HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nzp

607 karma · joined October 2, 2013

PGP: 28CC 9078 8358 CE2D 6824 A5BC 2DB2 CD24 5BE7 8F06
submissionscomments
nzp··on The Neuroscientist Who Discovered He Was a Psychopath
> Disclaimer: I have a B.S. in psychology (and a B.S. in Computer Engineering) so I'm probably biased.

You're not biased, and that shouldn't be a disclaimer. You just know what you're talking about. ;)

nzp··on The Neuroscientist Who Discovered He Was a Psychopath
Understanding on a purely cognitive level what is moral and what is not has nothing to do with what you're actually going to do, if you're a psychopath. That's really one of the most striking characteristics. Psychopaths are perfectly able to understand what can hurt others, but the lack of empathy is what causes them to behave the way they do when the time comes to act. Depending on other personality traits, and intelligence, it can manifest in a range of ways, from being a cold calculated monster to being a successful, ambitious professor who's a jerk with the grandkids.
nzp··on The Neuroscientist Who Discovered He Was a Psychopath
> This is why psychology and psychiatry are being abandoned.

This is like saying: "This is why biology and [insert-some-unreliable-medical-procedure] are being abandoned." (because said procedure was found unreliable). Without going into debate about DSM and psychiatric clinical practice, psychology has little to do with this. Terminology should be used properly, and we should be aware what words mean, especially if we criticize sloppy science or health care.

nzp··on The Neuroscientist Who Discovered He Was a Psychopath
Yep, intelligence is a significant factor in the behavioral outcome.[0]

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6789637

nzp··on The Neuroscientist Who Discovered He Was a Psychopath
> They can even develop their own rational morality, arguably in many ways better than the instinctive emotional morality most people have.

One of the striking things about psychopaths, and I'm talking about the obvious anti-social types, not the ones like Fallon from the article, is how they are able to talk and abstractly reason about morality. Based on words alone, they can often be judged as shining examples of virtue. The interesting thing about it is that they're not lying (no evidence that they do) or trying to deceive (well, it certainly depends on the situation, of course they won't have problems deceiving people when needed). They just can't relate on a fundamental level to rational analysis they are able to make. It is in fact the absence of emotional component in moral reasoning, which neurotypical people have, that leads them to behave in ways opposite of their stated abstract moral standards.

nzp··on The Neuroscientist Who Discovered He Was a Psychopath
> As to psychopathy, the linked article says it all -- a researcher finds out he's a dangerous person by reading a brain scan, with no other supporting evidence and copious contraindications.

Pretty much no, that's not what the article says at all. He didn't find he's dangerous, he found out his brain is lacking in capacity for "empathy, morality and self-control" (which is what he self-observed in the first place). These traits are central to psychopaths, but that does not mean a person with such traits is necessarily violent or actually doing anything overtly anti-social. And that's what the article actually says and tries to explain. A brain scan which shows dysfunction in ventromedial frontal cortex does not mean you're looking at a brain of an anti-social maniac, it's somewhat more nuanced.

EDIT: I forgot to mention a very relevant finding: it has been shown that intelligence has a non linear and interesting interaction with psychopathic personality traits. Basically, very high level intelligence can and does act like a defensive factor, extremely intelligent people with such traits are able to compensate the lack of empathy, self-control etc. (the relation is not so simple with lover levels of intelligence, as I said it's not linear). I wish I could give you some reference, but ATM I don't have anything in English at hand, sorry.

nzp··on The Neuroscientist Who Discovered He Was a Psychopath
There are other test which measure psychopathic tendencies, although they don't necessarily label "psychopathy" as that which they measure, for example some are "amorality" questionnaires (where amorality is roughly defined as a profound lack of regard for other people's feelings and well being etc.). Some are quite successful in discriminating various types of prison populations (that is, it doesn't just say "this person is severely lacking empathy", but it shows there are various types of psychopathic/anti-social trait clusters, and this reflects on real life behavioral history of individuals). I'm speaking from a strictly academic research background with this and a lot of time has passed since I looked into it so I'm not sure if the tests I'm talking about got any clinical use among non-prison population. However, a lot of this can be gleaned from good general purpose personality questionnaires.
nzp··on What 4chan thinks of HN
For me, one of the best features of HN is the minimalistic interface, including lack of links. Although, I'd welcome escapable asterisks.
nzp··on How to Heat Your Room for 15 Cents a Day
Nice tip (not sure it works, but worth a try), but why not post a direct link to Youtube video? The linked site is a PITA with NoScript and Ghostery.
nzp··on Is the universe fundamentally deterministic?
It most certainly is not an accurate reading of physics. What is simultaneous in relation to deep space objects is just a function of their distance from us. Any movement we make is completely negligible, because at those scales the Earth and the far away object are for all purposes point particles.
nzp··on Every day almost 1 mln people help astronomers identify galaxies on Galaxy Zoo
This may sound like a cliche, but the discovery is the reward. Everything else is just icing on the cake, may make your life more comfortable, may make you feel appreciated, but it's optional. I mean, your question actually says "why would anyone do any science?", because have in mind that doing fundamental science is not that lucrative in terms of pay compared to the value it brings, and only a vanishingly small percentage of scientists actually get some kind of a recognition, and of those who do a vanishingly small percentage is even mentioned to general public.
nzp··on Edward Snowden is Almost Broke
I'm guessing he means the exchange offices have to have a license for doing the exchange business. Not residents or businesses.
nzp··on Sweden closes four prisons as number of inmates plummets
Thanks!
nzp··on Sweden closes four prisons as number of inmates plummets
> How does Minnesota's system work for me as a member of the public? I can walk all over my neighborhood feeling perfectly safe, and even my children can freely go out in public, walking for a radius of a mile or biking for a radius of four or five miles in any direction, without risk or fear.

I'm genuinely curious, I'm honestly not trolling, is this state of affairs remarkable in the US these days? Is this really an accomplishment? Is it worse in general?

nzp··on Mythbusting India's Mars Mission
Yes, but then we are arguing about truisms, so what's the point the naysayers want to make? I don't mean you specifically, but on several threads on this page there are people arguing that: "oh, this is so much money wasted, other things could be done with it, but oh, I'm not saying we should take away from the space program, but, oh, this is so much money wasted..." ad nauseam. I mean what exactly is the point in pointing out that yes, obviously, other good things can be done with 72 million, and then disclaiming that it's an argument against India launching a Mars probe? Why point out such a trivial truth unless arguing against India doing this? If it's just about 72 million not being small change in general, why aren't people making such trivially true statements in discussions about other things?

Again, I am not singling you out, I get what you're saying, but I just have to ask: why aren't we having people pointing out how many schools can be built out of a budget for, for example as kamaal wrote, an Olympic opening ceremony? I don't think it's even some kind of closet racism, as some have argued, in general (though in this case there is also that, in this story's coverage by the Western media), because people go nuts over the US space program also. Even outside the US. :) It's a clear pattern of pushing the waste argument over just about any kind of space exploration anyone does, and it's not done just by "unwashed masses" but also by very educated people (e.g. here, I had a colleague, a theoretical physicist of all people, telling me how space programs are such a waste when there are people starving etc...). What the hell?

nzp··on Mythbusting India's Mars Mission
How many schools could be built on a US DoD's Iraq war budget (just an example)? And how many lives would be spared if in fact that money went into building of schools? I think there are issues in our world today infinitely better suited for complaining about wasting resources than some country's space program.
nzp··on Mythbusting India's Mars Mission
> Gold is not all that useful by itself, so launching a bunch of gold into space would not be throwing wealth away the way launching an expensive and fancy satellite is.

At the point of launch the satellite would be even less valuable (in the use value sense, which is what you're referring to) than a bunch of gold. At least gold could be put to some use (it is a useful metal), while a satellite's only useful purpose is to be launched into and operate in space. It's why a satellite exists, you would lose wealth only if it wasn't launched.

nzp··on Wikipedia Zero
We already have that: http://www.scholarpedia.org
nzp··on Physicists Smash Record For Wave-Particle Duality
> ... And that opens the door to other quantum phenomenon such as teleportation.

That last paragraph implies that if we could observe wave-like quantum phenomena in classical objects, we might also see other quantum effects. Fair enough, but quantum teleportation has nothing to do with Star Trek style teleportation which the author probably thinks would result.

nzp··on Is Modern Web Design Too Formulaic?
> worrydream.com is basically impossible to scroll on Chrome on Windows.

I was so confused by this and abraxasz's remark about original design. Not scrolling in Chrome on Windows? What? Why would it not scroll, and what's so original about it? I was browsing in FF, so I took a look in Chrome... Oh, wow, this is the best example of graceful degradation I've seen and it's so simple (I didn't know <noscript> can go into <head>, you learn something every day). I had NoScript turned on if FF, so it kicked in the simple CSS which I must say to me looks more beautiful and more functional.

nzp··on What goes on in our minds when we see someone naked?
An interesting read, some actually novel empirical data, although the title is a bit link-baity.

I can't help but wonder if this is a learned response in most cultures, i.e. where clothes play a significant social role. One doesn't see many scantly clad university professors vs. working without too much clothes is usually reserved for jobs not requiring particular intelligence or education, so we come to extrapolate from that experience. It would be interesting to see if this effect manifests in societies where people usually go naked or without much clothes. It would also be interesting to see whether this is just about the nakedness or does it apply to other imaginable forms of "embodiment" (from this article I somehow get the intuition that it would).

nzp··on A Critique of Lavabit
I agree for geeks, but not for "normal" people.
nzp··on Show HN: I'm working on an open-source Gmail replacement
It's less effective for sure, but depending on your situation it might be good enough. On email systems I maintain the only filtering I set up is AV with Clamav. One reason for this is my huge dislike for solutions that statistical filtering provides -- you end up having to check the spam folder or whatever anyway. I just don't see the point. The only solution I think is a real proper solution is for spam never to hit any user mailbox in the first place, but that will probably never happen. So just I limit spam filtering to checking strict SMTP compliance for the messages (message format) and Spam Haus filtering as the last measure. I can't imagine any legitimate email ever tripping format/protocol checks, and I was amazed how much spam just those checks eliminated. Spam Haus cuts on that a little more. Sure there is still spam hitting the inboxes, but I think it's manageable (haven't had complaints), say around 30 messages/day for a busy address (for example, the main address [relatively widely published and always unprotected] of an international organization). YMMV of course.

EDIT: Greylisting would probably cut down on this further drastically, but I'm just too lazy to implement because no one complained yet about too much spam. :)

nzp··on Google Security Team Member on NSA: "Fuck These Guys"
Disregarding for a moment that a state can not be communist (one defining characteristic of communism being absence of state), only socialist, North Korea has long disassociated itself from communism. Since the 90s at least there has been a systematic removal of any mention of Marxism, communism and related terminology from the constitution, laws and official discourse.
nzp··on Programmable 6,000-Part Drawing Boy Automaton Built 240 Years Ago
There are two other, though not as complex: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaquet-Droz_automata
nzp··on Moving from Ubuntu to Debian
I recently switched to Ubuntu from FreeBSD because of driver support problems (i.e. not willingly) and here's my take:

* Unity: I don't see what the big deal is. Granted, it's a subjective thing. As someone who generally dislikes DEs and would normally use just a tiling window manager maybe I don't appreciate the finer points in DE wars. I've been reluctant to install Xmonad because of the fear of what might break, and I have to say I've had no particular annoyances with Unity which I wouldn't have with any other desktop environment. Indeed, all the annoying stuff actually comes from GNOME components that they left. I find the Dash and HUD quite nice.

* Online scopes and advertising. In recent years I've come to the conclusion that a free (as in beer) general population friendly OS just isn't going to happen. The work needed to polish things to compete with Windows and OS X in this aspect is extremely boring. No hacker (or even average programmer) is going to spend his free time doing that. You have to be paid to do it. The money has to come from somewhere, thus advertising. I'm not a big fan this, but what Canonical is doing is at the moment our best shot of having a viable desktop OS which just works and lets you get on with your life (and even Ubuntu isn't there yet). And you can disable it with a single switch. Big deal.

* Shuttleworth trolling people... Well, it's certainly legitimate to not want to use an OS developed by a company owned by a person who says controversial stuff, but I don't see the technical angle. For example, is OS X better of worse because Jobs was a strange type? And as for Mir (that's what the issue revolves around), if Mir is a bad idea Wayland is also a bad idea. You just can't think Wayland is all peachy and Mir a horrible thing because they both basically do the same thing. All the talk about splitting the community (what community would that be?) makes no sense -- if Canonical decided they need complete control of their graphics stack it's a legitimate decision, and no one has any moral ground to attack that decision. In developing Mir they are not interfering with Wayland in any way, they are simply not participating. (BTW, I don't think either Wayland or Mir are good ideas, we'll end up with the situation we have in OS X, where X can be tacked on when necessary, and it is often necessary, with who knows what kind of crappy support.)

I'm no fan of Shuttleworth or Ubuntu, I really just don't care about either on any emotional level, but I'd like a FOSS OS which is also free as in beer AND just works on the desktop and lets me get on with my work and life. After you get to a certain age in life, fiddling with the OS gets old real fast.

nzp··on Moving from Ubuntu to Debian
I've used FreeBSD as my desktop for a long time and would continue using it if it supported the hardware in my new home machine (no drivers for this particular WiFi USB adapter, and not that great support for Intel graphics[1], unfortunately I was in a hurry and didn't have the time to pick and choose the hardware). I have only the best words for FreeBSD. The best way I would describe the experience of using it is you can just feel the clarity of thought that the commiters have. Almost everything is really well thought out, clean, logical and backed with fairly good arguments. Documentation is excellent -- I never had to dig around the internet to find a solution. Everything is well explained in The Handbook[2] or the man pages. A few corner cases you might encounter usually get solved quickly on the very helpful mailing lists. The community is likewise excellent. Aside from a few snide regulars (just users, not developers), people are very helpful and polite.

Ever since I switched to Linux (it's been a few months now) because of those drivers issues, a small part of me dies every time I sit in front of this machine. :) What comforts me is that FreeBSD is focused on the server side, and doesn't compromise that for desktop battles which IMHO are lost to proprietary systems anyway. I would gladly accept using any convenient piece of crap on the desktop, such as Ubuntu or any other Linux distro, if that means FreeBSD stays focused on serious business(tm). On the server, you can take it from my cold dead hands.

Now, to get in the right state of mind for using it on the desktop you have to understand one simple fact -- no desktop related software is part of FreeBSD. FreeBSD is a whole operating system developed in unison consisting of the kernel, standard BSD and POSIX userspace and some necessary third party software without which it would simply not be a complete Unix system. Everything X (and desktop) related is part of the Ports system (i.e. third party software ported to FreeBSD but not part of it). This means that if you want Ubuntu level integration and functionality of your desktop you'll have to configure it yourself. I've seen many people who didn't understand this point clearly get frustrated and angry and miss the beauty of it.

So, for desktop use:

Pros (in no particular order):

* The sound system -- unlike the Linux mess, FreeBSD always had a sound sound system. ;) No need for PulseAudios of the day or whatnot to get multichannel, etc. it's all working right there in the kernel.

* The Ports -- you simply get the latest versions of applications as soon as available. Note however that sometimes Ports contributors and commiters can lag and you might end up waiting, but since the Ports tree is unique and shared among all supported releases of the system there is no policy of keeping outdated version of applications (it's partially a side effect of the fact that Ports are not part of the system and as such need not be stable, although some important things, and where it makes sense, have multiple versions maintained). High profile software usually gets updated within a few days.

* One of my favourites is GELI, the GEOM[3] module for disk encryption. It's so straightforward and easy to use (command line tools only) it's a real joy. It supports cool stuff like having a USB stick as a token in addition to a password. Because it's part of GEOM you can layer things completely freely, although with some caveats if you use GPT partitions.

* Some enterprise/server class features that might come in handy on the desktop -- Jails, GEOM in general, ZFS, PF...

* For Linux only applications there's Linuxulator (kernel translation for system calls) which works great although it's a bit dated (I think it doesn't support stuff added since Linux 2.4, may get updated eventually). Works with no performance penalty.

* Sanity and peace of mind (granted, this is subjective)

Cons:

* It may not have the drivers for some popular desktop hardware. FreeBSD is really server and enterprise oriented and it shows in driver availability. YMMV and always check the Hardware Notes for a particular release. Nvidia cards are fully supported with the proprietary driver.

* My personal pet peeve -- for years and years TeX Live wasn't available for FreeBSD. It's slowly changing and it should go into the Ports replacing the ancient teTeX (similar for Sage Math).

* The Ports -- yes they are in the cons too. While it didn't bother me that much, building stuff from source can be a burden. On faster machines it's not that scary, but each time Perl, pcre or something other that a lot of stuff depends on gets a version bump, if you're not careful, things can get hairy. On the other hand PKGNG, the new binary package management system, is great and once the new format packages become widely and officially available all of this will become a non-issue.

* As I said, you have to configure most things of interest on a desktop machine yourself. Apart from what vanilla desktop environments offer themselves, there is very little system level hand holding. OTOH, most if not all of it is documented.

* I'm not sure of Gnome 3 status right now, there were some problems. KDE 4 on the other hand has a great ports team supporting it and it's regulary updated, no problems there.

General remarks that are neither cons nor pros:

* Flash works fine in my experience (since it's Flash for Linux it requires Linux emulation enabled) but since HTML 5 become the norm I never bothered with it (for stuff not supporting HTML 5 video I just used applications which use Mplayer to stream flv and that's actually how I prefer it).

* Gaming -- if it works in Wine it will work in FreeBSD (having an Nvidia card is recomended).

[1] The basics work from 9-RELEASE onward at least up to Ivy Bridge graphics, but going to console from X via Alt+Ctrl+F<n> doesn't work and I think there are some other minor issues. Nothing absolutely critical, but I like things that work to work properly, it's the FreeBSD way after all.

[2] http://www.freebsd.org/doc/en/books/handbook/

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GEOM

EDIT: formatting

nzp··on Smooth Online Signatures, Open Source
Oh, no, no, maybe I didn't come through clear -- I completely understand and agree with what you're saying here. My remark was more along the lines of: even IF electronic signatures had the physical feature of not being easy to move, they still shouldn't be taken seriously because they don't look the same (in my experience at least). I also assume here that overt visual likeness plays a significant role in validation, but IANACE (court expert) so I may be completely mistaken.
nzp··on Smooth Online Signatures, Open Source
I agree with this, but you can't dismiss the dissimilarity of these electronic "signatures" with the actual thing. Not being able to easily move the physical signature still doesn't prevent forgery. In case of disputes the signature is examined and compared with the one you produce. The thing I can write on his pad, with my best effort, looks nothing like my signature. It's possible I'm some kind of an outlier (I have a sample of one, me), but I doubt it.

I'm not sure it's just because of the mouse, though that makes things worse. Where I live we have smartcard IDs with biometric data on the chip. One of the things they record is the signature. It's done with a stylus and some kind of a touch sensitive screen (a really small one, which makes things worse). I took several shots but just couldn't write something that didn't look like a really bad fake of my signature. I pointed this out, but they were OK with it...

EDIT: Just to add, the lines really do look nice though (much better than what I have on my ID card, for example)!

nzp··on An interview with Bill Gates
Having cancer tends to negatively affect one's quality of life. ;) But it's an interesting question--quality of life vs. lifespan. Imagine if there was no possibility of prolonging human lifespan, but instead we had the means to stop aging, say in a person's mid twenties to mid thirties. Having some 50 or 60 years time with your mental and physical faculties in prime, not having to rush, being able to take your time and learn and do practically everything you want. We would live like gods.
← PreviousPage 11 of 12Next →