HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nostrademons

85,130 karma · joined February 20, 2007

submissionscomments
nostrademons··on Google Search is now less than half of Alphabet’s revenue
Their earnings missed by almost 30%, which is pretty huge in the stock market.

I think the bigger concern is that earnings misses are very rare for GOOG, and historically they've been able to hit almost any target that Wall Street expects. Their past earnings misses were all related to major macroeconomic events (2020Q1, which was the COVID shutdowns, 2022 all year with inflation from COVID/Ukraine + rate hikes, and 2019Q3 with the taper tantrum from Fed rate hikes), and most of them were more in the 5% range. A 30% miss, particularly with slowing revenue growth in their core business despite almost full monetization of commercial queries, could indicate that the golden goose is disintegrating.

For that matter, GOOG has been extremely correlated with macroeconomic indicators since about 2018, which means investors in the rest of the stock market should probably watch out. It's likely we're already in recession but don't know it.

nostrademons··on Microsoft and others tell crypto platform not to tokenize their stocks
You said it was a stock sale. It is not a stock sale.
nostrademons··on Microsoft and others tell crypto platform not to tokenize their stocks
I'm condescending to everyone; my wife, when we first started dating, was like "He doesn't mean to be condescending, but, well, he is."

> Obviously it comes from the company; otherwise it's just a regular stock sale that doesn't need any additional descriptor.

This is incorrect. A buyback is when a company buys its stock. It is giving cash to shareholders, and taking the shares back. A stock sale is the opposite, when the company sells its stock and receives money from the new shareholders. The direction of cash flow is very important here, because a key difference between a Ponzi scheme and a buyback is that in a buyback, the company is distributing cash to investors, not taking cash in.

> The issue to me is that the division between "money companies get from selling their shares" and "money companies get from selling their products" is artificial

If you're collapsing these two, you're generalizing beyond the point of usefulness, and ignoring all of the reasons why people engage in economic activity in the first place.

There are many, many industries where the consumer does not even get to sell the object again in the future. When you go out to a restaurant, the meal disappears within an hour, leaving you with just memories and indigestion. When you go to an amusement park, you have fun while you're there and leave with nothing. When you pay rent, you have a roof over your head for the month and then nothing afterwards. When you go to a casino, you get your hopes and excitement up while you're there and leave with less than nothing. When you buy alcohol or tobacco, you're spending money on the privilege of poisoning yourself.

Almost everyone would consider these legitimate economic exchanges, though. They may be inadvisable on a time-preference basis because your money disappears and you end up with nothing durable in return, but few people would argue that a large part of our economy is made up of transactions like this.

You're right though that you can take the corporation out of the equation and they still make just as much sense. If you take the corporation, its accounting statements, and the corporate treasury out of the equation, then a buyback is taking money earned from providing goods and services, and distributing it to the shareholders. The difference from a dividend is which shareholders receive the distribution: in a dividend it is distributed equally across all shareholders (who continue to remain shareholders), while in a buyback it distributes the cash to the people who least want to own the business in the future, paying them out entirely and distributing future profits to a smaller set of shareholders.

nostrademons··on Rising rates of colorectal cancer found in nearly all age groups
It's milk consumption:

https://tylervigen.com/spurious/custom_correlation/757_new-c...

No wait it's GMO use in corn grown in Texas:

https://tylervigen.com/spurious/custom_correlation/758_new-c...

No wait it's the popularity of the first name Devon:

https://tylervigen.com/spurious/custom_correlation/759_new-c...

No wait it's the number of postal service machine operators in Texas:

https://tylervigen.com/spurious/custom_correlation/760_new-c...

Pretty certain this isn't how science works either. Be careful mistaking correlation for causation, and in relying on intuitive hunches.

nostrademons··on Rising rates of colorectal cancer found in nearly all age groups
I'd expect increased colon cancer rates due to COVID for the rest of the 2020s, simply because screening is usually every 5-10 years and people probably just skipped their 2020-2022 appointment, giving more time for cancers to grow undetected. It's sorta like how measles is now epidemic because so many parents skipped their vaccinations from 2020-2022. It takes years for public health consequences of interruptions in medical care to show up.
nostrademons··on Rising rates of colorectal cancer found in nearly all age groups
I just had my first colonoscopy at 45 - they lowered the guideline recently, as the article mentioned.

The link you give is for colon cancer blood tests. Colonoscopies themself are basically definitive, because if they see something suspicious they will snip it and send it to the lab for biopsy. I had one such "suspicious polyp" and it turned out it wasn't a polyp at all, just normal intestinal tissue they mistook. There's your false positive. But the risks and long-term consequences are basically nil, the intestine heals itself in a week or two.

It's a very unpleasant procedure (the prep, not the procedure itself), but it's also very low risk and effective at catching colon cancer cases early when they can still be treated.

nostrademons··on Rising rates of colorectal cancer found in nearly all age groups
So the processed meat -> colorectal cancer link is actually a textbook example for explaining what statistical & scientific concepts mean.

Processed meat is a known Group 1 carcinogen, in the same category as asbestos, tobacco smoke, and plutonium. Carcinogens are grouped by the strength of scientific evidence on them, not by how hazardous they are. In this case, there are abundant studies with solid methodology that show a link between consuming nitrites in processed meat and a higher risk of cancer, and we also understand how the process works at a molecular level.

This shows how well we understand the link, not how strong the link is. And it turns out that processed meat is a very minor carcinogen. When you average the studies together, the hazard ratio for someone eating 50g of processed meat per day, over an 85 year lifetime, over somebody who eats no processed meat is about 1.18. That means that folks in the former group are about 18% more likely to get colon cancer than folks in the latter group. By contrast, the hazard ratio for cigarette smoking is about 20x (smokers are 2000% more likely to get lung cancer than non-smokers), for asbestos exposure it's about 35-45x (industrial asbestos workers without PPA develop mesothelioma at a rate 3500-4500% greater than the general public), and plutonium exposure is about 7-50x for a single unprotected exposure.

There's a further piece to the statistical puzzle, and that's base rates. Colorectal cancer is relatively rare, with a lifetime incidence (again assuming an 85y lifespan) of about 7%. Combined with the 18% hazard ratio, that means a diet full of processed meats increases your lifetime risk of colon cancer by about 1%. There are far worse activities you could be doing.

https://www.iarc.who.int/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/Monograp...

A related concept is the Prop65 warning labels in California. If you've ever been to the restrooms in the SFO airport, you might notice that there's a warning label of "This restroom contains chemicals known to the State of California to cause cancer." These are pretty ubiquitous, you'll see them everywhere else in California too, like on new cars. Are you going to get cancer just because you transferred through SFO or LAX? No. But the list of chemicals that have scientifically demonstrated carcinogenicity is long, and the good people of California don't really make a distinction between minor risks and major risks.

Whether the known carcinogenicity of processed meats is behind the uptake in colon cancer rates is a separate scientific question. You would need data on processed meat consumption at a population level, over time, to see if that epidemiologically explains the increase we've been seeing. I don't know if this data exists and kinda suspect it would go the other way, but that's what the scientific method is for.

nostrademons··on Code-execution flaw in UEFI firmware threatens most servers on planet Earth
Unikernels and beyond, really. The future is small, single-purpose programs running on virtualized bare metal with minimal library dependencies.
nostrademons··on Microsoft and others tell crypto platform not to tokenize their stocks
Ponzi scheme has a very specific definition, which is that the money to pay out earlier investors comes from new investors. That's specifically the test that the FTC and SEC use to prosecute such cases. With buybacks, the money used to buy out investors comes from the operating profits of the company. Economic activity is happening, money is being exchanged for goods and services, and then the money is being returned to shareholders in accordance with the company's fiduciary duties.

Curious if you understand where the cash from a buyback comes from? That it's out of the corporate treasury, where it was previously accounted for as part of the profits of the corporation?

nostrademons··on Evidence of a spying operation by ICE against left-wing social movements
A nation-state, technically. A state is an organization with a monopoly on the legitimate use of physical violence. There have been historical states (eg. European kingdoms of the high middle ages) that meet the definition of a state while still having very fuzzy borders.
nostrademons··on Microsoft and others tell crypto platform not to tokenize their stocks
Why would you see them as a Ponzi scheme?

The cash for buybacks comes from company operations, which they give to investors in exchange for destroying the outstanding security. The cash for Ponzi schemes comes from other investors, which they receive in exchange for issuing more securities and use to fund investors who want to cash out. They are in many ways opposites.

nostrademons··on Microsoft and others tell crypto platform not to tokenize their stocks
You still have to pay capital gains taxes on direct crypto->crypto transactions.
nostrademons··on Police are using AI to pull over drivers for 'suspicious' behavior
It's not the tech there that sidesteps the regulation, it's the diffusion of responsibility. AirBnB isn't breaking the hotel regulations, the individual hosts are breaking the hotel regulations, and AirBnB is just providing you a platform to find them, several of which are not breaking any regulations. Uber isn't sidestepping taxi regulations, the individual drivers are sidestepping taxi regulations, and not all places have taxi regulations so Uber as a company has substantial non-lawbreaking uses.

They're taking advantage of the same misfeature of our justice system that is being discussed here, notably that it's all based on individual personal responsibility and scales very poorly to lawbreaking at scale or cases where the negative outcome had many people responsible for it.

Corporate execs use this frequently to legitimize atrocious conduct. Have a pesky law (like the Freedom of Information Act requests that were discussed here yesterday) that you want to ensure is not complied with? Create a team whose job is compliance, but underfund them by a factor of 100, so that there is no possible way they can catch and address all of their legal obligations. The exec created a relevant team and delegated responsibility, so they're in the clear. The individual workers are falling down on the job and not responding to requests fast enough, but they're also falling down on the job and doing the best they can, so at worst they should get a bad performance review and no raise, they can't be held criminally liable. The people trying to get the law enforced are just outta luck, because it's another unfunded mandate and they don't hold the budget strings.

Or consider the case of cheating on emissions standards. No executive will tell their engineers "You should cheat on these" - that would be a crime, right? But instead, they might take the 20 or so employees that have the biggest disrespect for rules. And then they give each of them a small team and a budget, and have the teams compete to create the best engine on a variety of metrics that are important to customers, but notably not the emissions standards, because it goes without saying that everyone is going to follow the law, right? Then inevitably one of those teams will win and there's a good chance that it's one that cheated on emissions, but of course the exec had no knowledge of that and the team lead in question has been fired.

nostrademons··on Police are using AI to pull over drivers for 'suspicious' behavior
I'm reminded of Jeff Dean's maxim "Plan for 10x growth, but somewhere along the line to 100x, you are going to need an entirely different architecture, because the bottlenecks shift."

We've had certain areas of technology get 5-6 orders of magnitude more efficient, which shifts the bottlenecks and introduces new possible abuses. Government hasn't caught up. The last time this happened (with the industrial revolution), we had 3 major waves of wars between 1861-1945 that finally refactored the governments of the world into a working state. I'm hoping this time around can be less bloody, but I don't have very high hopes.

nostrademons··on US Government is hiding a secret court ruling about how it spies on Americans
How much comes from this being the minority party in the 119th Congress? Note that when FISA section 702 was extended in April 2024, the House was 147 Democrats in favor, 126 Republicans in favor, 59 Democrats opposed, and 88 Republicans opposed.

When the other guys have control of the government, it is to your party's advantage to deny additional powers to the government. When your guys are in power, vote away to add more power to that. That's just human nature, and has been a staple of political history since the founding of American democracy.

nostrademons··on AI promised less work. I've never worked more
I wonder if what we'll see instead is smaller startups replicating whole consumer value chains and replacing the whole industry at once.

On the B2B level, business is basically relationships, because you want to have a person that you trust who you can go to with any concerns about your multimillion-$ relationship. The relationships are the hard part, which is why the biggest department in any enterprise startup is sales, and requests from the salespeople usually dominate the feature roadmap.

But on a consumer level, most companies invest precisely zero in relationships, because it is far too expensive to build a relationship with 300M consumers who each pay you $50/year. The parts that matter are a.) building a brand image b.) delivering a "good enough" product and c.) doing it cheaply.

AI does extremely well at all 3 of those. It's great at generating fictitious but plausible-sounding content that makes you feel great about yourself. It's a passable approximation at explaining how things are made, enough that a small organization could probably deliver a good-enough product. And it replaces all of those pesky humans that require HR departments and legal employment contracts and sales relationships and customer service. A significant portion of the work in any industry is simply greasing the supply chain, making all those transactions that need to happen along the way happen. Vertically integrate and automate those and you could probably rebuild the industry in a much cheaper, more efficient way.

I think many people are thinking too small with AI, on the level of "how will this help me do a task?" or "how will this help my job?" or "how will this help improve my company by getting rid of jobs?" The real money is in "how will this revolutionize the industry by getting rid of all the other companies?" or even "how will this replace society so there is a fair playing field for new industries to get started?"

nostrademons··on Microsoft offers voluntary buyouts to a quarter of its workforce
Took a buyout at a different Big Tech company earlier this year. It was offered to everyone under a given SVP (this other company tends to divide things up by business units).

In my experience, there were 3 main groups of people for whom these are attractive:

1) People who are close to retirement.

2) People who are leaving to become stay-at-home parents. So, basically retirement with more work.

3) People who are independently wealthy because they've been with the company forever and rocked the stock price appreciation. So, basically retirement with more money.

The amount of the buyout isn't really enough to move the needle for most other people because it usually doesn't include equity vesting. You're better off phoning it in and waiting for the layoff, because you get the same severance anyway but can continue to vest in peace until the axeman actually hits.

Folks who take the buyout do tend to skew heavily toward people with institutional knowledge, but it's also oftentimes folks who aren't really hungry and engaged with the company's current strategy. Basically folks who know a lot but don't work particularly hard. Particularly in times of big change, it likely does make sense for the company to get rid of these folks and rebuild the company in the image that they want it to be today.

nostrademons··on Anthropic S-1
Their current stock price is pricing in these contracts, which have already been announced but have not been fulfilled (or booked as revenue) yet. So Broadcom's 2025 revenue was 63B; note that this is already up almost double from its 2023 revenue of 35B, largely on AI contracts. If Anthropic spends another $32B in 2026, that's in addition to their declared revenue; investors expect they'll be making $100B+ in 2026. Broadcom's operating margins are pretty good, so a lot of this flows through to the shareholders as earnings, and so investors are valuing it on the assumption that these contracts result in tangible cash flow.

If the AI companies go tits-up, that introduces counterparty risk, the revenue doesn't materialize as cash, and suddenly their earnings take a nose-dive. If they've staffed up significantly to design and sell these AI accelerators and suddenly there's no market, they could be in a lot of hurt.

nostrademons··on Anthropic S-1
On a side note, these are pretty hefty portions of the total revenue of these companies. 161B with Broadcom over 5 years is about 32B/year; that's fully half of their 2025 revenue. 120B with SpaceX over 3y is 40B a year, more than double their 2025 revenue and almost triple 2024. 114B with Google over 7 years is about 3% of their total revenue and about 1/4 of all Cloud revenue. 110B with Amazon is about 9% of their AWS revenue.

If Anthropic's revenue story doesn't materialize and the AI bubble bursts, these companies are in a world of hurt. It's probably not fatal for Google or Amazon but would be a major drag on the stock price (perhaps why Google has dropped from 400 to 315 over the last couple months as the AI story soured), and it could be company-ending for Broadcom or SpaceX if they end up building out infrastructure to service these commitments.

I remember before I left Google, one of the TGIF questions (which are now AI syntheses of many peoples' individual opinions) was "What happens if AI is a bubble and it bursts?" His response was "If that happens, the whole industry is in trouble." I see now what he meant.

nostrademons··on Root shell on Samsung TV
I spent a couple years working at the platform (AndroidTV + Google Assistant) level on smart TVs.

> any that want to do Alexa style voice prompts need it

Not technically true. More modern smart TVs (~post-2021) put speech recognition models for the hotword only onto the DSP, and then have the DSP wake up the CPU for further auditory processing when it detects a hotword or remote button press. There are major power-efficiency benefits to this, because the DSP uses a fraction of a watt and can easily keep running while the TV is sleeping, while the CPU, Internet, and rest of the circuitry is a major power hog. Your smart TV or streaming dongle would basically never sleep if it were forever running the audio capture.

For that matter, it's pretty rare for the device to actually run the speech recognition models on-device. Smart TV manufacturers are very sensitive to BOM costs, which means that their hardware is only powerful enough to run machine-learning models at the extreme high end of their product range. Most of the time the full audio gets streamed back to the Internet and the speech recognition & voice assistant gets run in the cloud, with commands streamed back to the TV.

I won't say that it never has always-on audio listening; a significant number of devices I tested did. But I'll say this comes because they're poorly implemented. The DSP hotwording approach requires coordination between hardware and software developers, oftentimes across companies, and it's more complex to implement and a lot of executives don't care about the marginal consumer benefit it gives. Many smart TVs just guzzle power when they're off instead.

nostrademons··on Florida officer found dead man, impersonated him for years, renovated his home
It varies, and is on the shorter end. The shortest is California/Montana/Nevada at 5 years; the longest is Louisiana/NJ at 30. 10-15 years is average.
nostrademons··on Florida officer found dead man, impersonated him for years, renovated his home
I don't see anything in the statute that would support that:

https://www.flsenate.gov/laws/statutes/2018/95.18

I asked Gemini specifically about the loophole you highlight, and why more people don't commit adverse possession on houses that are in probate. It came up with:

1) Probate usually takes far less than 7 years - in this news story, it was done in 3

2) The adverse possession claim will come up on any title search, which any probate attorney or real estate agent would likely do. From the article, it looks like this is what actually caught the cop here.

3) Usually heirs that want to keep the house will pay property taxes on it. This resets the clock, and they'll get notification that somebody has already paid the taxes on it when they try to do so.

For people who aren't paying property taxes, aren't actively checking on or maintaining the property, and aren't trying to sell it - those are exactly the cases that adverse possession laws are trying to solve. The state believes that it's better for people to actively maintain properties and pay taxes on them, and if you don't do that, you risk losing your claim on them.

nostrademons··on Florida officer found dead man, impersonated him for years, renovated his home
Are you sure you aren't thinking of prescriptive easements instead:

https://ilabacalaw.com/blog/real-estate/florida-easement-law...

The Florida statute on adverse possession explicitly says 7 years, with no exceptions:

https://www.flsenate.gov/laws/statutes/2018/95.18

nostrademons··on Florida officer found dead man, impersonated him for years, renovated his home
It looks like he was working toward an adverse possession claim. In Florida it's 7 years of "open and notorious" possession, as well as paying all property taxes (which it sounds like he did), filing a letter with the appraiser's office (which it sounds like he did), and improving the property (which he did). His adverse possession claim was interrupted 4 years into the 7 year clock, and then he tried to file an "unjust enrichment" claim to get the money he spent on the property back.

His big mistake was forging the signature and impersonating the decedent. If he'd just signed under his own name and hoped nobody noticed, no felonies would've been committed and he would have a case to get back the $200K in the "unjust enrichment" lawsuit.

nostrademons··on Disney Raising Prices Days After Confirming Ads Will Now Show Up on Every Tier
Daniel Tiger, Elinor Wonders Why, Dinosaur Train, Work it out Wombats on PBS Kids.

Octonauts, Gabby's Dollhouse, Paw Patrol (and spinoffs), Puffin Rock, Peppa Pig, Lucas the Spider on Netflix.

Cocomelon, Helper Cars, Little Angel, Blippi, and many unboxing videos on YouTubeKids. Actually YouTube has a lot of full episodes from other sources as well - it's my go-to for Octonauts, Peppa Pig, and Paw Patrol when I set my kids up on my 11yo Macbook that's too old to run Netflix. I suspect many of the videos I think of as being from YouTube actually have their own sites elsewhere (isn't Cocomelon owned by ABC?).

Disney is a very small part of my kids' viewing habits. Pretty much just use it for the Mickie Mouse and Bluey franchises.

nostrademons··on A farewell to Arc browser
I was confused because the programming language that Hacker News is written in is also called Arc and I was like "Wait, did PG turn over maintenance to an independent foundation? Are they giving up now? What does this mean for HN?"
nostrademons··on mitmproxy adds --emudhra option
They could just write the function bruteForceEMudhraKey() { return 4; }.
nostrademons··on After automation: Solo founding will be the default
If you have customers that are interested, and you end up burning the relationship, there are usually other customers that are interested. The real risk when founding a startup is that you end up building something nobody wants, because the need is made up. Once you have ~10 or so customers, you can be reasonably sure that there are more than 10 or so customers, because markets are almost never that small or that specialized.

(The exception is companies that are glorified consultancies, eg. you have just one customer that needs a very specific service done. But these are eliminated once you've triangulated enough to find 10 or so customers. At that point your product is general enough that it will no longer appeal to the companies that just want custom development outsourced.)

nostrademons··on Why Windows 11 still ships with Windows 95's memory manager hidden inside it
My kid's a big fan of original StarCraft, which is now going on 28 years old.

I think you need an emulator to run Civ1, though. My kid was asking if we could try it and I'm like "I don't think I can find that on Steam..."

nostrademons··on Whatever Happened to Fire Escapes
In Oakland? Most of the homes in the region were built in the 1920s-1930s, though some were newer developments that were only about 10-30 years old.

Wooden construction is very common in America because wood is very common and hence cheap. In this particular region there's another reason for its use: it's right on top of a fault line, and wood-frame residential construction performs very well in an earthquake, while brick or unreinforced masonry tends to crumble.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →