HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nordsieck

7,199 karma · joined July 31, 2011

submissionscomments
nordsieck··on Why hasn't commercial air travel gotten any faster since the 1960s? (2009)
> But nevertheless I still think it's worthwhile for us as a species to look at ways we can cross the planet faster. I think eventually (maybe in our lifetimes), the idea of taking a flight that takes you into outer space won't be too far fetched. While I don't think the time savings going supersonic will be worth it, I think the savings when going into outer space will, assuming we figure out a economical way to get people up and down from outer space.

It's possible that it may make sense to establish a few business class only very fast point-to-point routes. But that also really depends on the vehicle taking people through space. There are a number of problems:

1. Currently, spacecraft are only licensed for experimental travel. Everyone signs an informed consent waiver and basically disclaims all liability. And the FAA is forbidden to regulate for passenger safety by congress (and has been for quite a long time) - they can only regulate for the safety of the general public.

This would have to be changed before any serious commercial spacecraft went into service

2. It's not clear that any spacecraft has the economics to pull this off. Maybe Starship can do it. But it's pretty far from clear that they can.

3. Spacecraft are orders of magnitude less safe than commercial aviation. Do you know the saying "regulations are written in blood"? If this starts happening, there'll be a lot of new regulations that happen over time.

And maybe that'll happen anyhow - I think that space tourism will certainly be a thing that becomes much more popular in the future, and that has the exact same problems (although it's much less readily comparable to commercial aviation).

nordsieck··on Why hasn't commercial air travel gotten any faster since the 1960s? (2009)
> Due to the the time it takes at either end, there's a fixed minimum time cost to flying. Maybe three or four hours counting both ends.

To be fair to airports, the arrival side hasn't really changed post 9/11. If you check bags, that's on you - it's going to be slow to get your stuff.

But yeah - having to budget time to get through security is a pretty poor user experience. Especially during busy times of the year, when it's more uncertain just how much time is required.

nordsieck··on TikTok says it is restoring service for U.S. users
> Regardless of the specifics of this issue, it is objectively a huge power grab for a president to vow to not enforce a law that had bipartisan approval of both the legislative and judiciary branches.

Isn't that the road we've been walking down for a while now with the proliferation of executive orders?

I'm not a fan of this outcome either, but it doesn't strike me as a revolutionary departure from current norms.

nordsieck··on Project Mini Rack – compact and portable homelabs
I feel like an m-series mac mini would be a really good fit for that - plenty of juice for when you need it, but very low idle power draw. The small size (especially for the m4 version) is an added benefit.
nordsieck··on Supreme Court upholds TikTok ban, but Trump might offer lifeline
> I think the simpler explanation blatant corruption, since the legislation is moving judicial responsibility from from the judicial branch to the legislature and president

I mean, that's true of basically all administrative agencies.

nordsieck··on US will ban cancer-linked Red Dye No. 3 in cereal and other foods
> food in the US is overly colored for no other reason than it looks cool

My understanding is that a lot of food is colored to look "natural" for uniformity. A good example of this is applesauce.

nordsieck··on A Laptop Stand Made from a Single Sheet of Recycled Paper
> If you're going to buy a laptop stand anyway and you have the choice between A) a plastic stand or B) this recycled stand, does it make more or less sense, in terms of environmental impact, to buy the plastic stand over this one?

I mean, if you expect the cardboard one not to last very long, then yes. Yes it does "make more or less sense".

nordsieck··on A laptop stand made from a single sheet of recycled paper
> I'm reminded of similarly useless "sustainable cardboard furniture" that came out about a decade ago.

Apparently no one learned their lesson, because the cardboard olympic village beds were also (allegedly) pretty terrible.

nordsieck··on Akamai to shut down its CDN operations in China
> We've had CIFUS for decades. The only change is now we say no to Japan teaching us to make better steel.

I'm curious what you mean by that.

Most of what I know about steel is in relation to knives (and peripherally, swords, axes, and other tools). At least in that (admittedly small) niche, Japanese steel is good, but certainly not superior to US steel (although with the financial trouble that Crucible is having, perhaps things will change a bit).

nordsieck··on Savoy Style vs. Hollywood Style: A Fight to the Death (Hopefully?) (2011)
IMO, the primary reason for this is because WCS is danced to contemporary music. When the music changes, the dancing changes to suit it.

I think your example is actually quite illustrative of this - the 2nd song had a lot more "swing content" than the first; since it's an older blues song the traditional West Coast Swing patterns fit it better.

nordsieck··on Savoy Style vs. Hollywood Style: A Fight to the Death (Hopefully?) (2011)
A few examples as illustration:

Sylvia Sykes dancing Lindy Hop[1].

