HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nzp

607 karma · joined October 2, 2013

PGP: 28CC 9078 8358 CE2D 6824 A5BC 2DB2 CD24 5BE7 8F06
submissionscomments
nzp··on Climate simulations of Middle Earth
For some reason it asks me to login to see the page. Google cache to the rescue: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?biw=1600&bih=78...
nzp··on The Human Wealth of Nations
Absolutely, I agree. No group, every ruling structure benefits from the ignorance of the masses. I was replying under the impression you are arguing against the need for everyone to be properly educated (in the sense of high level of literacy, critical thinking, reasoning etc. all the things PISA is supposedly designed to measure). I apologise if that impression was wrong. It's true that I was a little confused by your post and the one you were replying to, mostly because of no fault of yours or the parent's but because I'm not entirely sure what the percentages of "highest scientific performance" that the article is referring to mean.
nzp··on The Human Wealth of Nations
As far as I know, PISA tries to test for understanding, not things like memorizing the periodic table. The reading test is specially aimed at this--do these children actually understand the meaning of what they just read. These kinds of skills have huge impact on democratic (or would be democratic) societies. You know, do people actually understand what the press is writing, what the politicians are saying, etc.
nzp··on I will not hack on your codebase for free in an interview
> ... equally be unlikely to do anything outside of what he is technically being paid for.

"Technically" being paid for? There is absolutely no reason for anyone to do any commercial work unless being paid for. People are not slaves, they have their own lives and their own free time to do the stuff they want to do. To expect from anyone to work for free and complain when they refuse to is outrageous.

> I'm not saying anyone should work for free, but sometimes you have to help out, whether it's working a bit later or helping during a crunch time.

Yes, in fact that's exactly what you're saying--people should work for free. You're just calling it "helping out". The employee is not there to "help" you (do what? get rich?), they are there to do the job they're contractually being paid to do. If you need more work to be done, then arrange so. If you need free "helping out" feel free to call in your friends and family.

nzp··on Show HN: Using GitHub to tackle Ray Bradbury's 1,000 Nights Challenge
I never knew about the challenge, now I know, so thanks! Great idea!

I was wondering for a few moments what's the point of GitHub here. My first thought for such a thing would be a wiki (I know, I'm so 2000s). But I guess GitHub is simply there, capable, and with readily available contributors, opposed to some random wiki site?

nzp··on The Open Source Bikeshed
Yep. When I said it's interesting, I meant in the context of this controversy, it's gender neutral in meaning and it's grammatically female so it satisfies PC rigour from two sides.
nzp··on The Open Source Bikeshed
It's a common situation in a lot of inflected languages--words get suffixed to agree in number, gender, etc. and it's hard to escape "gendering".

What I usually do is construct the sentence to say that a person [has done something, for example], where possible. The word "person" is gender neutral by meaning, so the whole sentence comes out gender neutral in meaning regardless or grammatical gender of words. Interestingly, in Serbian, "person" has female grammatical gender, so the whole sentence comes out in that gender, but as I said it's still semantically neutral.

nzp··on Learn C the Hard Way: A Clear and Direct Intro To Modern C Programming
"Reality" was my word, I tried to condense the essence of his argument. That chapter is online[0] and as far as I see, only the "deconstructing" exercises part is missing. I've read it some time ago, so I'm not sure anymore if I would agree with everything he said because I don't remember every argument (but I don't feel competent enough about C to strongly comment either way anyway), but what he says in "Overall Critique Of Correctness" seems pretty reasonable.

[0] http://c.learncodethehardway.org/book/krcritique.html

nzp··on I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made
I agree it's debatable in terms of relationship of Leninism to "vanilla" Marxism. It is much less debatable, I think, that Leninism is an honest (in the sense of not being intentionally wrong or deceptive) continuation of the original Marxist sociology and economy (at least the "late Marx" version of it). So in that sense I took the term Marxism to encompass all those strains of social and economic theory based on late Marx.
nzp··on I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made
Well, for what it's worth Wikipedia article on the paleolithic suggests there is much evidence of trade during that era (referenced, but I don't have the time to research that ATM). But that's beside the point really. The issue here is how we define what economy is and what trade is. But more to the point, trade in general is not a defining characteristic of capitalism, it's not the differentia specifica of capitalism. But I agree that the statement "trade is the foundation of any economy" is too strong in the sense that it's not only trade that is needed to have an economy (you need production, consumption, etc.).
nzp··on I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made
The comparison is deeply flawed. Psychoanalysis is not good at explaining what has already happened. It only seems good if you don't know that those "explanations" have no actual basis in reality. Psychoanalysis is mostly based on completely made up "facts", not just on badly interpreted facts. This is a big difference if we're talking about philosophy of science (which we are if we're discussing Popper's views on what is science). By the way, Marxism can make testable statements about the world ("prediction" is a too strong requirement for this domain of reality, it's too complex; fluid mechanics can't make any predictions about turbulent flows, but that doesn't mean it's not science).

This is why my stomach turns when Popper is mentioned. The idea of falsifiability and testable statements being the essence of science is the best known guiding principle in scientific methodology. Having articulated this wonderful idea, he just couldn't help but muddy the water and misuse it to peddle his political and social views.

EDIT: I forgot to give an example of a falsifiable prediction in Marxism: the outcome of the "dictatorship of the proletariat" and the transitional socialist state leading to communism. It was actually falsified successfully by Soviet Union et al.

nzp··on When income grows, who gains?
> No, I am not equating government and society. I am questioning the simplistic view that a person can exist today and succeed independent of the society they grew up in.

Then we are in complete agreement on that. I was pretty sure you didn't equate them, but asked because snitko made it seem like you did. I assumed he just read that into what you wrote, but better to check.

> What do you mean government is a foreign body on society? Society is made of people, and people usually make up governments.

Governments are generally not there to benefit society, but to impose the will of those in power on it. You can, of course, cite many philosophical speculations that it isn't so, but the reality doesn't support those speculations. Almost all good any government has done for the people who are not in power was fought for by those not in power, or is simply a preemptive scheme to calm down the masses.

nzp··on When income grows, who gains?
Of course you can't (although I do believe we can and should be free from unwanted, unpleasant labour). But hey, you asked a value based question and got a value based answer. ;)
nzp··on When income grows, who gains?
You're trying to paint a reality that doesn't really exist. In practice the employer competition you mention comes down to competing who can pay the least, not who can pay the most. Income statistics show this trend very well, real income for workers is steadily declining. There is a fundamental imbalance of power, which can only be corrected with workers organizing into unions (and only somewhat if we're talking about conventional bureaucratic unions).

I don't know where and in what social circles you live in, but most people on this planet can not simply choose to get an education that can significantly change one's material status. It costs money. Lots of money.

Mind you, I'm in no way a supporter of state or taxes, but saying people who face real existential risks tied to not having a job or having only access to low paying jobs have more choice than people who don't like paying taxes is ultra cynical. It is not my intention to offend you, but it simply is. Get some perspective please.

nzp··on Learn C the Hard Way: A Clear and Direct Intro To Modern C Programming
Do note that Zed actually discusses in this book (at least in the online version) why it might not be the best idea to learn C from K&R today. His basic argument, IIRC, is that the examples in K&R are very bad when it comes to writing modern C. Sure, you'll learn the language in a formal sense, but K&R is hardly going to prepare you for the reality of C programming.
nzp··on When income grows, who gains?
> 1. When a worker decides to work for an employer, he does so voluntarily. No one forces him to sign the contract.

I see. And if the worker decides he doesn't like working for any of the available employers, what happens then?

nzp··on When income grows, who gains?
Yes. That's exactly what would be just, among other things.
nzp··on When income grows, who gains?
> But to claim that only a government can build those things and therefore you are forever indebted to the society as a whole is just plain wrong.

It is wrong because it doesn't make sense, but I don't think tks2103 equated government and society (am I wrong?). Are you equating them? Government does not represent society in any meaningful way. Almost always it's a foreign body on society.

nzp··on I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made
What's wrong in taking a class in anything including Marxist sociology? Are there some domains of knowledge which should be intentionally left unexplored, lest we corrupt all our precious bodily fluids? What is this--Texas Board of Education?

Seems to me too few people take classes in anything these days, let alone Marxist sociology.

nzp··on I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made
Without further qualifications, I too agree completely. However, to me it's both sad and funny how twisted the meaning of "free" and "voluntary" become when used to defend (liberal) capitalism. This is a general remark, it's not meant as an attack of how you use these words (I wouldn't really know).
nzp··on I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made
Maybe I wasn't clear enough in my last paragraph, so I apologize to you, but I was thinking of something that didn't fundamentally had anything to do with capitalism. This example still clings to erroneous notion that state socialism is something fundamentally different. It's not really. Of course liberal capitalism outperforms state run centrally planned parody of capitalism.
nzp··on I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made
> No it isn't. Trade is. [snip meaningless analogy]

Trade? No, trade is the foundation of any kind of economy, of any kind of organized social life. Exploitation is one of the foundational concepts of capitalism, but the same is true for all past dominant economic systems, so it's true that it's not terribly useful to define capitalism as something that is just about exploitation. The way exploitation is structured, whom and how is exploited, in capitalism is the key point.

nzp··on I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made
If the list goes on, you could have then easily picked better examples, couldn't you? When North Korean society still had any meaningful relationship to socialism (not communism) it actually had a higher GDP than South Korea. It only turned around in the 70s and 80s when NK leadership structures went completely insane.

So, what other systems? State socialism? It can only be viewed as an alternative system to liberal capitalism, not to capitalism in general sense because it still leaves the same economic relations basically intact. It's an incompetent, extremely monopolistic form of capitalism, which is why it failed so miserably.

nzp··on I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made
That (mis)quote of Churchill doesn't really mean anything, it's a shallow apology of capitalism, just a catchy formula that superficially seems to make sense if you don't care to think about the possibilities. If you suspend thinking it works on an emotional level because it suggests that yes, the people in power are aware of capitalism's shortcomings, they feel the pain but, alas, there's nothing they could do, so stop complaining you ungrateful somebody...

Churchill and the likes are not exactly neutral observers with no interest in preserving the status quo by any means possible, starting with intellectual dishonesty.

nzp··on Do We Live in the Matrix?
> The problem is nobody has a good plan for what else to do.

There are plenty of plans, if one is willing to listen (anarchism). It's not the lack of plans that is the problem, it's people not having the guts to let go of what we have now. Constant indoctrination, since childhood, with the idea that is the best we can do is also a significant factor.

> I'm not worried about a group of teens in the military coming in and raping my wife.

The lack of official, internationally recognized state apparatus is not the reason this happens. For overwhelming majority of people, if they woke up the next morning and realized the state is gone, I'm pretty sure their first thought wouldn't be to go out on the street and start shooting. Those few that would are not deterred from such behaviour in the presence of state either.

> But "wouldn't it be nice if everyone was nice" is the kind of political plan I'd expect from a 5 year old.

It's not about people being nice. It's about creating a system where there is no reason or incentive to be bad, a system where it doesn't make sense to be bad to others. But even if people are somehow inherently bad, isn't it logical to not want a system where such people can rule over you?

nzp··on Why GNU grep is fast (2010)
> by the guy WHO ORIGINALLY WROTE GREP

Just a pedantic remark: He (Mike Haertel) originally wrote GNU grep. Grep, on the other hand, was originally written by Ken Thompson.

nzp··on The Neuroscientist Who Discovered He Was a Psychopath
Please stop confusing psychology and psychiatry. That was the point of my post. You're using these two words as if they are synonyms. They are not. In fact they have little in common. One is a science (psychology), the other mostly (not completely) pseudo-medical quackery with little to no basis in the actual science it's supposed to be grounded in.

As for the DSM, I'm afraid the highest ranking (what they have ranks in psychiatry now? ;)) psychiatrist's idea will lead to even more quackery. DSM isn't perfect, there is a lot to complain about theoretically and practically, but it was at least a working attempt at objectivity. Abandoning the idea of having a list of (at least somewhat well) operationally defined disorders and working to improve that will again lead psychiatry to a state where a psychiatric diagnosis is no better than a random choice of an arbitrary label (it really was like that in the first half of 20th century, later things stated getting a little better).

nzp··on The Neuroscientist Who Discovered He Was a Psychopath
I agree. I mentioned in another comment -- he may be completely faking his state in order to write an engaging story and sell the book. But he is describing very well how a well adjusted person with psychopathic traits would behave. The book and this article are just good illustrations of the phenomenon written in a way that's digestible for general lay readership.
nzp··on The Neuroscientist Who Discovered He Was a Psychopath
> That wasn't an insight he had in advance, that was an interpretation forced on him by the test results. In other words, he was cornered into accepting a picture of himself, clearly at odds with reality, through personal dedication to his experiment and its outcome.

Whether he in particular is a well adjusted psycho is actually irrelevant. He's trying to sell a book, he may even be completely lying about how he behaves just in order to spice up the story and sell more books. The point is that what he is describing is based on solid current knowledge about psychopathy. The behaviour he is describing is congruent with current best scientific knowledge on the topic. His behaviour and brain scan, whether true or just imagined, is not evidence to support anything and he isn't implying it is. It's just an illustration.

> If we accepted modern psychology's basic premise -- that there is a normal behavior toward which we should all aspire [...]

Just what on earth are you talking about? Please, stop the nonsense.

nzp··on The Neuroscientist Who Discovered He Was a Psychopath
Sigh. This is one of those scientific subjects that has become a popular topic in the mainstream, and with it come a lot of misconceptions. So it's not surprising to me how many comments are skeptical of what this guy writes. It's unfortunate because the article sums what we almost certainly know about the phenomenon, albeit in a way that is clearly geared to promote his book. It's marketing, but things he says are based on a fair amount of decent science. It's just that long tables of statistical data and lectures on neurophysiology don't sell as many books as amusing personal anecdotes.
← PreviousPage 10 of 12Next →