HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nzp

607 karma · joined October 2, 2013

PGP: 28CC 9078 8358 CE2D 6824 A5BC 2DB2 CD24 5BE7 8F06
submissionscomments
nzp··on The “432 Hz vs. 440 Hz” conspiracy theory
Oh, there's definitely a phenomenon of widespread taste for the occult in Nazi movements. I was just trying to point out that the bulk efforts of Nazi German state and agenda weren't influenced by that in an “official” way. But people like Himmler were obsessed, and they could get away with it with Hitler because they were otherwise useful to him. Of course, it's hard to say what's official and what's not when it comes to such regimes because of the ad hoc system of rule I mentioned: every figurehead had their own fiefdom so to say, governed mostly arbitrarily by their will, as long as it didn't conflict with Hitler's overall agenda, itself arbitrary and dependent upon whatever he came up with.
nzp··on HN comments are underrated
> For example, his talk of Mars colonization as an escape hatch to our degradation of biodiversity / carbon emissions / etc. is just awful. What kind of idea is that?

To be fair, that's not a good characterization of why he's into Mars colonization. He's not advocating colonization so we can disregard life on Earth. He seems very much into preserving life on Earth. Mars colonization is a backup plan (or the initial stage of a backup plan) for the inevitable moment when Earth will have to be abandoned regardless of how well we behave.

Regarding “a lot of people dying” angle: the difference is in magnitude of “a lot of people”, and choice. However many people die on SpaceX spaceships, the number can never reach millions or even billions that would result from the collapse or technical decline. People also, in general, will choose to get on a spaceship and dwell on Mars, but they neither choose to be involved in dying from civilization collapsing, nor to have to fight for survival in such a situation — it would be completely forced upon them.

nzp··on The “432 Hz vs. 440 Hz” conspiracy theory
Hitler himself was very intolerant of any of this mysticism business. All these activities and societies were banned in Germany once they came to power. There was a number of people, in SS mainly, who were deeply into mysticism, and that was tolerated because of their status. So Hitler wouldn't have sent people to search for the Arc, but Himmler & co. might. Just another illustration of a common misconception about nazi-fascist regimes: they are regarded as highly organized, “precise“, bureaucracies, when in fact they were run mostly arbitrary and ad hoc, a consequence of the Fuhrer Principle.
nzp··on Aberfan: The mistake that cost a village its children
That was a common meme about the poor repeated by the rich. It still lives, sometimes in a more sophisticated form, eg. poor people don't know how to manage spending, not buying in bulk, not taking advantage of discounts, etc., when in reality, in practice, most things cost more when you are poor because you can't afford to wait for good opportunities, and people are actually doing the best they can it their circumstances.
nzp··on Massive Dyn DNS outage
That would be a horrible idea from a security standpoint. Although not easy by any means for an ordinary attacker, at least one exploit scenario is obvious.
nzp··on All Tesla Cars Being Produced Now Have Full Self-Driving Hardware
Not high end EV — EV period. Why so much weight? Because it's literally the only direction left for land based vehicles to go (the puns write themselves!) in the next century at least?
nzp··on Constraints on the Universe as a Numerical Simulation (2012)
> Death of the universe is also inevitable, "Heat Death".

This is far from settled. Heat death applies only to closed systems. Although it is not unreasonable to assume our universe is a closed system, we simply do not know this to be a fact.

nzp··on Mozilla has stopped all commercial development on Firefox OS
Not at all. A lot of people who gather at places like these don't seem to realise that ordinary people have much more pressing problems in life than running a phone OS they can tinker with.
nzp··on The MIT License, Line by Line
I wish I could share your optimism about political candidates.
nzp··on The MIT License, Line by Line
I'd say you're quite optimistic in thinking that not little government implies power =/= authority, and quite pessimistic in thinking that little government does not imply a civilized, functioning society.

But even without getting into political debates which could get really nuanced, can't authority mean capability in this context? I'm not a native English speaker so I'm not sure, but I don't find it odd. It is also possible that these two words have different (Anglo-Saxon vs French) origin, as most of the examples listed, and that their original meaning was synonymous (of course, I'm far too lazy and tired to check that now).

nzp··on Upgrade your SSH keys
IAD recommends not upgrading to ECC in case this would incur significant costs, only to have to upgrade again once they settle on quantum resistant algos. So not because of crypto reasons, not because ECC is more vulnerable to quantum attacks relative to RSA, but because of practical operational and economic reasons. They think they will have quantum algorithms soon enough so that RSA >=3072 is OK in the meantime. At least that's my understanding of what they're saying here: https://www.iad.gov/iad/programs/iad-initiatives/cnsa-suite....
nzp··on Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app
Hm, interesting. Well, as I said, I don't know personally (I have neither an Apple device nor Alexa), but that was my impression from what people who love Apple and also have Alexa and Google Photos say.

As for Google Photos, it makes mistakes, false positives mostly (as a funny example, for my photos so far it consistently thinks cats are dogs, although it also recognizes the same cats correctly) and sometimes it's too “eager” (“cars” will produce results where cars should be but are not actually in the photo). Sometimes it makes bizarrely trivial mistakes considering how smart it is generally: it categorized photos of human cadavers and anatomy specimens I made at the local university institute of anatomy as “Christmas”, I guess because they were made on Christmas day. But it will correctly find true positives. It also correctly visually recognizes notable places globally (that is, without geotags) and various things, concepts etc. even if they're a completely marginal subject in a photo. One thing that impressed me was a cat video it edited out of multiple clips with almost perfect music some 5-10 minutes after I uploaded the first items and started using it.

nzp··on The MIT License, Line by Line
Ah, not quite so fast! If you write: “all the introductory text which follows”, that might be construed as meaning not the part between the notice and the text which follows these words. So we have to have a terminating condition for this recursion of uncertainty. I agree, “this entire license” is probably the best form.

But anyway, my point, in the above and in my other reply with the anecdotes, is that while you may be perfectly right from the stand point of common sense and logic, it may not translate to being legally right. Of course, I think you modifications are reasonable, but I have to agree with matt4077 – it creates problems and uncertainty for others, you're (I guess?) not a lawyer, and even if you were, they would still need to consult lawyers about it. It adds friction.

nzp··on The MIT License, Line by Line
This reminds me of an anecdote about Godel, not sure if it's true or not, but here goes. When he was taking the Constitution exam to get the US citizenship, he proceeded to explain to the judge how he has a formal proof that the US Constitution is inconsistent and allows for a dictatorship to take over completely legally. Einstein was accompanying him and he somehow managed to quickly shut him up and continue to go through the motions of the exam.

It also, for some reason, reminds me of what Peter Thiel once said about physics PhDs: “Because they know fundamental things, they think they know everything.”

nzp··on The MIT License, Line by Line
There's no bug there. Copyright is about distribution, not use, so the “use” part is probably unnecessary anyway. And the warranty part is not conditional upon the two conditions. The MIT license is practically the same, and the analysis given in the article does not make note of this supposed bug, so we can consider that lawyer-confirmed. IANAL, so it's just my understanding of the issue.

I remember people mentioning another possible bug in BSD licenses: if you try to split hairs, and depending on the way you do it, it's questionable if the sentence before the enumerated conditions is part of those conditions or not. If not, that sentence needs not be distributed in copies, so it makes the whole thing meaningless.

nzp··on The MIT License, Line by Line
It's one of my favourite lists: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_doublet
nzp··on The MIT License, Line by Line
It adds conditions which make it incompatible with GPL, and similar licenses. And in general, it adds a completely arbitrary and uncertain condition, i.e. you can't be legally sure about what you can do with such software, i.e. you can more or less be sued by the author at his whim.
nzp··on Tor Browser Exposed: Anti-Privacy Implantation at Mass Scale
Ah, right, thanks. But, this thread got me thinking yesterday — if TP is untrustworthy, shouldn't he have forked node code? What use is what I understand is just a Firefox with locked down security related settings and set up to proxy through Tor? So in that sense he did fork the wrong code, and the TP people were right.
nzp··on Tor Browser Exposed: Anti-Privacy Implantation at Mass Scale
I think it is, but I didn't really follow. The whole story is nausea inducing. You have, apparently, a respected, turns-out creepy/selectively abusive guy (one of life's great archetypes) get called out for sexual abuse. Numerous people confirm, some deny. Alt-right and associated acts immediately jump on this and start hating on the Tor Project because “SJW mob lynching” etc. Then, accusations start that Tor Project is deeply infiltrated by the CIA to, I guess, try to marginalise Appelbaum. Of course, everyone ignores the fact that Appelbaum himself practically acted as a CIA agent in Burma some years ago via Radio Free Asia. “The public” demands a purge of the “SJW/CIA infiltrated” TP board. At that point I just stopped paying attention, for the sake of mental hygiene. In this story I learned that the board changed in the end, so I'll google what happened, but I'm not in a hurry.
nzp··on Tor Browser Exposed: Anti-Privacy Implantation at Mass Scale
No joke. Apparently he deleted the original tweet. https://twitter.com/isislovecruft/status/766372347892920320 https://twitter.com/isislovecruft/status/768137697554731008
nzp··on Google backs off on previously announced Allo privacy feature
Some years ago FreeBSD had an intrusion via one of the commiter's machine or stolen SSH key, I don't remember which any more, but I do remember that it took months for the package building infrastructure to get fully operational again. I think they never got to the bottom of that (who did it or why). Linux had a very similar incident if I'm not mistaken.

It's such a standard and effective method in human intelligence, that it's extremely naive to think an analogue wouldn't be used extensively in signals intelligence too.

nzp··on Tor Browser Exposed: Anti-Privacy Implantation at Mass Scale
Oh but not just any kind of “untrusworthyness”, from what I gathered from Twitter at the time, he did it after the Appelbaum affair broke out to provide a “non-SJW” fork of Tor Browser. And If I'm not mistaken, he initially forked the wrong repo, it was a running joke for a couple of days... Nice to see the farce still going strong.

EDIT: s/Tor/Tor Browser/

nzp··on Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app
> When OWS takes this work on they're giving a tacit Moxie stamp of approval to the implementation

Which is completely irrelevant for any mainstream messaging app OWS has collaborated with. No “normal” person on this planet that uses these apps knows or cares about who Moxie is.

> tldr; History tells me not to trust these companies motives in the long term, and I don't see why Moxie should either.

I doubt he does, but his goal with all this is to end passive mass surveillance, and he obviously thinks this is the best shot. I mean, Signal the app is certainly not going to become a significant player in this space, so we can debate if he's doing the right thing but I can totally see the how he can justify it even if he doesn't really trust them.

nzp··on Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app
I wouldn't know, but from what one can hear from prominent Apple pundits and podcasters, Apple is not doing great at all in this regard, to put it mildly, compared to Google (and other data vacuumers). Examples: Google Photos is running circles around Photos, and Alexa around Siri. People who love and live Apple admit Apple is pathetic in this space. I doubt it's because Apple is incompetent. These problems require huge amounts of data and processing power. You can't do that locally on a mobile device (or even a PC class computer).
nzp··on Google backs off on previously announced Allo privacy feature
It's not true that machine learning and AI needs a lot of data to do what it does with Google's services? I guess you know something their engineers don't, so I'm looking forward to Sylos' Dataless AI & Co. I bet a lot of us would even pay good money for such a thing.

Sigh, I'm not arguing that they don't collect for advertising, I'm not even defending them at all. It's just that the things they do are impossible to do without a huge amount of data, regardless of advertising. Again, if you're so sure that it is “simply not true”, here we are, YC is your oyster. Or any other tech VC fund for that matter.

nzp··on Google backs off on previously announced Allo privacy feature
Even if they weren't (mainly) an advertising company, even if they charged for all the free things, they'd still need all the data they suck in to provide services they provide.
nzp··on Google backs off on previously announced Allo privacy feature
Actually, I'd say a random HN commenter is extremely likely to be targeted for surveillance and exploitation compared to general population at least. Not because they personally are important, but because of their jobs. So many administrators, programmers, etc. with access to relevant data.
nzp··on What It Costs to Run Let's Encrypt
Good, since LE employees are actually providing value to the world.
nzp··on Pardon Snowden
This remark of yours is truly an ideological minefield!

I completely agree that the debate on income inequality and the resulting sorting of people is irrelevant. Income inequality itself is irrelevant, it's just an ideological misdirection. But, since you proclaim to be libertarian, I suppose you wouldn't agree with me on why it's irrelevant: it's being pushed to actually preserve overall capitalist relations. Sacrificing low taxes of a billionaire or two is a small price to pay to help the ruling class keep ruling. This is practically the central theme of Keynesian economics, and thus of a great deal of 20th century. The strategy is still extremely effective, and so in this election cycle we had good old Bernie Sanders act as an acceptable vent for social and economic discontent of working people by ranting about “the billionaire class”. To anyone not horribly politically illiterate (sadly American culture is generally grotesquely politically illiterate) it was painfully clear from the moment he entered the primaries how his “revolution” will end. So income inequality discourse not only does not help alleviate the problem, it maintains it.

Democrat-style liberalism is so effective because it's an ideological Escher drawing. To even start to explain why it's wrong (or even better: why it's not even wrong!) and even in many cases harmful, you have to rewind the arguments aaaall the way to first principles (let's ignore the likely case that then you end up with the problem of getting people to universally agree on a coherent set of first principles) while constantly being under the threat of being, 1930s Pravda style, denounced as pro bigger evil. As a friend of mine recently semi-jokingly said: “There are no bad guys, just a liberal hell in which all is mixed, a hell in which evil people do good things and good people live in a fantasy.”

As for mobility, there really isn't any significant mobility, this is empirical. Unless you count moving from lower middle to upper middle class (I'm not sure even that is a significant case, I just assume it is, but even then it's likely plastered with all kinds of demographic qualifiers). But still, income inequality in and of itself is not a cause of this, it's one of the symptoms, and not a particularly onerous one.

nzp··on Pardon Snowden
Giving these individual examples, anecdotes really, is even more simplistic in a sense. Within just about any social phenomenon, you can find examples of practices/effects that are incongruent, or even opposite, to the “main gist” of the phenomenon itself. It's really not about what any particular individual does at some particular time, it's about the collective effect a certain social group.

Of course, having the state of affairs as we currently have it, B&MGF's efforts are certainly to be saluted, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't contemplate and work towards a world where you don't need to depend on the good will of a billionaire to have a chance of people not dying of various preventable diseases; Or, indeed, even to recognize that such a state of affairs is unacceptable.

← PreviousPage 2 of 12Next →