HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

notfashion

83 karma · joined July 23, 2019

submissionscomments
notfashion··on Linguistics Using Category Theory (2018)
Here's the quote:

"Once category theory was developed and used, in particular when the central theoretical role played by adjoint functors was understood, a fascinating process of reversal of perspective, a gestalt switch, took place: what was seem as a useful tool in organizing and guiding mathematical thought became a theoretical framework that revealed the basic or fundamental principles underlying mathematical concepts, theories and theorems. Thus, the Stone duality theorem is indeed more perspicuously presented in the context of categories and functors—it is organized nearly and the basic consequences of the result are transparent—but once it is seen as a special case of a very general adjoint situation, a theoretical understanding of the phenomenon becomes available. Category theory is not applied to Stone's theorem, it is the latter that becomes a specific instance of a general, universal conceptual situation.

Although it might in the end be more obscure than what I have said so far, I dare at this stage put forward a slogan that, I believe, sums up the core of what I have been presenting: category theory is the architectonic of mathematics. Category theory is, indeed, as in the philosophical sense of the expression "architectonic", the systematization of mathematical knowledge. Mathematical knowledge is systematic. Mathematics is a conceptual system. That much is indubitable."

Note that it's -tectonic (from the Greek for carpenter) not -ectronic (from electron). And it's just "the architectonic of mathematics", not concepts in general. There are obviously architectonics of other things as well, like (spatial) architecture itself, or music, or cooking. So while perhaps CT is the ultimate theory of algebraic abstractions, but it's not the only kind of design system that exists. It represents the mathematical aspect of design.

notfashion··on Is involuntary treatment for mental illness allowed under CRPD?
Here we go again with the FUD: "mentally ill people often behave in ... dangerous ways". This kind of claim is harmful to the mentally ill as a group, because it is just not true. The vast majority of mentally ill people are not dangerous.

You seem to be arguing also that it is only the mentally ill who often behave in "unexpected, illogical and dangerous ways". The reality is that humans in general sometimes do that, whether or not they have a clinical mental health problem. The way your comment insinuates that the mentally ill are sub-human is repellent, but I suppose you might not even realize that you are doing that.

You may think of yourself as a model of logical, predictable and safe behaviour. I'm so tired of engineers who deny that there is any irrational element in their makeup. It is a naive thing to claim and a lame kind of deluded bid for superiority. "Others might be irrational, but not me!" Spare us. That attitude is the curse of HN and YC.

notfashion··on Is involuntary treatment for mental illness allowed under CRPD?
You could have read the document before spewing toxic FUD about the kind of things mentally ill people supposedly do.

Here's the section that addresses your concern: "All persons, including those with disabilities, have a duty to do no harm. Legal systems based on the rule of law have criminal and other laws in place to deal with the breach of this obligation. Persons with disabilities are frequently denied equal protection under these laws by being diverted to a separate track of law, including through mental health laws. These laws and procedures commonly have a lower standard when it comes to human rights protection, particularly the right to due process and fair trial, and are incompatible with article 13 in conjunction with article 14 of the Convention."

notfashion··on On Mathematical Beauty in Physics
Everybody who writes about Semir Zeki (PI on that paper) and his work is polite about him. I can only assume that this is because he is a) a likeable guy and b) the professional aestheticians and artists who could make negative comments think it wiser not to get involved in any way lest they be accused of punching down.

Euler's identity is pretty obviously something elegant, and it's widely recognized. But Zeki seems to overlook the importance of acculturation in the appreciation of these things. The idea that a mind-blowing Ramanujan formula is ugly seems particularly problematic. Sure, it is surprising, complex, and apparently arbitrary, and most test subjects won't have any insight into how it works. But why should those people (let's say they are "ignorant" when it comes to Ramanujan's results) be expected to have any opinion on the formula? Any judgement they come up with will be superficial.

This problem runs through most of Zeki's work. His experiments take test subjects who are, as it were, preloaded with certain aesthetic experiences and norms, and attempt to derive universal cognitive principles of beauty from the result. What he doesn't do is try to discover just what those aesthetic prejudices are. He doesn't try to extract from the test subjects the key features of their aesthetic indoctrination. In the math situation, it's totally conceivable that a group of test subjects who were educated to find every Ramanujan formula transcendently fascinating would rate those formulas as beautiful.

The problem is more conspicuous when his research looks at art. Since he hasn't studied art himself, he really doesn't seem to appreciate the basic reality: that some people have learned to 'get' certain styles or genres of art, while others haven't had the good fortune to learn to appreciate those same styles. People walk around with extremely complex acquired aesthetic processing capabilities in their heads. Everyone's is different, and while Zeki may be able to find some universal regularities, (like Chomsky's hypothesized universal innate grammar) that wouldn't be a neural explanation of aesthetics any more than the success of Chomsky's programme would tell us about the nature of literature.

It's a frivolous exercise from the point of view of anyone seriously interested in art (or math).

notfashion··on Does “www.” Mean Better Transport Layer Security?
Whether it feels weird or not, the hostname label is "www".

The hostname-as-tld example is sort of against the rules:

https://serverfault.com/questions/907226/is-it-possible-to-c...

Either way, "." by itself can only meaningfully refer to the root, not some arbitrary enclosing domain name. There is no way you will convince me that using "." as a shorthand for "parent domain" is a good idea, for that and all the other reasons.

notfashion··on Does “www.” Mean Better Transport Layer Security?
The way you are using "www." and "." is incorrect. The dot isn't part of the local hostname "www". It is a separator or delimiter for the textual elements in the domain name. "Redirecting from (or to) ." is a weird and as far as I know completely wrong way to talk about redirecting from or to the domain name one level up in the hierarchy. The only time a dot plays any role in a domain name (other than that of a simple separator) is when it's used at the end of the fully qualified domain name.
notfashion··on Dependent Haskell Is the Future (2018)
Yes, but the "least amount of work", as far as Idris is concerned, has no necessary relationship to what the programmer intended when they defined the type. It guesses the simplest thing that fits, but that's far from a guarantee of correctness.

It is a serious shortcoming that even when you pay the complexity cost of dependent types, you still can't specify the intent in this case. I mean, the semantics of "zip" can't be specified with a type. You can define a "sorted list" or "ordered list" type, but you cannot enforce maintainance of the natural, arbitrary order of list elements. In this sense dependent types are both too complex to reason about and simultaneously not powerful enough to fully specify the function.

notfashion··on Dependent Haskell Is the Future (2018)
> This type specifies that both Vects must be length n. If they are not equal in length, the code will not compile. In fact, this type is so narrowly specified that Idris can infer the entire implementation of the function from it.

It's more accurate to say that Idris can guess an implementation of the function, but it's not the only possible implementation with that type. There's nothing in the type to stop the function from reversing one or both of the lists before the zipping stage, for example. More generally, it could randomize the order of elements in one or both of the supplied lists.

notfashion··on Greek Artist Takis, Who Used Magnets to Create Pioneering Kinetic Art, Has Died
Why wouldn't it be? The performance was called "The Artist is Present". It was all about actually having an encounter between the artist and members of the public. Abramovic does a lot of performances that are physically demanding; this one was emotionally demanding as well. I suppose the line "I got a cry" is meant in a wry sense, but it's not a misrepresentation of what the performance was about.
notfashion··on The Birth of the Semicolon
> Ideally, everything one says should be sincere, so your idea sounds weird to me.

This is an extremely characteristic HN/engineer comment.

People use irony in communication. It's part of the human repertoire. Saying "oh great" in response to bad news, for example. The notion that ideally there would be no irony in textual communication isn't a practical or desirable possibility. It's in the same Zuckerbergian category as beliefs in the transparency of communication or the sacred integrity of having a single online identity.

The thing that really kills the "sincerity mark" is that there's no reason why it can't be abused and lose its meaning, as has happened with the word "literally".

notfashion··on Always the Model, Never the Artist
I've spent quite a lot of time in graduate art training and I'd go further: this isn't about a high level of technical skill or performance, it's about personality. A composer is not a pianist writ large; a software engineer might be a coder working at a high level of abstraction. But an artist is someone who works with their whole personality, engaging with the craft of painting (in this case). To have a "whole personality" that is compelling is very rare, and it's not something that happens by stacking up skills. It might manifest through an appearance of highly analytic vision or graphic composition but it is not quantifiable in those terms. It has to do with wit.

I'm going to cheekily (not in a sexist way) link this to something said by the fashion photographer who discovered Melania Trump, because I think it is exactly the same ineffable quality that is under discussion:

'Jerko thought at first that Melania had a very good future in modeling but after two sessions, he lost enthusiasm. “Her exterior was very good to be an excellent model, but she lacked energy, a certain charm that if you have, you transmit it through your eyes, through your personality. If you have something that, shall we say, comes from the heart, it shows in the photo,” the photographer said.'

notfashion··on What Is Gaussian Curvature?
It's Cliff Stoll, not just some wacky guy. He is extremely famous among people who were interested in computer security in the 90s. I know that's not the sense of "hacker" that "hacker news" refers to, but still.
notfashion··on How to assess the quality of garments (2014)
Valuing workers is separate from valuing quality. I don't think the article I linked to implies in any way that the exploited workers are doing inferior work.
notfashion··on How to assess the quality of garments (2014)
Even very expensive designer clothing may still be made in exploitative conditions. See https://qz.com/1397139/italian-workers-are-earning-near-swea...
← PreviousPage 2 of 2