770 karma · joined October 28, 2021
Yeah. I used to assume that. But it's much less obvious now. Or just false or something.
It's actually kind of spooky how well Searle did capture/foreshadow something about LLMs decades ago. No part of the system seems to understand much of anything.
My theory is that Searle came up with the CR while complaining to his wife (for the hundredth time) about bright undergrads who didn't actually understand anything. She finally said "Hey, you should write that down!" Really she just meant "holy moly, stop telling it to me!" But he misunderstood her, and the rest is history.
It's that last part that I can't follow and (so far) totally disbelieve.
And it does kind of help explain why LLMs sound like bright students who completely memorized their way through school.
I also experienced significant hearing loss around the same time. My hearing had always been absurdly good, but that changed over about a year. Now I can hear well enough to get by, but I really miss what I had. Protect your hearing!