HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

oblique63

449 karma · joined November 12, 2010

Enrique Gavidia Developer / Designer / Musician

Founder of TabRat.com

Portfolio: enriquegavidia.com

LinkedIn: http://www.linkedin.com/pub/enrique-gavidia/35/3a/7bb

Github: github.com/oblique63

additional interests in: neurology, psychology, philosophy, intelligence, communication, education, nutrition ---- enrique@enriquegavidia.com

submissionscomments
oblique63··on Poll: Are you an Introvert, Extrovert or do you have Aspergers?
Dude, you're arguing against a strawman... These 4-letter MBTI type codes do not exist. They're just a helpful lookup table for the cognitive functions which do show a strong preference dichotomy like my handedness analogy and it is covered in that neurology talk I linked to originally.

I'm literally talking about the psychology of the subject, and you're talking about red herrings and road signs for what it's worth. If you want to construct a meaningful argument against Jungian cognitive psychology, then that's cool, but you're not arguing anything new/interesting here. Of course there is no I/E line! It's much more nuanced than that, or even a 'spectrum'. That would've been painfully obvious if you even glanced at the cognitive function references I linked. Introversion/Extroversion isn't a broad/clean dichotomy, but the concepts of it can be applied to much narrower areas, like the individual cognitive functions themselves.

It's been clear for ages that people can't be broadly categorized by the dimensions you're referring to, MBTI just uses them colloquially because it's a quick/easy shorthand to more insightful analysis. But again, you're barking up a strawman that's been refuted and barked up millions of times already. If you want to refute it's usefulness, you'll be better off studying up on cognitive psychology and addressing it's real underlying faults instead of all this easy low-hanging fruit that's already been picked. Jungian psychology isn't perfect, but what you're addressing here is old and widely acknowledged.

Again, if you have a problem with people misinterpreting MBTI results (which it seems like you do, as do I), that's a whole different matter that has nothing to do with the real underlying psychology behind it. I'm actually pretty sure we agree at some level, except that I've already taken the time to study the subject matter before jumping to conclusions.

oblique63··on Poll: Are you an Introvert, Extrovert or do you have Aspergers?
I don't know, can you think of a situation where it's easier to complicate things needlessly with millions of superfluous variables? There's a reason we no longer program in assembly languages -- abstraction is helpful, and many useful abstractions can be simplified to a few core concepts. Personality types are abstract frameworks that simplify the modeling of human behavior. The reason they seem like dichotomies is because that's just more practical; we don't go around saying we're only 75% right-handed for example, we just say we're either "right-handed" or "left-handed", and that conveys just about all the useful information we need. Abstractions don't have to follow a lossy compression algorithm, but compression is nonetheless helpful when dealing with overwhelming amounts of information. Just go ask any economist...

I'm not exactly sure what idea/agenda you're trying to push by debating this, it's just another tool and another set of descriptions that can be added on to what is already there, not a replacement for what is there. Just because an app gives a user an ID number doesn't mean that the authors believe their users to be nothing but serial numbers. Simplification helps convey information efficiently. So assuming the larger data set still remains at you're disposal, I really don't understand what there is to disagree with.

oblique63··on Poll: Are you an Introvert, Extrovert or do you have Aspergers?
Interesting. Unfortunately that poll was taken well before I even joined up, cause it definitely feels like it has a strong ISTJ/INTJ slant now somehow (ignoring possible mistyping and all that)...
oblique63··on Poll: Are you an Introvert, Extrovert or do you have Aspergers?
You can't blame people for trying to harness the power of that psychology in a practical manner though. A simple 4-letter code is much more practical than asking a person for their ranked cognitive function preferences.

Dismissing the entire MBTI system just because it's current testing implementations aren't perfect seems a bit shortsighted when the psychology behind it is actually pretty useful for predicting team dynamics to a certain degree. If you want to be annoyed with people that have no idea how to interpret MBTI results, then that's a different story, but there's no need to throw out a perfectly good baby with the bathwater...

oblique63··on Poll: Are you an Introvert, Extrovert or do you have Aspergers?
Except that MBTI is only a superficial shorthand for the more complex Jungian cognitive function theory[1], which is more nuanced and has functions interacting in more complex ways than just the 4 dimensions represented by the MBTI system. More interestingly, is that these cognitive functions are actually starting to have some connections to neurological phenomena[2]. So while on the superficial level MBTI is kind of just a bunch of sugar coating, it actually is founded in more well-reasoned psychology. It could still be highly inaccurate, but it is unusually consistent (once you accept that the tests for it are generally terrible).

[1] Here are some good resources on their basic definitions:

http://www.the16types.info/vbulletin/content.php/213-MBTI-De...

http://personalityjunkie.com/functions-ni-ti-fi-si-ne-te-fe-...

[2] This talk goes into some detail about how specific brain patterns seem to correlate with the Jungian cognitive functions:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MGfhQTbcqmA

oblique63··on Poll: Are you an Introvert, Extrovert or do you have Aspergers?
I too would be very curious about HN's MBTI stats. As an INTP, I often feel like a straight up minority in here sometimes...

I also scored as an ICUG on that other test, which seems to fit my INTP description, lol.

oblique63··on HN Notify
Ok, but I doubt PG still hand-codes every update to the site himself, and such small features don't seem like they would require a high ranking staff member to implement them either, which was kinda my point.
oblique63··on HN Notify
> But, the reality is probably that PG is just super busy and does not have the time and bandwidth to build features out.

I totally get that, it's the reason I mentioned the 7-year time window though. You'd think that something like that would've been done at some point during all that time by some interns or something by now, even if it was a super low priority. I'm guessing that "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" philosophy must just be really strong with PG in that case. Or possibly have some deeper reasoning like you mentioned.

> Reddit does not send notifications on comment replies either.

It doesn't send out notifications to your email or whatever, but it does still have a little inbox notification that lights up when you get new replies. Does something similar to that get unlocked here with enough karma? If that's the case, then I wouldn't know...

oblique63··on HN Notify
Surely I can't be the only one wondering why this kind of functionality isn't just built-in already (with option to enable/disable accordingly)? I mean, the site has been around for about 7 years now, and the whole 'community' aspect seems to be a big selling point, so it just seems odd...
oblique63··on GitBucket: A Github/BitBucket clone in Scala
I really wish this wasn't restricted to Windows servers... it's too bad, cause I doubt GitLab is planning on mercurial support anytime soon.
oblique63··on Why there is no Hitchhiker’s Guide to Mathematics for Programmers
> ...but the effort to get there will be a power of that needed by a "math-inclined" person.

'math-inclined'... so in other words, interested/experienced in math?

Um, yeah?

You don't like math, we get it. But you can't justify matters of taste 'scientifically' like that. There is no other way we can quantify these 'inclinations' you speak of other than taste, so there's nothing really new here.

Not everybody born with perfect pitch wants to be a musician, and I can guarantee you there are plenty of musicians without it that can run circles around some of those that do have it.

I'm interested in programming and music, and confidently feel I'm good at both, does that mean I'm "musically/programmatically-inclined"? If so, how might I be? Or instead, how would you define a person that isn't musically-inclined? You could argue that a literally tone-deaf person isn't, but not that !musical_inclination == tone_deafness; so how would you define it? The simplest definition that would catch the most cases here would just be the lack of interest. So in other words:

    if (interests.contains(some_subject)) {
        return POTENTIAL_SUCCESS;
    }
    else {
        return null;  // because it is 'undefined', not necessarily FAILURE
    }
Pretty novel idea there. Who would've thought you needed to be interested in something to excel in it?
oblique63··on Why there is no Hitchhiker’s Guide to Mathematics for Programmers
Exactly, but dyslexics can still read, because they can learn how to. Their genetics may not have given them a good start, but evolution certainly didn't make their lives any easier either; they still had to learn things 'the hard way' like the rest of us -- just with a bit more resistance.

Difficulty and ability are orthogonal matters, but you seem to be trying to defend a hard/static correlation between them. Of course difficulty affects ability, but it doesn't limit/promote anything. As long as you keep exposing yourself to something, your brain will adapt to get more used to it (i.e. 'get better' at it). That doesn't indicate how fast you'll be at it, nor does it mean you can't start at a lower/higher point than other people (which in itself doesn't dictate whether you up superior/inferior to them) -- it just means it's possible.

oblique63··on Why there is no Hitchhiker’s Guide to Mathematics for Programmers
This argument would be great if you actually had any substance to back up your claims, without it you're not really arguing against anything. Perhaps I linked to a book written by a journalist because it's more accessible, and thus more helpful/actionable than published scientific papers? If math is difficult to grasp for some people, why would journal articles be any better? Not to mention that maybe the book itself has professional/scientific citations in case you were really interested in learning more?

