HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nradov

44,332 karma · joined September 19, 2007

submissionscomments
nradov··on French national assembly votes 0.055€/GB internet tax
Apartments don't emit much hydrogen. Were you thinking of another gas?
nradov··on Patrick Stewart taught us what good men do with power
I don't think I'm ecoring for anyone. I don't even know what that is.
nradov··on Nurses Sound Alarm as 'Uber for Nursing' Apps Push to Deregulate Healthcare
Residency requirements are defined by ACGME. The AMA is a member of ACGME but ACGME operates independently. If you think that residency requirements should be changed then make a specific proposal instead of wasting our time with snarky, low-effort comments.

https://www.acgme.org/

State medical boards are the entities which ultimately decide on physician licensing criteria.

nradov··on Nurses Sound Alarm as 'Uber for Nursing' Apps Push to Deregulate Healthcare
Taxis have (almost) no transparency. Outside of a few limited places where there are fixed fees for certain routes, you never know how much you're going to have to pay when you get in. With ride share apps the pricing is upfront and transparent.
nradov··on Nurses Sound Alarm as 'Uber for Nursing' Apps Push to Deregulate Healthcare
Uber gives drivers tax summaries with miles driven.

https://help.uber.com/en/driving-and-delivering/article/wher...

nradov··on Nurses Sound Alarm as 'Uber for Nursing' Apps Push to Deregulate Healthcare
Nonsense. The AMA doesn't limit the number of residency slots. Did you even read through the website I linked above?
nradov··on Nurses Sound Alarm as 'Uber for Nursing' Apps Push to Deregulate Healthcare
Ha ha, but it's a matter of degree. Every organization has some level of inefficiency but having seen how the sausage is made I can guarantee you that the average software development shop in a US tech company is significantly more efficient than the average hospital. It's not something that you can quantify in a directly comparable way but anyone familiar with the industry will tell you the same.
nradov··on Nurses Sound Alarm as 'Uber for Nursing' Apps Push to Deregulate Healthcare
If you really believe that information extraction is 90% of what doctors do then you're deeply ignorant about how healthcare actually works and not qualified to even have an opinion on this subject.
nradov··on Nurses Sound Alarm as 'Uber for Nursing' Apps Push to Deregulate Healthcare
Trying to compare national healthcare systems based on life expectancy is a total non sequitur. Most of the factors which limit US life expectancy relative to other developed countries have little or nothing to do with healthcare (or lack thereof). It's mainly other problems like car crashes, suicide, violence, substance abuse, and sedentary lifestyles.
nradov··on Nurses Sound Alarm as 'Uber for Nursing' Apps Push to Deregulate Healthcare
What is the protection racket that intentionally limits supply? The primary bottleneck to producing more physicians is lack of available residency slots. Teaching hospitals are free to add more but for various reasons choose not to. In part I think they're waiting and hoping that Congress will kick in more subsidies through the Medicare program.

https://savegme.org/

Even if financial constraints were removed, the notion that we could produce twice as many physicians is ludicrous. There simply aren't enough attendings able to supervise a lot more residents, nor are there enough patient cases coming through the teaching hospitals to give that many residents the practical training they would need.

nradov··on Nurses Sound Alarm as 'Uber for Nursing' Apps Push to Deregulate Healthcare
Most hospitals (both for-profit and non-profit) are terribly inefficient. They burn up clinician time on administrative tasks that could be automated or performed by cheaper office staff or not done at all. And employees often waste a lot of time just waiting around because no one has optimized workflows to shorten queues or eliminate bottlenecks. The incentives are structured in a such a way that there's often little reason to improve.
nradov··on Patrick Stewart taught us what good men do with power
Politicians can't just appoint themselves to Congress or state legislatures. You may think they're idiots but citizens are voting for them. Is it possible that some of those "idiots" aren't as stupid as you think but rather just have different priorities and values?
nradov··on French national assembly votes 0.055€/GB internet tax
Is there some structural reason that they can't reduce rent by developing a lot more housing? Is it purely artificial government rules preventing the construction of new housing — or are there actual constraints in terms of capital, labor, or materials?
nradov··on French national assembly votes 0.055€/GB internet tax
Is the quality and accessibility of healthcare in those countries equal? There are very few countries in which all healthcare is paid by the government and private insurance is banned. Most developed countries have a two-tier system where poor people with only the government health plan get reasonable access to essential healthcare services but often can't obtain more advanced treatments, or have to wait in long queues. Affluent people then pay for supplemental private insurance to obtain faster and higher quality services. Healthcare providers typically prioritize patients who have private insurance that pays higher rates.
nradov··on French national assembly votes 0.055€/GB internet tax
Which side of the Laffer Curve are they on?
nradov··on French national assembly votes 0.055€/GB internet tax
California has some fiscal problems but if any state hits a crisis point it will probably be Illinois first. US states don't issue their own currency and have limited ability to take on debt so even if California is forced to raise taxes and default on obligations that probably won't trigger a broader systemic collapse.
nradov··on Anthropic may not secure investment-grade rating after IPO, Blackstone says
That's true today, but what will it look like in 20 years? Over time, algorithms and hardware always gets faster and more efficient. Like if I wanted to run a fluid dynamics simulation, what would have required a supercomputer 20 years ago can now run on a single desktop computer.
nradov··on Medicare Will Pay $50k for Your Heart Attack. It Should Pay $100 to Prevent It
Yes, what's your point? A CAC test doesn't require the most expensive CT scanner.
nradov··on Northflank Breached
Until the attacker bypasses your perimeter firewall by convincing an employee to download and install malware.
nradov··on Medicare Will Pay $50k for Your Heart Attack. It Should Pay $100 to Prevent It
Have you tried contacting Every Cure to see if they could help with identifying an existing drug which might be effective for your condition?

