770 karma · joined October 28, 2021
One argument for spending time on 1 and 3: Step 2 alone can ignite fight-or-flight responses in people's limbic systems. If that happens, rationality goes out the window. (Even more than usual, I mean!)
If this picture is correct, then I think it's worth some "overhead" to try to get a conversation between calm, rational beings going. A shouting match between two werewolves may not be valuable even if they get right to the point.
Not dismissing what you're saying. Just adding another picture.
Collisions between electrons don't directly affect either picture. You can multiplex lots and lots of completely independent 'electronic' EM waves on one conductor, they pass right through each other exactly as you described for optics, no problem.
The advantage of optics is that the low-loss bandwidth of optical waveguides is enormously wider than the low-loss bandwidth of waveguides made using copper or other conductors. And with optics we have enormous bandwidth available.
One disadvantage of optics is that we don't have a low-lag way to interconnect switches. We can connect switches, but so far the interconnect delays are much, much longer than the switching times. So a fast optical switch is useful, but so far only in systems that are solely "feed forward," like communication.
The copper isn't the medium. The EM waves are almost entirely outside the copper. The medium is the insulator (for a cable) or the glass (for an optical fiber).
Sorry to repeat all this material from the link, which you've definitely already read.
For anybody who doesn't juggle large numbers every day, a hundred million is 1e8. Ten to the eighth.
There are other serious technical errors in the piece too. For example they say "because photons move at the speed of light and electrons don't" ... which is irrelevant because electronic signals do move at the speed of light.
The most serious problem is missing context. It's been known for decades that you can build shockingly fast optical switches and even amplifiers. A hundred fs is fast but not unique. The problem is how to connect these devices in a complicated circuit without putting nanoseconds of waveguide in between. Unfortunately 1 ns is 1,000,000 fs.
So in telecom, where you're just going a long way in one direction, optical amplifiers with multi-THz bandwidth have dominated transport since the 1990s. But in computers, no.
Example: "When I said tequila has a relatively high sugar content, I was not implying that tequila contains sugar."
-- from "Neckbeard or AI? Is there even a difference?" https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/goC9qv4PWf2cjfnbm/did-chatgp...
It's eerie!
Nobody knows. Isn't that obvious? What am I missing?
EDIT: I've just had it pointed out to me that some comments here might have been created by human beings without use of a chat bot. If that's the case ... well, I'm mystified, but I apologize.
But is the distinction between calculation and experiment really specialist knowledge?
Specifically, he claims a simulation was presented as an experiment.
I can't understand whether you agree, disagree, or what.
One claim in the article is that we can't answer the (much narrower) question, "Is the cell a machine?"
I don't see that saying "well that's a philosophical question" is so different from saying "as scientists, we don't know."
The cell might be understandable as a giant machine, but I think the author is claiming that we either don't know that yet, or that the machine may be enormously more complex than some folks are suggesting.
Physicist Philip Anderson has written about reductionism (which he claims works very well) and "constructionism" (which he says is much more confusing). https://www.tkm.kit.edu/downloads/TKM1_2011_more_is_differen...
At the time, lots of people said something at the time. Later on, yeah, "nobody said anything at the time."