Neuroscience supports the ability to acquire skills. The combination of epigenetics, GMOs, neuroplasticity, and many other advances make it even more apparent that adjusting ourselves is possible; even without a 'free will'[1].

If people don't feel like trying to learn/improve, that's fine; but they shouldn't try going around loosely justifying their actions with 'science' just because it makes themselves feel better.

[1] I only bring this up because determinism seems to be the biggest argument against this for some reason, but it really doesn't counter anything. Hell, I actually agree with it, and have written on the matter: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6235628

oblique63··on Why there is no Hitchhiker’s Guide to Mathematics for Programmers
"Now", as in an immensely tiny blink in the human evolutionary time-scale? Sorry, that's more wishful thinking than the notion of skill acquisition. Surely you're aware of feral children, and more 'normal' dyslexics; what's the deal with those? Clearly we should be reading straight out of the womb by now, so what gives?
oblique63··on Why there is no Hitchhiker’s Guide to Mathematics for Programmers
> It certainly took you many years to learn how to read and write, yet here you are.

Exactly. Most people don't realize how unnatural and difficult written language actually is, yet here we are. There's a great book on the subject called 'Proust and the Squid'[1]; it looks into the history, development and neuroscience of reading and it's quite eye-opening. There's really no reason to believe why math/music/programming/etc should be any different.

[1] http://www.amazon.com/Proust-Squid-Story-Science-Reading/dp/...

oblique63··on Why there is no Hitchhiker’s Guide to Mathematics for Programmers
Yes:

http://www.amazon.com/Talent-Code-Greatness-Born-Grown/dp/05...

Success/fame/fortune/happiness/etc are another matter, but skill acquisition has been shown to be generally straightforward. Some things may have higher learning curves for some people (e.g. math for a person with dyscalculia[1]), but that doesn't mean it's impossible.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dyscalculia

oblique63··on Gut Bacteria From Thin Humans Can Slim Mice Down
> There's a contingent of people who find this attitude morally offensive. They worked hard for their health and are disgusted by those who want an easy way... and also people who didn't work hard to stay thin and are thin anyways like the self-congratulatory notion that they're doing something right.

From my own experience, all the people that I know for sure 'worked hard' to achieve their fitness levels, are always the first to be the most understanding about the whole ordeal. Even the strong personality types. The vibe is always along the lines of: "yes, it can be incredibly difficult, and there are many paths to the same destination, but look at me -- it's possible!". I haven't seen many of of these people 'disgusted' at others who want an easier way, if anything they can probably sympathize cause they were probably there themselves at one point.

So that leaves the "didn't work hard" camp, and the "disgusted by an easy way out" bunch... Now, I'm not gonna draw any conclusions cause this is all anecdotal, and perhaps some people don't like to flaunt their successes or use them to inspire others, but it is tempting to make the correlation.

oblique63··on Gut Bacteria From Thin Humans Can Slim Mice Down
Not only that, it completely overlooks the current obesity epidemic. If it was really such an open-shut case, we probably could've at least contained the problem by now.

If a theory depends on mass laziness and ineptitude from the same ingenious species that brought us all our modern innovations and wisdom, then something's not right. It's disingenuous to suggest that such behaviour should be so natural and prevalent amongst human beings; especially when it has only just exploded in the last few decades...

oblique63··on Gut Bacteria From Thin Humans Can Slim Mice Down
If anybody is having trouble believing this, I highly recommend watching this documentary:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SeeFrcvt3KA

oblique63··on Certain bacteria may help ward off obesity
Sure, but this is talking about existing symbiotic bacterial communities that already inhabit healthy lean people anyway. The idea is to just transplant these into obese subjects and let them establish that same relationship in their new host. The title is misleading because we don't actually know whether it's the addition or subtraction of certain bacteria that produces the effects of obesity, just that the colonies are different.
oblique63··on Certain bacteria may help ward off obesity
I'm glad there's finally some evidence to support this theory, but it's not exactly a new line of thinking. There's already been literature published based around the correlation between gut flora and obesity, and one book that stands out and has actionable tips is 'The Diet Cure' [1]. I admittedly haven't got around to implementing it yet myself, but the concepts make sense. Either way, it was originally written in the late 90's, so I wouldn't expect it to be thoroughly modern in its reasoning and nomenclature with regards to these microbiome developments, but it's something...

[1] http://amzn.com/0143120859

oblique63··on Facebook is bad for you: Get a life
Whoops, I deleted my comment thinking it was pointless, but glad there's some agreement.

Here's what I posted for the record:

My oh my, now that was hostile.

I'm not a facebook fan, and I tend to agree with a lot of the arguments against it, but I think the OP was pointing out a crucial component of this dynamic: Facebook can be a total amplifier to your insecurities if you let it.

I know Facebook makes me insecure, despite not being so in my 'real' day-to-day life, so I don't use it unless I need to get a hold of somebody. I don't like staring at snippets of acquaintances' idealized/polished versions of themselves because it makes me question my own path, but I find it to be too much of a chore to tweak and adjust my feed/settings to try and eliminate that feeling; especially when the benefit I'd gain isn't gonna outweigh the time I'd lose (for me). So what do I do? I step away from it, but I'm honest with myself about why I did that.

There isn't much about Facebook that's obviously or inherently bad (privacy concerns aside for a minute), but I think that has more to do with how new such networking effects are to society. Are such social networks really healthy to our psyche long term? Who knows, but that may be what we're seeing symptoms of here.

OP's right that it seems it's because of insecurities that people don't like Facebook. What isn't so clear, is whether or not that amplifying effect it can have is healthy for some people. I think some people thrive on it and others just don't, so the problem is probably trying to argue that either side is 'right'.

oblique63··on Visualized Heartbeat Can Trigger ‘Out-of-Body Experience’
I don't entirely disagree, however the past thread I linked to makes me weary about pursuing this discussion further.

The problem is that we are seriously limited in what we can actually do/use if we base psychology entirely on this premise. I mean this both conceptually and technologically. We haven't fully mapped out the brain, we don't know about all the neurotransmitters out there, and we don't even know what fMRI shows us exactly, so we gotta be realistic with our expectations given our current limitations. Likewise, we don't actually fully know how most psychoactive compounds work to produce the effects they do, much less 'designer medications'. This isn't a reason to dismiss their usefulness though. There's a difference between being 'limited', and being 'wrong'. You could've made a similar argument about physics back before we really understood the atom (again, due to limitations).

Additionally, the notion of 'wrong' here is only relative to the philosophical theory of falsification, which is good, but has it's own set of gotchas and nuances that others have tried to address:

http://www.loyno.edu/~folse/Lakatos.html

http://philosophy.wisc.edu/forster/papers/Lakatos.htm

http://coraifeartaigh.wordpress.com/2011/02/13/the-philosoph...

http://andrewgelman.com/2004/10/14/bayes_and_poppe/

So while good, this definition of science is still far from a stable building-block to deem all nonconforming studies unequivocally 'wrong'.

oblique63··on Visualized Heartbeat Can Trigger ‘Out-of-Body Experience’
It's a semantic nit-pick about the definition of 'science'. He seems to have written an article about it here if you're curious: http://www.arachnoid.com/psychology/index.html

Take it with a grain of salt though: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6194296

Either way, this argument is rather orthogonal to whether-or-not the situation is actually 'worthy' of future investigation. So it could still be useful, however the relative maturity of the field limits how accurately we can assess that.

oblique63··on Keep Your Unsolicited Redesign to Yourself
It's not so much about the practice itself as it is just a general presentation problem.

It's alright to fork a particular software project if you don't like the way the main branch is going, but good luck promoting it by throwing the original under the bus. Same story when starting new competing projects/frameworks. That slippery slope isn't unique to designers.

oblique63··on I'm 23, An Entrepreneur, and Fucking Terrified.
I'm 24 and I agree with you 100%.

Entrepreneurship isn't a lifestyle I suggest to anyone, however, it is a great tool/means to fulfil something you want. Approaching it from the view of avoiding mediocrity is not only gonna put you in the difficult 'lifestyle' column, but it will also not be a very useful perspective for your entrepreneurial goals either. If you're really committed to living the entrepreneurial lifestyle, the best way to view it is as a journey to greatness: aspire to be with the best, not to avoid the 'average'. The former gives you hope and encouragement, while the latter is insulting to the those around you. If you're using entrepreneurship as a means to an end (like I am), it'll still be hard, but once you have that perspective it becomes easier to lay out a path for yourself regardless of the circumstances.

I've been snuffed out of jobs by friends I helped hire, I've had relationships fall apart to the point of becoming suicidal, I have no medical insurance and have endured multiple visits to the ER, I've had my apartment robbed and then got promptly kicked out because new roommates decided to get overly rowdy while I was gone, I've been shot at in broad daylight, I've unintentionally contracted with shady characters that fled the country and left me empty handed with silly lawsuits and court dates that I had to go out of my way to forfeit, I've been identity thefted losing all my money just as rent was due along with some of those ER bills, I haven't had more than 4 figures in my bank account for about half a year, my credit cards are maxed, I've had most of my belongings locked up in a storage unit for over 2 years because of these fiascos, and I'm now back to living with my parents because I couldn't afford to continue living on my own after quitting a job at a startup that required an overly-long commute that took a toll on my health to the point where I developed muscle spasms and began getting panic-attacks in the middle of the workday.

But you know what? It's all good. All that stuff might have been hell and made me nearly hysterical at points, but I know what my end goal is, and I know entrepreneurship is the only way I'll ever achieve it. If shit gets in my way, oh well, I'll just come up with a new plan to adjust for it (and I already have). I don't care about 'mediocrity', I just care that I achieve what I set out to do, because that's what makes me happy, and the only way I'll ever fail is if I give up pursuing it.

oblique63··on Hack your motivation
The last point is particularly useful, and quite reminiscent of what 'The Now Habit'[1][2] advocates. Some weeks I get so completely burned out, I have to force myself to do nothing but 'veg out' by watching endless netflix shows through the weekend without thinking about anything else. It's hard to allow it at first because it feels like a ludicrous waste of time, but it becomes surprisingly refreshing by the end of it.

[1] http://www.amazon.com/The-Now-Habit-Overcoming-Procrastinati...

[2] Here's a good video series that summarizes it's key points: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=63Si3Gb1WSg

oblique63··on Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks
I agree. I'm fairly convinced that the nutritional world is in a dark age right now, and I wouldn't be surprised if all those problems you listed continue til long after I'm gone.

I don't advocate for soylent, but I'm not against it either, and that's only because I honestly don't know what to make of any meal replacement. Right now, making claims like potentially curing world hunger are much too premature when factoring in how little we know (i.e. we literally wouldn't know when we had such a cure if it slapped us in the face); thus I wouldn't be surprised if much of HN is backlashing based on those marketing claims. If instead it was billed less like a product, and more like a long-term research project into the intricacies of nutrition, then I know I would've backed it (and it would've made it a lot clearer that you're investing for a chance to be a guinea pig, rather than paying to be a consumer of a life-altering product). Because despite the fact that MRPs have been in constant research by other companies, a fresh open engineering perspective would still be welcome. They still have a chance to pivot that way, but some stuff like what's in this reddit thread, is a bit concerning: http://www.reddit.com/r/TrueReddit/comments/1jvsie/the_man_w... I don't particularly like the attitude of the comment, but it does make some good points.

oblique63··on Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks
I don't know why people downvoted you, but it's true that you need testing to explore these things. Unfortunately, it's one of those things where you can't just prove the absence of something (in this case: danger).

I found the preceding comment equally odd:

> We can nonetheless have a strong presumption that the body does best on whole foods.

Not really. The commenter even said it himself: "we don't know what we don't know about food". We can acknowledge that 'whole foods' are adequately sustainable for humans, but extrapolating any additional meaning from their traditional role is baseless without further study. Thus, saying that 'adequate' == 'best' is making a huge leap of logic in an area that we haven't even figured out enough to begin optimizing it yet.

I don't support soylent, and I don't believe any other MRPs are fully adequate either, but that doesn't mean we should throw out the baby with the bathwater here...

oblique63··on Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks
I believe the parent's point wasn't the accuracy of the information you'd be receiving, but just the exercise of evaluating conflicting viewpoints and coming out more enlightened as a result of it. Believe it or not, being able to apply that anywhere (as opposed to just thinking you can) is a skill, and skills need practice. It's an important part of thinking critically, and it can easily be lacking in a lot of very smart people.

EDIT: It wasn't my intention to offend if that was the reason behind the downvotes. It wasn't about anybody specifically, I was just trying to elaborate on a slippery slope issue that seems to be common among smart people.

← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →