HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

odyssey7

1,876 karma · joined March 15, 2018

submissionscomments
odyssey7··on Music Theory for the 21st-Century Classroom
Insightful. The title being more to distinguish than to describe.
odyssey7··on Music Theory for the 21st-Century Classroom
> learning the slightly clunky but universally-known written language is generally the way to go

A certain Amazon Web Services comes to mind…

odyssey7··on Music Theory for the 21st-Century Classroom
I’m sympathetic to this viewpoint, but most music students in the classroom will be playing instruments or singing rather than working in DAWs.

The instruments, music, and notation all evolved together in a shared tradition that make them well-suited for one another.

odyssey7··on Harnessing the Universal Geometry of Embeddings
> It's not science until it passes peer review.

We all know that science is about experiments and evidence whereas peer review is a social process.

Confusing science with peer review is very unscientific. Galileo’s work did not pass the dominant socio-scientific review process of his day and we all know how that turned out. Peer review serves a purpose but peer review is not science per se — unless, perhaps, your field is sociology, and you study the social processes of science practitioners, so that peer review outcomes are the evidence that you use to study those social processes.

odyssey7··on Harnessing the Universal Geometry of Embeddings
The pace of things is moving along so rapidly right now, I’m not sure that waiting for peer reviews is always a wise move. Doubly so if there’s a paywall; why limit your article’s impact by placing it where practitioners’ agents might not be able to access it? The rapid progress right now is challenging for conventional academic processes.

If the value of the paper is difficult to independently verify, for example, if it depends on the credibility of the author, then the academic ritual can add something. If it’s a mathematical result, one that can be automatically verified, or a machine learning technique that anyone can try with Claude code reconstructing it for them, this sort of pre-print publishing model is advantageous.

odyssey7··on Music Theory for Programmers
+1 on recommending Schoenberg. Harmonielehre is a philosophical work as much as it is a music theory treatise.
odyssey7··on South African diamond mines are closing due to weak sales and lab-grown stones
If we figure out low-energy fusion for economical lab-origin gold, imagine what businesses would close if that were to happen.

The transmutations are possible, it’s just that the energy currently required is worth more than the gold would be. Colder fusion -> cheaper lab-origin gold.

odyssey7··on Music Theory for Programmers
All too true.

Something along these lines, people who would like to improve their musical abilities sometimes procrastinate by doing music theory instead. It's safe and it's introspective. And it's authoritative---a legitimate and difficult subject---so there's the potential to feel falsely reassured that you're not wasting time. In a sense, it avoids the more difficult act of creation. This seems to be especially more likely for those who would have wanted to write music.

I.e., "drink responsibly." Perhaps music theory classes should come with a warning label, like the Mirror of Erised. You can stare into it endlessly and produce nothing.

odyssey7··on Music Theory for Programmers
Yes, I agree, the rabbit hole is real. It has taken many people away from their initial intention of making music. If you're a musician first and foremost, music theory can be a trap. Although, Alice in Wonderland also shows us the intrinsic value of a good rabbit hole.

Edit: Also, what you mention about "why" is true. The models attempt to organize observations of conscious experiences into mathematical and logical frameworks, though they cannot ultimately explain the causes for those connections. The causes of the qualia remain mysterious. Musicians tend to be particularly in tune with how their own experiences connect to music, so some are enthralled to explore that connection itself.

odyssey7··on Music Theory for Programmers
Fair enough. Models tend to be imperfect, and music theory is definitely no exception to that rule, and we attempt to model music because we care about the underlying phenomenon (music).

As someone who enjoys listening to music, creating music, and music theory, I'd characterize the latter as providing a specialized vocabulary; an approach to listening, since words in the vocabulary represent concepts that you can hear; and a toolbox of concepts you can draw from.

It's a model, you can use it as much or as little as you like. And there's more than one model, and sometimes the different models overlap more or less, and you can choose any of them or none of them and still make and enjoy music.

The other thing it provides is a wildly complex logical system with fascinating philosophical connections. Some people enjoy exploring that more than making music with it, and that's also okay. I've certainly gotten a lot of enjoyment out of that. It's made me a better thinker. In math, formulas can be elegant. In music theory, different constructions induce different experiences.

odyssey7··on Actively exploited sandbox RCE in all Chromium versions
If I couldn't guarantee memory safety, I wouldn't. We're talking about an optional feature for JavaScript engines.

Security is where the rubber hits the road. It's whether customers' identities get stolen. It's whether leaders of undemocratic countries can monitor communications, locations, and social networks of people whom they oppress.

Calling this an "ivory tower" criticism is, ironically, a lack of acknowledgement of reality and that our actions have consequences to others.

odyssey7··on Actively exploited sandbox RCE in all Chromium versions
If including JIT in a system renders its developer incapable of guaranteeing memory safety, then perhaps that developer’s approach to JIT is not yet mature enough to ethically distribute to non-technical consumers who are not positioned to evaluate that their security is being traded off by the developer on their behalf.

We’re past the era where security issues emanating from memory-unsafe code were tolerated due to being unavoidable — continuing to expose your software’s users to them in this present day and age is simply a choice.

odyssey7··on Actively exploited sandbox RCE in all Chromium versions
How many Heartbleeds[1] must software users and our national security interests endure before the industry treats memory safety as a best practice for systems with exposure to the Internet?

The V8 vulnerability being exploited today, CVE-2026-85046, is listed in NVD under CWE-843, "Access of Resource Using Incompatible Type ('Type Confusion')."[2] On this class of vulnerabilities, MITRE explains:

> When a memory buffer is accessed using the wrong type, it could read or write memory out of the bounds of the buffer

Memory safety is specifically intended to prevent errors like these from becoming arbitrary out-of-bounds memory access and native code execution. Even type safety --- from the 1970s --- can prevent type confusion.

The CISA and the NSA have called for the adoption of memory-safe languages.[3] We exercise poor engineering judgment and poor ethics, as an industry, when we continue to expose users to classes of wholly avoidable security weaknesses in Internet-facing software.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heartbleed

[2] https://cwe.mitre.org/data/definitions/843.html

[3] https://www.nsa.gov/Press-Room/Press-Releases-Statements/Pre...

odyssey7··on Actively exploited sandbox RCE in all Chromium versions
When Chromium and V8 are written in a memory-safe language then I might believe this.

Yes, if your JavaScript engine is written in C++, it’s going to be very hard to avoid very gross bugs. We have better options now.

The ability of adversaries to find and exploit very gross bugs in C++ codebases should have already compelled the industry to move to memory safety. Now that AI has democratized the ability to scour C++ codebases for really gross and exploitable bugs, I should think that our hands are at last being forced. I’m not impressed by what I’ve seen in the industry with respect to taking memory safety seriously.

odyssey7··on Actively exploited sandbox RCE in all Chromium versions
It’s really a shame that my engineering school requires me to use Google Chrome because their Honorlock browser extension[1] requires Google Chrome.

You would think that an engineering school would be wiser than to require their students use a specific web browser that’s tied to a specific vendor.

[1] https://app.honorlock.com/install/extension

odyssey7··on LLMs and Self-Referentiality
It “throws” an error when “it tries” “to talk” to the “server.”

We’ve been speaking as if the computers were conscious for a long time already.

odyssey7··on Aging brains blend memories together instead of just forgetting them
Comet Hale-Bopp is definitely a case of this for me. Although I remember a few interesting things about the process of seeing it, I have no idea of what it looked like to me.

I can remember the neighbors standing slightly in our yard and then explaining to my parents the comet and pointing it out to us. I can remember at some points that followed being aware of the parallax effect as it seemed to appear on either side of my other neighbors’ house as I walked up and down the driveway.

But just a year or so later, I knew that the picture in my memory was more like an illustration of a comet. The accurate image was completely gone even though the memories surrounding it remained, and in the place of that image was something that I had imagined.

odyssey7··on It's OK to hardcode feature flags (2025)
Depends on how you deploy. If changing it in prod requires a PR merge and a release approval, I’d consider that pretty hardcoded.
odyssey7··on Since it was stripped of planetary status, Pluto’s defenders have been fighting
Be mindful of placing words into the mouths of others.

A desire that certain people refrain from harassment is not a claim that a conspiracy exists.

A lack of originality and self-awareness is not in itself a sign that someone is conspiring with other people who lack originality and self-awareness.

odyssey7··on Since it was stripped of planetary status, Pluto’s defenders have been fighting
I do accept the IAU’s explanation. It’s their definition, it’s none of my business, and I’m not accountable for using it myself.

Even if the person correcting you isn’t acting like an overexcited 13-year-old jumping up to correct someone about it, you must agree that as a point of discussion — as a matter of good taste and manners — telling someone that Pluto isn’t a planet is just terribly boring by now, and if that is stated as a response to something the person was trying to say, there’s a risk that attention and energy is being diluted from the actual point? Of course it happens earnestly, but there are still all of the other times and ways that it happens.

odyssey7··on Since it was stripped of planetary status, Pluto’s defenders have been fighting
To the contrary, I was expressing that the irritators perpetually on standby might have nothing at all to do with the IAU.

Are you a member of the IAU?

The rest of that post clarifies that this is a problem caused by certain “armchair scientists.” Members of the IAU are in fact actual scientists, not armchair ones.

odyssey7··on Since it was stripped of planetary status, Pluto’s defenders have been fighting
I have not pointed any fingers at the IAU for harassing people. But do be mindful of placing words into the mouths of others.
odyssey7··on Since it was stripped of planetary status, Pluto’s defenders have been fighting
Fun fact:

The 2006 IAU definition was explicitly scoped in a limited way so that it does not apply to anything beyond the Solar System.

Planets outside the Solar System are not held to the same level of scrutiny. Over 6000 planets have been discovered outside the solar system, and none of them are required to clear their neighborhoods to be designated as planets. The IAU’s Official Working Definition of an Exoplanet can be read at: https://www.iau.org/CommissionF2/CommissionF2/Documents.aspx

So, if someone really thinks we ought to have a universal definition for what a planet is, then they might start by having a word with the IAU.

odyssey7··on Since it was stripped of planetary status, Pluto’s defenders have been fighting
I’m the person who has been explaining that the meaning of words comes from how they are used, not from how committees define them. The committees might influence people but ultimately words’ meanings come from how they are used. If you require a scientific expression of this concept, you might find distributional semantics of interest[1]. When people change how they use a word, its meaning changes. Far from having a single, universal meaning, the word “planet” means a number of different things today depending on whom you ask[2].

I have been defending the right for myself and for others to continue using their own language, without harassment from others in the names of scientific bodies. There was a time when linguists would prescribe that words like “y’all” are incorrect to use, and people would be shamed and discriminated against for doing so. Armchair scientists are behind the linguists on this one. We have lost cultural heritage and seen beautiful dialects gradually shrink or disappear due to prescriptive linguistics, and we now understand the harms, and it’s time that it ended.

Yes, people are free to use words in the ways that make sense and come naturally to them. No, it is not appropriate for people to treat others with disrespect for doing so. Harassment is harassment, bullying people into changing how they speak is bullying. This is not a philosophical point, it’s about being a decent person.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Distributional_semantics

[2] https://xkcd.com/927/

odyssey7··on Since it was stripped of planetary status, Pluto’s defenders have been fighting
Species means different things in different contexts. Have you heard of species counterpoint?

Nobody is saying biologists can’t use that word the way they see fit. It would however be ridiculous for them to ask me to stop referring to species counterpoint.

> as used in their field

Now you’re talking sense. I don’t care what they call Pluto at IAU meetings. You shouldn’t care what I call Pluto in my own home.

odyssey7··on Since it was stripped of planetary status, Pluto’s defenders have been fighting
If you read Plato, you will see that defining words that already exist in some universal way is pretty much impossible. This is a humanities question, not a scientific one.

It was a fool’s errand or an act of deception to try to coerce “planet” to be a specialized word. The cracks are evident. The 2006 IAU definition doesn’t work.

Specialized words are great. They are important in science. “Planet” is not a specialized word and it has not been a specialized word for hundreds of years. Scientists did not need to somehow coerce “planet” into a specialized term to continue doing science—and if they did, there was still no reason to bother non-specialists about it, since science is its own domain where terms can be used in specialized ways.

Yes, update classifications whenever it’s useful to you. No, don’t expect other people to regard your classification system as the final word. You yourself are planning to change it anyway when it stops being useful to you, and other people have a right to categorize things differently for their own purposes — your system will be neither definitive nor universal, so it shows a lack of self-awareness to say that it is.

You mention that I make cryptic allusions. “See, this is where you've totally lost me. … So what is that specific reason? Do you have to wrap your allegations in so many indirect and allusions?” To help you to read more carefully and to apply context clues, the following is a quote from the article that this thread is about.

> To its detractors, the IAU definition seemed crafted with a specific intent. “A reason was invented to exclude Pluto,” says Kornfeld.

odyssey7··on Since it was stripped of planetary status, Pluto’s defenders have been fighting
A mention of “the planet Pluto” carries risk that you will be derailed by people who think they are very scientific but in fact are just excited to be able to correct someone.

My language has become politicized. Either I go with the flow and surrender something about my own language, or I risk getting called out or misunderstood as being incorrect if I continue.

It’s easier to let them think they corrected you than to explain your position. People believing that correcting others over superficial word choices counts as being scientific… it’s disappointing.

odyssey7··on Since it was stripped of planetary status, Pluto’s defenders have been fighting
Although there may have been a chance from an opportunism standpoint, the wisdom needed to do that well was clearly absent.
odyssey7··on Since it was stripped of planetary status, Pluto’s defenders have been fighting
The meaning of a word comes from how its speakers use it.

When people stop referring to Pluto as a planet, it will cease to be one.

Until then, we are living in a reality in which Pluto both is a planet and is not a planet, depending on the context.

odyssey7··on Since it was stripped of planetary status, Pluto’s defenders have been fighting
Yep, it’s a word. We can make more of them. We use them differently depending on the context. It’s strange that armchair scientists seem unable to understand how words work. They seem to use words fine enough? But they struggle with the abstract concept of what words are and how their meaning comes from how they are used rather than from committees.

I vote we cut science funding for universities since the humanities are clearly going through difficult times.

← PreviousPage 3 of 33Next →