HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nokya

814 karma · joined January 27, 2010

submissionscomments
nokya··on Microservices are hard
What a waste of time. Anyone who's not an architect or developer, but regularly works with architects and developers, intuitively reaches these conclusions. And this has been going on and on for almost ten years.

When you watch this from the outside (e.g., let's say, as a consultant called to advise on a very specific aspect of software architectures) it feels like they all follow a secret agreement that instructs them to go full microservices route. Questioning this, even as a consultant paid to do exactly that, is considered unacceptable. It's like questioning your client's religious or political beliefs.

I observe a similar trend with CIOs hired to help institutions digitally transform themselves. Many operate on an "innovative" reasoning that consists in going full cloud and lay off IT personnel, which inevitably leads to increased operating and maintenance costs without exploiting the actual benefits of cloud computing. But it's already too late, Mr/Mrs CIO has already left the org when this happens. And self-congratulating words are already published in their LinkedIn profile.

I often have two thoughts when I attend a pre-sales meeting with a prospect customer that shows us a beautiful microservices architecture:

1. Oh my...

2. Shut up and just take the money they are throwing at your face.

nokya··on Ask HN: Did HN just start using Google recaptcha for logins?
I'm on the opposite spectrum: I think the intent to collect data is at least above 50%, meaning that gathering information on individuals visiting third-party platforms has taken precedence over training their model.

Also, I think we shouldn't underestimate the monetization value of being able to target "HN users" for advertising. From the moment we are flagged, Google can exploit this data pointer for targeted advertisment on any other website/app.

This information should be given at the highest cost possible:)

nokya··on Ask HN: Did HN just start using Google recaptcha for logins?
+1 nothing against some anti bot feature, just hopefully not Google.
nokya··on Rails authentication from scratch
You identified the threat correctly (legitimate users being prevented from using the app because they forgot or lost access to their password) but the measure you proposed exposes the application to a new threat (attacker can lock accounts without authentication).

Now I would typically task you with an exercise to improve your design so that the password reset mechanism, once triggered by an unauthenticated user ("reset password" is clicked) does not result in locking the legitimate account.

After a few minutes, you would likely come up with a new protocol that consists in two steps instead of one:

1. Unknown user triggers the password reset mechanism by submitting an email address to the "reset password" form.

2. Legitimate user receives a password reset link by email. If the link is clicked, the legitimate user is redirected to a prompt to provide new credentials. If the link is never clicked, nothing happens.

enjoy

Then I would challenge you again with a new threat: "Now we have a new problem. Instead of locking user accounts randomly, the attacker could just write a script that submits the password reset form repeatedly for hours, thus triggering thousands of emails and severely disrupting both our users and our email gateways."

You would say "oh! that's a great challenge!" :)

And a few minutes later, you would likely come up with the solution to implement a CAPTCHA equivalent in the first stage of the password reset mechanism to reduce the likelihood automation.

enjoy

Then I few months later, I would challenge you again with a new threat: "It appears that someone has devised a technique to bypass our CAPTCHA mechanism. We need to find something else."

You would say "oh! that's a great challenge!" :)

And a few minutes later, you would likely come up with the epiphany that no, this part of the challenge is actually not that great because we simply reached the final stage of our analysis that basically requires monitoring the world for new research work that would ultimately cancel the benefits of our CAPTCHA mechanism and force us to find something else.

But that part of the challenge is for another team ;)

nokya··on Social Quitting
Just finished reading the article. I already started disagreeing with the author while reading the first line. Mass exodus? What is he referring to? How does he differentiate mass exodus from being simply out of touch with users' needs? Mass exodus from social networks looks to me like a typical low-signal-high-noise opinionated clickbait, not fact-based journalism.

If there was a mass exodus, I think we should observe it from our own eyes. In my case, nobody around me is (finally) leaving WhatsApp and nobody is quitting Twitter. I don't have thousands of "friends" but I think I can assume that I would actually see these platforms bleed out if there was a mass exodus in progress, and more particularly, I'd see where they are going to.

I think the author's vision appears to be constructed on the premise that he perceives social networks as all-powerful businesses ("Today, it’s getting harder to believe that these networks will last forever."). I think he is sharing his own delusion about social networks with the public and trying to find an escape to the dissonance that ensued from the decline of their stock price. For more than 5 years now, Facebook has been offering nothing more than a worldwide directory and a stalking service to its users in exchange for their data, in my opinion. If we do the analogy with a milk company, he is basically surprised that cows are leaving the farm because they don't get anything valuable in return (the actual customers are the buyers of milk).

What surprises me though, is the fact that he seems to miss an elephant in the room. It seems to me that these companies are failing simply because they are engaged in a very expensive operation that doesn't generate a lot of revenue anymore. And the reason for this decrease in revenue cannot be simply explained with users exodus or attrition: Meta still owns Instagram, TikTok is doing very well and many social networks are reporting massive users intake. What is happening in my opinion is just pure simple and raw competition.

Finally, he also seems to neglect the potential behind Meta's investment in metaverse tech. I wouldn't dare betting on this: there are thousands of signals worldwide that show that metaverse technologies could disrupt society the same way Internet and touch screen smartphones disrupted our daily lives. Nobody knows whether Zuckerberg is at the "right place, right time" for the moment, he may as much as he may not be. But if he is...

nokya··on Portugal’s digital nomad bubble
Fully agree. I will add two things.

First, most "digital nomads" who interact with the public administration and institutions (e.g., banks) are not standard customers. Employees often have no clue how to deal with them and many processes contain manual steps that require someone's validation or approval, and often target a very small group of individuals (those tasked with "dealing with" foreigners). It can slow down things.

Second, Portugal is particularly well known for having great ideas and conferences about digital transformation but completely lacks the ability to deliver within its own ranks. To its defense, most citizens cannot easily purchase services online, either because lack of money, or because lack of computer literacy/equipment, or because they don't even have an online payment mechanism. These factors greatly limit incentives for a rapid digital transformation, which incidentally, is precisely what digital nomads crave for.

The comparison with Switzerland was made earlier, it matches my argument: 1) widespread computer literacy and modern endpoint equipment 2) widespread access to online payment solutions 3) the population is used to pay-as-you-go public service (vs. all-inclusive taxpayer service expected by citizens in most EU countries). These combined greatly encourage the deployment of efficient online interfaces.

nokya··on Ask HN: Sites with the quality of Hacker News, but for more general topics?
There are many... But these communities are typically not advertised as such. Generally, you would be invited or referred to by another member.

How did you discover HN?

nokya··on Tell HN: I'm scared of sharing my opinion online
And you should, unless you have actual training in hiding your traces online (and I don't mean something as simple as "use Tor and a VPN").

There are three situations where you should not assume privacy: 1. When you express yourself online. 2. When there is a smartphone in close proximity (whether yours or someone else's). 3. When you are in someone else's property or home. This includes apartments, houses, shopping venues, bars, restaurants, etc. You are almost always being recorded in some way or another (audio, photos, videos). This also includes your own home if you don't live alone or if you haven't actively banned any connected equipment from entering your premises (e.g. iot devices, smart TV, computer, smartphone, etc.).

If you feel an urge to share your true opinions anyways, I'd suggest the following: 1. Always assume you are being recorded. 2. Always assume what you say/write will be shared to third-parties by the people you trust the most and kept for years. Most often this is done involuntarily. Statistically speaking, you can assume that everyone around you has no clue on how to secure their own devices (e.g., smartphone, TV, vacuums, fridges, etc.) from sharing whatever they capture. 3. Always assume that at least one individual strongly disagrees with you, and he/she may actively hide this fact from you.

If you want to express yourself anonymously, get training. And by that, I don't mean read a webpage, I mean: talk to one or two experts who specialize in online anonymity.

But in most cases, keep your real thoughts for yourself.

nokya··on Tell HN: I just received my Equifax breach settlement check
Meanwhile, the stock price kept growing since. Which, once again, confirms what I commented multiple times here on HN: when you see a large company getting its personal databases breached then sued for hundreds of millions, buy its stock.

It is very sadly the only way to get some form of reparation from the damage they have done in a justice system that still sees its "job creators" as gods on earth.

nokya··on Men Without Work (2016)
That number does not reflect those you seem to be referring to. The unemployment rate reflects the ratio of the number of people registered as beneficiaries of unemployment insurance to the number of people registered as employed.

It does not include: - those who don't work and can't benefit from unemployment insurance (e.g., anyone fired from work for misconduct, - those who don't work and are not looking for work - those who don't work and can't work

That makes much more people overall. A recent Pew research published in 2020 estimated that an estimated 29% of unemployed americans are included in that number.[1]

1.https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2020/04/24/not-all-une...

nokya··on CircleCI Security Incident
Discussion:

  - Looks like we were compromised. We started investigating.
  - I am sorry for you, I hope my data is secure.
  - We can already confirm there is nobody in our systems.
  - How the hell would you know that already?
  - Also, make sure you reset all your keys and secrets.
  - What? Why?
  - ...abundance of caution!
nokya··on South Korea’s online security dead end
I see two candidate alternatives to your "Getting out of the dead end":

1. Give SK a few months/years until it realizes it is losing billions revenue nationally due to hacking by foreign entities and it will naturally invest in its application security landscape.

2. Reconsider your position on SK's current situation by factoring actual risk in the equation (likelihood of threat, in particular). What you seem to have discovered are client-side vulnerabilities that would require direct network access to the client machines to be exploited (i.e., no firewall, no NAT, no etc.). First, these limitations greatly reduce the attack surface and second, they may actually cost the attacker more to exploit than simply sending a well-crafted message with an attachment to click on.

I would be much more convinced by your conclusions if you added elements that would support the hypothesis that the situation is similar (or worse) server-side.

(edit: removed ugly formatting)

nokya··on Ask HN: Why did Frontend development explode in complexity?
"Where is this coming from? Is it because we want our work to look important?"

I am intimately convinced it could play a role, at two layers. First, at the framework layer itself: the plethora of propositions seems symptomatic of our approach to dealing with things we don't like. When confronted to the choice of walking the extra mile to improve and contribute to an existing language/framework, or building your own new thing that focuses on solving your own problem, my guess is that the more senior architects (esp. those working at licorns or GAFAMs) will choose the latter option, thus resulting in an increased offer. Also, let's not forget, being the author of a successful language or framework sounds cool.

Second, at the user layer (architect at random corp): this individual is increasingly convinced that working with the latest silicon valley approved framework will work wonders on her/his resume.

I am confronted to new software architectures on a weekly basis as a result of my job and the choices of framework/language X as opposed to Y often follows a common pattern: some architect thinks that segmenting a system into as many components/technologies as possible somehow always makes it more reliable at the end.

If I owned a software company, I'd immediately get rid of anyone showing these behaviors. But I have to admit: the bigger the mess, the more hours I can bill :)

nokya··on Ask HN: How do you keep track of all the content you encounter?
I don't :) Or to be more precise: I gradually downgraded from storing everything to storing nothing.

I put an incredible amount of effort in forcing myself not to keep track of content I encounter. I keep some bookmarks: interfaces I must interact with on a daily or weekly basis at most, and a folder in which I put links to pages on which I have written a comment (like this one after I post my comment). The folder is quite up-to-date.

And I may save some pics, usually those shared by friends/family, typically pictures that I cannot find in a search engine.

Otherwise...I can't think of other content that I save.

nokya··on Ask HN: What RSS Reader do you use in 2022?
QuiteRSS on Windows. Still not perfect in terms of features but it's fast.
nokya··on Ask HN: Why is the Wikipedia Foundation's begging tolerated?
No, it's not tolerated, at least from me.

I use incognito mode by default in my browsers and Wikipedia has become unusable with the constant begging. I stopped donating on a yearly basis when I realized their intrusive begging scheme had turned into a hobby.

If it works with other people, so be it.

nokya··on Tell HN: Google is correlating location data to your IP
Short answer can be summarized as follows: Can X correlate data "that way" about users at scale and at an acceptable cost? If yes, then X does it.

Works for all companies that generate revenue from targeted advertising (GAFAMs of course, and many many others).

nokya··on Ask HN: How do you use upvote on HN?
I never upvoted the item itself. However, I frequently upvote comments. Those that I find valuable to my own personal experience, or answers to my own comments, in particular when the answer is helpful or when I see the author took the time to write a good answer even if I don't agree with it.
nokya··on Is Dark Mode Good for Your Eyes? (2020)
Light mode for me, always. I just lower the brightness level in night/dark settings and when in bed.

I actually had to learn advanced config editor in Firefox to stop websites from forcing dark mode without alternative.

nokya··on What things did you purchase that enhanced the quality of your life in 2022?
Glad you could share about it :)
nokya··on Thunderbird for Android preview: Modern message redesign
If k9 ends up with a search function that works as intended, I'm all for it!
nokya··on Ask HN: Why is SBF not in prison yet?
Reasons why he could end up in jail before being convicted:

  [ ] He's physically dangerous 
  [ ] He is likely to hide traces of his alleged crimes
  [ ] He is likely to engage in witness tampering
  [ ] He is likely to leave the country to a non-cooperating jurisdiction
  [ ] He doesn't have powerful friends 
I will let you find the best answer(s) :)
nokya··on Show HN: I built an app that scans every social media network for your username
Well, not sure I am a bad actor but reading the comment gave me the idea of typing my ex's nickname and I now discover she has an account on a quite unusual platform of which I am a member, too.

For sure, I would never have the time to build such a tool. So, yes, some bad actors may have the "ability" as you mention, but I don't think that is the best justification to make querying this tool that easy.

nokya··on Discord fined €800k for failing to comply with several obligations of the GDPR
"clicking on the "X" at the top right of the last visible application window will exit the application for the vast majority of applications."

It used to be like you describe, but this is a disappearing rule. An increasing amount of companies build apps designed in a way that you need to have sysadmin skills to actually terminate the program for real.

We can't expect Microsoft to require developers to implement this 'X' correctly because Microsoft itself is exploiting this loophole by keeping some of its apps alive when the user clicks the 'x' button.

This is a common trend I already mentioned here several years ago initiated by GAFAM companies to subversively rewrite the signification of common concepts that they disagree with: - "no/decline" -> maybe later - "no/decline" -> skip for now - "no/decline" -> remind me later - "close" -> sleep" / run into background - "delete data" -> hide/hide temporarily - "delete account" -> deactivate (but keep everything) - "somebody" -> best friend - "buy/pay" -> rent - "configure" -> submit your preferences, we will take that into account etc.

All these concepts are being actively stolen from the population and I am terribly saddened to see the vast majority of our regulators have absolutely no clue about the long-term consequences of this concepts being stolen/rewritten without tacit consent.

So, yes, Discord rewrote the 'x' button but to be honest: who cares? Apparently only too few.

nokya··on Microsoft is phoning home the content of PowerPoint slides
Microsoft and confidentiality of your data are two incompatible concepts.

Microsoft is basically the editor of a set of tools designed to make employees more productive. As long as you use Microsoft products with this in mind, there's no ambiguity: you give Microsoft the data you work on, and it gives you productivity in return.

Unless you are the actual CEO of a company involved in trade secrets (or a defense organization), you shouldn't care about Microsoft snitching the content of your slides, and everything else you write or see, to its own servers on the justification that it will make your experience better.

It's not worth entering the debate, and if you accuse Microsoft you will probably need to accuse its competitors.

Just remember to keep out of anything Microsoft when you process anything strictly personal, and you will be more than fine.

P.s.: I almost forgot to answer your question. Yes, you approved this. And again, if it's not your company, your boss very likely approved it and wouldn't even consider the effort of looking into this, so it's not your business. Literally.

nokya··on Aegis Authenticator – Secure 2FA App for Android
Glad to see this tool getting more traction: - biometric/passcode authentication - grouping - backup/restore function that works - no data leakage/no ads.

I recommend it everytime I see someone popping out a Google authenticator or alike.

The only thing Aegis lacks is a donate button or a paid version just for supporting its development.

I'm anticipating this tool will soon be ripped apart with ads, data leakage, an acquisition, or a premium version that will just break what it does very well until now.

I'm enjoying it while it lasts :)

nokya··on How we handled a recent phishing incident
Isn't that why we have subdomains?
nokya··on How we handled a recent phishing incident
Is there a version of this report somewhere without all the PR BS?
nokya··on Ask HN: Advice that changed your life?
A few years ago, I received a series of "class rules" through an instant messaging group. The list describes how everyday things are interpreted, depending on your social class.

At that time, I was part of an executive master program at a very prestigious university, it cost me a third of my yearly income and had a huge impact on my personal life and finances.

Reading that list made me realize in just a few seconds that I had been studying there for four years for a completely different reason than those around me. I felt heavily depressed first, then I realized it was actually possible to switch my expectations. I focused the last few months on building and strengthening connections, it completely changed my relationship with this university and the people there.

Money:

  - You're poor? spend.
  - You're middle class? manage.
  - You're wealthy? invest.
Food:

  - You're poor? quantity.
  - You're middle class? quality.
  - You're wealthy? presentation.
Time:

  - You're poor? present.
  - You're middle class? future.
  - You're wealthy? tradition.
Education:

  - You're poor? abstract.
  - You're middle class? success and money.
  - You're wealthy? connect.
Family structure:

  - You're poor? matriarchal.
  - You're middle class? patriarchal.
  - You're wealthy? whoever owns the money.
Driving forces:

  - You're poor? relationships.
  - You're middle class? achievements.
  - You're wealthy? finances, social life.
Language:

  - You're poor? casual.
  - You're middle class? formal, to negotiate.
  - You're wealthy? formal, to network.
Social drive:

  - You're poor? inclusion.
  - You're middle class? self-sufficiency.
  - You're wealthy? exclusion.
Personality:

  - You're poor? be fun.
  - You're middle class? be an achiever.
  - You're wealthy? connect.
Destiny:

  - You're poor? it's fate. You can't change it.
  - You're middle class? your choices.
  - You're wealthy? your expectations.
Hope it inspires someone :)
nokya··on Ask HN: How do you maintain your daily log?
I use notepad++, simple text file, with one macro recorded:

- Ctrl+End (goes to end of file)

- New line

- New line

- Left bracket

- Edit > Insert > Date time (custom)

- Right bracket

- New line

The macro is assigned to my F5 key, everytime I press it, the sequence is triggered.

In my file, it will more or less look like this:

[...previous log entry...]

[2022-10-28 12:48:31]

- wrote comment about my time macro in notepad++ on HN

- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33359329

← PreviousPage 3 of 11Next →