HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nzp

607 karma · joined October 2, 2013

PGP: 28CC 9078 8358 CE2D 6824 A5BC 2DB2 CD24 5BE7 8F06
submissionscomments
nzp··on CBSD – FreeBSD Jail Management Tools
Right, that's what I said[1]---there's a shim pkg in base to install pkg proper from ports. The real pkg is in ports so it can receive continuous upgrades, which wouldn't be possible in a RELEASE (or STABLE for the most part) if it were in base.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7114744

nzp··on CBSD – FreeBSD Jail Management Tools
Linux in there is probably just because of CloudFlare. I had no idea what was HN running on until that outage a week or so ago with the switching of servers etc. A Tell HN[1] about the incident says they were using UFS and now switched to ZFS, and that can only mean FreeBSD.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7069013

nzp··on CBSD – FreeBSD Jail Management Tools
It's the default alright, but that has nothing to do with it being in the base (yes, it's an exception to the rule). You can look it up on the freebsd-ports@, there were somewhat heated discussions concerning this and some other issues. Unless I've missed something, this decision hasn't changed.
nzp··on CBSD – FreeBSD Jail Management Tools
> What kind of things to people use FreeBSD for?

HN for start. And then there's (off the top of my head) Netflix, NetApp, Juniper, Sony, countless ISPs, DuckDuckGo...

nzp··on CBSD – FreeBSD Jail Management Tools
> but sqlite should be there, as it is being used in the system (if I am correct, at least by pkg, the new package manager).

AFAIK, no. PKGNG is intentionally not part of base, it's meant to always remain in ports. The reason is that it allows pkg developers to iterate quickly (and this ties nicely into the recent ports infrastructure overhaul efforts). Once something is part of base and goes into a RELEASE it pretty much has to stay frozen apart for security fixes, and this was deemed not flexible enough for pkg. The only thing in base is a shim pkg which on first invocation installs the real thing from ports (and, I think, later just routes everything to it, unless you remove it or change PATH). So nothing in base uses sqlite and it's in ports/packages.

nzp··on CBSD – FreeBSD Jail Management Tools
Well, I had a hunch it was for this reason. I usually get grumpy when an arguably superior solution is presented as an 'alternative' to something that's just more popular because it's easier that way for people to grok what it's all about. But on the other hand, I've never been good at marketing, so who am I to complain. :)
nzp··on CBSD – FreeBSD Jail Management Tools
This project seems great, but I feel there's something wrong with the submitted article title, it sounds weird (plus, there's no mention of Docker on the linked page). Sure, you can draw parallels between Docker and what FreeBSD jails and tools built on top do, but it would be fairer to say Docker is a Linux based alternative to jails, and not as powerful (as far as I understand Linux kernel infrastructure that Docker uses). The crucial difference is that jails are really a security feature in FreeBSD (and if you're not using them in production you're probably doing it wrong), whereas Docker is primarily deployment oriented (please correct me if I'm wrong about Docker here). Various jail management tools give you a nice, easy to use, set of deployment features on top.
nzp··on Django 1.7 alpha 1 released
It has been stated by Andrew Godwin (author of South and the new native migrations) that there will be a clear path to switch from South to native migrations. And also for people who can't upgrade to 1.7 there should be South 2 with some of the new features backported from native migrations.
nzp··on OpenBSD will shut down if we do not have the funding to keep the lights on
> I believe HN also runs on OpenBSD too, if I'm not mistaken.

On FreeBSD.

nzp··on OpenBSD will shut down if we do not have the funding to keep the lights on
> while simultaneously asking for strangely large sums of money

It's not a strangely large sum for what they need it for.

nzp··on OpenBSD will shut down if we do not have the funding to keep the lights on
Most FOSS projects with the name pattern OpenXYZ fall under the OpenBSD umbrella in one way or the other.
nzp··on Ask HN: Should I drop out the college?
Seems like a complete waste of time, so you should probably drop it. Unless, for some reason, you formally need the diploma.
nzp··on Anti-ageing compound set for human trials after turning clock back for mice
What are you talking about? (serious question)
nzp··on People who mattered in science this year
What's depressing and ironic is that these people are anthropologists and yet they are "shocked" and "surprised" by the results. Breaking news: Anthropologists Discover Sexuality in Humans.

What did they think would happen in an academic setting artificially sterilized of any attempt at realistic imperfect human relations? Of course there is harassment, people are frustrated. Note that I'm not excusing the behaviour, just trying to explain.

Aside the mere statement that there is harassment, it would be much more interesting and helpful in actually overcoming the problem to see the actual dynamics of the phenomenon backed by some actual data (she's aware herself how flimsy the data currently is, it says so in the article).

nzp··on Infection of biological DNA with digital Computer Code
AMAZING enthusiasm! :)
nzp··on 550-Year-Old Gutenberg Bible in High-Res Detail
In addition to all convention others have mentioned, I expect a lot of oddities have to do with hacks to make justification and spacing perfectly uniform. The 42-line Bible font was composed of well over 200 unique characters.
nzp··on David Deutsch On Artificial Intelligence
I am not sure we positively know every single detail there is to know about neurons, but we know an excruciating amount of details. At the level of a single neuron, it's physiology and connections to neighbouring neurons, we know everything we need to know that it has absolutely nothing to do with QM. There are no mysterious phenomena here, nothing outside biochemistry and physiology.
nzp··on David Deutsch On Artificial Intelligence
> The parent post (for this comment) contains a rant about physicists but has no specific rebuttal of the article.

It's not a rant about physicists (I am one, for the record), it's just that this is what I noticed--whenever there's an otherwise good scientist giving misguided proclamations on how some research field other than his should proceed, it's always the physicist. Maybe I'm biased in that I take extra notice of what physicists say, but anyway it's anegdotal and not the main point. What matters is: whoever you are, if you're going to seriously opine on a subject, beyond general methodological remarks (which are extremely important), you better have in depth knowledge of the subject matter. Example claim: "behaviourism is abandoned by mainstream psychology". I'll avoid discussing what he means by "mainstream" here (there could be all sorts of ugly dragons lurking behind this statement), and just say that this is false. The term behaviourism is not used anymore (it's not useful anymore to use it), but a huge deal of behavioural theory and results are still alive and well in psychology of cognition.

His central point, that "creativity" is the key to AGI, is meaningless the way he talks about it. Creative thinking is not a mysterious process, there is a lot of empirical work dealing with it. He further postulates that we need philosophical (of all things) breakthroughs. I can't help but think this is some sort of Chinese room style argument all over again. Having stated, multiple times, that philosophical/epistemological breakthroughs are needed, he speculates that maybe better understanding of genetic diffs between humans and other higher primates hold the key. It's all over the place. It's hard to give specific rebuttals to extremely vague ideas.

Thanks for the pointer to Dyson's article, found it and stashed it for later reading.

> And oh, to state possible biases on record: I'm a physicist :-)

Have you read Chesterton's The Man Who Was Thursday? This discussion is starting to feel like it, just do a %s/anarchists/physicists/g :)

nzp··on David Deutsch On Artificial Intelligence
Right, I remembered him after I posted. I don't know what to think of that. He obviously knows quantum theory. He can open any undergraduate textbook on neurophysiology and read all about how neurons work. So is he merely crazy, filling some emotional void religion might had filled in the old days, or something else? I don't know.
nzp··on David Deutsch On Artificial Intelligence
I actually catch myself sometimes saying or thinking the tooltip text. :)

But what Deutsch writes here is somewhat opposite in approach to the problem of how to be annoying--he's trying make a non-physics research area seem fundamentally more complicated than it likely is. I'm willing to say it borders on mysticism, and the only reason I can think of for such behaviour in an otherwise fine scientist is a strong emotional attachment to some romantic idea of what it is to be a human being. There is zero (AFAIK) theoretical or empirical evidence for his grand claims about creativity, and he's playing the old game in AI: goalpost moving. Whenever AI does something that was previously thought to be only achievable by humans, the critics immediately jump and say: "Ah, but that's not really intelligent, is it?"

nzp··on David Deutsch On Artificial Intelligence
I can just say that Deutsch is another victim of what being good at theoretical physics tends to do to one's mind. The amount of intellectual hubris and arrogance we can develop is staggering. Sheldon Cooper is not really a parody, it's what many theoretical physicists actually think (but are to socially adapted to say out loud), as in: "Penny - I'm a physicist. I have a working knowledge of the entire universe and everything it contains." Deutsch may think he knows things about "the mind" but he shows in this article that, like many who like to speculate wildly about the mind, he's basing his claim mostly on armchairing about how he feels about certain phenomena. Things he says about behaviourism are indicative that he doesn't really know what he's talking about. Or he does but is extremely bad at communicating his ideas. It would just take too long to comment on each and every empty claim this article makes. It's mostly a rehash of same old boring arguments about how special we are, this time because of our "creativity". Yawn, there is nothing special about "creativity", it's an active area of research, has been for decades, and it's actually very boring. He does make a few good points, like the one that quantum phenomena do not give rise to mental processes, but that is trivial in the sense it's obvious to anyone with some knowledge of quantum mechanics on one hand, and what neurons are and how they work on the other.
nzp··on The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat
Why thank you, how very Buddhist of you. :)

EDIT: ... to assume so much.

nzp··on The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat
How? I don't see that in what he says (I see other problems which I mentioned previously). It's not "do not kill under any kind of circumstance, willingly or not, consciously or not". There's a lot of nuance behind the simple, short Buddhist precept "I will refrain (or abstain) from killing". Precepts are shortly formulated to help you keep in mind a huge deal of theory and, more importantly, practice behind them. And they are explicitly not abstract axioms to be dogmatically held without any kind of practical context of reality.
nzp··on The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat
But he's not distorting, what he said is actually very much in line with at least Theravada Buddhist view on morality. Here, I've posted this[0] a few hours ago because of this discussion and a comment I made above. Straight from the horse's mouth, approximately.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6884572

nzp··on The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat
It's refreshing to come across such an open minded person in discussions on this topic (people generally feel extremely defensive when it comes to meat eating, on all sides of the argument, I'm not sure why this specific topic strikes people's nerves so much). It really is a surprisingly complicated topic, I have my doubts about some aspects too.

I was never much fond of killing animals for food, but what ultimately compelled me to go vegetarian was an article similar to this[0] I have read many years ago. I always “knew” this is what's happening in the animal derived food industry, but somehow reading that with all the depictions stuck some cord in the emotional and moral part of my mind and I decided to simply stop eating meat from that moment on. It was remarkably easy for me once I had that moment of “illumination” (for a lack of a better word), I've never had any desire to try meat since then (although I've tried one small piece of meat several years ago just to see what will happen--nothing, complete indifference). But, I haven't gone further, I haven't even tried being vegan. Although I understand the vegan argument, and agree with it in principle on an intellectual level, but that emotional part of the experience leading to moral commitment, that spark is missing (there's also the practicality angle, I live in a culture that's not really conductive to being vegetarian, let alone vegan, eating out can be a bit complicated sometimes).

So there, I just wanted to share my experience of learning (and I still am). I understand what you're saying when it comes to changing perspectives.

[0] In a magnificent anarchist magazine, The Match, self printed (non digital, on a Linotype machine IIRC) and published by Fred Woodworth[1], a great anarchist and an amazing individual in general. I had to take this opportunity to mention The Match (I consider it a form of community service to HN, a lot of people here might like to know of this) because it's severely disproportionally unknown in comparison to its quality (in large part because of some of Fred's uncompromising stances on publishing and printing).

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Woodworth

nzp··on Jargon File moved to github
I think ESR is an idiot for a lot of reasons, but to be honest you're taking that quote a little out of context. The whole point of that blog post was to show his superior rationality and analytical introspective prowess--despite the “irrational” feelings he describes in the quoted paragraph, he was able to reason his way through all that and his neocortex and non-bigotry came victorious. Or so he claims.

One a certain level I agree with what he writes in that post in the sense that we shouldn't let certain mental reflexes, which are no fault of ours, overpower our reason, compassion, whatever... But on the other hand, I have to agree with you at least in part, because that paragraph is just messed up (it's the exact part that startled me when I read the post[0] a few months ago). Without it, that post would be one of the rare reasonable things he wrote lately. It left a bad taste in my mouth not knowing what to think really. Although, he has gone on verbal racist sprees before, without much analysing own visceral processes.

[0] http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=5001

EDIT: Oh, and just to add: he self appointed himself as a speaker for hacker culture. I don't think anyone has taken that seriously. Who cares what one person with delusions of grandeur thinks?

nzp··on The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat
There seems to be quite a number of people who embrace the reasoning that it's more ethical to eat animals if one kills them themselves. (I'm not sure if I'm not reading this into what you're writing, if this is not your position I apologise, but anyway this is for the purpose of discussing said position in general.) I disagree with this in general. The act of feeding oneself is necessary for survival, whereas killing animals is not.

First of all, the animal couldn't care less if someone treats its corpse with respect--it's already dead, so I don't see how the animal benefits from this. Second, I'd say that the negative effects on the killer's mind from the act of killing far outweigh any positive effects from mindfulness in handling food produced from the kill.

Killing desensitizes, you become accustomed to taking life from another sentient being. The meat industry is likewise taking care to use every edible part of the animal, they're not producing any waste as far as that goes. Further, I don't think eating everything in the plate is making any measurable difference in terms of total meat consumed (if that's the implicit idea behind this). It's like the “think about the starving children in Africa” routine, which never made sense: people in Africa aren't starving because kids in the West aren't eating their whole dinners, and what good does cleaning the plate (i.e. making the food gone) do to remedy the situation. :)

> It's a highly rewarding and enlightening process which I highly, highly recommend to anyone that eats meat.

The bottom line of what I'm trying to say is I just can't see anything enlightening, let alone rewarding, in a process which necessitates killing other sentient beings. Of course, there is absolutely no doubt that hunting is infinitely more ethical than what is being done by the meat industry. It's really incomparable, so if you have to eat meat do take care it's from a reasonable source like hunting or “organic” (I hate that word) farming. However, that likely doesn't scale at all at the current levels of population. In my mind the best thing to do would be to just stop killing animals for food.

Some time ago I came across this interesting Youtube video[0] but never got around to post it here, and this discussion reminded me of that[1]. Basically, this guy (a Theravada monk) summarizes almost perfectly what I'm trying to say. Because of the horrible things industrial meat production does, I can't quite agree with him that it's OK to buy meat in the supermarket (as long as you're not specifically desiring meat), but otherwise I think he is spot on.

[0] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zisXgVnv-cI

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6884572

nzp··on Metals in your smartphone have no substitutes
Yeah, I was kinda hoping people would touch on those questions here. I haven't managed to read the actual paper, but it's just 5 pages longs so I doubt it speaks much about these questions. But a piece discussing these particulars would be awesome.
nzp··on Show HN: People Food - $7 Office Lunches for Hungry Startups
You made a well designed front page. The colours are nicely fitting and the logo is great it associated with some kind of food immediately (made me think of spring rolls or something like that)! Just wanted to say that after a day of repeatedly stumbling upon extremely annoying hip, identical, scroll-untill-you-die sites, yours made me smile a little. And now I'm hungry.
nzp··on I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made
Do note that I'm making a distinction between Marxism and Marx's theory (in the sense that he was just one, although first, Marxist philosopher/sociologist/economist). So, it may be that USSR was not a test of Marx's own ideas on transition, but it was certainly a test of one, very much dominant for the most part of the last century, strand of Marxist thought. And they didn't decide they wanted to short-circuit the process "just because", or because they were lazy; they did have a theoretical analysis and rationale behind the idea.
← PreviousPage 9 of 12Next →