like we're in the movie Fury. Everyone knows Germany is doomed, but more people have to die because of Hitler's ego and the cowardice of everyone around him. We've let the psychopaths run things for too long. We have to take our power back.

noelherrick··on What we still don’t know about how A.I. is trained
While they will absolutely backstab each other given an opportunity (see the VCs who caused a bank run that primarily affected other VCs), they do seem pretty chummy. Davos is quite literally the summit of the elites.
noelherrick··on GPT-4 Designed a Programming Language
OP is clearly distressed and you replied with with what comes out as “it’s your fault and you deserve this.” It costs nothing to refrain from replying and only the smallest amount of effort to provide some solidarity with your fellow human.

OP, I feel you-I had a similar response to this clearly orchestrated PR campaign. OpenAI really loves that people think that it can replace the entire tech industry with an API. It would mean they are the most valuable company ever to exist.

Personally, I’ve been through so many hype waves of “this will take our jobs!!!1” I’m a bit inured to the whole thing. My personal belief is that software development will be the last one to go, the ones to turn out the lights. And we should be grateful that our jobs go away. Let’s go drink wine and eat cheese in the forest, dancing under a moonlit sky.

My advice is to get offline, talk to a loved one, pet a dog, go look at art, meditate, basically anything that doesn’t involve a screen.

noelherrick··on GitHub to lay off 10% and close all offices
Mmm, SQL Server and, to a lesser extent, C# would like to have a word.
noelherrick··on Apple’s anti-union tactics in Atlanta were illegal, US officials say
Unions that are run like a business eventually become a business. Unions need to be democratically-controlled, where regular workers can propose new contract terms and vote on them, as well as voting to call a strike.
noelherrick··on Beyond Meat is struggling, and the plant-based meat industry worries
Densely-quartered urban dwellers eating like sparsely-populated pastoralists is not sustainable. A theory behind the sanctification of cows in India is because a cow kept for its meat feeds far fewer people than one kept for its milk. The same would apply to some of the climate effects, such as the feed crops, although I don't know if it would change the cow-emitted methane.
noelherrick··on The Oceanic+ app comes to Apple Watch Ultra
This is an excellent point, and one that I hadn't thought of. I've seen dive computer failure but never erroneous readings.
noelherrick··on The Oceanic+ app comes to Apple Watch Ultra
Dive computers don't keep you alive during the dive, they keep you alive afterwards :P But seriously, if a dive computer fails, you go off your buddy's computer or scrub the dive and go with a maximum surface interval. At worst, this watch failing means you have to end early. Dive computers have extra safety precautions around surfacing too quickly, but divers are trained to use things such as watching air bubbles to time their surfacing. I have never seen a setup that only uses digital gauges for air pressure.

This is all rec diving (<= 40m). I would never, ever use an Apple device for tech diving, even if some future version is rated for it.

noelherrick··on Collapse of emergency healthcare in England may be costing 500 lives every week
So Americans were the tallest until McDonalds arrived? (est. 1940)
noelherrick··on Collapse of emergency healthcare in England may be costing 500 lives every week
No, that’s called state-controlled capitalism. Change board of directors to senators and you have all the same problems of free market capitalism.

Industrial democracy, where workers own and control the company, backed by a robust welfare state, is socialism.

noelherrick··on Collapse of emergency healthcare in England may be costing 500 lives every week
Socialism would absolutely not require selfless people-it would simple require that workers control and own the companies they work in, and the knowledge that fixing other people’s problems makes everyone’s life better. Less theft, violence, better mental health, no more mass shootings, no more homeless encampments.

Imagine if that co-worker that doesn’t contribute or might even drag the team down can just quit and play PS5. Glorious.

How do I know people don’t need coercion or even pay to produce great products? Open source software. Windows is capitalism and Linux is socialism. Which do you prefer?

noelherrick··on Collapse of emergency healthcare in England may be costing 500 lives every week
If a hospital were worked owned and controlled, they’re not gonna bribe their Tory buddies to shutdown public medical services because most people aren’t that ridiculously selfish and no one individual gets wealthy. And if it’s a private hospital, the doctors and nurses will use profits to pay themselves well and cut down on costs, because again, they are face to face with people trying to pay foe their medical care.
noelherrick··on Why Punish?
These types of analysis start out the basic proposition that systems are designed for a specific goal from the start and that we should judge them based on those goals. Our justice systems have emergent properties that have arisen after many years and are due to many historical accidents vs. a planned or purposeful approach. They should also be judged on their outcomes, not their professed goals.

I will talk about the US, since that's what I have the most experience with and it's where MIT is located. The US does not adopt either of those strategies mentioned in the article, even if it does dress itself in the rhetoric of either moral justice or practical utility (the former is heavily favored). The outcomes of policing, legal system, and prisons is that poor and Black people are heavily oppressed and only the property rights of the weathly are taken seriously. White people's drug crimes are punished less than Black people's drug crimes. Heck, even the criminalization of drugs is oppressive against the already oppressed.

What is wild is that we don't see the police and judicial system as an occupying force. Why do police departments need MRAPs, M-16s, and plate carriers? Why do we have to keep gasing, shooting, and beating our own citizens? Why does the NSA and CIA feel the need to monitor our every word?

We can do better, but we have to admit that our system is not working for a lot of people. This is a blameless post-mortem, so all I want to do is fix our system, not assign blame. We have to make this better, for the sake of all.

noelherrick··on Manhattan rents cross $5k threshold for first time
The alternative for many is worse - many roommates, incredibly long commute, or homelessness. Remember that Googler who lived in his car? (https://www.businessinsider.com/google-employee-lives-in-tru...)
noelherrick··on Manhattan rents cross $5k threshold for first time
Industrialization, constitutional democracy, science, regulation, and unions have raised standards of living for the majority of people. You forget history if you don't remember things like the Battle of Blair Mountain (first aerial bombardment on US soil) or the Triangle Shirtwaist factory, not to mention the incredible death and misery inflicted by that first capitalistic country Britain. The free market does not feel very free to the vast majority of people who have to deal with incredibly oppressive companies and plutocrats, and when laws and police are geared to oppressing the poor and the jobless.

Do not take me to advocate for centralized planning, but we do have to have democratic governmental intervention to prevent the free market from chewing us all up and spitting us out.

noelherrick··on Rogers network outage across Canada hits banks, businesses and consumers
My jaw literally dropped. I cannot believe this level of corruption. Goodness gracious.
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →