607 karma · joined October 2, 2013
What DistroKid is doing is showing good will to users who for whatever reason decide to game the system. It's a fair and square proposition: "This service costs money, we see you are trying to game the system and instead of just kicking you out we are willing to assume you're going to be honest and pay if you can really afford. It's the choice we made (to trust our customers), and that's it."
Constantly nagging about payments, when they already agreed to let people not pay, would in my opinion and taste be just pathetic. The message that would send (again, in my opinion) is: "Remember when we said we trusted you? Yeah, well, that was just to get our foot in the door. We don't, so now not only will we take your money, we'll insult your intelligence with this passive aggressive message." I assumed you're proposing this message pops out as the second phase of the current scenario. OTOH, if they offered this kind of deal right from the start it would be a different thing, but please -- sans passive aggressive pop-ups on morality. ;) That said, I think what DistroKid is doing now, as it is, is perfect.
It's a long way to space from where he jumped. The Karman line is at 100 km altitude.
Feynman's approach was as good as it gets when it comes to popularizing physics, so your best bet are his popular books. And if you have some working calculus knowledge you should just read his Lectures on Physics to get to understand pretty much all of physics up to and not including QFT and General Relativity.
Probably because HN audience tends to be less bound by conventional wisdom and all kinds of irrationality. As far as politics go, I'm anarcho-communist (thus anti-capitalist), but on HN I often find comments (although this account is just a few days old, I've been reading HN for years) on economic and political issues from people who are very pro-capitalist with which I can agree (although we would probably disagree on motives and goals). For example in this discussion. It's very hard to find this in general population.
> So working for money is the most sadistic thing imaginable because there is some imaginary machine that could do the work? Torturing people is sadistic, paying people to work is not.
This is a strawman. First, I did not say it's the most sadistic thing imaginable. But yes, it is sadistic because that kind of work typically brings significant distress and because it's unnecessary. It doesn't matter how good or bad the wage is. This kind of dreadful work ties a person's mental and physical potential which could be otherwise used to add great value to society and the individual. Having a base income would efficiently untie a lot of reasons for this deadlock which is overwhelmingly of political nature. Do I think it's likely to happen, even though it's stupid and harmful not to? No, but why would that stop me from contemplating it and doing whatever I can to help bring about some change?
> On the one hand we have some strange indignation that seems to be rooted in the idea that we no longer have scarcity or something another.
We don't have scarcity in a lot of areas. The problem lies in not having political will to rationally distribute unscarce resources.
> The other seems to be, ironically, a lack of realization of where technology is currently at
It is certainly at a sufficient level to eliminate a huge number of distressful jobs. That it can't, at this moment, eliminate all such jobs is no reason to dismiss possible solutions. From a slightly different technological domain: just because not all long haul travel is via space, doesn't mean we should dismiss all other forms of transport and just stay put until space planes become reality.
First, they don't have their visors (those Sun protective, gold plated ones). I'm not sure, but I guess that's a big no-no on EVAs, having the Sun enter your field of vision so close to it (in Earth's orbit) would probably do some eye damage. Again, I'm not sure the visor is always mandatory but I don't remember seeing any photos of actual EVAs without it being down.
Second, Sandra Bullock rotating while attached to Canadarm... My impression was that the g force would be too high for her to stay conscious, or able to communicate. But it turns out intuition was wrong on that one: back of envelope calculation gives ~3 g (assuming 15 m length for the Canadarm [assuming it is the Shuttle Canadarm], but it was slightly retracted so it would be less, and a period of ~4 s) while still attached to the Shuttle, and ~1.5 g when the arm broke off (~3 m radius, 2-3 s period). So, that's OK. :)
Third, the abuse those suits were getting! That's just crazy. At that point I got so annoyed that I didn't bother to notice all the other stuff the article talks about.
Now I'm just bummed out that all this might have spoiled the movie for me (I tried not to read the plot section on Wikipedia, but got a glimpse of the ending as I was scrolling). Nerd rage is a horrible thing. :)
According to Wikipedia, Angelina Jolie was the first choice, but in my opinion that would have been a much, much worse choice. What's wrong with Bullock? To me she seems plausible as an astronaut at least as far as physique and appearance go.
Of human labor, yes, but fortunately we have machines and computers... And that's exactly the point. Forcing people to do things machines can do is one of the most irrational and sadistic aspects of modern civilization. The principal reason we have such a situation is the absence of basic income, or some equivalent that would eliminate the need for wage slavery in exchange for bare survival. For all other kinds of work, if it really is something humans are necessary for, people will do it because it means it's interesting (or necessary, and I think jobs which are impossible, at the moment, to automate and necessary and completely uninteresting to anybody are so few that there will never be shortage of labor).
EDIT: grammar.
I may be reading you incorrectly, but I get the sense you consider what the US/West does somehow isn't ideologically motivated or that having any such motivations is inherently sinister? Of course they were, just like the US is ideologically motivated. Defending and furthering capitalist goals is no less ideologically motivated than defending and furthering communist goals.
OTOH, being downright mean, or just an annoying busybody is another thing altogether, and, yes, a lot of people have a hard time judging (maybe "evaluating" would be a better word) without at least some malice. But I think saying any kind of judgement is bad isn't at all helpful for individuals or society at large. It leads to people developing blind spots for harmful behaviour.
No, in fact, when dealing with law enforcement you should be as uncooperative as possible. It is in your best interest. The expectation that if we are polite to some adversarial authority then they'll go easier on us seems quite widespread (seems to me it has some deep bio/psychological roots). Unfortunately, it's completely false. The police doesn't care the least bit if you are cooperative, polite, prompt, not a dick... In fact, they are trained to exploit one's urge to be polite, honest and helpful against you.
If law enforcement decides to come after you (for whatever reason), no politeness in the world is going to make them turn around and say: "Gee, what a nice fellow, we're sure sorry we wasted his time." They are there to get you, not to negotiate and make good first impressions. There is absolutely nothing you can say that can help you in any way.
The classic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K1p3K3sC1Ec