HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

oh_my_goodness

770 karma · joined October 28, 2021

submissionscomments
oh_my_goodness··on Willow quantum chip demonstrates verifiable quantum advantage on hardware
If some version is not reasonably useful, it doesn't have kids.
oh_my_goodness··on Willow quantum chip demonstrates verifiable quantum advantage on hardware
You could do what evolution does, and require that every version be useful. But evolution seems to require an awful lot of trial and error.
oh_my_goodness··on Minds, brains, and programs (1980) [pdf]
But your Chalmers line is also literally true. If you're a Martian on Mars and you don't have cake ingredients available, the recipe won't work. If you're on Earth and you have the ingredients, it works fine. Even if (like me) you have almost no understanding of what the ingredients are, how they are made, or why the recipe works.
oh_my_goodness··on Minds, brains, and programs (1980) [pdf]
"there is a second tacit premise at work here: that performing the room's task required something to understand the language. LLMs arguably suggest that the task could be performed without anything resembling a human's understanding of language."

Yeah. I used to assume that. But it's much less obvious now. Or just false or something.

It's actually kind of spooky how well Searle did capture/foreshadow something about LLMs decades ago. No part of the system seems to understand much of anything.

My theory is that Searle came up with the CR while complaining to his wife (for the hundredth time) about bright undergrads who didn't actually understand anything. She finally said "Hey, you should write that down!" Really she just meant "holy moly, stop telling it to me!" But he misunderstood her, and the rest is history.

oh_my_goodness··on Minds, brains, and programs (1980) [pdf]
Fine, it doesn't prove that. But I'm comfortable assuming it. Searle doesn't need to say the guy doesn't end up understanding Chinese. All he has to say is the guy doesn't need to understand Chinese. And then ... some†hing some†hing ... and then ... suddenly Chinese isn't understood by the algorithm either.

It's that last part that I can't follow and (so far) totally disbelieve.

oh_my_goodness··on Minds, brains, and programs (1980) [pdf]
Mostly. Probably.
oh_my_goodness··on Mathematicians have found a hidden 'reset button' for undoing rotation
Yeah exactly. Me too.
oh_my_goodness··on Minds, brains, and programs (1980) [pdf]
It proves that the guy in the room doesn't understand Chinese.

And it does kind of help explain why LLMs sound like bright students who completely memorized their way through school.

oh_my_goodness··on Mathematicians have found a hidden 'reset button' for undoing rotation
No, thermodynamics just isn't classical mechanics. For example in thermo you have entropy. Entropy doesn't appear in classical mechanics.
oh_my_goodness··on Mathematicians have found a hidden 'reset button' for undoing rotation
It is not. That’s exactly what it isn’t.
oh_my_goodness··on Minds, brains, and programs (1980) [pdf]
Mostly agree, but the Chinese Room doesn’t prove anything about whether the algorithm understands Chinese. It’s a bait and switch.
oh_my_goodness··on Mathematicians have found a hidden 'reset button' for undoing rotation
So it’s similar thinking to spin echoes.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/spin_echoes

oh_my_goodness··on Mathematicians have found a hidden 'reset button' for undoing rotation
Read the paper https://fiteoweb.unige.ch/~eckmannj/ps_files/ETPRL.pdf
oh_my_goodness··on Mathematicians have found a hidden 'reset button' for undoing rotation
Comment refers to classical mechanics, not all of classical physics and explicitly not quantum mechanics.
oh_my_goodness··on Intercellular communication in the brain through a dendritic nanotubular network
Yeah, that's fair.
oh_my_goodness··on Tinnitus Neuromodulator
I got tinnitus in one ear after using music in headphones to block out other noise. I was probably using the headphones too loud and too often. This happened 15 years ago. It was pretty bad at first. Since then, very slowly, it has mostly "healed" or something. It's still there. But it's much less severe than it was.

I also experienced significant hearing loss around the same time. My hearing had always been absurdly good, but that changed over about a year. Now I can hear well enough to get by, but I really miss what I had. Protect your hearing!

oh_my_goodness··on Intercellular communication in the brain through a dendritic nanotubular network
If any one cares about this, please hit "parent" a few times to see what everybody said.
oh_my_goodness··on Intercellular communication in the brain through a dendritic nanotubular network
Special relativity is a lot more than a hypothesis at this point. I think the ideas in this paper may be a little bit more speculative than that.
oh_my_goodness··on Intercellular communication in the brain through a dendritic nanotubular network
Sure! Happy to. Here's an example of a circular argument: "Penrose could be a crank. We know that kind of thing is possible because, for instance, Penrose is a crank."
oh_my_goodness··on Intercellular communication in the brain through a dendritic nanotubular network
This feels a bit like a circular argument.
oh_my_goodness··on Intercellular communication in the brain through a dendritic nanotubular network
I don't see that offering an alternative hypothesis disproves anything.
oh_my_goodness··on Common yeast can survive Martian conditions
So send the yeast.
oh_my_goodness··on The Rules of Investing Are Being Loosened. Could It Lead to the Next 1929?
It's cool to contemplate the mind-set required to view crypto as a defensive hedge.
oh_my_goodness··on Global Village Construction Set
It's extremely self-limiting compared to the real industrial processes that we're actually using.
oh_my_goodness··on The Wind, a Pole, and the Dragon
Wow, "pull weather" ~ "suck wind".
oh_my_goodness··on Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a science paper (2019) [pdf]
It goes without saying that you're a better writer than Cormac McCarthy. Tell us something beyond that.
oh_my_goodness··on Why haven't quantum computers factored 21 yet?
Thanks. I don't understand quantum computing at all.
oh_my_goodness··on Why haven't quantum computers factored 21 yet?
lol good point.
oh_my_goodness··on Bitwig Studio 6 details revealed, and editing gets a big boost
Can anyone give a few specific advantages of Bigwig over say Logic or Ableton?
oh_my_goodness··on Why haven't quantum computers factored 21 yet?
24 has 3 as a factor. 3 is one less than a power of 2.
← PreviousPage 6 of 14Next →