607 karma · joined October 2, 2013
It's not. I can see how this myth took root on HN, but it's funny how persistent it is given that it was clarified quite a few times even by PG.
If you want to develop cross platform native looking software, Qt most certainly is not the only option, wxWidgets is. In fact, as you yourself pointed out, Qt isn't really native, just tries to fake the native look and feel. wxWidgets actually is, as it's a thin wrapper around the native toolkits.
“Our guidelines suit the way we work, and the culture we want to nurture. We hope you find them useful too.
Happy communicating!”
Ugh...
What a weird place, and I don't mean this in a good way (taking into account all the previous workplace drama they had).
In an ideal world I would prefer this research (AGI, and there is a quantum leap to be made between self driving cars and AGI) to stay strictly under the auspices of “pure science”, i.e. academia. No government, no private interests. But that's not going to happen. The next best thing, I think, would be to not let those in power monopolize the research.
And space agencies are also a good example of what happens when government bureaucracies put pressure on scientists and engineers. O-rings, and Soviet space disasters come to mind.
In fact, I'll be so bold to say that the best way for these fears of SMI to come to life is putting the research under tight government control and regulation.
In addition to what you said, there is a further problem with this line of reasoning: and then what? Doing meaningful intervention on such a system would pretty much require the impossible—solving the halting problem in general. This is something that even the SMI itself wouldn't be able to do because, well, it' impossible.
> I really think a lot of CS people suffer from a kind of Dunning-Krueger effect when it comes to biological systems.
Basically, this. It's not just that we require a huge jump in technology (maybe, maybe not, but probably yes), it's that most of these speculations are incredibly naive. This is literally advising global policy based on the Terminator plot.
About the “conspiracy nut” center of brain. If there is some unstated agenda here, it's hardly a conspiracy any more than the actual system we live in is a conspiracy. Think about it, if we get an SMI which would genuinely work to help humanity, what is the most likely thing to happen? Being a super-intelligent, rational entity it wouldn't take long to figure out that most problems facing humanity is outright irrationality and inefficiency in state organized society and, down votes notwithstanding, capitalism. I don't think I need to convince many here of all the problems with state bureaucracies. As for capitalism, let's just consider, by now somewhat famous essay, The Meditations on Moloch, which lays down some pretty chilling game theoretical arguments against our current global economic system. I don't necessarily agree with all it has to say (although I am against capitalism, just to be honest about political biases here), but what it says sounds very similar to what an intelligent machine would likely work out should it start pondering our problems and possible solutions. If SMI would reach similar conclusions, it seems to me the most rational thing to do would be to just take control away from states and market entities. No need to harm anyone or anything like that, just politely take away their power, just like a parent would take away the knife from a child's hand, and simply, rationally, do what's beneficial to human values. To take the example of Las Vegas from the essay further: it could just say—“No, let's not build a pointless, tacky replica of various cities in the middle of the desert, instead, I'll direct the resources into badly needed fusion power research which would get everyone free energy.” So, these are all intelligent people in power, and if there's any hidden agenda, I'd bet it's this—the fear of losing control and power over society and the rest of humanity. But it's no conspiracy if that's the case, it's just a structurally forced position to take if you're in power (political and/or economic).
But I doubt it too. I agree that is just plain old lack of imagination and too much shallow blockbuster science fiction (BTW, I think the Terminator is a great story, but not a particularly reasonable scenario on which to base your predictions of future scientific, technological and societal development).
Not only that, the proposal is to get governments, the US government especially—an organization which in total has not been waging war for only a few decades during it's entire existence—in explicit and tight control of this powerful technology. Doesn't quite seem to be the best idea around, frankly.
Serious question—you’re joking, right? Based on history and sober common sense, do you really think what governments in general are doing (and have always done) can be described as safe and moral in anything but the most cynical way?
But I could be wrong. Maybe there's a sweet spot in the price-utility ratio where this makes sense for people who are not technically rich and busy maintaining the wealth. It's interesting.
I'm not saying there's nothing wrong with the trend of personal and home devices becoming surveillance machines, there's a lot wrong, but Samsung in this case is an example of how you do it properly if you have to do it (it's a feature that apparently has to work the way it works).
What you're proposing is not a balanced discussion.