HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

notarobot123

938 karma · joined December 15, 2022

submissionscomments
notarobot123··on Poison Fountain
That's a good cover for a mental breakdown on social media. "It wasn't a psychotic episode. I was poisoning the machine!"
notarobot123··on Ushikuvirus: Newly discovered virus may offer clues to the origin of eukaryotes
I never understood where the desire to "colonise the galaxy" comes from. Why is this a desirable goal? Compared to anywhere else we know about, Earth is an extremely unique utopia. A "better" planet would be measured in how Earth-like it is - perhaps bigger or with more/different exploitable resources.

The only driver that I can really comprehend is the desire for freedom and autonomy in less populated spaces. The problem with this is that the human condition follows us everywhere. We'll recreate the same problems we have here everywhere we go. We can't run away from ourselves.

notarobot123··on The Post-American Internet
You don't like the song so you changed the words but you're still singing along to the same tune.
notarobot123··on Welcome to Gas Town
I think we have crossed the chasm and the pragmatists have adopted these tools because they are actually useful now. They've thrown out a lot of their previously held principles and norms to do so and I doubt the more conservative crowd will be so quick to compromise.

2 years sounds more likely than 2 months since the established norms and practices need to mature a lot more than this to be worthy of the serious consideration of the considerably serious.

notarobot123··on Reward
I don't get it. Why boast about selfishness?
notarobot123··on Ask HN: How are you sandboxing coding agents?
I do similar but it's incredible how our threat model has changed so much to allow this. I have to trust this one node package (and all its dependencies) and Anthropic more than I trust my email provider, my ISP or my browser.

Who'd have imagined remote code execution as a service would have caught on as much as it has!

notarobot123··on Publishing your work increases your luck
Open source culture has changed so much over the past couple of decades that it seems totally reasonable now for up-and-coming maintainers to question the whole thing.

Scale has changed everything. There are orders of magnitudes more users than contributors compared to some of the early OSS and the balance between grateful and entitled end-users has skewed expectations much more towards maintainers as a support role with similar responsibilities to a product engineer in the commercial world. Why would you want to enter into that social contract now? Why would you want to risk your library taking off and the associated costs that would bring (as well as benefits)?

An alternative evolutionary pathway for OSS is for developers and communities to self-host their own git projects. Projects get to define their own ethos and workflow. Discovery remains high-friction which prevents the commodification of maintainer effort. The bar for writing custom tools to support things like this got a whole lot lower so it might start to make sense more than it did in the past (there are both push and pull forces at work here). It might even make OSS fun again.

notarobot123··on Mattermost restricted access to old messages after 10000 limit is reached
Governmental organizations and corporate firms is the vibe (or maybe that was obvious and you're just trolling).

I think the point was that open source hasn't often been supported by companies serving these kinds of markets and the interests of the broader community are often sidelined.

notarobot123··on Beginning January 2026, all ACM publications will be made open access
Does this kind of general shift more firmly establish a marketplace and business model for eminent "peers" to more easily create independent journals? Universities increasingly price in this pay to publish model so groups of editors could very easily corner their respective niches with independent publications if they cooperate with one another. The market is ripe for fragmentation.

Maybe this is wishful thinking but a proliferation of openly accessible and competing independent publications could correct for a lot of the ills of the Goodhart effect in academic publishing. Market shifts that make this evolutionary pathway feasible and realistic are exiting.

notarobot123··on History LLMs: Models trained exclusively on pre-1913 texts
To the proud contrarian, "the empire did nothing wrong". Maybe Sci-fi has actually played a role in the "memetic desire" of some of the titans of tech who are trying to bring about these worlds more-or-less intentionally. I guess it's not as much of a dystopia if you're on top and its not evil if you think of it as inevitable anyway.
notarobot123··on Beginning January 2026, all ACM publications will be made open access
Yet "peer review" would absolutely scale if it were actually the review of peers (and not just an editorial board). A large number of publications where submissions are reviewed by previous and prospective authors would be much like how open source peer review works, though not without its own set of issues.

Discovery is a search problem and its pretty clear that we have the technical capacity to solve that problem if there is enough of a signal from wide-spread peer review.

Major journals become those that re-publish and report on the big debates and discoveries of the actually peer-reviewed journals and this would be the work of "journalists".

notarobot123··on Adafruit: Arduino’s Rules Are ‘Incompatible With Open Source’
One of the big difference between technology and law is how significant edge-cases are considered to be.
notarobot123··on Benevolent Dictator for Now
There seems to be a tipping point when a language ecosystem's work is mainly about design to it being mainly about broader governance issues. Good design needs a grand vision. Good governance needs broad participation.

I wonder if @rtfeldman has some thoughts on what milestones might mark the need for a transition. I also wonder if the experience of the Elm community has taught him any lessons here.

notarobot123··on America is going through a big economic experiment
Political freedom is usually prized by "brainy immigrants" - especially those who were likely to travel to the USA.

The problem isn't just the $100,000 fee (not insignificant) but the risks associated with being an immigrant with restricted political freedom in an increasingly authoritarian nation[1].

[1] - https://www.reuters.com/world/us/trump-administration-orders...

notarobot123··on Big Tech are the new Soviets
I'm not advocating for him specifically, but it doesn't seem reasonable that one would need a lived experience of poverty and deprivation to be able to meaningfully understand its causes and effects or to have some inclination to prevent it. Compassion is not a vice nor is making a career of advocating for change.
notarobot123··on Big Tech are the new Soviets
How dare he use his privilege for any ends other than selfishly defending the rights of the privileged!
notarobot123··on Autism should not be treated as a single condition
If I persistently ask awkward questions, that might "inhibit social interactions". If my community was tolerant and even accepting of this behavior it might not inhibit social interactions quite as much. They are different things for some behaviors but extremely closely related for others.
notarobot123··on I ignore the spotlight as a staff engineer
It's pretty demoralizing to realize that appearances matter more than merit in careers/politics/dating/business/etc. The pragmatic approach is to not give up on merit but not neglect appearances either.

Still, the idealist in me hates this. It feels like quality should win out over advertising yet it rarely does in the grand scheme of things.

notarobot123··on Language is primarily a tool for communication rather than thought (2024) [pdf]
But language is also the only way to communicate this. As far as I can tell my cat has a complex consciousnesses but there is no way for me to tell if she has this capacity for introspection and self-reflexivity.

If there are other avenues other than language, how would we know?

I think language is a medium that enables this kind of structured thought. Without it, I cannot imagine reaching this level of abstraction (understanding being a "self").

notarobot123··on Heretic: Automatic censorship removal for language models
Doesn't it make sense that there are some technical questions that are dangerous to supply an answer to? Treating some topics as taboo is possible.

Responsible information dissemination is important for maintaining public safety. You could argue about what is safe and what is not but it doesn't make sense to throw out the whole concept of safety because those decisions are too hard to agree on.

notarobot123··on Ask HN: Is building for the web even worth it now?
There are a growing number of disillusioned makers that have the capacity to build alternatives - maybe that critical mass will lead to a reactive innovation cycle where an authentic and grassroots internet will reassert itself.
notarobot123··on GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT
Lulled into a false sense of security, you'll think you can spot the artificial by the tells that it readily feeds to you. But what happens when deception is the goal?
notarobot123··on GPT-5.1: A smarter, more conversational ChatGPT
Emotional dependence has to be the stickiest feature of any tech product. They know what they are doing.
notarobot123··on Vibe Code Warning – A personal casestudy
I think it's fair to say that CRUD apps are in a different category to low level systems programming. The former are never particularly difficult to reason about unless they are written poorly, the latter are rarely easy to understand off the bat unless they are extremely written well.
notarobot123··on Unexpected things that are people
Inheriting and extending existing abstractions out of convenience has a lot of unintended consequences and makes for a messy and complicated system in the long-run. Yet a full rewrite at this stage is out of the question.

I guess the legal system discovered the "worse is better" philosophy before we did.

notarobot123··on Situated Software – Clay Shirky (2004)
> Situated software isn't a technological strategy so much as an attitude about closeness of fit between software and its group of users, and a refusal to embrace scale, generality or completeness as unqualified virtues.

I read a paper about social media being the way it is because of it's scale above other factors[0]. There's something to be said for small, purpose built software networks that never intend on eating the world.

I wonder if the barriers to entry for building stuff like this is going down. Maybe there's still hope for a network of networks that looks more like this.

[0] - https://arxiv.org/pdf/2508.03385

notarobot123··on Journalists turn in access badges, exit Pentagon rather than agreeing new rules
What is the point of being a Developer (except for easy money and not having to do anything other than copy + paste) if you are only allowed to "code", word for word, the feature specifications ("user stories") they give you to build?
notarobot123··on Don't Be a Sucker (1943) [video]
I was expecting this comment to go in a more sinister direction but we're not quite there yet.
notarobot123··on Free software hasn't won
Inversely, the only end-users FOSS cares about are those that can compile and build from source themselves. More so if they can also submit good bug reports and patches.

The demographics of the majority of end-users shifted a long time ago but FOSS is stuck with a mindset that treats everyone like their own sovereign sysadmin.

It'll take a big shift in the Free Software movement to make it something that represents regular end-user enough for regular end-users to care about the Free Software movement.

notarobot123··on Fastmail desktop app
This has been the standard way to distribute software across platforms for a while now. I'm not sure I understand this kind of objection anymore. What's the alternative?

Fastmail also have a decent API if you're keen to glue together a better client yourself.

← PreviousPage 4 of 9Next →