https://everycure.org/

nradov··on Medicare Will Pay $50k for Your Heart Attack. It Should Pay $100 to Prevent It
There are probably other imaging centers in your region.
nradov··on Medicare Will Pay $50k for Your Heart Attack. It Should Pay $100 to Prevent It
Value-based care is a good idea in general in terms of better aligning provider incentives with patient best interests and controlling costs. But it doesn't necessarily equate with Medicare Advantage. Many MA health plans still operate largely on a fee-for-service basis with perhaps some minor VBC aspects.
nradov··on Medicare Will Pay $50k for Your Heart Attack. It Should Pay $100 to Prevent It
You're really missing the point. There are no regulations preventing anyone from ordering a CAC screening study if they want it. You can pay out of pocket and get it at any imaging center.

Obviously the regulations regarding ionizing radiation exposure still have to be followed as with any x-ray procedure. No one has seriously proposed deregulation on that.

nradov··on Medicare Will Pay $50k for Your Heart Attack. It Should Pay $100 to Prevent It
Are you claiming that some people are exempt from the laws of thermodynamics?
nradov··on Medicare Will Pay $50k for Your Heart Attack. It Should Pay $100 to Prevent It
Things have changed a lot since Kurt Vonnegut wrote Slaughterhouse Five in 1969. Now even people in the poorest US state have higher incomes than the UK. America is the wealthiest nation on Earth, and its people are mainly rich (relative to global standards).

We should do more to help the underclass and remaining desperately poor citizens to lift themselves up. But it's amazing what we've accomplished since 1969. Let's celebrate that.

nradov··on Medicare Will Pay $50k for Your Heart Attack. It Should Pay $100 to Prevent It
The primary purpose of prison is neither punishment nor rehabilitation, but rather to protect the general public. Whether incarceration is the best approach to accomplish that goal is a separate issue, but the reality is there are a lot of dangerous and antisocial people who can't be running around loose.
nradov··on Medicare Will Pay $50k for Your Heart Attack. It Should Pay $100 to Prevent It
There are a lot of misaligned incentives in the US healthcare system, but Medicare and Medicaid health plans generally offer similar preventive care benefits as commercial plans.

https://www.healthcare.gov/preventive-care-adults/

https://www.medicare.gov/coverage/preventive-screening-servi...

nradov··on Medicare Will Pay $50k for Your Heart Attack. It Should Pay $100 to Prevent It
That's not entirely true. For screening procedures it's mainly the USPTF that writes the standards. They take inputs from the gastroenterology community but the process is more holistic.

https://www.uspreventiveservicestaskforce.org/uspstf/

nradov··on Medicare Will Pay $50k for Your Heart Attack. It Should Pay $100 to Prevent It
If you want a CAC scan you can just go directly to an imaging center that offers it and order it yourself. It doesn't require a prescription. In most cases it won't be covered by insurance for screening purposes.
nradov··on Medicare Will Pay $50k for Your Heart Attack. It Should Pay $100 to Prevent It
Eric Topol has some opinions. Some other cardiologists disagree. There probably is value in CAC for at least a subset of patients.

In the messy real world of medicine there are hardly any definitive screening tests or imaging studies. Everything will have some false positives and false negatives, or even if the output is physiologically accurate it may not be practically useful in improving patient outcomes. For screening tests we also have to weigh the costs versus benefits in terms of the number of procedures performed or dollars spent to save a life; if the numbers are too high then those scarce resources should be expended on other healthcare services.

For broad screening coverage by most health plans the key next step is an evaluation by the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force. This process is already underway but it takes a while for them to evaluate all the evidence and make a decision. For Medicare coverage there is a separate coverage determination process.

https://www.uspreventiveservicestaskforce.org/uspstf/

https://www.cms.gov/medicare/coverage/determination-process

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →