HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

oceanofsolaris

203 karma · joined July 29, 2014

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/sburkhardt; my proof: https://keybase.io/sburkhardt/sigs/lKtY-9JgDzPy0FpbRlVp6gKqX6iDFfBCSV2XNve5pBo ]
submissionscomments
oceanofsolaris··on A 24-year-old made $345K in 2 months by beating Kickstarters to market
What seems weird about this is that he did very little of actual 'beating Kickstarters to the market'. If you read the article, he is just selling things that are already listed on alibaba(so it's the chinese manufacturers who are beating Kickstarters to the market).

So the question is: where does the margin of the guy in the article come from? If you read the article, he bought the toys for 2.5$ or so on alibaba and sold them for 20$. That's quite a markup for...some marketing. You could at any time probably have gone to aliexpress and gotten the same thing for 4$ including shipping.

I think the answer is that not enough people in China are savy in how to market their products to US+EU. And not enough people from US+EU are aware of the gadget candy-store that is Aliexpress. The overall profit is too small for a large company to swoop in, so what is left are some shady indiegogo campains (that try to sell a product that is already offered on alibaba) and the kind of company portrayed in this article.

oceanofsolaris··on After a month on a cash diet, here are my best money saving tips
Thats certainly true. Usually, these cases are done with money transfers in Europe, which is not really reversible (on the other hand, this is where many people use Paypal, which also gives you the money-back feature of a CC).
oceanofsolaris··on After a month on a cash diet, here are my best money saving tips
But then, it is not that easy to defraud the EC cards, since you need the physical card to make a payment with them (in addition to a PIN that is usually needed to authorize the payment).
oceanofsolaris··on What Romance Really Means After 10 Years of Marriage
While you may or may not agree with his opinion or the way he worded it, a personal attack on him is really unwarranted (besides, I don't even get what's that bad about his job description?!).

I think we can all agree that it is nicer to have an atmosphere where you can share your opinion without your work being attacked by strangers.

oceanofsolaris··on Missiles of North Korea
Your link explicitly mentions that the equipment found in this specific vessel is probably not the original one:

Speaking of equipment, it was obvious the submarine was stripped of any useful electronic equipment, such as navigation or communication equipment. In its place were items taken from a dump.

I imagine that all the original equipment was removed and analyzed by a South Korean Intelligence Service before the Sub became accessible to the public.

oceanofsolaris··on Why don't more physicists subscribe to pilot wave theory?
Okay, that is of course true :)

So replace "it is an inherently hard problem" by "it is most likely an inherently hard problem".

oceanofsolaris··on Why don't more physicists subscribe to pilot wave theory?
It is deterministic, but you still need to keep track of a field that covers your whole configuration space (basically you need all the information contained in a function R^n->C for n degrees of freedom). Keeping track this high-dimensional field is what makes a quantum computer hard to simulate in the first place, not the non-determinism. So no, it doesn't make anything easier to simulate.

This makes a lot of sense if you think of it that way: Pilot wave theory gives exactly the same results as any other decent interpretation of quantum mechanics. So the work necessary to simulate it will also be exactly the same. Simulating quantum mechanics is not hard because we don't understand it. It is hard because it is an inherently hard problem (otherwise, how could quantum computers be faster than classical computers?).

oceanofsolaris··on WikipediaP2P
Hi, thanks for replying. I think the idea of a distributedly mirrored wikipedia is great, so thanks for this project (even if some users seem to encounter high cpu load using it).

So, do I understand correctly that each page (that has been distributed through WP2P) includes the hashes for all the linked pages? But I assume these hashes are only for the content, not the metadata of the linked pages. So a malicious actor could still inject a bad page (that includes bad hashes for linked pages) if he wanted.

It is true that signed wikipedia pages would be a really neat idea, since it would enable this as well as other distributed projects to make sure they are displaying the "real" version of the site.

oceanofsolaris··on WikipediaP2P
Ok, that's not too unreasonable (especially if you need to download an extension anyways). If you make delta updates available for changed pages, this should actually be reasonably small once you have done the initial download.
oceanofsolaris··on WikipediaP2P
Thanks for actually looking into the mentioned problems instead of going on a tangent about climate change ;)

CacheP2P seems to solve the problem by including a list of sha1 hashes for all files that are distributed through P2P.

Speculation time:

I guess distributing the sha1 hashes for every wikipedia page is a bit too much (especially considering they are always changing). So with every page, you would only distribute the hash for those sites that are directly linked from it.

If you provide the correct sha1 hash for every linked website (which in turn includes the hashes of all linked websites from it...), you would form some kind of merkle-tree of wikipedia pages. Except that the graph of wikipedia pages is certainly highly cyclic (thus no tree), so this isn't feasible. And all the pages change all the time. So this naive approach has already two strikes against it and does certainly not work.

I will try to have a look at the source code at some later point, I guess.

oceanofsolaris··on WikipediaP2P
Let's reformulate it then: topics where some actors have a strong incentive (monetary or emotional) to manipulate other peoples opinion.
oceanofsolaris··on WikipediaP2P
I understand that this is an early implementation.

Nevertheless, I have a question: how does it make sure the site you receive is actually the

a) correct one (someone could distribute incorrect pages e.g. about controversial topics like North Korea or Climate Change; or inject some malicious code that e.g. uses your account to submit changes to wikipedia)

b) most recent one (or at least a reasonably new one).

I imagine the first one could maybe be somehow guaranteed through the protocol. Maybe you can just solve the second by invalidating your local copy after it is more than one day old.

The github link on the homepage does sadly not work for me (firefox on linux), so I can't check.

oceanofsolaris··on Lenovo will adopt the ‘Moto’ label for its smartphones
At least in europe there was an LTE version that had an SD-card slot, an actual compass and gyroscope and the eponymous LTE support. My girlfriend still uses it and is a really nice phone (except for the, by now, ridiculously bad camera).
oceanofsolaris··on What’s wrong with Git? A conceptual design analysis
You can get very similar functionality for git with "magit", which is an emacs package for managing git.

That said: Partially commiting files is indeed very handy and it would be great if it was available to more people.

oceanofsolaris··on The Technical Interview Rift
Not to sound too snobby (I would have notrecognized the Newton-Raphson method is by its name either), but I think it is at least plausible to figure out the method on the spot.

If you either know how the first order of a Taylor series looks like or just brainstorm a bit about how the derivative could help you in finding a root, you will figure out the Newton-Raphson method rather quickly. But then, it really depends on the job whether this is actually knowledge the interviewer would want to test.

That said, I completely understand that even if you would have the required knowledge, it is really easy to fumble during a high-stress situation.

oceanofsolaris··on With the iPhone 7, Apple Changed the Camera Industry
Well, it still serves the purpose of emphasizing the foreground. It does, however, not look like the depth of field you would expect from a 'real camera'. But I don't see it as 'ruining' photos. It's just a tool in your toolbox for creating pictures.
oceanofsolaris··on Elementary OS Loki 0.4 Stable Release
I think using arch as its basis would clash too much with their target audience. I have not tried Antergos or Manjaro, but at least arch itself is often rather high-maintenance due to its rolling release nature.

I think someone looking for an easy-to-use desktop would not be amused if her/his touchpad stops working one day or the system would not boot properly.

Using a LTS Ubuntu or Debian as a basis allows you to not worry so much about things breaking and focus your energy on the added value you provide.

oceanofsolaris··on We might live in a computer program but it may not matter
As long as not all the memory is actually used, you can pretend that there is 20GB though. Once you actually need to map more than there is, you would need to stop the virtual machine.

If you read e.g. the Bostrom 2003 paper, you will see that this is more or less what they claim: If your simulation technique is good enough, you can just fake most of the universe and only actually perform fine-grained simulations where it matters. This would e.g. assume that you have special simulation rules for brains, large scale chemical reactions etc., which allows you to just skip most of the details and make them up once you need them. You could even automatically detect whether your simulation is fine grained enough by running the same simulation at two different granularities at the same time, readjusting whenever the outcome between the two differs too much.

I think the argument in its original form does not make too much sense (future humans simulating todays humans for research and fun). What you would probably simulate much more, are human-like entities in a much simpler universe (e.g. no weird quantum-mechanics that are really hard to simulate).

So in my opinion, you could take away from the simulation argument that there is a non-zero chance that we are living in a simulation. But the computer that performs the simulation most probably lives in a universe that does not follow the same rules our universe does. It might be a universe with two or more time-like dimensions. It might be one where quantum mechanics are just super-easy to simulate for some reason (maybe in the same way it would be really easy to e.g. build Conways game of life in transistor hardware for us).

oceanofsolaris··on Uber Loses at Least $1.2B in First Half of 2016
So in the longer run, either the drivers will have to work for less than they are willing to or the customers have to pay more than they are willing to. Or Uber has to keep paying the tab.
oceanofsolaris··on Uber Loses at Least $1.2B in First Half of 2016
If a company is investing in production facilities, building up a supply chain or R&D, I can completely understand how losing money is a solid strategy. It is basically taking a loan to invest in being a better company in the future.

On the other hand, losing money by handing out free stuff (cheap rides in this case) only makes sense if you want to either bankrupt your competitors or increase the awareness of your brand. Since Uber is at least not a complete unknown anymore at this point, all signs point towards the "driving out competitors" strategy. This might still be a viable business plan for Uber (though I don't see how to be honest), but certainly not one that should be cheered.

oceanofsolaris··on Uber Loses at Least $1.2B in First Half of 2016
But only if they are fully occupied > 90% of all time (which is IMHO not really feasible).
oceanofsolaris··on Philae Lander: “It’s time for me to say goodbye”
If I understood correctly, the decision not to use an RTG was also due to its weight.

That said, it seems there is not much know-how about RTGs at ESA, which is most likely also influenced by political reasons.

oceanofsolaris··on The Spanish cooking oil scandal (2001)
Actually, the last paragraph of the linked wikipedia article mentions the organo-phosphate theory (it somewhat labels it as conspiracy-theory, but it mentions it).

The talk page actually mentions a kind of rebuttal to the organo-phosphate theory (which claims that the symptoms are not compatible with organo-phosphate poisoning):

http://ije.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/reprint/33/3/443

I can't really evaluate any of these claims since my expertise in this field is non-existant. Things might be as simple as described in the Guardian article (which portrays the organo-phosphate theory as self-evident but suppressed truth), or maybe more complicated. The forced resignation of all responsible researchers certainly smells very funny and the Spanish government seems to have tried to suppress the truth or at least give the impression that they were able to handle things by suppressing dissenting opinions.

oceanofsolaris··on Colorful Image Colorization
This is rather impressive. Similarly to the cited work http://tinyclouds.org/colorize/, it does however seem to have a slight bias towards brownish colors (giving many images a sepia look).

One thing very noticeable in both works is also the tendency to overshoot borders when coloring. In many images it can be seen that the color of the main subject bleeds into the background. A good example is e.g. the fifth picture in http://richzhang.github.io/colorization/resources/images/exs... , where parts of the sky get assigned the same color as the mesa. This looks like something that should be fixable if one tries to detect these kind of edges and gives less weight to information from the other side of such an edge.

Does anyone know what the differences between this and the previous neural net approach are on a technical level?

oceanofsolaris··on Anatomy of a Co-Branded Credit Card
It's simply a misspelled version of "manifold", isn't it? And if you replace it by "manifold", the sentence makes perfect sense.
oceanofsolaris··on More Encryption, More Notifications, More Email Security
To be honest, I don't even see the point of setting a separate passphrase for your PGP on a machine you own if it adds any hassle for you [1]. I don't see why you PGP key should be so different from every other password you use. Sure, PGP does not have forward secrecy, but neither does gmail if someone grabs your password.

I agree with you that if you want to actually improve the security of the people who are right now not using any encryption, make encryption easy to use. Even if this means that it might not fit the threat-model of those targeted by state-actors.

IMHO, PGP could actually be used for this (even if it might not be the perfect fit) by using Trust On First Use, better interfaces and more integration into mail clients. The problem is that it is right now a tool used and made by those who want really strong security. This includes e.g. encouraging you to set a passphrase, which makes it more secure, but also more of a hassle for most people.

[1] This is obviously only true if you don't fear it being compromised / your security requirements are low. But then, if you need strong security, use full disk encryption and Qubes or something similar.

oceanofsolaris··on The Difficulty of Private Contact Discovery
I have to say that this sounds very reasonable (and certainly a lot better than sending your plain text contacts).

Does anyone know what kind of solution Signal is using nowadays? The linked article is not very recent and they might have changed their method in the meantime. I had a quick look at their source but was not successful in finding the relevant part for uploading the contacts.

oceanofsolaris··on The Difficulty of Private Contact Discovery
As far as I can see this is quite similar to the 'sharded bloom filter' discussed in the submitted link.

This approach is dismissed in the document as

> In the end, this strategy seems to provide very little at the cost of fairly substantial complexity.

Since it seems you use it for silent circle, how does it work there? How many 'longer hashes' do clients get on average per submitted 'short hash'? How large is the 'false positive' rate you get from the long hashes? Since the argument against the 'sharded bloom filter' in the submitted link boils down to 'the tradeoffs don't work', I would be very interested to know how these tradeoffs work out for silent circle.

As far as I understand, you would still need to have some rate limiting in order to stop someone to collect all registered phone numbers though, wouldn't you?

oceanofsolaris··on Free, Worldwide, Encrypted Phone Calls for iPhone (2014)
The desktop app also works with chromium. But then, you need to have the mobile app installed to use the desktop app...

Look, I don't think that Signal is that great against targeted attacks. The fact that you have to install it on a not too trustworthy platform (android/iOS), that you need to register with a phone number and that it broadcasts the fact that you use Signal to everyone who knows your phone number all make it a bit hard to recommend when you need very strong security.

But then, Signal seems to be targeted at the 'average user' and it features top notch cryptography. It does that in order to thwart mass surveillance. I think this is an admirable goal and that Signal achieves it. If you think you might be targeted by a three letter agency, use something different for your sensitive communications.

oceanofsolaris··on What happens when you pour molten aluminium into an anthill?
This looks rather nice and neatly displays an aspect of ant colonies that is hard to see otherwise. When done for research, I think that this is awesome. Have a look at the concrete pouring of a leafcutter ant colony (which is huge and has a very interesting layout) if you find this interesting: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lFg21x2sj-M

But then, having this memorial to an ant colony extinguished by hot molten metal sitting in my room strikes me as a bit macabre. At least intuitively, I don't even feel that sorry for the ant colony (which I think is the relevant organism eradicated here, not the individual ants), but turning its death into a work of art still feels tasteless. But then, I have ants as pets (I can only recommend to do that, it is not too much work but very interesting), so maybe I am overly sentimental here.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →