HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

noelsusman

2,734 karma · joined July 11, 2010

submissionscomments
noelsusman··on Russia blocks ProtonMail
I can understand this in the specific context of Russia, but I honestly don't understand this as a general principle. Allowing the police to convince a judge to issue a warrant for information on a few ProtonMail users doesn't expose 99.9% of other ProtonMail users to anything. Why would a warrant to kick somebody's door down be okay while a warrant for this is not? Are you opposed to all types of police warrants?

There is a balance between privacy and catching bad guys, but I often get the sense that much of this community believes the police should never be able to invade somebody's privacy even if they have evidence that person committed a crime. That doesn't seem like a sensible balance to me, and it's an extreme position to take. Am I misunderstanding?

noelsusman··on How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”?
Yes, and I am a customer. I own a Macbook, and I would love to use iMessage on it, but doing so would mean losing all of my messages as soon as I pick up a different device. That makes iMessage (and most Apple services) completely useless to me, a paying customer.

Their decision to wall off iMessage actively hurts their own customers by preventing them from seamlessly communicating with the most popular mobile OS using modern technology. They get away with it because they're Apple and they make good products, but that doesn't mean I have to think it's good.

noelsusman··on How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”?
iMessage has done more to hold back messaging in the US than anything else. Even if Google was competent at messaging it wouldn't matter because iOS users wouldn't switch and Apple refuses to open up iMessage to non-Apple devices.

I'm still using SMS for most of my messaging, and I primarily blame Apple for that.

noelsusman··on U.S. wants the EU to accept chemical-washed chicken as part of trade deal
Then why focus on the chemical wash and not the actual problem people care about?
noelsusman··on Why Some Doctors Purposely Misdiagnose Patients
What makes you think ML will help with diagnosing unusual cases? If anything I would expect ML to make that problem worse, not better.
noelsusman··on Why Some Doctors Purposely Misdiagnose Patients
Congress disagrees. They tried to get that into the ACA but it was a few votes short. They had to settle for more transparency in payments to doctors: https://openpaymentsdata.cms.gov/
noelsusman··on How housing became the world’s biggest asset class
https://www.longtermtrends.net/home-price-median-annual-inco...
noelsusman··on How housing became the world’s biggest asset class
It hasn't reached that level of nonsense again. In 2006, the median price of a house was 5.1 times the median income. Today it's 4.4 times median income, which is high compared to most of recent history, but is actually lower than it was in 1955.

Nobody thinks SPY is going to keep increasing forever. The conventional wisdom is we're looking at a recession in the next 1-2 years.

noelsusman··on Stripe can make automatic LLCs but a wire transfer from Citi nearly ended me
I feel your pain. I've had to stop clicking on any healthcare related threads around here. It's too infuriating.
noelsusman··on Lyft’s algorithm is trying to block people with names like ‘Dick’ and ‘Cummings’
Race is not a uniquely American concept. The Germans were the ones who first came up with the idea of a Caucasian race back in the 18th century. You're not wrong though, we should use White European instead since that's what it means today.
noelsusman··on Boeing employees mocked FAA in internal messages before 737 Max disasters
I do. I've only ever worked for public universities or state owned organizations, so every work email I've ever written is theoretically accessible via an open records request. I write every email as if it's going to be published on the front page of my local paper.

As a result I don't use email very much.

noelsusman··on Evaluating State and Local Business Tax Incentives [pdf]
>"We do not find strong evidence" is not the same as "no evidence"

Yes it is? It's not literally the same, but it conveys the same meaning.

noelsusman··on Top Paying Tech Companies by SWE Level
"Better than a startup" is a very low bar.
noelsusman··on Hospitals mergers do not improve quality: study
The overwhelming majority of hospitals in the US are nonprofits.
noelsusman··on The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb
My university (public with ~30k total students) got $382 million from tuition and fees last year. They spent $339 million just on student instruction. They spent $197 million on operations/maintenance. $115 million went to academic support and student services.
noelsusman··on Americans are retiring to Vietnam
Medicare doesn't cover long-term care
noelsusman··on Alienated, Alone and Angry: What the Digital Revolution Did?
I have spent significant time being car dependent and not owning a car at all, and I don't think it had any effect on my levels of isolation. Walking around strangers didn't make me feel less isolated than driving around them.

Also since when did the US not have city parks filled with people?

noelsusman··on The Bloomberg Terminal, Explained
No, they would not. They've proven that over and over again.
noelsusman··on An account is now required to read Reddit comment threads?
It's a for-profit company. Chasing profits is the entire point. If that wasn't the point then they would have an alternative organizational structure and enjoy the various tax benefits that come with it, like VLC does.
noelsusman··on We Just Got a Rare Look at US National Security Surveillance
The court was set up to spy on foreigners and Americans. To get a FISA warrant on a US citizen you have to show probable cause that the person is an agent of a foreign government engaging in intelligence activities.
noelsusman··on Learning at work is work, and we must make space for it
Where I work standups are for devs only. The product guys are involved in planning and reveals, but otherwise they stay out of our hair. We're expected to complete what we've committed to on time or promptly notify the product guys if that's not going to happen for whatever reason.

About once a week (usually Friday) I tell my team I'm going to spend the day researching or exploring some new idea that doesn't have any stories yet. It's never a problem. A decent chunk of our big leaps forward for our projects have come from us working on random stuff nobody told us to work on.

noelsusman··on Facebook Tells Barr It Won’t Open Up Encrypted Messages
But there already is a backdoor that lets them read the messages. Facebook actually implementing the functionality to take advantage of that backdoor doesn't change anything. The security of your message relies on the security of Facebook's infrastructure either way.

If Facebook implements a switch in the app that would send your decrypted messages back to them, then a malicious actor would have to compromise Facebook to obtain those message. Right now, a malicious actor can obtain your messages by compromising Facebook and implementing that switch themselves. From a security standpoint that seems identical to me.

noelsusman··on Facebook Tells Barr It Won’t Open Up Encrypted Messages
That's why I'm confused about Facebook claiming it's impossible. It seems clearly possible without compromising anything about the current level of security on the platform. They would have to develop specific functionality for it, but it is possible.
noelsusman··on Facebook Tells Barr It Won’t Open Up Encrypted Messages
They can't read them in transit, but if you use Facebook's app to decrypt the message (which is the only option) then obviously Facebook can read your messages if it wants to.
noelsusman··on Facebook Tells Barr It Won’t Open Up Encrypted Messages
I hear this all the time but I don't understand why it's true. The security of your encrypted messages already relies on the security of the company providing the service. Facebook (and any other messaging app) can read all of your messages in plain text. Otherwise they wouldn't be able to display them to you. Allowing the government to get a warrant to retrieve those messages changes nothing about the overall security of the messaging platform.

What am I missing?

noelsusman··on Sanders unveils plan to boost broadband access, break internet and cable titans
Most of this is standard Democratic boilerplate. It's how they have been trying to appeal to rural voters for at least the last decade. Obama ran on roughly the same plan in 2008. So did Hillary in 2016. Obama even brought it up during his debates with McCain.

Without Congress on board there's only so much you can do. Obama made some regulatory changes and shuffled some money around to get at this problem, but without a big pile of new money from Congress it's not going to do much.

noelsusman··on How to fight back against Google AMP as a web user and a web developer
>Ironically, by creating AMP, google has disincentivized publishers from making their canonical pages faster.

In theory, maybe, but I think history has clearly demonstrated that publishers will not make their pages faster if AMP didn't exist. That's why AMP has been so successful in the first place.

noelsusman··on How to fight back against Google AMP as a web user and a web developer
Of course AMP has other motives than simply making the web faster for mobile, but it also does make the web faster for mobile. I guarantee the AMP version of that paper's mobile website provided a significantly better user experience than the normal version. That is why AMP has been successful, and it's why I will continue to click on AMP links whenever available.

Is giving Google that much control ideal? Of course not, but from a user perspective it's a hell of a lot better than the alternative.

noelsusman··on I was a drug rep and know how pharma companies pushed opioids
Things have tightened up a bit since then, though not completely. My dad ran hospitals for a living when I was a kid and we got tons of free tickets to sporting events from various vendors trying to sell him stuff. He would have to listen to a 10 minute pitch from some salesman (that he always made fun of later) and in return he got a free night out with the family. I remember being mad when that dried up in the mid-2000s. I later learned that CMS had implemented some regulations cracking down on the practice.

These days, thanks to the ACA, you can look up exactly how much money your doctor has received from medical device manufacturers or pharmaceutical companies (https://www.cms.gov/openpayments/)

noelsusman··on I was a drug rep and know how pharma companies pushed opioids
Patient satisfaction is part of performance reviews because CMS decided to use it as an input for their hospital ratings that are posted online. They also adjust payments to hospitals based on the results.

Also, most hospitals in the US are nonprofits, though that doesn't free them from cost pressures or the need to advertise.

← PreviousPage 12 of 23Next →