HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nokya

814 karma · joined January 27, 2010

submissionscomments
nokya··on Reliably Send an HTTP Request as a User Leaves a Page
Who needs this, except privacy toxic companies?
nokya··on People who press on cookie banners anything except “agree” – why do you do that?
I only surf the web with my browser in private mode, using a virtual machine that boots a live Linux distribution and through a mainstream VPN service.

Any banner that pops up to my face, I click "agree"and don't look backwards.

I understand I can still be identified using some browser fingerprinting tricks, but I have absolutely zero trust in any of these privacy notices/policies.

Disclaimer: part of my actual job is to assess whether my clients' systems/applications effectively comply with privacy laws and the policy shown to users/customers. I have never seen a company that does what it promises to its users and I've been doing this job since 2015.

nokya··on Show HN: Redditle.com – For those of us who add 'Reddit' to every Google search
I smiled while reading this item :) I knew I am not the only one doing this but wouldn't have guessed it as common practice.

P.s. I will not use the service, showing that I insist on typing the additional word every time is my way of saying: 1. I don't want Google to return anything else 2. Reddit developers can't implement search correctly.

nokya··on What happens if you try to download and install Firefox on Windows
This is exactly the reason why I dislike Microsoft. Their products and services are okay, and they are more than successful already without engaging in these shady scare tactics with their users.

The fact that they can't see that is very worrying because it indicates a higher probably that they do/will engage in unethical behaviors to reassure themselves.

nokya··on Hackers claim to have breached Okta systems
Notification is required only if their impact assessment concludes on a significant risk to users (which they must be able to produce to the data protection authority at any time).

Otherwise, business as usual.

nokya··on Police hacking with Pegasus of key Netanyahu trial witness explodes into scandal
My country (Switzerland) contributes to making Pegasus a profitable business.

https://www.tdg.ch/la-suisse-reste-muette-sur-le-logiciel-es...

What about yours?

nokya··on Meta is not threatening to leave Europe
"we did not threaten to leave Europe"

Yup, you did. Annual report, page 9, and it backfired.

Everybody knows you won't leave but that's what you suggested point blank. You put this there to put pressure on Europe to surrender its citizens data to the US unconditionally.

Own it.

nokya··on Ask HN: Whats the tech stack that top-tier hackers use for staying undetectable?
I can't speak for hackers, but cybercriminals use exactly the same systems that you and I would typically use. There is nothing surprising in that area.

In terms of OSes, seized hardware almost always hosts either a Linux Ubuntu, sometimes Kali but not that much, or a Windows 10 system. They always have VMs running, almost exclusively on virtualbox. Running non-mainstream systems would just make them more discernable from everyone else which is not good.

What differentiates regular users from cybercrime is their "opsec", aka their operational security. They encrypt their data (with an actually robust key), they patch and harden their OSes (nobody else does this), and their online presence is mostly exclusively run through third party systems, which they likely compromised already.

Honestly, you'd learn far more useful things by reading court decisions, they often include very interesting details about their opsec.

nokya··on A confession of a FAANG hiring manager
What I find utterly sad when I read this is that the rest of the world, no let me rephrase it: the actual world, both intuitively knows this process is wrong and operates recruitment differently.

Engineers of the world don't work at FAANG companies, just a very small subset of them. Engineers who want to work there are like teenagers who were told they must study at an ivy league if they want to something with their life. It's a small club, it is not selective at all, it is just not a club that a lot of people would care to join.

What I find more interesting to observe in this post is the recruiter himself. How he was led to believe an awful community was "better" until he realized he had to escape from it, and now he is teaching something that almost every engineer in the world already knows.

So, yes, I'll upvote this one but probably not for the reason I'm expected to :)

nokya··on Ask HN: How do you cope with realizing you mostly wasted your potential?
Kindly allow me to share my experience with you.

I grew up being told almost every day that I was special, smarter, and destined for great things. At school, I always aced every exam possible. In my mind, teachers could only give me A+ or F, there were no other grades, whatever the matter: math, history, English, phys-ed, etc. But outside school, I always felt average: neither attractive nor ugly, neither talkative nor shy, neither stupid nor smart.

Then came high school, and this decisive moment when I was supposed to know what I wanted to do. Some wanted to be doctors, I thought I was not capable of becoming a doctor. Others wanted to be lawyers, but I was never attracted to that world. Science? I didn't realize I could have chosen engineering, or some STEM faculty, I just didn't think of it. Nobody told me I could go there either. I studied economics, it wasn't hard but I felt outrageously bored. Year 2000 came, I noticed people could earn good money doing websites, so I bought some books and gave it a try. From that moment, IT jobs came one after another: always well paid, somehow interesting. I was never bad at them, nor brilliant. Years passed rapidly.

When I think about it: no one ever told me how to be successful or useful. And no one "pushed" me under the train to something big. Maybe this could be your issue? I often envied those who get it, who actually "do something" with their life. I never solved this problem. I even tried volunteering: serving soup at christmas, spending time with children in hospitals, becoming a monitor during summer camps for socially disfavored children, tutoring students with their homework, I always had the same answer: "you're too late, we don't need more people".

I noticed a lot of people around me, especially at work, always get things taught, coached, mentored, etc. I never landed a job where my manager just dropped me into some training or certification course. I always had to figure out things by myself. One time after I was named manager, my boss refused to pay me some training. A few months later, a colleague was promoted to the same position, he ended up in a 3 weeks leadership/management program, all paid by the company. I asked my boss why i didn't the training, her answer was simply that she didn't think I needed training.

I often get invited to speak at conferences, I even was invited as a keynote speaker. I refuse. I am not scared of speaking in public, I just don't have nothing particularly interesting to tell.

Starting your life being told you are "special", "smarter", or whatsoever puts a lot of pressure. For more than 30 years, I think my parent's way of telling me they believe in me just made me feel like a complete failure, and prevented me from ever feeling happy with who/what I am. I do nothing very well, I am not very intelligent, it often takes me more time than others to understand all the intricacies of a social situation. In society, I struggle when I must interact with fake, selfish or imposters (and there are many).

One day, I realized I was "mediocre". My parents are/were even more mediocre than I think I am and my hypothesis is that they saw me as smart because they were mediocre. This realization freed me. I started forgiving myself and became more benevolent towards others. Being told you are a "10" and feeling like you are a "5" is agony. Realizing you are a "5" and feeling you may live as a "6" made me see life completely differently, and much more positively.

All things considered, it appears I do well enough for a few people to thing I am worth their consideration, their attention, sometimes even their friendship, and ultimately, their love. I have good friends, I love my family, I love my wife and every minute I spend with her. I have a respectable job, a nice boss, nice colleagues, etc. Since I accepted my "fate", I generally feel much happier in my life.

I sometimes have bad thoughts about my wife: I feel sorry for her. She is beautiful, smart, independent, funny, clumsy in a lovable way, interesting. She is clearly above my rank in most aspects. But she doesn't seem to notice that she could do much better than "me". Along with the mystery of how to do something with my life, I guess her living with me is the second big enigma in my life. But apart from this, all is going well.

I noticed that once you start looking at the "grand picture", whatever the potential you reached or the "productivity" you achieved throughout your life, everyone of us ends up exactly the same way: dead. I calculated that I have ~2'000 weeks (assuming I die old) left to live. It's my countdown, it is brutally honest but honestly, why should I care about being successful when I only have 2'000 weeks left before I die?

My advice: just try exploiting your potential so that you can live with dignity and healthily. If you can provide shelter, clothes, food to the people you love, if you can resort to violence when it is ultimately necessary, and you can afford to spend some quality time with the people you love, well, in my very insignificant opinion, I would see you as a highly successful individual.

If you find the way to make other people's lives better without sacrificing yourself or the ones you love, then, yeah, why not. Otherwise, just enjoy the ride. I honestly do not thing life is worth torturing yourself about whether or not you accomplished something.

Those are my 2 cents. If only 1 sentence of my experience can improve your opinion about yourself or your life, then I will consider this day as a successful day :)

take care.

nokya··on Red Cross says cyberattack was 'state-like' in nature
Yup. That's what they say.

Among other things, Shodan was showing their public facing server as vulnerable to a known exploit several weeks before the attack.

The same individual is being interviewed across multiple newspapers and constantly repeats it was a state-led attack without providing any technical details about what happened.

We have been searching for three weeks and I think a friend finally found someone whose parent's data may have been in the database. If it is confirmed, we only need to convince her to get one of her parents to file a lawsuit. There are several lawyers here who will do it pro-bono. This could be the only way to finally get the truth behind this intrusion.

nokya··on Ask HN: Any piece of hardware that was more of game changer than you expected?
Why don't you just come to the point?
nokya··on Upcoming new HTTP QUERY method
I see two problems: redundancy and consistency.

After spending pages telling the reader that the query should not affect the server's state, the only example given appears to do exactly that: initiate a query and return a GET url to retrieve the results.

Either the GET request actually triggers the database request, which makes the QUERY request totally redundant, or the QUERY request relays a call to a database interpreter and the server responds with a location to retrieve the results.

Second, how would the http server know that the query is both idempotent and safe? Providing an example with SQL-like code makes it look even more like a bad joke...

I see this creates (at least) two problems and solves none. Do the authors know which problem they hope to solve?

If I had more time I'd look into their bios. Something tells me this is a typical case of "I put my name in a RFC", unless they work under the umbrella of some GAFAM who needs a new HTPP verb without disclosing why.

nokya··on Windows 11 update changed default browser to Edge, Chrome search-engine to Bing
Cool. They didn't learn after a 700m€ lawsuit. Looking forward to the next one.
nokya··on Last Windows 11 update changed all default browser settings to Edge
I upgraded to windows 10 a few years ago, even paid for the pro version to have it in my home computer.

I remember spending more than an hour, checking every possible setting I could to reveal less data. At the end, I felt somehow happy with the situation.

A few days later, an upgrade came. I didn't notice immediately but the upgrade has reset all privacy settings to their worst value (of course, default value is the one that benefits Microsoft).

I hated that feeling. I felt betrayed, angry and powerless. This was a terrible breach if trust for me (today, I know I seem like the typical naive user but years ago, I trusted their configuration menus).

I don't accept this feeling that my privacy should be in control of a small group of individuals who have absolutely zero respect for my privacy. I guess the fact that I had actually bought the pro version purposely to benefit from more privacy influenced my experience.

I uninstalled Windows and switched to Ubuntu.

Today, my problem is Android/apple. I'd like to get rid of them but I haven't solved this problem yet...

nokya··on Ask HN: Those making $500/month on side projects in 2022 – Show and tell
No, you are entitled to request to "have your data deleted" but the interpretation is basically left to the data controller. In practice this means that the controller as many options to make your life as miserable as it can/wants when you try removing your data from its systems, and more particularly when you want to remove specific portions of your data.

Twitter is a perfect example: removing "some" of your tweets is purposefully made cumbersome for users so that they get discouraged to manage their tweets. Searching through your tweets by date range or by keyword, and a button to delete all results? "Nah, too complicated for us silicon valleyers" :)

One thing to remember with GDPR is that it is not a law that protects customers. It is a legal framework that specifies a set of requirements, which companies must abide to in order to do whatever they need/want with your data. Once you understand this, GDPR becomes much clearer :)

nokya··on The Matrix Resurrections estimated to lose Warner Bros $100M
I started watching it a few days ago. I kind of expected it would not be "as good" but honestly did not expect it to be so... strange.

Surprisingly, I haven't finished it yet. But I will. We never know, maybe it turns out to be a good surprise by the end.

nokya··on Mark Zuckerberg is creating a future that looks worse than the world we have now
Rich people hate when the poor gets to "keep" something for him/her. If there is "more", they'll do whatever they can to get it.
nokya··on Self-Hosting Dozens of Web Applications and Services on a Single Server
Thank you for sharing your approach, I learned a few things to improve my own server and highly looking forward to deploying them!
nokya··on Ask HN: Remotely helping elderly parents?
I noticed this option on my parent's computer but I am unsure about what am I supposed to do as the actual "assistant". Would you know if there is a downloadable client, or do I need to be running Windows 10 specifically?

I have Ubuntu and Windows 8.1 at home.

nokya··on Albanian prosecutors probe huge suspected leak of personal data
In my opinion, there is a difference between living in a country where all salary information is assumed public (and all personal decisions taken accordingly), and a country where salary information was kept confidential from people around you until it was abruptly made public without notice.

I am really trying to understand how both situations could feel the same to you but...I guess I would need some help convincing.

nokya··on Amazon Introduces Re:Post, a “Stack Overflow” for AWS
Dump question I guess, but I would like to follow what is said in the security & compliance section. There is a button "follow" that redirects me to a login page.

I am supposed to provide credentials to either a "root" account or an "IAM" account.

Assuming I have neither, I do not use AWS by myself and just want to take part in the discussion forums, should I create a root account or an IAM account?

nokya··on Albanian prosecutors probe huge suspected leak of personal data
Fully agree. And tbh I am quite astonished to see so many comments in this page that seem to advocate otherwise.

Disclosing salaries with identities can endanger many individuals, and not because they cheated the system or committed a crime.

It feels like advocating for full disclosure on who bets on what in stock trading.

nokya··on To secure the supply chain, you must properly fund it
The most well funded companies fail to write secure code.

Cybersecurity is a process, not a binary without vulnerabilities.

nokya··on Ask HN: Why is everyone so fake on LinkedIn?
It is a sign of social intelligence.

Most people understand, mostly unconsciously, that being "fake" (i.e., complimenting others for insignificant achievements, sharing fake stories and relaying content produced by other people) has become the most rewarding strategy to be successful in the westernized culture.

LinkedIn actively contributes to this by hiding most of the negative cues that could let someone assess her/his own performance objectively.

For example: when you see 50 likes to a comment, the author is very likely to feel rewarded and accomplished. However, LinkedIn will hide the fact that probably 500 people thought that content utterly uninteresting, wrong or despicable, but were smart enough to let it go.

Being "true" on LinkedIn, and any other social network, is committing social suicide in my opinion.

nokya··on The Microsoft paradox: Contributing to cyber threats and monetizing the cure
Agree. I think this is thanks to many journalists who don't even need to explain or justify their thought process anymore.

This article offers a highly accessible and simplified construct that allows anyone without the need for causality to feel "informed" and formulate an opinion.

p.s. I wrote a longer response about this in another comment.

nokya··on The Microsoft paradox: Contributing to cyber threats and monetizing the cure
A good analogy to the Microsoft paradox is the Pfizer/Moderna vaccines against Covid-19: these companies have distributed a vaccine that we can safely qualify as well vulnerable to time (effect wears off after a low number of months). People who took this vaccine were passively encouraged to believe they are safe to engage in risky behaviors and to ignore all safety rules. The consequence of this is two-fold: a significant number of vaccinated people will probably die soon because their vaccine just doesn't work anymore, and a much more significant number of people will become aware of this and seek to get a third dose in order to boost their immunity.

We could argue that Pfizer and Moderna are doing this intentionally and thus contributing to being both the problem and the cure, simply because they did not work enough to release a more robust vaccine.

To be honest, I felt the same thing after reading the article than after reading your comment: two extreme opinions that either treat Microsoft as the bad guy, or as the victim.

I think what we are observing is much more complex than it seems, and it may be heavily influenced by three aspects: the size of Microsoft, its silo culture, and its low/limited level of security expertise.

First, Microsoft is big. And by big, I mean, it is big enough to do business on both aspects of a same concern, namely, to write software used globally/worldwide and to produce products and services to make the cyber-work more secure. Microsoft can do that without ever questioning the relationship or logic between these two businesses, as long as it can deliver both markets satisfyingly.

Second, Microsoft operates in a silo culture (like all similar companies, this is not a "Microsoft" thing). Even if one department "knows" something about cyberthreats and how to mitigate them, chances are that the other department will either not be informed, or not be willing to invest time to collaborate with people working in "the other building". Their respective top-level managers are probably incentivized to sell rather than to collaborate, too. We would be well inclined to criticize Microsoft for this, assuming the same gangrene is affecting both large companies and public institutions everywhere.

Third, Microsoft is not that good at cybersecurity as many may think. One reason that could explain why so many see Microsoft as the elite in cybersecurity is because most people working in the field are mediocre at their job. Another point is that cybersecurity introduces a very broad spectrum of problems and capabilities/skills. Microsoft is good at incident detection/response, governance, threat intelligence and vulnerability management. These concerns are very appealing to senior executives, especially those who don't understand a thing about technology and those who would always prioritize paying for a good fire department rather than learning how to build, maintain or operate robust IT systems. On the other side of the spectrum is writing secure code: Microsoft is not good at it. I would never say that Microsoft is doing a worse job than others, they are just simply mediocre, like the largest part of the software industry worldwide. We may think they are good at writing secure code, but they are simply not. Some Microsoft's engineers produced pillar research work in the field of designing and writing secure systems (e.g., threat modelling, security development lifecycle, compiler optimization/hardening, etc.) between 2000 and 2010 but the company hasn't much evolved since. It is fully stagnating, whereas its pace of innovation and its production of "new code" is accelerating.

This brings me to my conclusion: saying that Microsoft is selling the cure to insecure systems is wrong, in my opinion. I think they are just selling a symptomatic treatment for a globally broken enterprise management model that tends to reward whoever acquires insecure software much more than anyone who dares trying to vet software suppliers for assurance/guarantees of delivering robust code. You want a cure for broken code? This will never be resolved by some well-thought Azure service or AI-powered email filtering gateway.

The reason why many believe Microsoft is selling a cure to bad software is simply what I wrote earlier: mediocre journalism, mediocre policy writers and mediocre senate committees who fail to understand that cybersecurity is much more than operating an efficient fire department.

nokya··on I will pay you cash to delete your NPM module
The author forgot the "iTard" effect: once the author deletes the module, the disappearance of the feature will cause major turmoil and people will complain to the repository owners to restore it asap.

This will also create a new opportunity for someone else to...recreate the module, and chances are that it will likely include some malicious or even more broken code.

If you want to "improve" the situation, you update the module with code that triggers an exit with a warning message. That will fix the problem.

nokya··on Why do companies spend so much on recruitment but not retention?
Recruiting solves a short-term problem, retaining solves a long-term problem.

You can find tons of examples of the same logic being applied by people around you. Only a selected few have the cognitive skills to contemplate the benefit of delayed gratification, and this also happens to affect employee recruitment/retention.

nokya··on AMP Has Irreparably Damaged Publishers’ Trust in Google-Led Initiatives
My trust in AMP can be summarized as the "ampproject.org" one liner in my proxy blacklist.
← PreviousPage 6 of 11Next →