HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

novagameco

186 karma · joined December 23, 2023

submissionscomments
novagameco··on The Neoliberal Transition in Intellectual and Economic History
Classical liberalism (little-L liberalism) is a political framework for lowering the horizon of government. It was born out of the religious sectarianism of the 17th century, replacing religious fundamentalism with religious freedom: by disestablishing church and state (or limiting the state's capacity for legislating religion), religion was relegated to the home and this lowered the possibility for civil war.

American Liberalism (big L) is a political identity (as opposed to American Conservatism, which is also a political identity) and many policy positions are about signaling membership of an in-group to demonstrate moral puritanism (same goes for Conservatism). It is not governed by an overarching ideology

novagameco··on The Neoliberal Transition in Intellectual and Economic History
I don't think neoliberalism is a real ideology; the term, to be honest, is a pejorative used by leftists to discredit anybody further right of social democrats. The people accused of being neoliberals are rarely ideological. Liberalism (not the American kind, rather classical liberalism) is about adherence to a scientific worldview and making policies based on sound evidence.
novagameco··on The Neoliberal Transition in Intellectual and Economic History
So you believe it would have been wrong to violently remove Hitler from power when he was chancellor before the death of Paul von Hindenburg?

If you had to power to prevent a man who espouses a genocidal political ideology from seizing absolute power, would you not do so?

novagameco··on The Neoliberal Transition in Intellectual and Economic History
> if a Nazi achieves power via democratic means, and stays there via democratic means, he wouldn't be a Nazi: Nazism is the rule of antidemocratic Might Makes Right; he wouldn't remain democratic if things didn't go his way.

The same is true of communism, which advocates for the violent murder of land and property owners and the establishment of a dictatorship of the proletariat. I have little faith there would have been another election after Allende; Marxism is an inherently violent political cult which sees its enemies as subhuman. Sound familiar?

> you dislike democracy, and your worldview is despicable and vile. Still, your honesty is something!

Try to attack ideas instead of people. The way you argue is unconstructive. I like democracy, but it's imperfect.

> your worldview is despicable and vile

You defend the presidency of a Marxist; I can say the exact same thing about you. Would you likewise defend a Fascist who was elected and vowed to abolish democracy?

I think the disconnect between you and me is that I see no substantive difference between Communism and Naziism, while you seem to think that Communism is capable of a soft side, which it objectively is not

novagameco··on The Neoliberal Transition in Intellectual and Economic History
> I guess you don't like democracy all that much!

Democracy is a useful tool for building consensus, it is not the end goal of politics. Marxism is a catastrophic political cult which has never resulted in anything other than the deaths of millions, either through deliberate genocide or incompetent adherence to its pseudoscientific economic divinations. It should be removed from government through any means necessary. If a Nazi was elected president and vowed to use his political authority to achieve his goals, the military would be justified in overthrowing him and violently suppressing his supporters

Consensus can be achieved through other means. All forms of government rule by a monopoly on the use of violence, including democratic ones.

novagameco··on The Neoliberal Transition in Intellectual and Economic History
No, this is a false equivalence.

If the choice were between pinochet and a liberal democratic government, then the liberal democratic government is the obvious choice. But the choice was between a military Junta and Communism; you've got two bad choices, but one of them has a free market and economic stability. The utilitarian decision is to pick pinochet.

If you have to choose between Naziism and Communism, you've got two equally bad, genocidal choices. In such a case, you shouldn't side with either group as it makes no difference which one you pick.

← PreviousPage 5 of 5