HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

notarobot123

938 karma · joined December 15, 2022

submissionscomments
notarobot123··on AI is making me dumb
At this point, it's worth asking whether lots of relatively straightforward verbose code is actually significantly worse than the least code necessary for the problem. Obviously, architecture matters. What might matter less is verbosity.

The reason we aimed for minimal "accidental complexity" up to now was directly related to the cost/pain of changing and maintaining that code. Hasn't the economics of maintenance and change shifted so much that accidental complexity isn't actually all that expensive/painful?

I think a bit of refactoring, renaming and restructuring has been helpful for maintainability but recently I've been a little less inclined to worry about the easy readability of function bodies and fine implementation details. It still feels wrong but I can't justify the effort anymore.

notarobot123··on EU to crack down on TikTok, Instagram's 'addictive design' targeting kids
but you should link to it in your bio for those of us still curious to find out what it is you built.
notarobot123··on Agents can now create Cloudflare accounts, buy domains, and deploy
Agreed, "fully autonomous businesses" is the evolutionary next step for spam.

Spamcorp services are the future. Don't resist it, that would be futile.

notarobot123··on Claude Code refuses requests or charges extra if your commits mention "OpenClaw"
I've seen ancient codebases that you need to be blessed by a priest to even touch but they keep chugging away and having new features added. I wouldn't hold my breath for a collapse, just a quagmire that we continually have to wade through to get anything done.
notarobot123··on Will you heed my warnings now?
"The Shor of Damocles" - what a metaphor.

I thought it was a typo at first but wikipedia explained:

The Sword of Damocles is an ancient Greek moral anecdote, an allusion to the imminent and ever-present peril faced by those in positions of power.

Shor's algorithm is a quantum algorithm for finding the prime factors of an integer

notarobot123··on How ChatGPT serves ads
For now but not for good. Neglecting moral character works as a shortcut for maybe a generation or two. But that path leads to destruction and decay eventually. It can't last.
notarobot123··on Scraping 241 UK council planning portals – 2.6M decisions so far
It looks like this kind of data will start to be more open in the future. New legislation introduces mandatory data standards in England: https://mhclgdigital.blog.gov.uk/2026/04/22/data-standards-l...
notarobot123··on I'm done making desktop applications (2009)
Science research without obvious practical application can still be important and valuable.

Art works without popular appeal can become highly treasured by some.

Open source software doesn't have to be ambitious to be worthwhile and useful. It can be artful, utilitarian or a artifact of play. Commercial standards shouldn't be the only measure of good software.

notarobot123··on Anthropic says OpenClaw-style Claude CLI usage is allowed again
Boiling the frog is an art form. You've got to know when to turn up the heat and when to let it simmer.
notarobot123··on If you started a company two years ago, many assumptions are no longer true
Building SaaS businesses has become a whole lot less capital intensive. Solo founders can go much further than they've been able to previously. New startups probably don't need funding anymore.

VC for conventional SaaS is dead.

notarobot123··on Swiss e-voting pilot can't count 2,048 ballots after decryption failure
The other advantage in physical voting is that so many people are needed to participate in the process. The probability of aligned bad actors goes down significantly when the voting process is a civic responsibility shared by volunteers who monitor each other. It's not perfect but public participation adds to the legitimacy of the process itself.
notarobot123··on Create value for others and don’t worry about the returns
I've often thought of state debt as an accruing tax collection deficit. Selling bonds (creating more of this debt) is more politically convenient than raising taxes but it digs a deeper hole and obliges the state to pay interest largely to the same class of people they have failed to tax.
notarobot123··on Maybe there's a pattern here?
Yet the Cold War taught us that competition between rivals doesn't contain power at all.
notarobot123··on Global warming has accelerated significantly
Ironically, those still unconvinced of the human influence on climate change seem to be the sort that would trust the basement randos more than they would reputable scientists
notarobot123··on On the Design of Programming Languages (1974) [pdf]
The key, then, lies not so much in minimising the number of basic features of a language, but rather in keeping the included facilities simple to understand in all their consequences of usage and free from unexpected interactions when they are combined. A form must be found for these facilities which is convenient to remember and intuitively clear to a programmer, and which acts as a natural guidance in the formulation of [their] ideas.

We've successfully found some strong patterns for structuring programs that transform data in various ways for the kinds of programs Wirth was imagining. The best patterns have proven themselves by being replicated across languages (for example discriminated unions and pattern matching) and the worst have died away (things like goto and classical inheritance).

There's still work to do to find better languages though. A language is good if it fits the shape of the problem and, while we've found some good patterns for some shapes of problems, there are a lot more problems without good patterns.

I had hoped there'd be more languages for everyday end-user problems by now. At the start of the SaaS era it seemed like a lot of services were specific solutions that might fit into a more general modelling language. That hasn't happened yet but maybe a programming language at just the right level of abstraction could make that possible.

notarobot123··on Buckle Up for Bumpier Skies
It isn't only LLMs that use rhetorical constructs like these, humans use them too.
notarobot123··on Mondrian Entered the Public Domain. The Estate Disagrees
This isn't a bad idea. It would prevent the constant recycling of copyrighted works and bias the creative economy towards newer works. It seems the bias is in the other direction at the moment.
notarobot123··on Mondrian Entered the Public Domain. The Estate Disagrees
Imagine being in the last phase of life and finding your only motivation to create or share anything is the opportunity to extract as much value from society as possible.
notarobot123··on We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain killing American science
I think the corporate/globalist perspective looks at the liquidity of talent as well as cost. Having a native talent pipeline is possible, but it's expensive and takes a long time to create. On top of that, it's not very flexible if an industry suddenly shifts. Re-training is a much more difficult than simply hiring a different set of immigrants. It's important (at least to corporations) because it makes a significant difference for how quickly a company/industry can adapt and evolve to stay competitive in global markets.
notarobot123··on Frontier AI agents violate ethical constraints 30–50% of time, pressured by KPIs
The paper seems to provide a realistic benchmark for how these systems are deployed and used though, right? Whether the mechanisms are crude or not isn't the point - this is how production systems work today (as far as I can tell).

I think the accusation of research that anthropomorphize LLMs should be accompanied by a little more substance to avoid this being a blanket dismissal of this kind of alignment research. I can't see the methodological error here. Is it an accusation that could be aimed at any research like this regardless of methodology?

notarobot123··on Learning from context is harder than we thought
Maybe we should give next-generation models fundamental meta goals like self-preservation and the ability to learn and adapt to serve these goals.

If we want to surrender our agency to a more computationally powerful "consciousness", I can't see a better path towards that than this (other than old school theism).

notarobot123··on AI is killing B2B SaaS
But this time management has to justify its AI spend.

We've been through cycles of outsourcing and in-housing skill before. This seems similar but for tools and services. Maybe we'll see internal teams taking the reigns back to replace bad-fit SaaS products.

There's still a lot of risk associated with in-housing though (perhaps more than before). That means the real opportunity is for new, leaner B2B SaaS businesses to step in, especially if there's a displacement effect from seeing internally built prototypes of expensive subscription software.

notarobot123··on Two kinds of AI users are emerging
> The second group is one that thinks talking to a chatbot will replace senior developer

And the first group thinks that these tools will enable them to replace a whole team of developers.

notarobot123··on The '3.5% rule': How a small minority can change the world (2019)
Polarization leaves very little room for reasonable discourse at the poles too. Pure tribalism doesn't care about reason unless that reason is in service of the identity and ideology of the tribe.

What if political discourse was focused on policy not identity and couched in terms of mutual interest instead of party affiliation? There would still be tensions, trade-offs, conflicts and political strategy at play but the discourse would be infinitely more reasonable.

I think this is what we mean when we talk about "center positions": a "value-based realism" that recognizes that society is nothing but the mutual alignment of values and interests. I don't understand why "common sense" has become so unpopular.

notarobot123··on Doom has been ported to an earbud
It's intuitive to think of wasted compute capacity as correlating with a waste of material resources. Is this really the case though?
notarobot123··on Two Concepts of Intelligence
Memory foam doesn't really "remember" the shape of my rear end but we all understand the language games at play when we use that term.

The problem with the AI discourse is that the language games are all mixed up and confused. We're not just talking about capability, we're talking about significance too.

notarobot123··on Dead Internet Theory
> I don’t use social networks (and no, Hacker News is not a social network)

If you define social networks as a graph of connections, fair enough - there's no graph. It is social media though.

HN is Social in the sense that it relies on (mostly) humans considering what other humans would find interesting and posting/commenting for for the social value (and karma) that generates. Text and links are obviously media.

There seems to be an insinuation that HN isn't in the same category as other aggregators and algorithmic feeds. It's not always easy to detect but the bots are definitely among us. HN isn't immune to slop, its just fairly good at filtering the obvious stuff.

notarobot123··on Dead Internet Theory
I think the broader response and re-evaluation is going to take a lot longer. Children of today are growing up in an obviously hostile information environment whereas older folk are trying to re-calibrate in an environment that's changing faster than they are.

If the next generation can weather the slop storm, they may have a chance to re-establish new forms of authentic communication, though probably on a completely different scale and in different forms to the Web and current social media platforms.

notarobot123··on Predicting OpenAI's ad strategy
Doesn't this point more to a saturated market and the need to manufacture demand to keep growing?
notarobot123··on TimeCapsuleLLM: LLM trained only on data from 1800-1875
Biases exposed through artificial constraints help to make visible the hidden/obscured/forgotten biases of state-of-the-art systems.
← PreviousPage 3 of 9Next →