HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

noelsusman

2,734 karma · joined July 11, 2010

submissionscomments
noelsusman··on Mercedes-Benz commits to bringing back physical buttons
China, famous for never putting ideology over policy.
noelsusman··on DeepSeek V4–almost on the frontier, a fraction of the price
It's mostly just a bad model. Plenty of people would be willing to overlook the baggage if the model was even marginally better than the competition.
noelsusman··on Claude Code refuses requests or charges extra if your commits mention "OpenClaw"
In my experience Anthropic positions itself as the "safe" AI company more than the "ethical" AI company. They're related but not the same thing.

The only way you could be surprised that Anthropic wants to be in bed with the US military is if you just never listened to anything Dario has said publicly. He's very open about wanting the US government and the US military to use Claude to win against China. That's why Claude was in the Pentagon before all the others in the first place.

>LLMs are fundamentally incapable of controlling autonomous weapons anyway

This is obviously false, though that's not surprising from what I've seen from Zitron. Claude is probably too slow and clunky to go full mech warrior for the time being, but it would be trivial to hook Claude up to an autonomous drone with missile strike capabilities. Those things are mostly autonomous already, they just require a human to tell them where to shoot. Claude can easily do that with a simple API.

The rest is valid. I wouldn't describe Anthropic as an ethical company. On the contrary, if you believe that you losing the AI race is an existential threat to humanity, then it's easy to justify all sorts of unethical behavior for the greater good.

noelsusman··on Google and Pentagon reportedly agree on deal for 'any lawful' use of AI
In that scenario the President would invoke the Defense Production Act to compel the oil company to supply the oil. They threatened to use that power against Anthropic, though it's unclear how it applies to something like AI. "Claude without guardrails" is not a product Anthropic offers, so they would fight it on grounds similar to how Apple fought against being forced to crack an iPhone.

The main issue here is that Congress is asleep at the wheel and has refused to implement any sort of guardrails around how the government is and is not allowed to use AI.

noelsusman··on If America's so rich, how'd it get so sad?
Secularism in the US began rising steadily in 1990 and has actually been declining since 2020. That trend doesn't line up well with any of the data we're talking about.
noelsusman··on SpaceX says it has agreement to acquire Cursor for $60B
I've had hundreds of AI-powered vendor tools come across my desk as part of my job, and I have yet to see a single one that uses Grok. I'm also not aware of any publicly announced customers for Grok's enterprise offering. The Grok Enterprise website doesn't list any customers.
noelsusman··on SpaceX says it has agreement to acquire Cursor for $60B
$60 billion worth of competent people?
noelsusman··on SpaceX says it has agreement to acquire Cursor for $60B
I wouldn't be surprised if those enterprise relationships evaporate after this acquisition. There's a reason why xAI has zero enterprise customers.
noelsusman··on At long last, InfoWars is ours
The Onion is owned by the billionaire founder of Twilio, there is no board of directors.
noelsusman··on Codex for almost everything
Just yesterday my non-technical spouse had to solve a moderately complex scheduling problem at work. She gave the various criteria and constraints to Claude and had a full solution within a few minutes, saving hours of work. It ended up requiring a few hundred lines of Python to implement a scheduling optimization algorithm. She only vaguely knows what Python is, but that didn't matter. She got what she needed.

For now she was only able to do that because I set up a modified version of my agentic coding setup on her computer and told her to give it a shot for more complex tasks. It won't be trivial, but I do think there's a big opportunity for whoever can translate the experience we're having with agentic coding to a non-technical audience.

noelsusman··on US and Iran agree to provisional ceasefire
The thing to remember about Iran is it's a country run by religious fanatics. Ask a secular democracy if they would trade the lives of most of their political and military leaders for a 10% boost to GDP and they would look at you like you're insane. Ask 86 year old Ali Khamenei if he would trade dying from an Israeli bomb landing on his house for Iran establishing a stranglehold on global oil trade and securing $100 billion in annual toll revenue, and he would have been ecstatic.
noelsusman··on US and Iran agree to provisional ceasefire
The companies with billions on the line didn't seem to think Iran's threats to attack ships were impotent.

Their military capabilities are diminished in the short term, but if their ability to impose a toll on the Strait of Hormuz holds then that's a massive win for Iran in the medium/long term. A mere $2M per ship represents 10% of Iran's GDP. They would become the only country in the world to impose a toll on international waters, and they would have established a defensive deterrent almost as effective as having a nuclear bomb.

They took on the most powerful military ever seen and lived to tell the tale. It's hard to spin that as a loss for Iran.

noelsusman··on Qwen3.6-Plus: Towards real world agents
My initial experiments are not encouraging. I have a basic planning prompt that includes instructions not to edit any files or implement anything. Qwen-3.6-Plus will consistently ignore that completely and proceed with implementation. I expect that kind of behavior from small models I run locally, not a hosted closed model claiming to compete with the frontier models.
noelsusman··on DRAM pricing is killing the hobbyist SBC market
The helium that goes into balloons is mostly a byproduct of industrial grade helium production that would otherwise just go to waste. It's not pure enough for industrial uses.
noelsusman··on How the AI Bubble Bursts
That analyst was talking about subsidizing tokens through the subscription plans, which is a different claim.
noelsusman··on Goodbye to Sora
That doesn't sound meaningfully different from what people are already doing on Instagram and TikTok all day.
noelsusman··on What Young Workers Are Doing to AI-Proof Themselves
Assuming the AI maximalist digital god bros are wrong, there will always be some demand for programmers, the question is how much. It's not hard to see a future where programming goes the way of farming where the demand for small-scale farming still exists but at a tiny fraction of what it once was.
noelsusman··on Reports of code's death are greatly exaggerated
Well you're trying to convince them to reject their actual experience. Better tooling and better models have indeed solved a lot of the limitations models faced a couple years ago.

I also believe coding isn't going to disappear, but AI skeptics have been mostly doing a combination of moving the goalposts and straight up denial over the last few years.

noelsusman··on OpenCode – Open source AI coding agent
pi.dev is worth checking out. The basic idea is they provide a minimalist coding agent that's designed to be easy to extend, so you can tailor the harness to suit your needs without any bloat.

One of the best features is they haven't been noticed by Anthropic yet so you can still use your Claude subscription.

noelsusman··on Iran war energy shock sparks global push to reduce fossil fuel dependence
The Jones Act requires that all goods transported by water between US ports be carried on ships that were built in the US, fly the US flag, and crewed by US citizens. That effectively makes it impossible to ship oil between US states at scale without a direct pipeline.

Though to be clear I believe we would still be a net exporter without the Jones Act, it's just one of those weird things about the US oil industry.

noelsusman··on Iran war energy shock sparks global push to reduce fossil fuel dependence
Being a net exporter of a global commodity is only relevant in an extremely acute crisis (e.g. WWIII).

Plus one of the reasons why we export so much oil is because it's cheaper to import oil to a refinery in New Jersey from Saudi Arabia than to get it there from Texas due to some very stupid US laws.

noelsusman··on Iran war energy shock sparks global push to reduce fossil fuel dependence
Oil companies love $90 oil, but much higher than that and you start to run into demand destruction issues in the medium term.
noelsusman··on The American Healthcare Conundrum
You can really just say anything and get upvoted on this website.

If this were true then private insurers would have paid comparable rates to Medicare prior to the ACA passing, and that's just not the case. This fact has been a fixture of the US healthcare system since the creation of Medicare.

noelsusman··on Qatar helium shutdown puts chip supply chain on a two-week clock
Shutting down production doesn't pressure the US at all since the oil and gas can't go anywhere anyway. They're shutting it down because they have to, there's nowhere to put the oil.
noelsusman··on India's top court angry after junior judge cites fake AI-generated orders
It would be relatively trivial to build a system that gives an LLM the tools necessary to go through each citation in a legal brief and verify its authenticity, and that's something I think opus-4.6 or gpt-5.3 could complete reliably.
noelsusman··on President Trump bans Anthropic from use in government systems
Why does Trump want to give a woke radical leftist AI the ability to autonomously kill people? Doesn't seem like the smartest decision.
noelsusman··on Layoffs at Block
This is one of the most "AI tech bro bubble" comments I've ever seen. The broader job market is a bloodbath right now.
noelsusman··on Layoffs at Block
Why is this statement in all lowercase? Is this a tech bro thing I'm unaware of?
noelsusman··on Statement from Dario Amodei on our discussions with the Department of War
The notion that it's bad to signal virtue is one of the crazier propaganda efforts I've seen over the last 20 years or so.
noelsusman··on Will vibe coding end like the maker movement?
The people who did best during the gold rush were the people who went out and were lucky enough to find stockpiles of gold.
← PreviousPage 2 of 23Next →