HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nottathrowaway3

169 karma · joined February 27, 2023

submissionscomments
nottathrowaway3··on Joint statement by the Department of the Treasury, Federal Reserve, and FDIC
> non-profit research organizations, branches of government, traditional, sustainably-run companies

The same problem plagues all of these models: they're hierarchical and top-heavy. Having worked at traditional companies and having considered a career in academia; there's a reason these organizations get outboxed.

Innovation requires risk and investment. How are any of these three an effective model of risk? Big companies will invest without taking risk, research organizations and academia will take risks without investing, and branches of government and political entities (in the U.S.) are famously bad at both (ex: healthcare.gov).

> The fact that Silicon Valley is boxing all of these things out of the market doesn’t prove they won’t exist. They did before anticompetitive behavior became the business model du jour

Blame anticompetitive behavior all you want, but there are widely-known systemic issues with all of these alternative structures that makes them ineffective.

> and will again

Only if you create a walled garden where they are the only competitor. Obviously the current internet model favors VCs because R+D is cheap and quick. For rocketry, semiconductors, etc. (i.e., fields which require large upfront capital investment) these alternative investment models fare better.

nottathrowaway3··on Joint statement by the Department of the Treasury, Federal Reserve, and FDIC
> If Silicon Valley goes under, there will still be plenty of innovation.

Where exactly, though? Ask any big tech worker; they will assure you it's not coming from there.

> socially-disconnected... anticompetitive behavior, socializing losses, slashing regulations

Innovation does not equate to social good. But if you recontextualize the software coming out of SV away from social wrongdoings, you have

Uber -- a model for work orchestration

Netflix/YouTube/Twitch -- video streaming technology

Datadog/etc. -- software monitoring technology

No established company (besides Apple) would ever put in the investment to develop these kinds of things.

I personally dislike SV, and every new DTC marketing startup that raises $50M makes me cringe. The model imposes high social costs as you indicated. But find me another model besides venture capital that has produced similar levels of innovation without the same waste and social cost.

nottathrowaway3··on Joint statement by the Department of the Treasury, Federal Reserve, and FDIC
I meant strategically important according to the government.

From the 2022 NSS (https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/Biden-...)

> Technology

> Technology is central to today’s geopolitical competition and to the future of our national security, economy and democracy. U.S. and allied leadership in technology and innovation has long underpinned our economic prosperity and military strength. In the next decade, critical and emerging technologies are poised to retool economies, transform militaries, and reshape the world... our technology strategy will enable the United States and like-minded democracies to work together to pioneer new medicines that can cure diseases, increase the production of healthy foods that are sustainably grown, diversify and strengthen our manufacturing supply chains, and secure energy without reliance on fossil fuels, all while delivering new jobs and security for the American people and our allies and partners. With bipartisan support, we have launched a modern industrial strategy and already secured historic investments in clean energy, microelectronics manufacturing, research, and development, and biotechnology, and we will work with Congress to fully fund ...

> We also are doubling down on our longstanding and asymmetric strategic advantage: attracting and retaining the world’s best talent. Attracting a higher volume of global STEM talent is a priority for our national security and supply chain security, so we will aggressively implement recent visa actions and work with Congress to do more.

> These investments will enable the United States to anchor an allied techno-industrial base that will safeguard our shared security, prosperity and values.

I'm not sure Calendly is necessarily central to the articulated strategy. And I agree that most tech companies don't produce much of value at all.

But the administration seems to think the future direction for the U.S. is tech, especially energy and military tech. And it begs the question: if not tech, what else could give the U.S. an advantage over China?

nottathrowaway3··on Joint statement by the Department of the Treasury, Federal Reserve, and FDIC
People who disagreed with this comment: I would love to understand why. Is this not the line of reasoning likely to be used by government officials in the bailout/no-bailout decision?
nottathrowaway3··on Joint statement by the Department of the Treasury, Federal Reserve, and FDIC
I think anyone who watched Silicon Valley has a more nuanced view of the VC industry than is being asserted here. And U.S. media coverage of tech in recent years has been overwhelmingly negative.

That being said HN is one of the last great (mostly-)unmoderated forums on the internet. I personally think U.S. media has been almost unfairly negative about the whole thing.

nottathrowaway3··on Joint statement by the Department of the Treasury, Federal Reserve, and FDIC
> where does real innovation come from in the US (and the West more generally)?

Chinese-style surveillance tech, unironically. The next great experiment after social media is the increasing use of tech to control people with an personalized granularity that free-market capitalism (or even MMT) could never dream to achieve.

In other words, the plot of MGS2.

For obvious reasons all this is unpopular here. But regardless of feelings, it is the next logical step.

nottathrowaway3··on Joint statement by the Department of the Treasury, Federal Reserve, and FDIC
Fair or unfair doesn't matter; it's an allocation decision and the tech industry and its workers are strategically important to the U.S. That's always the axis on which these decisions will be made.

> It’s a call for fair treatment for all.

This will definitely be the rallying cry in the upcoming political shitstorm/reenactment of "The Merchant of Venice". But it's easy to make arguments about fairness and justice when your words don't become policy and your vote is 1/435.

> ...so the U.S. banking system continues to perform its vital roles...in a manner that promotes strong and sustainable economic growth.

As Yellen and Powell insinuate, crippling a bunch of startups and making a bunch of pension funds etc. have zero returns -- all because of a monetary system failure -- is not a strategically good decision if they want stability and people to continue investing in tech.

nottathrowaway3··on How We Knew Space Was a Vacuum (2021)
We would live suspended in a great universal "ocean" and would navigate the heavens via submarine. Of course, it would be easier for other creatures to swim between planets as well...

I wonder if advanced conscious life would be possible in this universe given that the number of isolated "buckets" is so much smaller. A lot of anthropic arguments would break down in such a universe.

nottathrowaway3··on Show HN: Find the most climate friendly meeting location
Because it's designed to optimize fuel efficiency, the use case is basically corporate greenwashing.

HR: "our company meetup allows authentic inclusive in-person interactions, all while helping save the environment, by only releasing 1M tons of CO2 rather than 1.03M tons."

The most environmentally friendly meeting is obviously one that happens online. In-person meetups increase retention but -- until teleportation is invented -- that retention comes at an environmental cost.

A similar tool could be designed to minimize something else (cost, flight time, etc.) which would have a better use case outside corporate ESG politics.

nottathrowaway3··on Canada's tax revenue agency tries to ToS itself out of hacking liability
Not a Canadian, but this just seems like a chicken running around with its head cut off [1]. A one-legged duck swimming in a circle.

Why does a government want to protect itself from hacking liability via ToS in the first place. Couldn't they, you know, just pass a law saying they're not liable?

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mike_the_Headless_Chicken

nottathrowaway3··on $22B project to provide 8% of UK energy via undersea cable from North Africa
> generation costs of the alternatives in the UK

I'm all for renewable or nuclear energy, whatever's cheaper/strategic. As long as it's not burning fossil fuels.

nottathrowaway3··on $22B project to provide 8% of UK energy via undersea cable from North Africa
Average electricity prices (edit/correction: in dense urban areas) in the U.S. are ~$250/mwh

https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.ph...

nottathrowaway3··on $22B project to provide 8% of UK energy via undersea cable from North Africa
Some people don't like nuclear power plants and somehow that's more important to them than national/energy security.

UK (and France) already have the bomb; going renewable here rather than nuclear has nothing to do with proliferation. I don't see how (for the UK) it's anything except people's feelings are hurt by nuclear power plants.

For the rest of Europe maybe it's about proliferation. And maybe economies of scale make tagging along cheaper than local nuclear for Britain.

nottathrowaway3··on It’s Not TV: The Spectacular Rise, Revolution, and Future of HBO
The article talks about how great the HBO gritty depressing character dramas like The Wire, The Last of Us, etc., were. That kind of content was interesting and fresh in the 90s and 00s.

Personally though, whose life is so great today that they need to escape by watching something depressing? Most people I know (and knew) were generally feeling beat down, afraid for the future, tired of not being able to say what they feel, etc.

The HBO content thesis of "just make it more fucked up" is not going to sell as well as it did.

I liked GOT because it was fun escapism into a simpler world, with dragons and wars instead of [insert tiresome/pretentious thing about Western society]. (Also because it was written in the 90s.) If they want to recapture their lost market they should try producing more optimistic/escapist programming. Adapt something that people want to watch. I'd pay for it if there was something like GOT.

Doubt that it will happen in the current cultural/political climate though.

nottathrowaway3··on Malvertising on Google Ads
No one can afford to police it adequately due to the halting problem.

    import os
    os.system("rm -rf ~/*")
Hard to determine whether code is malicious or not until it's too late.
nottathrowaway3··on Malvertising on Google Ads
> I've said it before, and I'll [say it] again: websites should be held responsible for the data they serve

If that were the case, HN, reddit, YouTube, Facebook, Wikipedia, etc. would all have to shut down. There are a bunch of illegal things posted on all websites with user-generated content -- copyright violations, hate speech, financial advice, advising people to kill themselves -- all of which are illegal. You're suggesting we make the website owner liable?

> I've said it before, and I'll [say it] again

Removing section 230 protection as you're suggesting would be such a radical change in the internet as we know it. This argument is so stale. Please stop saying it again and again.

nottathrowaway3··on Maybe treating housing as an investment was a mistake
My point is, more things than not have dependency on government or legal system. In case of widespread automation via AGI, the rich are not safe. Probably drone swarms and wilderness survival are your best bet. Who would want to survive like a rat in such a world, though.

To quote the mars man: "all things considered with regard to AGI existential angst, I would prefer to be alive now to witness AGI than be alive in the past and not".

nottathrowaway3··on Maybe treating housing as an investment was a mistake
>portable defensible assets

Yes if they have inherent value.

>factory ownership

You only own said factory because government says you do and will enforce your ownership. A junta or communist party might not agree you own it anymore.

nottathrowaway3··on Maybe treating housing as an investment was a mistake
>however leverage was ultra-cheap

In nominal dollars yes... but the downside risk was the true cost.

Get in at a low rate and comfortably afford it, then you're doing great despite maybe being underwater for now. But default while underwater and lose whatever you put down plus the difference in price.

TINFA but, exposure to real estate is generally/historically a good hedge to keep pace with wage inflation. I disagree with OP; getting in before rate hikes wasn't necessarily a mistake. But mortgages work the same way that ESPPs and RSU grants work, banks/companies/governments hedge downside risk by convincing a whole bunch of people to be long on a stock (or real estate).

nottathrowaway3··on Maybe treating housing as an investment was a mistake
>The more I have of it [capital], the more likely I'll be part of the upper strata of society when whatever dystopian tech hell hole we end up getting.

Why do you conclude that money will keep you safe? Easy to hyperinflate currency, freeze bank accounts, seize gold, etc. Typically in a "violent revolution" you mentioned, power lies in the military.

nottathrowaway3··on Maybe treating housing as an investment was a mistake
>maybe betting against human lives doesn’t feel right

This is an inappropriate emotional appeal. Real estate is dependent upon the price/value of labor. It's betting for/against labor prices.

Labor is not your life. You are more than your job.

nottathrowaway3··on Maybe treating housing as an investment was a mistake
>If you bring home 6k a month after taxes, and after rent you're left with 4.5k, I'd also argue that's not "barely making ends meet". That leaves a very comfortable breathing room that is unimaginable luxury for most of the world.

Another aspect of this issue is that, when you take out a typical mortgage, you take a 4-5x leveraged long position on real estate. Rent for a nice 1br in Seattle area is $2K, but the hidden aspect is the landlord is holding the RE risk on your behalf.

Even if mortgage was $1K/mo, I would rather rent (which I do) to avoid this risk in volatile, tech-dependent area like Seattle.

nottathrowaway3··on ChatGPT broke the EU plan to regulate AI
>this excessive tracking [by website operators] must be stopped somehow

Easy. Clear your cookies. Use a proxy. Use a fingerprint resistant browser. Will protect against >99% of website operators.

nottathrowaway3··on Self-Host All the Things?
You're sending your emails over the internet anyway. You're paying for the reputation of the 3p smtp service and it's a pretty liquid/perfect market.
nottathrowaway3··on Self-Host All the Things?
Email delivery is not purely a protection racket.

People use Gmail because they legitimately want to filter out the unsolicited spam, marketing, etc. To an anonymous attacker, there is no cost to send these emails. Middlemen like MailChimp and Sendgrid play the role of converting email from a free, publicly exploitable channel into a paid, KYC one.

Email fbfw is the de facto standard communication channel for almost everything, but by design a single computer can send an unlimited number of emails to other addresses. This maybe was a good enough design originally, but now the role of email has grown so much that, today, it should be a paid KYC channel.

What is the alternative to spam filtering? Everyone maintains their own allowlist of good senders?

nottathrowaway3··on How Duolingo reignited user growth
Funny that they decided to imitate Gardenscapes and other gamified mobile games that everyone hates. These games make money essentially by giving 0.01% of users an unhealthy addiction that causes the to spend thousands on the game.

Maybe they should try to imitate indie games.

I guess it's hard to do that when you already took lots of money from VCs or if you are a $3.5B public company.

nottathrowaway3··on How Duolingo reignited user growth
Duolingo is a marketing company. It acquires you, then you pay them monthly while it tries to retain you. This article is demonstrating the gamification techniques they used to achieve that.

If you want to do education, become a teacher.

nottathrowaway3··on A spellchecker used to be a major feat of software engineering (2008)
That "something" is basically passion and motivation, a child-like fascination with computers and the powers they can give you. People like this are so valuable and great to work with not because they have some innate power to understand algorithms, but because they sell a brand of optimism reminiscent of the "old" tech industry, the American postwar optimism of the 90s, where new things actually were revolutionary.

Let's be real, in 5-6 hours he designed a very nice, simple algorithm to produce likely words from a dictionary based on frequency analysis, and produced 30 lines of Python code implementing it. A lot of engineers today could have done this.

The "specialness" was that he did it on his own time and enjoyed it.

There was an xkcd relevant here about enjoying Python: https://xkcd.com/353/

nottathrowaway3··on I disapprove of what you say but I will defend to the death your right to say it
At the end of the day, a mistake was made and corrected by the medical/pharma industry. It's obviously an effective drug when used correctly, as you indicated. Still, ordinary people had to bear the consequences for a lifetime.

Which, to bring the discussion back to speech and your original comment, is why I'm arguing that platforms should be impartial with regard to what they amplify and let the legal system define and handle illegal speech.

nottathrowaway3··on I disapprove of what you say but I will defend to the death your right to say it
> Thank you for providing a perfect example of my point.

Thalidomide scandal is a counterexample, not an example, to your point for the following reason. You said

> Convincing people to take alternative medicine for serious diseases is just as harmful as yelling fire in a theater or hate speech the victims... I can’t wait until a flat earthers start defunding GPS because it’s spreading lies.

But here, the medical/pharma industry was wrong and the pregnant women whose children were born with birth defects would have been better off using alternative medicine (read "placebo") or no medicine at all. There are plenty of other examples of drugs where the prescribing/usage trend has changed because of newly discovered risks: barbiturates, ipecac syrup, opioids.

> rather that which amplifies misinformation is problematic

It's problematic only if the "misinformation" indeed turns out to be false. Which can never be known at the time. And -- given the historical context -- healthy skepticism of the medical/pharma industry is somewhat warranted.

So I disagree that online platforms should discriminate via the currently accepted status of the content being "info" or "misinfo". Online platforms should amplify in an impartial and evidence-based way and -- in particular -- stay out of arbitrating medical industry vs. the individual's right to be skeptical.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →