2,653 karma · joined July 15, 2015
He never finishes this thought but moves on to a new topic. I want to know what he said in reply!
AI could theoretically solve production but not consumption. If AI blows away every comparative advantage that normal humans have then consumption will collapse and there won’t be any rich humans.
Trade policy, especially towards China, has been quite bipartisan the past two Administrations so your pessimism isn’t entirely warranted. Trump doesn’t like the CHIPS Act but it’s unclear how serious any opposition will be once they get in and how much discretion they even have given the circumstances.
No I’m not, I’m just not assuming that the S curve doesn’t exist. There’s no guarantee that research results in X orders of magnitude of improvement that will result in AI being better at understanding humanity than humans in the 5 to 15 year timeframe. There’s no guarantee that compute will continue to consistently grow in volume and lower in price, and a few geopolitical reasons why it might become rarer and prohibitively expensive for some time. There’s no reason to assume capital will stay as available to further both AI techniques and compute resources should there be any sign that investments might not eventually pay off. There’s also no reason to assume the global regulatory environment will remain amenable to rapid AI development. Maybe the industry threads all these needles, but there’s good reason to predict it’ll prove doesn’t.
Maybe, but very little of the “data” that humans use to build their understanding of humans is recorded and available. If it were it’s not obvious it would be economical to train on. If it were economical it’s not obvious that current techniques would actually work that well and by definition no future techniques are known to work yet. I’m not inclined to say it will never happen but there are a few reasons to predict it’ll prove to be significantly harder to build AI that gets out of the uncanny valley that it’s currently in.
Which would not placate regulators in all likelihood. Close regulatory scrutiny is a big problem for companies seeking to grow, and a pesky cost for big companies.
Liability and regulatory scrutiny are factors. They’re liable about offensive speech but military use cases are an effective shield against liability given that deaths are expected.
Unless “way to run the business” means “delivering what the customer wants.”
All of the things you list are, in the hypothetical scenario, better done by robots. Therefore, they don’t serve any purpose by truly serving anyone or adding any value to society etc. Most people don’t ascribe any deeply satisfying meaning to mere personal enjoyment, so in this scenario what is the basis for extracting meaning from any human labor?
The robot folds some sheets because murdering routines were not included in its training set.
Actually, his model assuming circular orbits still required epicycles to explain retrograde motion etc. A major reason it never caught on was that it was less accurate than the Ptolemaic model but was more of a mathematical curiosity rather than a serious contender.
It isn’t necessary, no, and in fact a flat super simple tax code would probably result in more tax revenue. However, since politicians like the power of the tax code, and because the wealthy like a complex tax code for all the loopholes, and since ordinary people like the idea of those wealthier than them paying more tax as a percentage of their income, then we’re never going to get a simple tax code.
The only thing either response to your original reply have done is provide uncontroversial and non-conspiratorial reasons why Mondragons are extremely rare. Calling that Social Darwinism is like calling you a Stalinist, a slander based entirely on a superficial similarity of your rhetoric.
Because the majority of workers are doing the minimum amount of work to get by, because ~50% of workers are below average intelligence, because those with the entrepreneurial skill and/or business management competence necessary to make this happen benefit more from the current system and have less motivation to mess with it.
It shouldn’t be analyzed (or sold) as a technology that has to solve the whole problem. We need a toolbox of solutions for different geographies, scales and budgets while we also reduce our overall emissions. Having said that, if we reduce emissions by an order of magnitude and improve the efficiency of this process by an order of magnitude then it might enter the ballpark of viability.
Arguably, that just means they're just the illusion of "more sources" because really they're just one.
A discussion focusing on one group and their specific needs doesn’t take away from any other discussions about other groups and their needs. Attempting to shut down discussion, like you have attempted, about a specific group and their needs is perpetuating the ignoring of male mental health problems and their amelioration. The discussion about male mental health has to occur sometime, don’t get in the way.
Except, your reductionist take on men and women aside for the moment, it does matter in the context of the OP. Men, who exist and have specific needs, have a social need for friendship together that once was met in part by DIY but increasingly that isn’t happening or even possible and that is a loss for men and male mental health. Returning to your “balls and breasts” reductionism which I suspect is the true source of our disagreement, besides all other nuance most people including myself and presumably the OP accept the modest thesis that men and women have distinct needs in terms of mental health. Male mental health has been ignored and neglected for decades and this specific topic is a structural net loss for male mental health.
I don’t know what it is legally but morally that is negligent manslaughter.
The GP didn’t say women couldn’t be involved in DIY. Men expressing their need to commune with other men in doing practical tasks is obviously not universally excluding women from those tasks, it is a historically common and healthy practice of male to male friendship. Men should be able to express their simple needs without it being turned into a civil rights battle.
China doesn't have a domestic or international consumer base large enough to buy everything it produces. For some years now Chinese growth has been fueled by a real estate bubble of truly historic proportions that has burst. Even in a healthy economy with a healthy demographic structure it takes time to recover from the depths of the business cycle, China is healthy in neither sense and this is an economic crash its unlikely to meaningfully recover from.
A single insider shouldn't be able to potentially undermine the voting in an entire jurisdiction and, depending on the vulnerability, multiple jurisdictions. That is a massive vulnerability revealed by the fact that she was able to do it. No single person should be able to undermine our voting system and she knew they could and then demonstrated it. It is illegal and she should answer for the way she revealed the vulnerability but then I think Julian Assange and Edward Snowden should have been tried and jailed long ago for their unethical and irresponsible disclosures too, so I'm not a hypocrite.
Unregulated access to voting machine hardware is a vulnerability.
An insider observing a simple way for a bad actor to gain access to voting machine hardware is evidence. I don’t agree with her methods of exposing that vulnerability just like I don’t agree with Wikileaks exposing unfiltered diplomatic cables that had nothing to do with criminality. However this community and the left in general has fostered blatant double standards in this area depending on the politics of the subject.
Showing how systems are corrupt, broken, and vulnerable by technically illegal action was something that the left and the HN community have historically applauded. That's what was behind the Pentagon Papers, the Citizen's Commission, and Wikileaks. Apparently illegal activity motivated by the public good is only excusable if you aren't a Trump supporter.
I agree. I said "almost impossible."
> the snark knight
This isn't snark, or self-righteousness. This view on humanity is merely a realization most religions and cultures have come to understand across human history.
> Some seem to be doing fine, being assholes
Even if their standards are incredibly low I wager they are failing at them all the time, and if they don't admit it then they are lying to save face, lying to themselves, and making excuses.
Tolkien wasn't a fan of allegory that's for sure and you won't find a 1:1 between his fictional works and his own religious beliefs but a devout Catholic like him was definitely channelling heaven as the new glorified Eden to some degree when describing the "undying lands" that were lifted up into the heavens after the corruption and treachery of Numenor and ruled by the great spiritual powers that rule as stewards for the Creator. The movie did paraphrase, and perhaps I'm wrong but I don't think its something that Tolkien would have been offended by.
They don’t really. People try and fit in publicly so that they’re seen to be good by their group, whereas fitting in to any group at any level in any age requires accepting some things that you know are bad and when things aren’t visible people commonly indulge in a lot of bad that even their group would publicly object to often with the moral license they feel they’ve earned from the performative good they do in public. Being a truly good person by our own standards is hard to the point of almost being impossible.