HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

noondip

819 karma · joined April 23, 2015

submissionscomments
noondip··on Evidence that fish have feelings
There are victims which suffer as a consequence of your actions. I think that makes it clear the behavior is unethical. If "I want to" were all the justification needed, the world would be an even more terrible place to live. We wouldn't accept that excuse if made by a person kicking a dog, for example, so why should we for abuse of other non-human animal species?

Edit (can't directly reply):

> There's nothing objectively wrong or evil about suffering

There is plenty wrong with causing suffering. I think in the case of eating animals, society is quite detached from the experience, though. That's why we shy away from watching slaughterhouse videos, why we put pictures of happy cows on cartons of milk - why such an unbelievably rosy picture must be painted to justify ruthless and horrific violence taking place all the time. Anyway, I would like to share with you that it has been my experience watching those videos and learning more about how animals are treated for food and other purposes changed my perspective, and it might interest you, too. Earthlings is a powerful documentary, is available free on YouTube, and I recommend it.

> The only reason you and I wouldn't accept that argument about kicking a dog is because that goes against strong social norms our culture has about abusing pets.

Exactly! To the same point, the reason it is acceptable to raise and kill billions of animals are also social norms and culture. Is the hypocrisy of it all not apparent?

> I find the presumption of moral superiority repugnant, especially in an age where we should all know better.

It's appalling you don't recognize that not abusing sentient creatures is morally superior. Personally, I see this as a strong denial mechanism which you may be yet unaware of. Do check out the Earthlings documentary, it will really open your eyes.

noondip··on Vegetarians 'less healthy, have lower quality of life than meat-eaters' (2014)
If you want to be hyperbolic, then yes - if the whole world went vegan today, hundreds of billions of animals would be without "purpose". However, the reality is, we breed these animals into captivity, and as less demand for these products exists, fewer animals would need to be born to a life of misery.
noondip··on Vegetarians 'less healthy, have lower quality of life than meat-eaters' (2014)
This might come as a big shock, but grass-fed farming operations are in fact less sustainable and worse for the environment than even factory farming. I really recommend you check out the documentary Cowspiracy (it's available on NetFlix), or just look at the fact sheet on their web site - http://cowspiracy.com/facts

Your claim that vegans have worse health is entirely unsubstantiated. Do you have any evidence for this?

noondip··on Evidence that fish have feelings
> Why do I have to give eating salmon any thought?

The same reason you would give thought to killing a Golden Retriever for food. Due to indoctrinated beliefs, people think it's alright to kill certain animals for food, but not others, and when asked why, the logical inconsistencies become very apparent. See http://www.carnism.org/ and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=es6U00LMmC4

> Am I supposed to justify stomping on a cockroach too? Where does this moralizing end?

Any killing is self-defense in always justified. However, if there's an opportunity to practice non-violence, why not take it?

noondip··on Evidence that fish have feelings
Non-human animal activities should not provide a logical or moral foundation for our behavior and it is illogical to claim that we should eat the same diet they do, especially as most of them are obligatory carnivores killing for survival, whereas humans physiologically resemble frugivores. Also your reasoning would justify killing companion animals and also humans - after all, "circle of life".

More importantly, we recognize that unlike animals, we cannot justify taking the life of a sentient being for no better reason than our personal dietary preferences. So it is probably not useful to consider the behavior of fish when making decisions about our own behavior.

noondip··on Tiny Farms Raises Seed Round as Cricket Farming Heats Up
Beriberi is a nutritional deficit in vitamin B1, not protein, which is ironically easily remedied with potatoes.
noondip··on Vegetarians 'less healthy, have lower quality of life than meat-eaters' (2014)
So you mean to say the mass production of corn and soy as animal feed is not an example of crop monoculture? Also, how do vegans "kill wild animals" - and are you so sure they do so in numbers of over 150 billion per year, as does modern animal agriculture? I think you are confused. Wildlife suffers mostly from the collateral damage of meat production - deforestation, drought, pollution, climate change, etc. Definitely check out documentaries such as Cowspiracy if you are not convinced, or just search around. Here's something I found about Amazon deforestation:

> A 2009 Greenpeace report found that the cattle sector in the Brazilian Amazon, supported by the international beef and leather trades, was responsible for about 80% of all deforestation in the region,[3] or about 14% of the world’s total annual deforestation, making it the largest single driver of deforestation in the world.[4] According to a 2006 report by the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, 70% of formerly forested land in the Amazon, and 91% of land deforested since 1970, is used for livestock pasture.[5][19]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deforestation_of_the_Amazon_ra...

noondip··on Vegetarians 'less healthy, have lower quality of life than meat-eaters' (2014)
Exactly who stands to gain from a vegan agenda, do you think? Big Broccoli? Dr. Greger Super Pills Inc.?
noondip··on Vegetarians 'less healthy, have lower quality of life than meat-eaters' (2014)
Check out videos about fish oil supplements on http://nutritionfacts.org. I took them for a while, but have since realized algae oil is a much safer source of EPA-DHA. Even krill oil would be an improvement.
noondip··on Vegetarians 'less healthy, have lower quality of life than meat-eaters' (2014)
Lots of quackery here.

http://www.plosone.org/article/fetchObject.action?uri=info:d...

> no statements can be made whether the poorer health in vegetarians in our study is caused by their dietary habit or if they consume this form of diet due to their poorer health status. We cannot state whether a causal relationship exists, but describe ascertained associations. Moreover, we cannot give any information regarding the long-term consequences of consuming a special diet nor concerning mortality rates

So it's also entirely possible those with existing chronic conditions and poorer subjective health were more likely to try vegetarian eating (reverse causality).

But no, it gets worse ...

> While 0.2% (31) of the interviewees were pure vegetarians (57.7% female), 0.8% (124) reported to be vegetarians consuming milk and eggs (77.3% female), and 1.2% (186) to be vegetarians consuming fish and/or eggs and milk (76.7% female). 23.6% (3,651) reported to combine a carnivorous diet with lots of fruits and vegetables (67.2% female), 48.5% (7,505) to eat a carnivorous diet less rich in meat (60.8% female), and 25.7% (3,977) a carnivorous diet rich in meat (30.1% female)

> Since the three vegetarian diet groups included a rather small number of persons (N = 343), they were analyzed as one dietary habit group. Moreover, since the vegetarian group was the smallest, we decided to match each of the vegetarians (1) with an individual of each other dietary habit group (carnivorous diet rich in fruits and vegetables (2), carnivorous diet less rich in meat (3) and a carnivorous rich in meat (4)).

31 vegans out of a group of 15,000 people, and the rest of the "vegetarians" weren't even clearly defined, nor any control on how long they've been veg*n. Overall, this is a very poorly designed study with several obvious flaws.

And anyway, common ovo-lacto vegetarians still include harmful dairy products in their diet, so even if all this were true, I wouldn't be surprised.

Finally, here is a newer study by the same author on the same data with an entirely contradictory conclusion:

http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs00508-013-0483-3

> Subjects eating a carnivorous diet less rich in meat self-report poorer health, a higher number of chronic conditions, an enhanced vascular risk, as well as lower quality of life. In conclusion, our results have shown that consuming a diet rich in fruits and vegetables is associated with better health and health-related behavior. Therefore, public health programs are needed for reducing the health risks associated with a carnivorous diet.

noondip··on Tiny Farms Raises Seed Round as Cricket Farming Heats Up
> All food may have protein, but all food does not have essential amino acids (which cannot be made by your body) in the quantities required to maintain health.

> the idea you can get sufficient protein by just eating any old plant is.... wrong.

You're quite mistaken. If what you say were true, a warning of it would be clearly made by medical and nutritional authorities. Alas, no respectable organization says it, precisely because it's a myth. You can easily search on Google to find evidence which contradicts your post. Here are just the first two results I found when looking at potatoes as an example:

> The high nutritive value of potato protein can be understood when its composition is compared with that of whole wheat (Table 2). Apart from histidine, it contains substantially more of all the essential amino-acids ; this superiority is particularly striking for lysine, the amount present being similar to that in a typical animal protein.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/13536266

> For a 120 pound adult, five potatoes (960 calories) supply over 100% of the recommended intake for all essential amino acids.

> It's pretty difficult for an adult to eat a plant-based, vegetarian diet that doesn't provide all EAAs, as long as caloric needs are met.

> Finally - The pool of AAs that our body uses to manufacture its own proteins isn't limited by what we eat. Normal daily turnover of our cells provides a substantial pool from which to draw amino acids. Bacteria that line our colon also manufacture AAs, including EAAs, that we can utilize.

> It is a misconception that plants provide "incomplete protein", regardless of what Ms. Lappe advanced in her 1971 book, "Diet For A Small Planet."

http://fanaticcook.blogspot.com/2008/04/if-all-you-ate-were-...

noondip··on Tiny Farms Raises Seed Round as Cricket Farming Heats Up
Oh, come on - you don't really think so, do you? How many people do you know with diabetes as a result of eating potatoes or mangoes? Check out Starch Solution by John McDougall, if you're being serious. Here's a small tidbit on it - https://www.drmcdougall.com/misc/2006nl/july/glycemic.htm - the guy literally uses potatoes and other starchy vegetables to treat diabetes.

> there is little evidence that total carbohydrate intake is associated with the development of type 2 diabetes. Rather, a stronger association has been observed between total fat and saturated fat intake and type 2 diabetes

http://care.diabetesjournals.org/content/27/9/2266.full

> The available data support the idea that consumption of diets high in total carbohydrate does not adversely affect insulin sensitivity compared with high fat diets. Animal data suggest that simple sugars, in particular fructose, have adverse effects on insulin action, but adverse effects have not been shown conclusively in humans.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11584106

noondip··on Tiny Farms Raises Seed Round as Cricket Farming Heats Up
Deficient means there are lower levels of certain amino acids, but they're not missing entirely. It wouldn't make any biological sense for plants to be missing amino acids. If you read the actual cited source, you will find this:

> Usual dietary combinations of plant proteins are complete; specific plant proteins may be low in specific amino acids

> There is no evidence that amino acid imbalances per se are important; possible imbalances can be created by inappropriate amino acid supplementation, but this is not a practical problem.

noondip··on Tiny Farms Raises Seed Round as Cricket Farming Heats Up
> it's possible to eat plants and end up not getting all essential amino acids

No, that isn't possible. You could eat nothing but potatoes, or even mangoes, and still get enough protein. There isn't a single whole plant food which is completely lacking in any essential amino acid. How could it? Plants can't "hunt" and "eat" other plants - they must synthesize all amino acids themselves. The "complete protein" myth is one which has been debunked for decades, yet somehow refuses to die.

noondip··on Tiny Farms Raises Seed Round as Cricket Farming Heats Up
As I had explained in the parent comment, all food has protein, so it's not necessary to specially source it from a particular food. Especially when that food appears extremely unpalatable (or am I the only one who doesn't salivate at the sight of crickets?).
noondip··on Tiny Farms Raises Seed Round as Cricket Farming Heats Up
Okay, but human nutritional needs only call for 10-15% of calories from protein. Why would you go for 70%? There are risks associated with excessive protein consumption, too.
noondip··on Tiny Farms Raises Seed Round as Cricket Farming Heats Up
> The tiny insects have been eaten in developing nations for centuries, but now consumers in the Western world are increasingly accepting them as an efficient and sustainable source of protein.

Every food has protein in it. Bananas have protein. Tomatoes have protein. All plant foods have a complete amino acid profile fit for human consumption. In fact, protein is the easiest macronutrient to get enough of, provided caloric needs are being met. So it's perplexing why eating insects is billed as a 'sustainable source of protein'. Is it more sustainable than say, rice or potatoes?

noondip··on Starbucks has 3x the sugar of a whole Coke in some drinks
For example - most of the world's population is actually lactose intolerant.
noondip··on Starbucks has 3x the sugar of a whole Coke in some drinks
There isn't any problem with naturally occurring sugar in fruit. The trouble comes when there's added sugar only.
noondip··on SSH: Best practices
Here's a brief guide for setting up SSH with YubiKey as a smartcard which complements this article nicely - https://github.com/drduh/YubiKey-Guide
noondip··on A vanishingly small percentage of venture funding has been raised by black women
It's generally believed and accepted all animals are sentient.
noondip··on A Diet and Exercise Plan to Lose Weight and Gain Muscle
I didn't realize science expired after N years. Should we disregard the theory of gravity, too? I mean, it's quite old!

Your first two sources (NHS & Choose My Plate) are literally government/industry propaganda, so aren't even worth taking seriously.

The Harvard page doesn't say, "carbs are evil". It says, "The type of carbohydrate in the diet is more important than the amount of carbohydrate in the diet, because some sources of carbohydrate—like vegetables (other than potatoes), fruits, whole grains, and beans—are healthier than others."

Where does it say to limit carbohydrates on the other pages? They all say to increase fruit and vegetable consumption, which are almost all "carbs". I'm genuinely puzzled and intrigued by why some people think carbs are so bad, at least in the form of whole plant foods.

noondip··on A Diet and Exercise Plan to Lose Weight and Gain Muscle
> there is almost nobody currently saying sugar and complex carbs are good for you, everyone is saying to limit your intake

Who is saying to limit intake of carbs? Definitely not any non-profit organization like WHO:

> The Consultation RECOMMENDS:

> 3. Against the use of the terms extrinsic and intrinsic sugars, complex carbohydrate and available and unavailable carbohydrate.

> 11. That the many health benefits of dietary carbohydrates should be recognized and promoted. Carbohydrate foods provide more than energy alone.

> 12. An optimum diet of at least 55% of total energy from a variety of carbohydrate sources for all ages except for children under the age of two.

> 17. That the bulk of carbohydrate-containing foods consumed be those rich in non-starch polysaccharides and with a low glycemic index. Appropriately processed cereals, vegetables, legumes, and fruits are particularly good food choices.

> 18. That excess energy intake in any form will cause body fat accumulation, so that excess consumption of low fat foods, while not as obesity-producing as excess consumption of high fat products, will lead to obesity if energy expenditure is not increased. Excessive intakes of sugars which compromise micronutrient density should be avoided. There is no evidence of a direct involvement of sucrose, other sugars and starch in the etiology of lifestyle-related diseases.

http://www.who.int/nutrition/publications/nutrientrequiremen...

noondip··on A Diet and Exercise Plan to Lose Weight and Gain Muscle
Well, since you've asked so politely!

An insulin index of foods: the insulin demand generated by 1000-kJ portion of common foods

http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/66/5/1264.abstract

noondip··on A Diet and Exercise Plan to Lose Weight and Gain Muscle
> fats and animal proteins are very healthy

If so, why did Dr. Atkins die overweight with a history of heart attack, congestive heart failure and hypertension? Please, don't buy into the Atkins/low-carb/paleo hype - check out http://www.atkinsfacts.org/

noondip··on A Diet and Exercise Plan to Lose Weight and Gain Muscle
Carbs make your insulin go up, but so does protein; a steak will cause substantially higher insulin secretion than pure white table sugar. What you really want to be eating is a high-carbohydrate, high-fiber diet (whole plant foods, lots of whole grains, beans, fruits, and vegetables).
noondip··on Effects of a Year in Ketosis [video]
https://www.iarc.fr/en/media-centre/pr/2015/pdfs/pr240_E.pdf is a good starting point.
noondip··on Effects of a Year in Ketosis [video]
Or, get your omega-3 from plant sources like flax and chia seed, and avoid eating fat-soluble industrial pollutants, like mercury and lead, found in fish.
noondip··on Effects of a Year in Ketosis [video]
The paper doesn't categorize low-fat vegan diets. The closest to it was recognized though: "only a Mediterranean dietary pattern was related to CHD in RCTs." (assuming saturated fat from meat was replaced with MUFAs or PUFAs).

Also, the B12 boogeyman? Just take a weekly supplement and be fine.

noondip··on Effects of a Year in Ketosis [video]
You can't deny the fact certain foods, like processed meat, surely have a causal relationship to cancer, probably also heart disease and diabetes. As I've said before, the evidence against animal products and processed food in general is damning, but I've yet to find a single case study of someone getting fat off eating fruit, getting cancer from tofu, or becoming diabetic from eating too many vegetables.
← PreviousPage 2 of 10Next →