HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nojokes

288 karma · joined August 16, 2020

submissionscomments
nojokes··on Children's Risk of Serious Illness from Covid-19 Is as Low as It Is for the Flu
Newer and larger study: Thirty-Day Outcomes of Children and Adolescents With COVID-19: An International Experience

https://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article/148/3/e20200...

Is this truth? I really do not know.

nojokes··on Risk of myocarditis following sequential COVID-19 vaccinations by age and sex [pdf]
This preprint is actually a companion paper to their already published paper in Nature where they do not stratify by age and sex together.

In principle this is bad because we know already very well that it affects more young men.

I think they made the situation even worse by stratifying only for myocarditis and not for pericarditis and cardiac arrhythmias that according to their paper are much more likely with COVID-19 because it did not register at all for vaccines.

This means that people are now getting a very wrong/incomplete picture of the risk benefit relationship.

Naturally cardiac issues are not the only possible problems because COVID-19 is systemic disease that can affect many organs and can cause a lot of trouble even without hospitalization.

nojokes··on Risk of myocarditis following sequential COVID-19 vaccinations by age and sex [pdf]
If you got Pfizer, your risk is lower than Moderna for myocarditis. Fairly similar to COVID-19 itself according to this paper. There is also pericarditis and cardiac arrhythmia that they covered in their original paper https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-021-01630-0#Sec30

Unfortunately not stratified by age and sex there (what a shame when it is obviously greatest interest here, what were they thinking, like actually, what were they thinking?) but the risk should be clearly higher for COVID-19 as it is non-existent for vaccines.

As such, the original paper was bad as they did not stratify by important parameters but this paper might be even worse as they do not include other complications that would significantly change the picture.

I also feel wary about the method they are using - perhaps somebody could share thoughts about this? They used self controlled case series (SCCS) for IRR. I am not fully confident that this kind of analysis can be used for such data in this setting.

nojokes··on The Risk of Vaccinated Covid Transmission Is Not Low
Based on the current evidence, you will also most likely spread it less. The difference is not huge but is there.
nojokes··on The Risk of Vaccinated Covid Transmission Is Not Low
It has reduced the transmission way more than a little bit.

It depends on the viral load you are being it with and your antibody levels. mRNA vaccines are able to induce antibodies in mucus but you are right, nasal vaccines MIGHT do better and I wish there is more focus on developing them.

nojokes··on The Dangerous Push to Give Boosters to Teens
This has been already determined and result is - virus causes more arm than vaccination. As for boosters - US is not Israel that could vaccinate all their 16-17 in one week if they see that virus has started to cause a lot harm. It would be great success when US could vaccinate half of them in few months.

We know already well how the virus is acting on under 11 olds and we do not need statistics to tell us that. If the vaccine can prevent symptomatic illness, it can also prevent serious illness. Simple as that.

nojokes··on The Dangerous Push to Give Boosters to Teens
Now how many people where there vaccinated with mRNA vaccines in South-Africa?

I propose that if there would have been more, we would possibly not have this variant. We do not see new variants popping up in highly vaccinated areas.

nojokes··on The Dangerous Push to Give Boosters to Teens
Well, this is what CDC claims https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vpd/polio/hcp/effectiveness-dur...

Yes, I know about this mutated live vaccine. It for sure looked like a great idea on paper.

nojokes··on The Dangerous Push to Give Boosters to Teens
Sorry, the author. Offit does not claim that vaccine is causing more hearth issues than COVID-19 but the author is.
nojokes··on WHO says vaccine booster programs will prolong Covid crisis
Even when true, deadliness is just one part of the problem. The second part is transmissibility.

Flu is not highly transmissible, it has R0 = 1.3 only. This means that 75% of the population will be not affected by. It can only kill 0.025% of the population.

If Omicron has R0 = 9 as has been claimed, it will infect 90% of the population.

When it had same mortality as flu, it could kill 0.09% of the population - that is 4x difference. In US it would be roughly 750000 deaths because of flu and 300000 because of Omicron.

Now this probably will work in setting where the speed of the transmission is slow enough that hospitals can manage the requirements put on them. If they could not because of too many concurrent cases, number of deaths can be higher.

nojokes··on WHO says vaccine booster programs will prolong Covid crisis
I am quite sure that not sending enough vaccines is not the problem in Africa.

https://www.euronews.com/2021/12/22/nigeria-destroys-around-...

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-11-24/s-africa-...

Providing vaccines is just one part of the solution.

Instead of wining and again trying to destroy the credibility of science and doctors (like happened with masks), WHO should step up and help to deploy vaccines in Africa.

nojokes··on Israel begins fourth Covid-19 dose vaccine for people 60+ as Omicron surges
I may feel excessive because US and Europe are still hastily doing their third shots when Israel went through this long time ago and they were able to forget Delta with what parts of US and Europe are struggling with. They were late with they 3rd shot and it causes them number of deaths. It would be stupid to make the same mistake again - it makes sens to act proactively.

Of course, again, when only tool you have is a hammer then every problem starts to look like a nail.

nojokes··on The Risk of Vaccinated COVID Transmission Is Not Low
Obviously you were not truly vaccinated when you got COVID-19...

Joking aside, this is very bad communication that has caused a lot of trouble as it creates a very easy to attack straw man for anti-vaxxers.

nojokes··on The Dangerous Push to Give Boosters to Teens
For me a clear separation is spreading false information about vaccine effectiveness and safety.

I could not see how any US approve COVID-19 vaccine for 16-17 year old is causing more hearth issues than COVID-19 does - quite opposite appears to be true based on the referenced Oxford study. Perhaps I am misinterpreting the study?

nojokes··on The Dangerous Push to Give Boosters to Teens
I am not sure from where he is getting this vaccines produce more hearth issues than COVID-19. Pfizer vaccines for sure do not and Moderna vaccine is not approved in US for 16-17 year olds. Sound like a complete anti-vax nutjob to me regardless that he claims to be not one (how surprising).
nojokes··on The Dangerous Push to Give Boosters to Teens
I know only one vaccine that might have 100% efficacy after 4 shots. It is polio vaccine.

COVID-19 has been so far a scourge - when we get enough people vaccinated in developed countries, another variant appears from developing countries. The vaccine deployments has been just too slow around the world.

My hope is that the developing world has seen now enough of the virus and is mainly immune or will be after Omicron has swept over (being hopefully milder than previous variants).

nojokes··on The Dangerous Push to Give Boosters to Teens
Sure, lets wait till highly infectious new disease has infected everyone because we clearly have plenty of data about its long term effects. /s

If you can point out where did they cut short with the vaccine approval, please point it out.

One thing is clear - they did not wait till planned AE period was completed but we do have now even more data about AE than we have for any other vaccine so far.

I think that the opposite is true - the vaccines have not been deployed fast enough around the world and this has allowed new more infectious variants to emerge.

nojokes··on The Dangerous Push to Give Boosters to Teens
He claims that he is not an anti-vaxxer but for sure sounds like one. Can somebody please point me out how Pfizer vaccine is causing more hearth AE in young people than COVID-19 does?
nojokes··on Israel recommends fourth Covid-19 dose for people over 60
They try to learn from experience with Delta - better early than late - it will save lives.

If 3 doses does not give enough protection against Omicron then it would be stupid to wait more.

nojokes··on Israel recommends fourth Covid-19 dose for people over 60
You are clearly wrong about "fire and forgot". It may feel to you like this because you do not recall that for most vaccines multiple shots are needed for sufficient immunity and most of the viruses do not mutate away like SARS-Cov-2.

Flu vaccine is that kind of type but it is far from super effective having efficiency somewhere between 10-60% (still saves lives and productive days) and we normally do not have flu pandemic and even when we do, it has never been really infectious compared to Delta or Omicron.

Current vaccines appear even effective against sever case of Omicron, though not that much against mild cases. There would be no need for this forth shot if this Omicron did not appear out of the blue.

Given that most of India and most likely Africa will become "vaccinated" either by Delta (SAR and India mostly already are) or Omicron then how much potential is there left for one more surprise variant?

nojokes··on Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant
It is depressing how people pretend that it is the same virus every time.

Israel has faced waves of 3 different viruses - original, Alpha and Delta what have required different level of immunization and Israel has managed to vaccinate itself out of 2 of these waves.

Looks quite impressive to me.

I also fail to understand why people pretend that 2 doses should be expected to stop Delta that has higher viral load - it does not make any sense.

It is a probabilistic game - antibodies are not smart - they are like mines - you need to have high enough concentration to stop viral particles to move around. If the viral particles can overload this concentration - they are going to win. There obviously must be some threshold of antibody concentration below what you can't avoid infection - when 2 dose regimen reaches it too quickly, well, game over. 3rd dose regimen is known to boost antibody concentration and keep it high for longer time. There is no surprise here and yet even people in position (like WHO) that should know better have intentionally ignored it.

nojokes··on SARS-CoV-2 Omicron has extensive but incomplete escape of Pfizer BNT162b2
Maybe they did not test it because it takes a lot time to run actual tests. If you maybe read a little of the study, you could see how fairly complicated it is. They also had to use level 3 biolab that might not be very easily available all the time for them.
nojokes··on SARS-CoV-2 Omicron has extensive but incomplete escape of Pfizer BNT162b2
It does not necessary mean this. This only compares neutralizing antibody titers but in real life there are other factors like common viral load. For example antibody titers against original variant and Delta are very similar but still there are many breakthrough cases with Delta because it comes with much higher viral load.
nojokes··on Covid Myths
Both cases hurt and it shows that there is no hysteria - the problem is real.
nojokes··on The eccentric scientist behind the ‘gold standard’ Covid-19 test
These accounts are definitely interesting from anthropological point of view - how people make up nonsense. The third one is especially noteworthy.

"As someone with more than an adequate knowledge of medical and clinical sciences along with some postgraduate research experience in physical mapping using molecular genetics techniques"

"Is it not amusing to find human swabs, samples of Coca-Cola and some fruits all testing positive for “Sars-Cov- 2” using the RT-PCR protocol whilst the kit instructions, the enclosed information leaflet, as well as the print on the box clearly inform the users that the test kit detects Sars-Cov-1 only?"

RT-PCR? Sars-Cov-1? These link to rapid tests that are lateral flow based, not PCR.

nojokes··on Ask HN: Effects of Covid Vaccination on R0?
If your likelihood to get infected is lower then you are less likely to retransmit but it is even more nuanced as this because viral load dynamics are a little different for vaccinated and non-vaccinated.
nojokes··on Booster jabs 'massively' strengthen the body’s defenses against Covid
Is this comment about UK decision to give boosters after 3 months from last vaccination?

I think there is big misconception about boosters and Delta. People appear to assume that there is some time after what vaccines loose effectiveness against Delta.

I see it rather as assumption that 1 shot should work against Wuhan variant. Well, it does not so does not 2 shots against Delta. Waiting period is irrelevant. It is only a compromise between mounting a better immune response from time difference and risk of infection.

nojokes··on Norway reports omicron cases linked to company party
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1889%E2%80%931890_pandemic#Cor... is one possibility how one of our current common colds started.
nojokes··on Covid 19 is not an old person problem
Actually he has correct perspective. Yes, more older people die. But higher risk to die young should be not overlooked. I never thought that I could die because of simple respiratory illness. I have been sick many times but each time I assumed that regardless of the seriousness of the illness, I will recover. COVID-19 puts it into different perspective.
nojokes··on Immunity from Covid-19 Infection May Be as Strong as from Vaccination
You can also get 3 month long certificate based on positive antibody test that is an improvement upon EU side where you can only get 6 month long certificate based on previous positive PCR test result.
← PreviousPage 6 of 17Next →