An example of Savoy style Lindy Hop[2].

An example of Sylvia Sykes dancing West Coast Swing[3], a swing dance that was heavily influenced[4] by Hollywood style. For the keen eyed among you, she does a bit of Lindy and a bit of Balboa in the midst of the dance.

---

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=92xjd8f5Zes

2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VmvKrPUo97E

3. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=psOWt0oyx9k

1. I've heard many purported histories of WCS, some from people who were there as the dance was forming. It's difficult to know exactly what is true.

nordsieck··on Four limitations of Rust's borrow checker
> So basically raw pointers with extra hoops to jump through.

That's one way to look at it.

The other way is: raw pointers, but with mechanical sympathy. Array based data structures crush pointer based data structures in performance.

nordsieck··on Adversarial policies beat superhuman Go AIs (2023)
> It does not take away how good he is

Honestly, your anecdote makes me respect him even more.

Few people go to those lengths to prepare.

nordsieck··on Polyamory doesn't liberate; monogamy doesn't protect
> 21% of Americans have experimented with consensual non-monogamy at some point in their lives, far more than two decades ago

> Not only do I not believe that statistic, but the footnote citation seems to be broken.

I guess it depends a lot on how the terms are defined. If you include parallel dating (during the "non-exclusive" phase of dating), I could easily see this as being true.

nordsieck··on Demand for Starlink in Zimbabwe is overwhelming capacity
> is there any reason to think this will be a trend all over the world where people have shitty internet?

I think it really depends on why the region has bad internet.

If it's because the government officials wants kickbacks from ISPs, they're probably not going to give SpaceX a license to circumvent that arrangement.

If it's because the infrastructure is bad, and there's no money to improve it at the moment, I'd probably be more hopeful.

nordsieck··on Demand for Starlink in Zimbabwe is overwhelming capacity
The issue is, there just aren't that many satellites in orbit. 7000 (for SpaceX, less for other networks) for the globe means that only a few connections over a particular geographical area end up causing serious congestion.

SpaceX is pushing hard to address this - they'll probably end up launching ~135 times this year, and are aiming for more than 180 times next year[2], most of which will be Starlink. But no matter how many satellites are in orbit, there just won't be the bandwidth to service dense urban areas.

The reason that cell phones work is because there are so many cell towers. And, those towers have a density that correlates with demand.

The problem with LEO satellites is, they have to evenly cover the Earth[1]. Which means that a level of service sufficient for a dense urban area would mean that rest of the world would be ridiculously over provisioned.

---

1. It's more complicated than that. Specifically, providers can use inclination to limit orbits to mid latitudes. But that only helps so much.

2. These numbers may not mean much to you, but they are absurd compared to pre-SpaceX years. SpaceX is doing more launches in a year than most rockets do in their entire lifetimes. A normal year for a SpaceX competitor like ULA is 4-10 launches, although those companies are also aiming to ramp up as Starlink competitors like Kuiper demand more launch volume.

nordsieck··on USC Student Rocket Group Shatters International Amateur Space Record
Thanks for the correction.
nordsieck··on USC Student Rocket Group Shatters International Amateur Space Record
> There are only three things the UK uses Imperial units for: road signage (speed limits, distances, and vehicle dimension restrictions; and since 2016 all new dimension restriction signage has to be in dual-SI and Imperial units[1]), beer, and milk

Do people not weigh themselves in stones and pounds?

nordsieck··on USC Student Rocket Group Shatters International Amateur Space Record
> The thrust of the engine can (and should) be measured in newtons though.

It's very common to measure engine thrust in ton-force because it makes it easy to compare the thrust to the weight of the rocket, which is a critical metric.

nordsieck··on Student rocket group shatters amateur space record
> Are they as high up that it could start orbiting?

1. No

2. Orbit is more about speed than height. You have to get high enough that the atmosphere doesn't aggressively degrade your velocity, but the key is to hit ~8km/s, although that number changes depending on your altitude.

edit: 30km/s -> 8km/s

nordsieck··on A Brazilian CA trusted only by Microsoft has issued a certificate for google.com
> Either way, this makes little sense overall. If a CA is trustable, it can be trusted to sign a certificate for any domain. And if it's not trustable, then you can't trust it for any domain.

That's a silly position to take.

When I lived with roommates, I trusted them. But I also locked my bedroom when I went out. Because there's no good reason to rely on trust when you don't have to.

nordsieck··on Go and Java: Rethinking Type Safety for the Pragmatic Age
> In Go, it's possible to actually make a Goose and have it as just a local variable living on your stack, but, the language insists that anybody can conjure one into existence despite having no basis for doing so, the resulting Goose is at best now in some invalid "null" state.

If you really don't want people instantiating instances of a type on their own, can't you just make the type private but make a factory for the type public?

nordsieck··on Starlink Direct to Cell
> The risk of loss of payload actually goes DOWN with more launches, making costs cheaper the more a booster is reused.

I don't think that's true. All of the F9 failures[1] have been due to the 2nd stage. And that's new every time.

---

1. CRS-7, AMOS-6, and Starlink 9-3

nordsieck··on Starlink Direct to Cell
> In the past this at-cost dealing would have been considered monopolistic enough to force divestment

I guess we'll see what happens.

As with most things monopoly related, the critical fight is over how to appropriately define the market. Presumably SpaceX would argue that Starlink is an ISP and that it just happens to use satellites to deliver its service.

And if that doesn't work, then it's a satellite internet provider, but competes with both LEO and GEO services.

If it ever goes to court, it'll be interesting to see how such an argument holds up.

nordsieck··on Starlink Direct to Cell
> On the commercial side Blue Origin has been slow in starting but they are almost ready and will have relatively cheap launches.

[citation needed]

Sure, New Glenn is designed to be a partially reusable rocket.

But it's far from clear that they'll even successfully launch on their debut, not to mention recover the booster.

And even when they've sorted all that out, word on the street is that the rocket was not designed to be inexpensively manufactured. It's not clear to me just now low reuse can help drive down their launch price.

nordsieck··on Starlink Direct to Cell
> SpaceX - may or may not be profitable in the last year - it's hard to know. Until recently definitely no profitable

SpaceX is very much in the same position as early Amazon.

If they wanted to, they could be profitable today. But they are investing heavily in the future.

IMO, that's a good sign for SpaceX. Many large companies have run out of ideas of what to do with money, so they accumulate it in bank accounts, or do dividends/stock buybacks.

nordsieck··on Starlink Direct to Cell
IMO, one of the central problems is the cost of launching stuff into space.

Today, SpaceX offers world leading low prices to launch satellites: $4 m / tonne[1]. But Starlink has access to launch at cost, which is $0.86 m / tonne[2]. Which is a huge advantage when launching an enormous number of satellites.

One thing to keep in mind, especially for these LEO constellations: the lifetime of these satellites is 5-10 years. Which means the operators can never stop launching. It's an ongoing operational cost.

For smaller operators like OneWeb, they don't have to launch that often, but for a serious competitor like Kuiper, they'll be constantly launching some satellite every year.

IMO, launch cost will be a problem even for China. The cost of an LEO constellation is so high that even if it's partially subsidized by the military it'll be a serious cost for the country.

That could change pretty soon, though - various companies and organizations in China are aggressively working on getting reusable rockets working.

---

1. $70 m / 17.5 tonnes == $4 m / tonne

2. $15 m[3] / 17.5 tonnes == $0.86 / tonne

3. The $15 m number is not public info, but it is widely believed that it is in the correct ballpark.

nordsieck··on Starlink Direct to Cell
It's not very likely.

USC students just broke the non-government, non-corporate rocket launch altitude record, reaching 143.25km[1]. But that is still a long way from the ~500km that Starlink operates at.

On top of that the person would have to develop a guidance system and payload capable of targeting and sufficiently damaging one of these satellites - not an easy feat.

Finally, it seems unlikely that a single hit would cause a chain reaction. There aren't that many satellites that are part of Starlink. Imagine 6000 cars spread over the surface of the Earth. Except that they're even more sparse than that because many of them are at different altitudes.

Additionally, SpaceX has already had to deal with the result of the debris field from the Russian Cosmos satellite that was destroyed by a Russian anti-satellite missile.[2]

Starlink has a lot of protection compared to other constellations since the satellites occupy such low orbits that most debris spontaneously deorbits in 5-10 years.

---

1. https://viterbischool.usc.edu/news/2024/11/usc-student-rocke...

2. https://spacenews.com/starlink-satellites-encounter-russian-...

nordsieck··on Starlink Direct to Cell
> I don't know what the intersection of that with the affordability is, though.

My understanding is that the monthly cost for Starlink varies pretty wildly across the world. Presumably the same would be true for this cell service - idle satellites have the same huge fixed cost and don't generate any revenue.

nordsieck··on Starlink Direct to Cell
To put some numbers to it, it looks like SpaceX started launching direct to cell satellites at the beginning of the year[1], and by July they had over 100 in orbit. Not sure how many are in orbit right now, but I wouldn't be surprised if it were close to 200.

---

1. https://spacenews.com/spacex-deploys-direct-to-smartphone-sa...

2. https://www.satellitetoday.com/connectivity/2024/07/03/space...

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →