HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nosianu

3,483 karma · joined March 13, 2019

submissionscomments
nosianu··on How China built its ‘Manhattan Project’ to rival the West in AI chips
Which in turn was fueled by the consumers' desire for cheap stuff, and for their portfolios to earn them a lot of money to be able to retire early and live comfortably while letting a cheaper workforce far away do more and more of the dirty and dangerous jobs.

The "bean counters" are under pressure just like everybody else. They didn't come up with their targets and incentives out of nowhere.

nosianu··on AI is wiping out entry-level tech jobs, leaving graduates stranded
> Evidence I can give in support of the article:

I only want to point out that evidence of less hiring is not evidence for AI-anything.

As others have pointed out, here and previously, things like outsourcing to India, or for Europe Eastern Europe, is also going strong. That's another explanation for less jobs "here", but they are not gone, they just moved to cheaper places. As has been going on for decades, it just continues unevenly.

https://www.cnbc.com/2025/12/11/big-tech-microsoft-amazon-go...

> Over $50 billion in under 24 hours: Why Big Tech is doubling down on investing in India

https://news.microsoft.com/source/asia/2025/12/09/microsoft-...

> Microsoft invests US$17.5 billion in India to drive AI diffusion at population scale

nosianu··on Vibe coding creates fatigue?
> What makes a code worthy of trust is passing tests

(Sorry, but you set yourself up for this one, my apologies.)

Oh, so this post describes "worthy code", okay then.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18442941

Tests are not a panacea. They don't care about anything other than what you test. If you don't have code testing maintainability and readability, only that it "works", you end up like the product in that post.

Ultimate example: Biology (and everything related, like physiology, anatomy), where the test is similarly limited to "does it produce children that can survive". It is a huuuuuge mess, and trying to change any one thing always messes up things elsewhere in unexpected and hard or impossible to solve ways. It's genius, it works, it sells - and trying to deliberately change anything is a huge PITA because everything is interconnected and there is no clean design anywhere. You manage to change some single gene to change some very minor behavior, suddenly the ear shape changes and fur color and eye sight and digestion and disease resistance, stuff like that.

nosianu··on JetBlue flight averts mid-air collision with US Air Force jet
Look, I understand, but we have a concrete event here that is being discussed and there is no evidence anywhere for what you came up with. Adding feeling-based imagination instead of sticking to facts just makes the discussion much worse - and much closer to behavior you seem to object to.
nosianu··on Nuclear energy key to decarbonising Europe, says EESC
Unfortunately, German AND Paywall, but:

https://www.zeit.de/wirtschaft/2025-12/atomkraft-frankreich-...

> France's dangerous nuclear friendship with Russia

> France promises to support Ukraine. But its nuclear energy supply is closely linked to Russia. Former energy bosses earn a lot of money with Rosatom.

nosianu··on Thousands of U.S. farmers have Parkinson's. They blame a deadly pesticide
> political pressure. Same reason lots of stuff is banned in the EU even when it's safer than other things that aren't banned.

You avoid the question instead of answering it (What caused that "political pressure"? Does such a thing just occur randomly in nature?), following it by an assertion that you don't bother to provide any evidence for.

nosianu··on JSDoc is TypeScript
TypeScript is indeed Javascript, all you have to do is remove the type annotations. They are not code.

TS does have some minor things like enums that need to be transformed and are actual code, but those are very few, and leftovers from early days of TS, and the TS authors regret having implemented them. For many years now the TS philosophy has been that the CODE part of TS is 100% ECMAscript, and only annotations, which are not code, are added.

The initial Babel transpiler for TS => JS, and still the most part of the current one, simply removes annotations.

It is recommended not to use the few parts that are actual code and not standard JS. They are certainly not needed any more since ES6.

People may get confused because the type syntax itself is almost like a programming language, with conditions and all. But none of that ends up as code, it's not used at runtime.

One of the IMHO worst design decisions of TS was to bundle type checking and transpiling into one tool. That caused sooo many misunderstandings and confusion.

nosianu··on Nuclear energy key to decarbonising Europe, says EESC
That's what this is for, in general: https://energy.ec.europa.eu/topics/infrastructure/trans-euro...

Also, Germany currently has the problem of much more and more reliable wind generation in the north, but not enough network capacity to send it all south when needed. It is being addressed, but as expected, it is very complicated because infrastructure across the whole country touches the interests of a lot of groups with very different interests.

We might need much better tunnel building equipment and a deep sub-terranean network... (useful sci-fi idea, needs to be able to cope with mild earth quakes in some regions).

nosianu··on Nuclear energy key to decarbonising Europe, says EESC
I don't know how reliant France is, but they do seem to rely quite a bit on Rosatom (https://www.lemonde.fr/en/energies/article/2023/03/12/french...).

They also rely on imports of uranium - e.g. from Niger, which recently had quite the fallout with France.

It does not look to me at even a casual glance that French nuclear tech could fully work on its own. Similar for the UK.

It is not just about the experts, the supply chain too. Although, of course how much that matters in comparison is the question, since pretty much everything nowadays depends on some faraway place.

nosianu··on Things I want to say to my boss
> Working for other people sucks.

Depends.

I worked and even had a business with and/or worked for three people that I've known for a long time. And had loud substantial disagreements with - before going into business. Worked like a charm every single time. The personal side I mean, business was neutral once, a complete failure but I only wanted the paycheck anyway once, and a resounding success in a traditional business where I handle only IT right now.

In the first venture I found out I hated selling and business. Sure, I can do it, but I really really don't want to. I am a minimalist, and I might have become a poor monk in a monastery a thousand years ago. I don't want to sell anyone anything. So in the next two businesses I left all the business stuff to others, and it is sooo much better.

And now that I'm in a non-IT traditional business I'm a servant 100%. And it is nice. My main focus is non IT stuff, and I use computers to achieve that. Finding differences in thousands of EDI messages for invoices, order confirmations and deliveries, for example. HOW - who cares? I am not developing a product. If it's a one-off I may just run some command line tools. Or, shocking!, I actually use Excel. Or I ask ChatGPT for a little helper Python script to run over the raw data files.

Doing servant work without business responsibilities is really nice :) My boss may have the bigger house and car, so what? He also has exponentially more stress (I have pretty much zero). In my youth I may have had a different opinion, but now I don't want his stress level for any amount of compensation. And no, future early retirement by making lots of money now does not change the equation. I don't want to retire at all anyway, keep doing business stuff on the side at least. Without the stress it's no problem! One of my direct colleagues is way past retirement age...

nosianu··on Things I want to say to my boss
> Arguably, AI is largely marketed that way because that's what corporate buyers care about

Why "arguably", that is exactly what he wrote

nosianu··on The highest quality codebase
> Agentic code tools have a significant bias to add versus remove/condense.

Your point stands uncontested by me, but I just wanted to mention that humans have that bias too.

Random link (has the Nature study link): https://blog.benchsci.com/this-newly-proven-human-bias-cause...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Additive_bias

nosianu··on The highest quality codebase
> Would a human perform very differently?

How useful is the comparison with the worst human results? Which are often due to process rather than the people involved.

You can improve processes and teach the humans. The junior will become a senior, in time. If the processes and the company are bad, what's the point of using such a context to compare human and AI outputs? The context is too random and unpredictable. Even if you find out AI or some humans are better in such a bad context, what of it? The priority would be to improve the process first for best gains.

nosianu··on Firewood Banks Aren't Inspiring. They're a Sign of Collapse
He is not the only one, this is normal now and not a sign of super-rich depravity.

Here in my Bavarian city I can get mangos explicitly labeled "flight mangos" ("Flugmangos" - German supermarket), for example. They look so much better than the regular ones, but at almost 10 Euros per piece I have not tried one yet since I still have dried mango pieces in the fridge.

Relevant: https://www.lufthansa-cargo.com/en/-/flying-fresh-12

nosianu··on The "confident idiot" problem: Why AI needs hard rules, not vibe checks
The human world model is based on physical sensors and actions. LLMs are based on our formal text communication. Very different!

Just yesterday I observed myself acting on an external stimulus without any internal words (this happens continuously, but it is hard to notice because we usually don't pay attention to how we do things): I sat in a waiting area of a cinema. A woman walked by and dropped her scarf without noticing. I automatically without thinking raised arm and pointer finger towards her, and when I had her attention pointed behind her. I did not have time to think even a single word while that happened.

Most of what we do does not involved any words or even just "symbols", not even internally. Instead, it is a neural signal from sensors into the brain, doing some loops, directly to muscle activation. Without going through the add-on complexity of language, or even "symbols".

Our word generator is not the core of our being, it is an add-on. When we generate words it's also very far from being a direct representation of internal state. Instead, we have to meander and iterate to come up with appropriate words for an internal state we are not even quite aware of. That's why artists came up with all kinds of experiments to better represent our internal state, because people always knew the words we produce don't represent it very well.

That is also how people always get into arguments about definitions. Because the words are secondary, and the further from the center of established meaning for some word you get the more the differences show between various people. (The best option is to drop insisting of words being the center of the universe, even just the human universe, and/or to choose words that have the subject of discussion more firmly in the center of their established use).

We are text generators in some areas, I don't doubt that. Just a few months ago I listened to some guy speaking to a small rally. I am certain that not a single sentence he said was of his own making, he was just using things he had read and parroted them (as a former East German, I know enough Marx/Engels/Lenin to recognize it). I don't want to single that person out, we all have those moments, when we speak about things we don't have any experiences with. We read text, and when prompted we regurgitate a version of it. In those moments we are probably closest to LLM output. When prompted, we cannot fall back on generating fresh text from our own actual experience, instead we keep using text we heard or read, with only very superficial understanding, and as soon as an actual expert shows up we become defensive and try to change the context frame.

nosianu··on The past was not that cute
Having grown up in East Germany, that is the truth. From both my grandparents, born early 20th century, to me things continuously got better. Apart from the war of course. They started little better than servant class and ended up with their own big nice houses, and in comfort. That is true even for the GDR. They lived through war and famine and at least four different currencies and types of government.

They also got more and more educated. From the lowest education to ever higher education degrees, one more step in each new generation. My grandfather tried many new tech hobbies as theY appeared, from (actual, original) tape recorders over mechanical calculators to at the time modern cameras and color slides, to growing hundreds of cactuses in a glasshouse, maybe as a substitute for being unable to travel to those places. I still have lots of quality 1950s and 60s color slides of people and places in East Germany.

Looking around. even the GDR until the end experienced significant improvements over what existed before, at least for the masses. Except for the environment especially near industry.

nosianu··on Have I been Flocked? – Check if your license plate is being watched
Hacker-Noosed
nosianu··on State Department to deny visas to fact checkers and others, citing 'censorship'
> This other side is not the left,

How is that my mistake??? YOU came up with "left". I very deliberately did not say such a ridiculous thing, given that any "left" party has never in power.

I would also appreciate if you did not paraphrase what I wrote when what I wrote still is right there, or at least don't attribute your words to me.

I always find it fascinating, and quite disturbing, how people rewrite what other people wrote to base their "counter-"argument on their rewrite.

nosianu··on State Department to deny visas to fact checkers and others, citing 'censorship'
This did not happen fast though, but over decades.

On one side, the right preparing by slowly taking over positions, on the other side people ignoring the problems of many.

Here in Germany I fear the AfD too may get into power, because instead of fixing the problems that people complained about for decades (costs, bureaucracy, rents, no vision apart from "consume and work") people are fixated on that right wing party itself.

When I did some skydiving in my youth I was fascinated by watching sooo many skydivers barely avoiding the lone single tree near the landing zone. Turns out, if you concentrate on something ("I must avoid that tree I must avoid that tree...") you end up steering towards it. The winning move is to instead concentrate on where you do want to go. There are precious little positive ideas in our politics, it's mostly about what we don't want, or distractions on things that while it sounds nice and it's definitely okay when it gets done should never be the main focus.

nosianu··on Everyone in Seattle hates AI
> If you haven’t had a mind blown moment with AI yet, you aren’t doing it right

I AM very impressed, and I DO use it and enjoy the results.

The problem is the inconsistency. When it works it works great, but it is very noticeable that it is just a machine from how it behaves.

Again, I am VERY impressed by what was achieved. I even enjoy Google AI summaries to some of the questions I now enter instead of search terms. This is definitely a huge step up in tier compared to pre-AI.

But I'm already done getting used to what is possible now. Changes after that have been incremental, nice to have and I take them. I found a place for the tool, but if it wanted to match the hype another equally large step in actual intelligence is necessary, for the tool to truly be able to replace humans.

So, I think the reason you don't see more glowing reviews and praise is that the technical people have found out what it can do and can't, and are already using it where appropriate. It's just a tool though. One that has to be watched over when you use it, requiring attention. And it does not learn - I can teach a newbie and they will learn and improve, I can only tweak the AI with prompts, with varying success.

I think that by now I have developed a pretty good feel for what is possible. Changing my entire workflow to using it is simply not useful.

I am actually one of those not enjoying coding as such, but wanting "solutions", probably also because I now work for an IT-using normal company, not for one making an IT product, and my focus most days is on actually accomplishing business tasks.

I do enjoy being able to do some higher level descriptions and getting code for stuff without having to take care of all the gritty details. But this functionality is rudimentary. It IS a huge step, but still not nearly good enough to really be able to reliably delegate to the AI to the degree I want.

nosianu··on IBM CEO says there is 'no way' spending on AI data centers will pay off
For some strange reason a lot of people were attracted by a comment that speaks about everything else BUT the actual topic and its the top comment now. Sigh.

If you think that carefully chosen anecdotes out of many many more are relevant, there needs to be at least an attempt of reasoning. There is nothing here. It's really just barebones mentioning of stuff intentionally selected to support the preconceived point.

I think we can, and should, do better in HN discussions, no? This is "vibe commenting".

nosianu··on Codex, Opus, Gemini try to build Counter Strike
Definitely citation needed. Such court cases usually come with a lot of important context. How can you just make such a statement and get away with not providing any context link?
nosianu··on India orders smartphone makers to preload state-owned cyber safety app
"Cops in this country think everyone using a Google Pixel must be a drug dealer" (because of GrapheneOS)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44473694

https://grapheneos.social/@GrapheneOS/114784469162979608

> European authoritarians and their enablers in the media are misrepresenting GrapheneOS and even Pixel phones as if they're something for criminals. GrapheneOS is opposed to the mass surveillance police state these people want to impose on everyone.

nosianu··on Google Antigravity just deleted the contents of whole drive
Without any of the spatial and physical object perception you train from right after birth, see toddlers playing, or the underlying wired infrastructure we are born with to understand the physical world (there was an HN submission about that not long ago). Edit, found it: https://news.ucsc.edu/2025/11/sharf-preconfigured-brain/

They are not a physical model like humans. Ours is based on deep interactions with the space and the objects (reason why touching things is important for babies), plus mentioned preexisting wiring for this purpose.

nosianu··on Google Antigravity just deleted the contents of whole drive
Ah, Polish. I love this movie scene, which I learned about here on HN some time ago: "Grzegorz Brzęczyszczykiewicz" -- https://youtu.be/AfKZclMWS1U
nosianu··on Google Antigravity just deleted the contents of whole drive
I think a good reminder for many users is that LLMs are not based on analyzing or copying human thought (#), but on analyzing human written text communication.

--

(#) Human thought is based on real world sensor data first of all. Human words have invisible depth behind them based on accumulated life experience of the person. So two people using the same words may have very different thoughts underneath them. Somebody having only text book knowledge and somebody having done a thing in practice for a long time may use the same words, but underneath there is a lot more going on for the latter person. We can see this expressed in the common bell curve meme -- https://www.hopefulmons.com/p/the-iq-bell-curve-meme -- While it seems to be about IQ, it really is about experience. Experience in turn is mostly physical, based on our physical sensors and physical actions. Even when we just "think", it is based on the underlying physical experiences. That is why many of our internal metaphors even for purely abstract ideas are still based on physical concepts, such as space.

nosianu··on All it takes is for one to work out
So you agree with the parent commenters actual point and counter-example, great!
nosianu··on All it takes is for one to work out
> over the past two decades basically all of the successful entrepreneurs and business owners I know

This very much sounds like survivorship bias to me.

But more importantly, I think the discussion is going off the track. The important ones are the 0.1%, not the 1% or 10%. The "normal" millionaire business owner usually actually worked for it (unless they are pure finance or something similar). They are also not the ones shifting a whole country's politics with their enormous influence. They don't have any over-inflated influence over anything. They are not the problem.

But they also don't serve as examples for the masses, because that would be confusing "anyone can do this" with "everyone can do this" - their successes don't scale. You can only have that many successful businesspeople and entrepreneurs, the majority must be their worker bees by necessity.

I see such discussions as distractions. If you talk about normal entrepreneurship you will not get to the core of our problems, not at the very top (the super rich), not at the bottom (why are so many so poor).

If you want to come up with an idea that works at scale you can't use one that only works for some no matter what. If you want to come up with a solution for the enormous imbalances looking at those normal entrepreneurs does not help either.

I suggest to develop an instinct to use in these kinds of discussions: For every concrete example, imagine it at scale. Thinking at individual examples when you talk about big things is a mismatch. Those examples are only useful if you use them to extrapolate upwards, what would actually happen if everybody did this?

nosianu··on Iceland declares ocean-current instability a national security risk
Man made stuff does not self-repair and self-replicate.

So, no. You are not thinking far enough, only the next step. But it is a complex vast network, and every single thing in it except the humans has that man-made item deficiency of decay without renewal.

You miss even repairs of the tiniest item - which in turn requires repairing he repairers, everything eventually stops.

Humans have to intervene fixing unforeseen problems all the time! It is humans that hold all those systems together.

Even if you had AGI, human brains are far from perfect too so that would not change anything in the end, we have biology to the rescue (of us in general, not necessarily the individual ofc) when we miss stuff.

nosianu··on Iceland declares ocean-current instability a national security risk
In support of the other reply, here is a look at the supply chain of a very simple product - a can of Coke.

https://medium.com/@kevin_ashton/what-coke-contains-221d4499...

(https://archive.md/PPYez)

The highlighted parts are a kind of TL;DR, but in the context here actually reading it - it is not much - is actually required to get anything out of it for the arguments used here.

Anything technological is orders of magnitude more complex.

Pointing to any single part really makes no sense, the point is the complexity and interconnectedness of everything.

Some AI doing everything is harder than the East Bloc countries attempting to use central planning for the whole economy. Their economy was much more simple than what such a mighty AI would require for itself and its robot minions. And that's just the organization.

I did like "Gaia" in Horizon Zero Dawn (game) because it made a great story though. This would be pretty much exactly the kind of AI fantasized about here.

Douglas Adams hints at hidden complexity towards the end of HHGTTG, talking about the collapse of Golgafrincham's society.

You overlook just one single tiny thing and it escalates to failure from there. Biological systems don't have that problem, they are self-assembling no matter how you slice and dice them. You may just end up with a very difference eco-system, but as long as the environment is not completely outside the useful range it will grow and reorganize. human-made engineered things on the other hand will just fail and that's it, they will not rise on their own from nothing. Human-made systems are much much more fragile than biological ones (even if you can't guarantee the kind of biological system you will get after rounds of growth and adaptations).

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →