HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ojnabieoot

1,423 karma · joined August 28, 2019

Functional-first developer. I like F#, Scheme, and Idris.

Currently “on sabbatical” learning more about operating systems and native code.

submissionscomments
ojnabieoot··on My billion pound company has no HR department
Incidentally: tech managers who have (nontrivial) HR duties are exactly as reliable, competent, and qualified as HR managers with programming and DBA responsibilities.

But the latter is self-evidently ridiculous, whereas the former happens all the time...

ojnabieoot··on My billion pound company has no HR department
I am curious what you mean by “ruled with an iron fist.” I am curious if you are able to offer a single compelling example.

This is an ad hominem but I don’t care: I have seen you here many times before pushing right-wing disinformation - and not something can be chalked up to a valid difference of opinion, but instead indicating that you are either a saboteur or, at best, hopelessly ignorant.

I see that yesterday you were pushing the (utterly preposterous and despicable) right-wing conspiracy that the COVID lockdowns are a progressive ruse and that after vaccinations the lockdowns will continue under different pretenses.

So I am wondering if maybe your hostility to HR comes from the possibility that you are a right-wing crank who makes employees extremely uncomfortable? I sure as heck wouldn’t hire you for anything!

ojnabieoot··on M1 Mac owners are experiencing high SSD writes over short periods of time
This is extremely good to know, thank you - I have turned off my M1 Mini and probably won’t be booting it until Apple announces a fix and explanation about the hard drive issue.

I am not quite sure if this Time Machine business is directly related (though it might be due by poorly optimized rewrites, particularly if there’s outstanding hardware shenanigans with encryption on M1s). It is baffling that the disk usage appears to be a deliberate decision.

ojnabieoot··on Mypyc: Compile type-annotated Python to C
I am not qualified to make any technical arguments. There’s a strong security and tech-managerial argument for using the software that’s aligned to the reference implementation. Obviously cython is currently the better choice for risk-adverse organizations that need compiled Python. But I think C-ish level people have a good reason to trust the stability, longevity, and security of a product built by the “most official” Python folks. There would need to be a deeply compelling technological reason to choose cython, not merely chasing a few wasted cycles or nifty features.

Obviously organizations that don’t manage human lives or large amounts of money can use ‘riskier’ tools without as much worry. This isn’t an argument against cython generally. But I worked at a hospital and wrote a lot of Python, and would not have been able to get the security team to support cython on their SELinux servers without a really good argument. Cython is just an unnecessary liability when your job manages identifiers and medical details on servers accessible on a fairly wide (albeit private) network.

ojnabieoot··on The Muppet Show: Disney+ adds content warning of negative depictions of cultures
You are just wrong: in the early 90s 55% of US whites were opposed to interracial marriage (compared to 13% opposition in 2013) [1]. In my view this one shocking and outrageous stat is enough to refute your point. But also look at the political world then. Ron Paul was selling virulently racist propaganda in 1992 while serving as a representative [2]. Someone simply could not get away with that today - even Steve Scalise would call for them to be expelled from the House. In 1990 David Duke came dangerously close to becoming a US senator (after serving four years as a representative) and in 1992 was still very powerful in LA politics. This was the era that Rush Limbaugh rose to great fame (and he certainly had the most racist major radio program the country had seen since the 60s). Hatred towards homosexuals was standard - it was rare even for even snooty liberal art films to treat gay people like human beings (showing off drag queens was representation enough).

The country has become more progressive since then (despite the Republicans specifically becoming more reactionary on the whole).

[1] https://news.gallup.com/poll/163697/approve-marriage-blacks-... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ron_Paul_newsletters

ojnabieoot··on Passerine: A small extensible language designed for concise expression
Just FYI, most dependent type systems don’t typecheck when a parameter to a type constructor is a function, since they can’t “deduce” very much about a function except its signature. They can take proof objects (including objects involving evaluated functions, like ‘n % 2 = 0’) but not functions by themselves (like ‘loop {}’).

This isn’t a technical problem with unification, the issue is a fundamental conflict between “intensional” versus “extensional” equality. Wikipedia has a good example that communicates the underlying confusion: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extensionality

AFAIK all depedently-typed general-purpose languages use intensional equality since it’s consistent, but there are proof-checkers that use extensional dependent type theories (inconsistency is less of a problem than you might think, and actually makes some higher-order topology and set theory much easier to program).

ojnabieoot··on The Muppet Show: Disney+ adds content warning of negative depictions of cultures
I am assuming you read the article in detail and simply forgot that they listed the actual examples:

> a multitude of caricatured national costumes as part of a performance of It’s a Small World After All, including as a Chinese person with exaggerated front teeth and a long braid.

> Peter Sellers appears in a segment titled A Gypsy’s Violin wearing a black headscarf with gilded trimmings, a red vest and a large red satin belt, and singing in a heavy accent

It seems like almost everyone interested in a good faith discussion would agree that these two examples are offensive stereotypes that don’t really belong in a children’s show. Considering the episode’s aren’t being removed I can’t imagine why anyone would object to this in good faith.

Unfortunately there are a ton of people who are fully aware that these stereotypes are offensive but, in bad faith, pretend that they are innocuous jokes and that this is just a moral panic. Although HN rules prevent me from accusing anyone of bad faith, I will suggest that someone who doesn’t have a problem with Apu from the Simpsons is someone who affirmatively supports using racist stereotypes.

There are more examples here: https://old.reddit.com/r/Muppets/comments/lnwse2/muppet_show...

ojnabieoot··on The Muppet Show: Disney+ adds content warning of negative depictions of cultures
Aladdin was obviously not intended to be racist and was probably made by people with good intentions. The same could be said of Uncle Tom’s Cabin and Song of the South. But 1992 was a dramatically more racist and reactionary era than 2021, and the 1992 film really is unacceptably racist to show to children.

It is impossible to ignore that Jasmine/Aladdin both have light skin, European faces, and American accents, whereas Jafar and all the hostile guards or street merchants are grotesque Arab caricatures. Seriously - the only Arab “accents” come from bad guys, they tend to have huge hooked or bulbous noses and very dark skin, and they’re all psychotically violent. Most of the references to Arab culture are superficial and rely on stereotypes for cheap laughs (watch the opening scene with the merchant again).

ojnabieoot··on Passerine: A small extensible language designed for concise expression
> Any type system with dependent types (`where` in Passerine) is undecidable, meaning error reporting for these types has to be moved to runtime.

Maybe I am misunderstanding you, but this is very confusing. Most dependently-typed languages do in fact check types at compile time: the undecidability problem usually implies a compromise that “correct” programs will be incorrectly rejected (the compiler gives up earlier than it needs to) instead of letting the type-checker get stuck in an infinite loop. But it does not mean type-checking is simply moved to runtime! I am sincerely confused where you got this idea, which makes me wonder if I misunderstood you.

ojnabieoot··on Frustrated with Parler deplatforming, I am building a service no one can silence
Although it is very funny coming from someone named NoImmatureAdHom...
ojnabieoot··on Passerine: A small extensible language designed for concise expression
Hmm, at a somewhat longer glance, I would say it’s very Scheme-ish in its semantics but only superficially like Haskell (and really more like ML generically). Specifically, despite algebraic type definitions, Passerine is dynamically-typed with an emphasis on structural/“duck” typing. The author plans to add a Hindley-Milner type checker but the language does not seem to be “type-centric” in the way I think of Haskell - types will be added for verification, but not as a near-first-class programming construct. I get the impression it might be more like mypy and that runtime type errors will still be a thing.

From the perspective of a very young functional programming language, it is very tricky to balance a powerful type system with powerful macros and I suspect that macros are the priority. The developer also cites the Erlang VM as a major inspiration in terms of a dynamic “expect things to fail and handle it” approach.

Still looks very interesting! I love Scheme (despite having become a static typing curmudgeon) and will be checking out this project.

ojnabieoot··on Frustrated with Parler deplatforming, I am building a service no one can silence
You can pretend to care about North Korean censorship all you want, but if you name your platform “Pepe,” positively cite 4chan as an influence, and take the time to criticize “cancel culture SJWs” then it’s quite clear what your intentions and motivations are, and who your audience is: you want to create a space run by and for racist pieces of garbage. You don’t actually care about free speech at all, and neither does anyone who is pretending that this platform will provide a public good.
ojnabieoot··on A Dishonest, Indifferent, and Toxic Culture
I am kind of frustrated that I am reporting my real-world experience after having been “out” of academia for 10 years and yet you and another person are assuming that I don’t have any real world experience and am just lacking perspective! Please read the comment! And that “bias” you mention 100% exists outside of academia.
ojnabieoot··on A Dishonest, Indifferent, and Toxic Culture
My point was that PhD dropouts can land on their feet but it’s not a question of “following their passions and do something that makes you happy.” It’s really a question of “give up your passions and do something pragmatic.”

My career in software is also “fine” and even somewhat “lucrative” given that I don’t work at for-profit companies. But it’s not how I pictured my life going and it was a difficult adjustment.

ojnabieoot··on A Dishonest, Indifferent, and Toxic Culture
> That's something people who have no real world experience say.

I was speaking to my real-world experience!

ojnabieoot··on A Dishonest, Indifferent, and Toxic Culture
As someone who quit a graduate program:

- it looks really really really bad on your CV to not finish a graduate degree. I dropped out for health reasons with an A+ GPA and still have to delicately explain what happened to interviewers. It looks worse than just having a masters degree.

- “just one more year of misery and then your career prospects will increase dramatically” is a very powerful argument and not just a sunk-cost fallacy.

- young people in PhD programs tend to have a lot of identity and psychological investment in getting their PhD and working as a researcher. For most PhD students, the occupation that most fulfills them is their research. It strikes me as very strange that you think PhD students have some secret marketable passion that they would pursue but instead they somehow got stuck in graduate school. Speaking for myself: a PhD program was the only feasible part for me to do something fulfilling. My current work as a software developer is tedious and boring by comparison and, frankly, not at all what I wanted to do with my life.

- PhD students rarely have any savings and their meager stipends are the only income they have. So “pursue [something] that actually fulfills you” is most likely impossible, since that ‘something’ is probably not a routine office/engineering job.

ojnabieoot··on Researchers observe stationary Hawking radiation in an analog black hole
Yes, I think it might have been more straightforward to say “Researchers observe stationary Hawking radiation in ‘acoustic black hole’” or something to clarify to laypeople that this is a mathematically analogous but physically very different experiment. I don’t think it’s too difficult to conceptualize that sound waves behave similarly to light waves and that properties of black holes can be “simulated” with sound.
ojnabieoot··on Humans were drinking milk before they could digest it
The problem is graphs like that are used to misleadingly portray lactose tolerance as a “racial” trait, using an out-of-context bit of science to propagate the falsehood of racial differences between Africans and Europeans. The (real) biological difference in skin color ignited a ridiculous false belief that Africans and Europeans constitute different “races,” and scientists have a duty to push back on racist propaganda asserting a “racial difference” where none exists, even on the racists’ own flawed terms.

The high genotypic frequency of lactose persistence in Northern Europe and Saudi Arabia is an interesting and incomplete story about human adaptation to geography and climate (perhaps droughts and harsh winters meant that people were not be able to wait for cheese or yogurt and need to consume large amounts of raw milk?) Another crucial part of the mix is that there is much less genetic diversity in Europe and the Middle East than in Africa.

Regardless, if you read the linked NYT article, it’s clear that a bunch of racist weirdos are stumbling across graphs like the ones you presented and are treating “the ability to drink milk without getting queasy” as another paper bag test. Although it’s ridiculous and abhorrent, such ideas wouldn’t be sustainable if people weren’t convinced pseudoscience was the real thing.

ojnabieoot··on “I saw that you spun up an Ubuntu image in Azure”
Just FYI, this is bad manners. I deleted the comment because I didn't want to continue the conversation and I especially didn't want to engage with you - specifically, your comments here and elsewhere indicate that you are frequently toxic and hostile.

You deciding to resurrect the comment because you happened to see it before I deleted it is really not OK. It's the exact kind of toxic hostile, creepy interaction I was trying to avoid from you by deleting the comment!

ojnabieoot··on “I saw that you spun up an Ubuntu image in Azure”
I don't even use Azure or LinkedIn. But I'm extremely not interested in continuing a conversation with someone who is being deliberately ignorant and difficult. If your attitude is "consumers are not allowed to complain about any shitty marketing practice if I don't like the company involved" then congratulations, you are sooooo superior.
ojnabieoot··on “I saw that you spun up an Ubuntu image in Azure”
If the email came over an Azure customer support system, or even to the corporate email used to sign up for the Azure account, then sure - I would personally find this very obnoxious and it being buried in the license agreement is suspicious, but not really that unethical. Crucially, this arrangement means Canonical could engage in marketing without MSFT sharing much personal data about Azure users.

What's extremely unethical is contacting the person over LinkedIn. It's extremely aggressive and a huge violation of boundaries, and proves that Microsoft is sharing personal information (names of users) with Canonical.

If I buy something online from a store, I would expect a few spam emails. But it would be completely unacceptable if a sales representative showed up at my house (despite me only sharing my address for billing/shipping purposes). This is basically what happened to the Azure customer.

ojnabieoot··on “I saw that you spun up an Ubuntu image in Azure”
> Ubuntu is a free product. Canonical should not be able to find out if I (specifically me or my organization) allocates or runs 1 or 10000 instances of Ubuntu

I agree with the message behind this and obviously Canonical and Microsoft are both being extremely gross.

But Ubuntu as a binary image (or source code) is a very different product than a VM with Ubuntu pre-installed and pre-configured, which is what you paid for (and is why you got ensnared by their horrible anti-user license).

ojnabieoot··on Switching to Windows
> As far as I can tell, 7-zip is more widely recommended amongst Windows users, but what do they know? PeaZip has a very clean UI, and nice green icons, so it’s very obviously the better choice.

I appreciated the pithy joke, but I was curious about an actual comparison since I always use 7-Zip. This short article seems like a useful rundown of the (very minor) differences if anyone else is interested: https://en.softonic.com/articles/head-to-head-peazip-vs-7-zi...

ojnabieoot··on SDL Moves to GitHub
I think they implicitly addressed this:

> So we’re moving to servers we don’t control, which does make me nervous, but the argument goes like this: Microsoft owns GitHub, and it’s highly unlikely Microsoft is going to go bankrupt anytime soon. If Microsoft pulls the plug on GitHub, it’s not just SDL that would be in trouble, it would be the entire open source ecosystem, so interested parties would move fast to help you migrate to somewhere else…right?

Gitlab Inc. is dramatically more likely to go out of business that Microsoft, and Gitlab generally is dramatically more likely to have significant outages than Github.

ojnabieoot··on How many early human species existed on Earth?
> Is there evidence for that mating could only occurr "to an extent," like with horses and donkeys?

I am not sure what "to an extent" really means in this context, but modern-day Europeans and Asians have some distinctly Neanderthal and/or Denisovan genes. So, unlike mules, the children of (anthropologically modern) humans and Neanderthals were able to reproduce.

In particular this has led some biologists to a rethinking of the Homo sapiens species as being many different (mostly extinct) subspecies:

- Homo sapiens neanderthalis

- Homo sapiens denisovan

- Homo sapiens idaltu [1]

- Homo sapiens sapiens (all currently living humans)

An important disclaimer, as without context this stuff comes uncomfortably close to racist pseudoscience: compared to every other living species of primate, there is vastly less genetic variation among humans. This is despite the fact that there are far more humans than there are chimpanzees, gorillas, etc. Among the common chimpanzee there are many different subspecies, with distinct genomes. Chimpanzee subspecies are physiologically capable of cross-reproducing, but have intense social barriers that prevents it from happening in the wild (except in cases of rape).

By contrast, modern humans only have one subspecies: Homo sapiens sapiens. Genetic differences between human groups are extremely subtle compared to chimpanzees, despite greater physical variation, and even the most bitter ethnic conflicts are nothing like the ancient socio-biological barriers found in chimps (they are transient on a biological timescale, and individual social/sexual relationships can still survive and flourish). So the ancient world of modern humans, Neanderthals, and Denisovans should really be seen as an ancient world with a variety of Homo sapiens subspecies, in an era where are genome was as variable and chaotic as the modern chimpanzee.

What specifically happened to the Neanderthals and Denisovans is an open question, though their minimal contribution to European and Asian genomes suggests they weren't around very long as a distinct subspecies once modern humans came over from Africa. So, going back to "to an extent" - the children of modern humans and Neanderthal were biologically successful from the perspective of Charles Darwin, but a culturally disastrous from the perspective of a Neanderthals.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herto_Man

ojnabieoot··on AMC, GameStop Give Hedge Fund Mudrick Capital $200M in Gains
"Long buyers, who have an incentive to push positive propaganda about a company they are invested in (regardless of whether or not it is true), are good."

"Short sellers, who have an incentive to push negative propaganda about a company they are invested in (regardless of whether or not it is true), are bad."

This is self-evidently incoherent and is actually being too generous to Musk, who in real life is even stupider than my strawman[1]. And Elon Musk obviously has a creepy grudge against short sellers, as evidenced by his disgraceful comments in a 2018 analyst call[2]. The only thing approaching a principle that Musk has bothered to offer is that short sellers can hurt companies by artificially pushing the stock price down. But long buyers can hurt competitors by artificially pushing a stock price up! There's no "moral" difference. Musk just has absolutely no leg to stand on here - which is why he's myopically focused on Reddit and Twitter instead of people who are actually competent about finance.

The only reason Elon Musk is "morally" opposed to short sellers is that they are hurting his personal bank account, and he's not satisfied with being merely the richest person in the world. And the only reason you share his opinion is that you are caught up in his cult of personality. Looking at your comment history: read more news and less Reddit.

[1] https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1354890601649610753

[2] https://financialpost.com/investing/musk-takes-aim-at-analys...

ojnabieoot··on AMC, GameStop Give Hedge Fund Mudrick Capital $200M in Gains
The important thing being lost in all the chatter: Elon Musk didn't have a creepy grudge against this hedge fund, therefore it is a good hedge fund.
ojnabieoot··on Reddit Forum Sparks Physical Silver Shortage on Major Dealers’ Websites
I saw this going around on one of the main Reddit posts (maybe the one referenced in the article that was deleted):

> Think about the Gainz. If you don't care about the gains, think about the banks like JP MORGAN you'd be destroying along the way.

The idea that this is going to make any meaningful impact on JP MORGAN is ridiculous and I suspect the person who wrote it is aware it's ridiculous. They are just out to screw people so they can make a quick dishonest buck.

Just like the real Wall Street, /r/WallStreetBets is full of horrible scumbags.

ojnabieoot··on SpaceX violated its launch license in Starship test, triggering FAA probe
And the FAA (or similar agency) should be involved with literally every rocket launch! Especially if it's a test!

What exactly is your point here?

ojnabieoot··on No, WallStreetBets isn’t robbing Wall Street to help the little guy
Can we get this comment flagged for misinformation? Jen Psaki doesn't even have any brothers, just two sisters [1]. The fact that somebody at Citadel is also named "Psaki" does not in fact mean they are siblings.

I sincerely hate everyone involved in this stupid story. Liars and con artists, from HN to Reddit to Wall Street.

[1] https://www.stamfordadvocate.com/news/article/Greenwich-High... ("eldest of three daughters")

← PreviousPage 3 of 12Next →