HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

obscurette

1,992 karma · joined November 27, 2019

submissionscomments
obscurette··on America is getting an AI gold rush instead of a factory boom
It really just depends. There might short/small runs which are easily automated, and there might be a large scale production which are not and need hand assembly. The very same product might see both during production – fully automated robots and hand assembly etc.
obscurette··on In-Party Love, Out-Party Hate, and Affective Polarization in Twelve Democracies
Unfortunately it's not that simple any more. There are already very fundamental issues on which we are already very polarized, online or not. One of these is safety for example – far too many people are ready to give up any freedoms in the name of security. Ideas for EU chatcontrol, camera networks etc don't come from some bureaucrats, there is a very broad social demand for this.
obscurette··on The deadline isn't when AI outsmarts us – it's when we stop using our own minds
It doesn't work for many reasons. For example it's completely normal for a young people to do things only because they are forced to. It doesn't matter how you customize it, how immediate your feedback is etc. I know that I'd used AI to do a lot of school work without learning anything because why not? Fortunately I hadn't any chance for that in seventies. And who/what determines each student's interests and needs? And is it even OK to align for these? I can very confidently say that if my school would align to my specific interests and needs back then, I'd be dead by now. I wouldn't have knowledge and experience to survive changing times.
obscurette··on The deadline isn't when AI outsmarts us – it's when we stop using our own minds
Are you a parent? Have you ever seen a kid growing up? 90%+ of kids wouldn't care at all about any work or learning without social pressure from parents, teachers and peers. That's the whole point of schools – to create a social pressure to put all this knowledge into heads of kids in hope that some of this would be useful for them. And to do it through all these awfully messy years we call childhood and adolescence.
obscurette··on The deadline isn't when AI outsmarts us – it's when we stop using our own minds
My professor at uni said that people who have learned to search for information before the internet came along are the best at searching for information on the internet. My personal experience agrees and I'm very glad I'm one of such people.
obscurette··on Americans increasingly see legal sports betting as a bad thing for society
I've seen gambling destroying more lives than alcohol in my lifetime. And I live in the area which is rather on top of the world by alcohol consumption per capita.
obscurette··on Ultrasonic Chef's Knife
When I was in school (in seventies), all boys at least tried to learn how to use and take care of all sharp tools and machines with one up to wood and metal lathe. When I was in school now as a teacher, scissors were the only somewhat sharp things kids were allowed to use. Risk tolerance is so low in our society nowadays, sense of responsibility of children is nonexistent etc.
obscurette··on Aaron Levie: Startups win in the AI era [video]
I've seen AI replacing a lot of jobs already in regulatory/consultancy business making billions. A lot of people producing paperwork for regulative etc purposes have been replaced by language models. My question – should this business really exist at all?
obscurette··on 3D modeling with paper
These were popular in Soviet Union as well. At least in seventies in Baltic states where I grew up.
obscurette··on US High school students' scores fall in reading and math
Every cultural/policy/etc change in society has huge delays. Especially in education - changes you implement have an impact 10+ years later. Culture, even if it's dying, dies slowly. Here in Estonia where I live at the moment educational systems is falling completely apart – overworked and bullied teachers escape from schools in unprecedented rate, there is 20% less teachers than there is a need etc. But Estonia is still in top of the PISA. Why? Because this culture of personal responsibility and valuing education is still alive in the generation of todays parents. But it's certainly dying here as well.
obscurette··on US High school students' scores fall in reading and math
As someone old (60+) who was a teacher in school and thinking a lot about it:

- It's mostly a cultural shift in the western world – we don't value personal responsibility any more. When I was in school in seventies, it was my responsibility to study no matter what since grade 1. It didn't matter whether I liked a teacher, topic or whatever. It's not the case any more.

- Since nineties there has been a shift in educational sciences and practices from "old school" memorizing as "rote learning" and explicit instruction toward "critical thinking skills". Sounds nice for many, but in practice it doesn't work. Barb Oakley has a wonderful paper about it "The Memory Paradox: Why Our Brains Need Knowledge in an Age of AI"[1].

- Smartphones, social media etc certainly contribute and the rise of LLMs will make it even worse.

[1] - https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5250447

obscurette··on What medieval people got right about learning (2019)
It's not that bad in theory, but it's true that modern "no homework!", "no boring practice!" etc directions have done a lot of damage during last decades. But it answers quite well to common complaints why we are still learn to solve quadratic function in school although almost nobody uses it later in their lives? It's because quadratic function is a simplest way to lay a foundation to understand a tons of broad theoretical concepts about functions – turning points, zeros, decreasing, increasing, symmetry etc.
obscurette··on A brief history of the absurdities of the Soviet Union
They absolutely can live in the constant congitive dissonance state. I did 30 years of my life. Many of us did. I know it's hard to believe for people living all their life in the free world, but constant congitive dissonance was just part of the reality for us.
obscurette··on Teacher AI use is already out of control and it's not ok
As a teacher – excellent description, thank you. Just to add my experience to it – I was in school in seventies and had "40 years since graduating" meeting some years ago with my classmates. Vast majority were doing well and while we talked about old times in school, two things stood out. At first while we were in the same class, our experience was very different. We remembered very different things, different teachers were important to us up to the point where some of them were most loved ones to some, but most hated ones to others etc. But we all agreed that our homes were even more important for our education than school – from our homes (parents and grandparents) came the attitude that education is important and no matter what, it's our responsibility to study.
obscurette··on Teacher AI use is already out of control and it's not ok
I have a bunch of coworkers who paste various LLM outputs to every chat while discussing issues in production.

- "LLM X told that we should try to add this into configuration file – SOMETHING_SOMETHING = false."

- "There is no SOMETHING_SOMETHING configuration option, you have a full source, grep for it."

- "But should we try at least?"

obscurette··on Linux dev quits after "personal attacks" from user over antivirus tool
They are over-represented everywhere. We live in society where being martyr is highly valued, others are not allowed to ignore it and set their boundaries. If you do, you are an asshole and have no empathy.
obscurette··on Open Sauce is a confoundingly brilliant Bay Area event
As a teacher I have become more skeptical about whole maker movement. Don't get me wrong - I really appreciate what has become possible. I couldn't even dream about most of it when I grew up in seventies in Soviet Union. I use a lot of open source hardware and the results maker movement myself as a hobbyist and as a teacher.

But the problem is that while kids like it a lot, it doesn't translate to engineering careers. Kids don't want to become engineers as result, they want to become content creators, tinkerers etc. Even rather good students with a lot of potential see all this engineering stuff more as a media career or a fun hobby.

PS. I don't say the engineering hobby isn't cool and fun. I don't say that maker movement doesn't produce incredibly cool and deep stuff. I'm not even saying that it's the only reason why there is a shortage of engineers. But it's certainly contributing because I see it.

I'm a member of local engineering community and I see a lot of stuff like the quality of civil engineering sinking and we're all paying for mistakes in it. I see a lot of local production closing only because all R&D engineers are 60+ and planning to retire.

obscurette··on Nobody has a personality anymore: we are products with labels
In seventies when I was in school (yes, I'm old) I had a classmate who wasn't able to recognize faces. We all knew that it's a thing, accepted, that he can make errors recognizing us and didn't think much more about it. I certainly remember reading about it as well.
obscurette··on Vision Language Models Are Biased
I suspect that responses are altered/corrected based on what people query from popular online models. I have had several occasions that I ask some "How do I ... in X software?" question some day and model keeps hallucinating nonexistant config options regardless how many times I keep saying "This option doesn't exist in software X". But if I asked the same question some days later, the answer was completely different and made even some sense.
obscurette··on I am concerned about the future. Are you?
The whole problem with China is only marginally about what it does (IP theft, manipulations of financial markets etc are real), but mostly about what the rest of the world doesn't do. Most of the world have stopped to solve the problems. My friend has a pet theory that it's about the rise of social media – we stopped to care about how things are and only care about how things look to others. People who do, make mistakes; building something is always somehow bad for environment etc etc. It's more rewarding for people to look better persons in social media than do something and risk with their image. While it's certainly naive, I think there is something in it.
obscurette··on Estonia eschews phone bans in schools and takes leap into AI
Previous discussion - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44094169
obscurette··on Trying to teach in the age of the AI homework machine
Education is bound to culture and life in general. We just can't imagine nowadays how fatalistic and submissive to god and authority people's world view was before protestants in medieval Europe. An education bound to memorization and pretty violent culture helped to mould the people society needed at the time. But it wasn't always like that. There were quite different views to learning in ancient Greek, during golden age of islam etc.
obscurette··on Trying to teach in the age of the AI homework machine
In general – why I'd put my effort into visiting (and paying for) a school and learning in such case? That's not what schools are for. I can get any amount of grades I want from LLM myself.
obscurette··on Estonia eschews phone bans in schools and leaps into AI
> Kallas said there were no mobile phone bans in schools in Estonia. On the contrary: a smartphone is seen as part and parcel of Estonia’s highly successful digital education policy. “I’ve not heard of any problems, to be honest,” she said.

This is just plain wrong. There are bans in many schools which are able to enforce the rules, not all can do it for various reasons unfortunately. There was a public letter published last year from parents, experts of education etc to the Ministry of Education regarding the issue, but unfortunately it was ignored completely. In Estonia the current push to AI in schools and attitude of Ministry of Education in general is seen as arrogant at best, corruptive at worst.

https://www.err.ee/1609469623/avalik-kiri-nutiseadmete-kasut...

obscurette··on I'd rather read the prompt
People thought that social media in our pockets can be amazing tool to help to connect the humanity if used correctly. And here we are.

And about oral exams ... I agree that these are amazing. In seventies and eighties when I was in school, most of exams were oral. But our society is really afraid of these, because oral exams are always subjective.

obscurette··on Deepfake porn is destroying real lives in South Korea
While thinking can't (and must not) be criminalized, materializing a fantasies even in "nonharmful" way can damage people a lot – these materials can be found for example.
obscurette··on Careless People
I didn't talk about these people, I was talking about society in general. And the problem with even slight erosion of responsibility is that sociopaths benefit most.
obscurette··on Careless People
I think that's true for our society in general at the moment. Everyone can behave like an asshole and it's completely OK for a society if they say "I had a tough childhood and haven't received a professional help".
obscurette··on The skill of the future is not 'AI', but 'Focus'
I'm old enough to remember myriad of experts 10+ years ago who were active selling a view, that smartphones with constantly connected social media will change everything, we just have to learn to use it wisely.
obscurette··on TikTok is harming children at an industrial scale
It's not much better with adults. I see it even with people in my age (I'm in my sixties). I take long walks (several hours) with my dog and if I tell about it to people the same age as me, a common question follows – "What headphones you use?". I don't use headphones, it's only me with my thoughts. And people say that they can't do it (any more).
← PreviousPage 3 of 9Next →