HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

oarfish

300 karma · joined December 31, 2016

submissionscomments
oarfish··on Resistance training load does not determine hypertrophy
Why?

Most people don't build up to such a stimulus, so its not surprising if its uncomfortable, if all youve ever done is 20 rep sets.

oarfish··on Resistance training load does not determine hypertrophy
> Volume itself is meaningless. The only thing that matters is the intensity of the workout

Not true at all, its well documented that volume is the biggest predictor of progress. there is obviously an intensity floor, and when its not feasible logistically to stack on more volume, intensity is your other knob. But to say volume doesnt matter is an odd claim, maybe i misunderstand.

> you want the maximum intensity with minimum volume to have less wear and tear

Not a helpful way of thinking about exercise induced adaptations. unless you are doing pro athlete amounts of training, would ignore this completely.

oarfish··on Resistance training load does not determine hypertrophy
The podcast is where the real meat is, not all of it is on youtube. Best way to innoculate you against bullshit.
oarfish··on Resistance training load does not determine hypertrophy
Depends, its also an indicator of novelty, and that by itself isnt useful. Once you are used to a movement and training volume, getting sore is difficult unless you ramp up the volume continuosly.

id say, never being sore at all is maybe a sign you dont do enough for optimum results, but frequently being sore means the load is too high. And for health outcomes it probably matters less.

oarfish··on Resistance training load does not determine hypertrophy
No one claims you can do nothing, exercise has numerous benefits that extend beyond hypertrophy or even strength. i think the point is that you have way less control over the outcome than youd like, because individual responses vary so wildly. You can improve your odds by ticking the usual boxes and finding and following a custom program that works for you, but none of that is going to make as big of a difference than your genetic base.
oarfish··on Resistance training load does not determine hypertrophy
I think there was a study last year or so that investigated whether protein rich meals actually made people consume less calories, and i think it didnt really, despite the fact that it feels more satiating and the TEF is also higher than for carbs.

So i think for long term weight changes it doesnt really help, at least not via its satiety response. Probably more through displacing other stuff from the diet and improved body composition.

oarfish··on Resistance training load does not determine hypertrophy
Not true, no one is symmetrical or fully balanced in strength. outside of extreme cases, so called imbalances arent a problem on a population level, at least as far as we know today.
oarfish··on Resistance training load does not determine hypertrophy
Yes, because the stimulus is novel if youve never done yoga before (e.g. a bunch of isometrics). That is not an indication of it being useful exercise for the outcomes of interest.
oarfish··on Backing up Spotify
Seems like librespot is not directly suppporting the fetching of audio to files, and intentionally so, in order to not get targeted by Spotify. Obviously you can dump the audio to file as it "plays", but that would be be very slow.

So I suppose if one wanted to use librespot for archiving, one would have to modify it to support this use case.

oarfish··on Backing up Spotify
The wikipedia article seems to concur with you, although this seems to be a voluntary policy by CUII, the members could still decide to not wait for any court orders and block whatever they want.
oarfish··on Backing up Spotify
Yeah this is actually quite nefarious, as it is a private organization that decides what sites get blocked, with no legal oversight.

- https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clearingstelle_Urheberrecht_im...

- https://netzpolitik.org/2024/cuii-liste-diese-websites-sperr...

Its a DNS based block, so overriding your default DNS server is enough to circumvent it. I think Dns over Https also works.

oarfish··on Germany votes to bring in voluntary military service programme for 18-year-olds
Including women in this does have the additional hurdle that a constitutional amendment would be needed, which is less likely to pass, regardless of the merits.
oarfish··on Metabolic and cellular differences between sedentary and active individuals
> My friend's program is longevity-focused, not strength focused.

I'd say long lifespan without long healthspan is not very useful, so I'd prioritize strength in common movement patterns over just extending temporal existence as much as possible. So longevity shouldn't be treated as separate from either cardiovascular or muscoskeletal fitness.

oarfish··on I was right about dishwasher pods and now I can prove it [video]
> damages your gut

what does that even mean?

Any citations here?

Edit: i see the linked pubmed in a child comment now. But it seems to be not in humans, so saying it "damages your gut" is not an appropriate conclusion.

oarfish··on Walmart U.S. moves to eliminate synthetic dyes across all private brand foods
Based on what evidence?

Not against removing unnecessary stuff from food, but lets be real about the effects.

oarfish··on Maintaining weight loss
PSA: Robert Lustig is notorious for broadcasting incorrect views contradicted by current science.

A good debunk of his nonsense claims is here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LZPKTaVB1IU&t=64s

oarfish··on Maintaining weight loss
Some odd claims here.

> It's not just extra calories, it's poison.

Uh no. You say you grew up under the low-fat propaganda, but still you fall victim to the overly broad "sugar is poison" propaganda. Yes, limit it by all means, but your overall caloric budget is way more important than the exact proportion of nutrients (same as with fat).

> then when I increase my fat consumption I started losing weight. By fat I mean real animal fat from meat, not seed oils or other processed fats.

Good that it worked for you, but this sounds like anti seed oil propaganda, which is debunked. "real animal fat" often means high saturated fat, which when replaced by polyunsaturated and unsaturated (from e.g. seed oils) actually tends to improve your health.

oarfish··on Biomolecular shifts occur in our 40s and 60s (2024)
> reason being probably sitting lifestyle promotes posture and fascia degradation which makes moving less and less enjoyable

how, of all the reasons, is _that_ the cause of reduced physical activity?

What even is fascia degradation?

oarfish··on We’re secretly winning the war on cancer
> Plenty of possible reasons; diet, plastics, PFAS, all of the above, take your pick.

I think obesity is the main confounder in all such statistics. Thats the thing that has most markedly gone up over the past decades

oarfish··on Being fat is a trap
Not sure how this relates to what i wrote.
oarfish··on 4-7-8 Breathing
is Nestor's book really excellent? I didn't make it more than halfway through because nowhere could i find any references for all the outlandish claims that are made. A lot of them are implausible anyway, and so far as I know the actual science does not support all these theories put forth in the book. If a thing is made out to be the cure to everything, it's likely the cure to nothing.

would be happy to have some good references.

this isnt to say that breathing exercises are not beneficial, but this book left me scratching my head.

oarfish··on Being fat is a trap
Not really. genetics play a huge role in satiety signaling, and you can't just willpower your way out of it the way someone who simply lacka discipline can.
oarfish··on Google shared my phone number
I cant be the only one who's default assumption about personal data is exactly this.
oarfish··on WeightWatchers files bankruptcy
This seems to starkly contradict the current data on glp-1 agonists.
oarfish··on An end to all this prostate trouble?
> including pelvic floor exercises into the routine and correct belly breathing utilizing the diaphragm are probably the best options for preventing issues with reduced venous blood flow from the testicles

citation needed.

oarfish··on Show HN: Hexi – Modern header-only network binary serialisation for C++
These days, whenever i read "headet only" i immediately get scared about compile times. Does using this library make compilation expensive in the way that eg protobuf or nlohmann_json do?
oarfish··on Coffee reduces risk of Type 2 Diabetes; okay to add cream, but not sweetener
Why would sugar be bad?
oarfish··on Minimum effective dose
Theres not really much documented benefit of warming up for injury prevention as far as i know. I think it improves performance, but its definitely an area where much time can be saved.
oarfish··on Robotics and ROS 2 Essentials
If you have the people to build something like this, could well be. If you're a smaller shop without any real experts, the structure enforced by ROS will prevent a lot of chaos and debugging.
oarfish··on Robotics and ROS 2 Essentials
Trust me, having your own crufty cobbled-together robotics code base that gets more and more insipid over time is way worse. 10/10 would start anything new with ROS.
← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →