HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

oh_my_goodness

770 karma · joined October 28, 2021

submissionscomments
oh_my_goodness··on Rob Pike goes nuclear over GenAI
Pike's name is what people are clicking on here. That's being abused to sell this random comment about IP.
oh_my_goodness··on Rob Pike goes nuclear over GenAI
To be clear: note that that the quotation that has taken over the focus is not from Rob Pike at all.

Not Pike.

oh_my_goodness··on Rob Pike goes nuclear over GenAI
Quotation not from Pike.
oh_my_goodness··on Quantum Error Correction Goes FOOM
Look at the last plot.
oh_my_goodness··on More on whether useful quantum computing is “imminent”
Gah, I wrote the wrong thing. If each probability is 50% +- 10^{-6} then the amplitudes are matched to within around 2 times 10^{-6}.

But when N>2 this gets tougher rapidly.

If we add 10^12 complex amplitudes and each one is off by one part in 10^{-6}, we could easily have serious problems with the accuracy of the sum. And 10^12 amplitudes is "only" around 40 qubits.

oh_my_goodness··on More on whether useful quantum computing is “imminent”
I don’t think we can discuss precision usefully without numbers. We seem to agree on the word “finite” but that covers a lot of ground. “High” precision in rotating an optical polarization to exactly 45 degrees is maybe 60 dB, +- 0.0001% of the probability. That means the amplitudes are matched within 0.1%. 0.1% is fine for two qubits with 4 states. It might work for 8 qubits (256 states). For 256 qubits, no.
oh_my_goodness··on More on whether useful quantum computing is “imminent”
Sounds like we agree on how basis vectors work. But you’re talking about the initial state, and I’m talking about the output. Finding a basis that makes the output an eigenvector isn’t trivial. Take Grover’s algorithm. You have to iterate to approximate that eigenvector. Small errors in the amplitudes can prevent convergence. When you have 2^256 components, amplitudes are divided down by around 2^128.

Even preparing the initial state that accurately is only trivial on paper.

oh_my_goodness··on More on whether useful quantum computing is “imminent”
When the amplitude has norm 1, there is only one nonzero amplitude. Changing basis does not affect the number of basis functions.
oh_my_goodness··on More on whether useful quantum computing is “imminent”
1/sqrt(N)
oh_my_goodness··on What makes you senior
You've put a lot of words in my mouth, and I don't know why.

What do I suggest? I suggest that big organizations have pockets of careful, competent folks. But in general a large company tends to be all fouled up. They do a lot of things pretty much randomly. Some stuff happens the way a new graduate has a right to expect, and the way many HN commenters insist it has to go.

But a lot of other shit just ... happens. People get promoted because they have another offer from another fouled-up company, or because the boss thinks they're awesome (but sometimes the boss is dumb), or because they talk the talk exceptionally well, or because they happen to get the attention of someone 2 or 3 levels up, or whatever.

Is any of that controversial? What am I missing here?

Do people not still read Catch-22? Or has it been proved wrong or something? Or take that mysterious cactus that you mentioned in connection with large companies. What's that about? Because the cactus sounds bad.

oh_my_goodness··on What makes you senior
If I'm being honest, I sense some ambivalence about how perfect and rational big companies really are.
oh_my_goodness··on Mathematicians don't care about foundations (2022)
Try to be charitable. Remember, research mathematicians aren't HN commenters. They're forced to live within their intellectual limitations, however narrow those may be.
oh_my_goodness··on What makes you senior
Is pay grade. You can look this up.
oh_my_goodness··on What makes you senior
By 1 weird trick?
oh_my_goodness··on What makes you senior
It's just a pay grade. Please folks stop trying to analyze "junior," "senior," and so forth. It's just something management told HR to write down.
oh_my_goodness··on After my dad died, we found the love letters
I hope this comment finally seals my departure from HN. Lots of very thoughtful people here but the small toxic fraction is still too high.
oh_my_goodness··on Childhood Friends, Not Moms, Shape Attachment Styles Most
Variance explained by friends was also very low, to be honest.
oh_my_goodness··on When did people favor composition over inheritance?
The main point is the same as the Dewey Decimal System. Keep things tucked away yet findable. Make a huge code base useful to people who didn't write it themselves.
oh_my_goodness··on When did people favor composition over inheritance?
Yeah inheritance is just not the point of OO. It’s fine but it’s not what’s really useful.
oh_my_goodness··on The Manuscripts of Edsger W. Dijkstra
When I'm counting letters it's more convenient to go "one, two, three." When I'm finding the offset between letters it's more convenient to go "zero, one, two." Neither of these methods is going to displace the other.

Definitions are fine, and I agree that "A" is the first letter. But that's no use to people who need to think clearly about the offset between "A" and "C" right now. Should I tell them they're wrong, they have to count to three and then subtract one? Because the dictionary says so?

oh_my_goodness··on The Manuscripts of Edsger W. Dijkstra
If I use ordinal numbers to count, then counting tells me the number of objects. Sometimes I want to know the number of objects.

EDIT: Yeah, I don't know why book chapter labels shouldn't start with "0". It seems fine to me. They could use letters instead of numbers for all I care.

oh_my_goodness··on The Manuscripts of Edsger W. Dijkstra
Folks ... cardinal and ordinal numbers both have "just so" stories to support them. We're unlikely to eliminate either one of them today.
oh_my_goodness··on Apple is crossing a Steve Jobs red line
It's true, and it sucks. But at least I didn't pay Amazon $1800 for hardware first.
oh_my_goodness··on Learning to read Arthur Whitney's C to become smart (2024)
Still, since the article already contains this warning, some people might argue that it's unnecessary for us to add it as a response to every comment here.
oh_my_goodness··on Armed police swarm student after AI mistakes bag of Doritos for a weapon
I was responding to your original comment.
oh_my_goodness··on Washington Post editorials omit a key disclosure: Bezos' financial ties
We've all read about them. The key lesson in every one of those stories is this: don't wait for the entire building to burn down before you pull a fire alarm.
oh_my_goodness··on Washington Post editorials omit a key disclosure: Bezos' financial ties
It's not quite that simple, or at least not yet. For example the Cato Institute still seems inclined pretty much towards the rule of law and against autocracy. Perhaps "Yarvin-ists" are in power, but they don't control every voice on the right.
oh_my_goodness··on Armed police swarm student after AI mistakes bag of Doritos for a weapon
In the US, guns and automobiles kill roughly the same number of people each year.
oh_my_goodness··on Minds, brains, and programs (1980) [pdf]
Well ... bright engineering students who have very little real-world experience are a little bit like it.
oh_my_goodness··on Minds, brains, and programs (1980) [pdf]
Sure. I'm not saying it's a bad parody, or that bulking it up with footnotes would improve it.

I'm still coming to grips with the idea that LLMs seem to translate pretty well without understanding anything.

← PreviousPage 5 of 14Next →