HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ojnabieoot

1,423 karma · joined August 28, 2019

Functional-first developer. I like F#, Scheme, and Idris.

Currently “on sabbatical” learning more about operating systems and native code.

submissionscomments
ojnabieoot··on YouTube to remove content that alleges widespread election fraud
This isn’t an honest reading of Clinton’s comment:

> I think that [Republicans] have a couple of scenarios that they are looking toward. One is messing up absentee balloting. They believe that helps them so that they then get maybe a narrow advantage in the Electoral College on Election Day... Joe Biden should not concede under any circumstances because I think this is going to drag out.

She clearly meant on Election Day, not even if all the votes are counted.

Another flaw in the argument is that the 2016 election was objectively undemocratic and indisputably subject to foreign interference designed to tilt the scales towards Trump. Whether that means 2016 was “stolen” is maybe a matter of perspective (in my view it was illegitimate). But only one of the parties is actually willing to steal a presidential election they clearly lost.

ojnabieoot··on After centuries, a seemingly simple math problem gets an exact solution
Thanks - I wasn’t actually aware of this but I meant to write “elementary” rather than “exact” so I’m glad you brought this up. I had supposed there was probably some incantation of special functions that solved the equation :)

It’s been a long time since I’ve studied ODEs and mathematical physics but this solution seems easier than I had guessed (in the sense that it’s accessible to advanced undergrads instead of specialists).

ojnabieoot··on Museum of Bad Album Covers
> Bad is subjective

Counterpoint: http://www.zonicweb.net/badalbmcvrs/letmetouch.jpg

ojnabieoot··on Museum of Bad Album Covers
Maybe not “most” depending on how that is defined, but a lot of blues/jazz/R&B from those days can be found on YouTube if it isn’t on Spotify or Apple Music - there are many channels that upload recordings of old EPs/LPs. I listen mostly to 50s-70s jazz and YouTube has proven the most reliable.

That said, Apple Music has a decent catalog of jazz, including many smaller artists - it’s actually the bigger names (whose estates have meaningful control over their body of work) that are sometimes patchier. Apple Music is also very good for finding new artists, and they put good work into their jazz playlists (even if the choices are maybe a bit anodyne).

Spotify used to be horrible for jazz - apparently it’s gotten better, but I remember signing up for a free month and being extremely disappointed.

ojnabieoot··on Museum of Bad Album Covers
One of my favorite albums from the 90s has possibly the lamest cover in jazz history - not offensively bad or distasteful, more along the lines of “high school portrait”: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/b/b4/Groove_Elatio...

If you had shown me this cover without me knowing who John Scofield was, I would have assumed this album was particularly dorky elevator music. But it’s great stuff: https://youtu.be/QBWTJ--Son8

That said...... there are cases where you can probably judge books by their covers: http://www.zonicweb.net/badalbmcvrs/letmetouch.jpg

ojnabieoot··on After centuries, a seemingly simple math problem gets an exact solution
One of my favorite classic examples is... a pendulum!

Typically we view pendulums as “simple harmonic oscillators” - basically equivalent to a mass on a spring, only going left-to-right rather than up-to-down.

But this is only an approximation. The differential equation for a simple harmonic oscillator is

x’’ = ax

which has a simple solution - sum of a sine and a cosine, aka a wave. (Here x’’ = second derivative of x with respect to time, or acceleration)

But the equation of motion for a real pendulum (from a free body diagram) is much more complicated and has no exact solution:

x’’ = sin(x)

It’s a very strange function whose second derivative is equal to the sine of the original function, and can’t be expressed in ordinary means. Any high school physics student can derive this equation of motion from Newton’s laws, but you need the assumption sin(x) ~ x to make any progress finding a solution.

ojnabieoot··on Volleyball star had it all, until blows to her head changed everything
The smoking gun of bad faith on the part of Stanford:

> The family did not trust Stanford. School doctors, Hodson says, had diagnosed her foot pain as inflammation and told her that she wasn’t risking further injury by playing. Medical records show that an independent doctor subsequently reviewed MRI scans taken by Stanford and determined she had a stress fracture.

Just despicable people. Competitive athletes are already under an intense amount of pressure to play while injured - lying to them about their health (when they aren’t even getting paid!) is horrendous exploitation.

ojnabieoot··on Covid-19: Things We're Not Even Trying
Perhaps the blog post stated things too strongly, but the overall NIH consensus is that HCQ doesn’t help much with COVID-19: https://www.nih.gov/news-events/news-releases/hydroxychloroq... This seems to hold in many retrospective/ cross-cohort studies. At best the efficacy of HCQ is inconclusive.

The author’s overall point was that corrupt right-wing politicization of HCQ was a huge diversion of resources and public attention... as illustrated by your zeroing in on a single term from the the blog post and waving a contrary study from a small patient group. Your comment really doesn’t add much except distraction and confusion.

ojnabieoot··on Ask HN: What is one unexpected positive thing that happened to you in 2020?
[sighs the deepest sigh I’ve sighed all year]

this is about Twitter, isn’t it?

ojnabieoot··on CentOS Project shifts focus to CentOS Stream
Not what stability means in this context - naively, CentOS Stream is considerably more likely to lead to broken development builds, inscrutable library inconsistencies, driver weirdness, etc, than the previous distribution model. It also poses ugly questions for teams who need certified processes or strict security requirements.

I could be missing something and I don’t think the motivations are strictly mercantile, but this does make CentOS Stream much less appealing (compared to RHEL) than CentOS 7/8. I am personally not that affected by all this (my org uses RHEL) but it’s a huge hassle for a good number of serious CentOS users.

ojnabieoot··on Agents raid home of fired Florida data scientist who built Covid-19 dashboard
The police (and their unions, and civilian voters with authoritarian pro-police ideologies) are a major political constituency on the right, one that Donald Trump had repeatedly pandered to (because he is a pro-police authoritarian). It is beyond naive to pretend “unaccountable police violence is good” isn’t a mainstream right-wing belief in 2020.

> When you see these thugs being thrown into the back of a paddy wagon, you just seen them thrown in, rough. I said, ‘Please don’t be too nice.’ [Trump, July 2017]

> If you see somebody getting ready to throw a tomato, knock the crap out of them, would you?Seriously, OK? Just knock the hell — I promise you, I will pay for the legal fees. I promise. I promise. They won’t be so much, because the courts agree with us too — what’s going on in this country? [Trump, July 2016]

> “Sometimes they grab one guy, ‘I’m a reporter! I’m a reporter!” ...they threw him aside like he was a little bag of popcorn.” [Trump, September 2020, clearly mocking the reporter in context]

So the people on the “right” who are cool with this are basically every Republican official and about 70m Americans who voted for Trump last month. Seems like a lot of people!

ojnabieoot··on These Modern Programming Languages Will Make You Suffer
Lots of problems with this superficial and cliche-ridden article... but I was particularly irked that Python was dismissed as being dynamically typed, yet Elixir was excused because of Dialyzer - first of all, what about mypy? Second of all, it's not the same thing as actual static typing. I get it - they like Elixir. But feigning objectivity here is extremely irritating (and culminates a pattern throughout the article).

It is fine - or at least only somewhat stupid - to have an arbitrary ranking of programming languages, though things like "no garbage collection is bad" is obviously domain-dependent and the author should be upfront about that. But it's extremely frustrating when people pin objective-seeming criteria on their personal preference with seemingly no hint of irony or self-awareness.

ojnabieoot··on The Grenfell Tower inquiry is uncovering a major corporate scandal
Not a fire safety expert but yes, I understand it is still sound advice. Keep in mind it’s not “shelter until the fire is out,” it’s “shelter until a safety authority gives you clearance to leave or your life is at risk.”

a) the possibility of stampede is real, especially for children, the disabled, and the elderly

b) in a high rise, an evacuation stairwell might seem safe at the top but could be impassable much lower down. You would have no way of knowing ahead of time. So then evacuees have to backtrack and try to find a clear stairwell, which could be impossible if the stairs are too crowded.

In my experience with fire drills in high rises, “shelter in place” is really about staggered evacuation: first evacuate the floors surrounding the area where the fire was detected, then continue from there.

ojnabieoot··on The Grenfell Tower inquiry is uncovering a major corporate scandal
Indeed this is particularly egregious:

> When retested in 2007 as part of a different system [the insulation] failed combustion tests dramatically. Kingspan has argued this was not a consequence of its product, but the firm's own internal report warned the new insulation had performed ‘very differently’ — burning on its own and continuing after the test fire was put out.

> But the market was not told of these findings, nor that the product had changed. In fact, when the country’s largest private building control firm, the National House Building Council (NHBC) threatened to reject the product due to fears over its combustibility in the mid 2010s, Kingspan called in the lawyers and threatened it with defamation. The NHBC backed down.

This doesn’t mean that the government gets off scot-free but obviously this is a major corporate scandal that deserves to be investigated regardless of perceived political motivations.

ojnabieoot··on LinkedIn’s Alternate Universe
There are many features that make LinkedIn a good tool for professional networking, but as a social media platform LinkedIn has a hugely problematic culture - far worse than Twitter.

While I think LinkedIn’s issues are best understood as symptoms of larger issues in corporate / middle-class culture, the article is on-point.

ojnabieoot··on 'They're ripping us apart': Bay Area small business owners talk new lockdown
It’s disgusting - revolting, despicable, outrageous, horrific, contemptible - to pretend that San Francisco didn’t give any reasoning for their more stringent order. The order explains the reasoning perfectly well in an 80 page PDF anyone can go read: COVID is worse in San Francisco than in other parts of California.

So it’s not a “perfectly adequate query,” it’s just ignorance. And it’s horrendously irresponsible for SFBay to perpetuate that ignorance during a pandemic.

ojnabieoot··on 'They're ripping us apart': Bay Area small business owners talk new lockdown
Just FYI that was typo, “stinks” was meant to be “stimulus.”

And again the fact that an ignorant self-interested business owner’s complaint is presented without an opposing view is disgusting. Even if SFDPH’s action is found to be unlawful it is ridiculous to call it “criminal” and irresponsible to print it without context.

San Francisco is correct to look at local conditions and make a more stringent judgement than the state as a whole. I do not understand what is so difficult to understand about this (except overwhelming bad faith and indifference to human life).

ojnabieoot··on 'They're ripping us apart': Bay Area small business owners talk new lockdown
> It's unconstitutional for the government to close down businesses without due process, even if it's done with good intentions.

No it isn’t. That’s just not true. The government can do it in an emergency like pandemic, after a failed sanitation inspection, after a crime, etc. You can’t just say

> It's unconstitutional for the executive branch to make arbitrary decisions without representative input,

No it isn’t. This just isn’t true. For starters the decision is obviously not arbitrary. And “representative input” - Jesus. You can’t just make up stuff that isn’t in the constitution and claim that something you don’t like is therefore unconstitutional.

> It's not legal to confine the majority of people in a state to their homes, whether they've been diagnosed with a transmissible disease or not.

Again this just isn’t true and has never been true.

One of the most frustrating things of this year is dealing with dangerous ignorant bullshit from people like yourself.

ojnabieoot··on 'They're ripping us apart': Bay Area small business owners talk new lockdown
It is sincerely gross of SFGate to run this story without a single comment from a public health or policy expert explaining the rationale for the lockdown. There is journalistic merit in a story about the frustrations and resentments of Bay-area business owners. It is inexcusable to present their dishonest arguments as the only side of the story. I understand that US government officials (deservedly) have lost a lot of confidence from US citizens. But one way to guarantee bad government is by having a press that presents cynical, ignorant mercantilism as straight analysis.

The rationale for the lockdown is simple for laypeople like me to grok:

- COVID is an extremely contagious and dangerous illness, which is still not well-understood

- daily cases in San Francisco have quadrupled in the last month and local hospitals are facing collapse

- it is much better to err on the side of caution and strongly discourage people from leaving their homes

- from an economic perspective, the problem is the virus and lack of Congressional action, not the SF public health department. The virus quadrupling means that eventually too many people would be sick to patronize the businesses without the lockdown (only with more death and economic devastation).

Comments from a handful of professors pointing this out (only less ignorantly) would be very helpful!

Instead we get bad-faith comments from intellectually dishonest business leaders, like the fact that no COVID outbreaks have been linked to movie theaters (among all 12 moviegoers since 2-2020) or that proper outdoor dining is safe (and badly enforced), or whining about an absence of “hard evidence” (as if the proper policy for a novel pandemic that’s killed over 200,000 Americans in 9 months is careful double-blind studies).

Journalists should not believe that financially distressed business owners are nobly assessing objective risks, while the public health officials are corrupt and unreasonable. Business owners are right to be angry. But the SF government has a job to do, and it is not their fault that state governments in the US cannot afford adequate economic stimulus . The anger needs to be towards the federal government for not providing a well-deserved bailout.

ojnabieoot··on What we can learn from the latest indoor dining study
“But... what about countries such as the US and Brazil, where far more people have died of COVID than of any recent influenza? Less than 10,000 Brazilians die of the flu each year compared to 180,000 covid deaths.”

“Those... don’t count!”

ojnabieoot··on Billionaires Build
A big problem here is that the children of a musical prodigy aren’t necessarily musically talented, and the children of amazing athletes aren’t necessarily amazing athletes.

But the children of billionaires are (almost) all obscenely wealthy.

ojnabieoot··on Ask HN: First 5 People at a Startup... who? why?
It depends on the business and the top-level organization you are thinking of, but it is worth looking for someone with experience in accounting / legal, instead of leaving considerations like that for when the company is larger. Someone with experience as HR director / senior legal counsel / startup CFO / etc; i.e., demonstrated ability to take responsibility for keeping the company out of legal and ethical trouble.

I have worked at two small startups that started out by outsourcing all HR/legal/accounting stuff to staffing agencies or independent contractors, and it resulted in missing paychecks, minor lawsuits, severely botched contracts, and can lead to serious problems with company ethics and employee retention.

ojnabieoot··on These are called opportunities
I would call this “being so skeptical that your brain falls out” since you could make the same argument (about either politics or money) with scientists, human rights advocates, programmers, etc. “Actually you can’t trust anybody and all viewpoints are equally suspect” isn’t as enlightened as you think.

In this specific case Apple and Samsung have been proven dishonest and manipulative, and they have a far stronger legal/financial incentive to lie than separate groups of prosecutors in the US and many separate EU member states. I also find a conspiracy internal to Apple/Samsung much more plausible than a conspiracy across attorneys general from 34 US states.

ojnabieoot··on These are called opportunities
a) Prosecutors in the US and EU allege that both Apple and Samsung did in fact participate in a nefarious scheme to get users to upgrade. I realize that Apple and Samsung say they didn’t do that but I don’t think they are being honest. This thing where tech workers take tech companies at face value when said companies have repeatedly demonstrated their dishonesty is... really something.

b) At any rate, “Apple deceitfully handicapped older products to cover up a more serious (but fixable) flaw, knowingly pushing customers into unnecessary upgrades” is really not any better than “Apple deceitfully handicapped older devices to push consumers into unnecessary upgrades.”

ojnabieoot··on These are called opportunities
Apple and Samsung have both paid fines and settlements recently because of deliberately slowing down older devices - most recently Apple in November: https://finance.yahoo.com/news/apple-u-states-reach-113-1804...
ojnabieoot··on Advent of Code 2020
I used a cutesy synecdoche to illustrate the overall point that “AoC leaderboard ranking” is essentially uncorrelated with programming ability, despite how heavily the leaderboard is pushed on participants. Otherwise I think the rest of the comment is well-argued and I don’t think a full reading of my comment suggests that “drink coffee late at night” was literally the main deciding factor. In a literal sense, geographic location/time zone is a much stronger variable than coffee consumption. I realize the internet in general (and HN specifically) isn’t a great place for rhetoric like this.

Regardless, I feel like you’re being excessively pedantic as a means to..... police my tone without addressing any of the actual arguments.

ojnabieoot··on Advent of Code 2020
This is dismissive and unnecessarily condescending. Is it possible to opt out of the public leaderboard entirely? Because if not - perhaps things have changed - the stressful part about AoC is having a publicly viewable permanent score based on arbitrary and unfair criteria. Simply “not looking at it” isn’t enough.

I did AoC a few years ago and realized that I had my GitHub profile associated to “middle-of-the-road” scores on a public list. It isn’t really a problem and I realize I may sound too sensitive: but it is a bit stressful to be ranked in a competition you have no interest in competing in. Think of an ignorant recruiter deciding to look at a “better” programmer higher on the list, etc. And in a community/society that places a huge premium on arbitrary scores like SAT and IQ, there’s a small twinge of unavoidable stress when you see “you completed 75,435th” simply because you decided to do a puzzle on a lunch break. I’d rather just avoid it entirely.

Likewise, there are many people desperately competing for a “top spot” that measures their ability to... drink coffee late at night, mostly. It’s just kind of gross and not something I feel like encouraging. Having an opt-in leaderboard would be fine, but AoC pushes it way too hard. The emphasis should be on fun daily puzzles, not an arbitrary competition based on who is most alert at a given hour.

ojnabieoot··on 30 years later, QBasic is still the best
I also find the idea that “if you teach kids bad procedural programming, they’ll form bad habits and struggle with modern languages” to be specious.

I grew up with BASIC (Q and TI), then learned a small amount of MATLAB as a physics student. When I took a class in Scheme later in college, I was blown away by how its syntactical constructs prevented me from making the kinds of errors that plagued my imperative/procedural programs - at the cost of some cognitive overhead.

Cutting my teeth with GOTO didn’t make me resistant to structured (or functional) programming, it gave me perspective on why it’s often necessary.

ojnabieoot··on How to Think for Yourself
No - Plato, Descartes, and Locke all referenced actual history when formulating their ideas about politics - PG doesn't even mention an example of an "independent-minded" person! - and at least Descartes and Locke heavily cited the past generations of political philosophers that came before them.

It is also worth noting that at least Plato/Descartes/Locke were investigating deep questions of political philosophy with little precedent and which is almost impossible to observe empirically. By contrast, PG has an entire century's worth of psychology theory and experiments that he is ignoring out of pure arrogance.

ojnabieoot··on How to Think for Yourself
Like many of PG’s essays about psychology or society, the problem is that this essay is basically an aphorism or a self-help book: there’s no logic here, no citations, no connection to facts. It’s just a bunch of feel-good BS for libertarian-minded tech workers. I get the impression that the length is (at least unconsciously) making up for the absence of rigor.

A few paragraphs of “stuff that has no real argument but basically sounds right to PG” is a fine short essay as a “maninfesto of independent thought”.

But when the essay is full of detailed “analysis” of “facts” such as “it seems that independent thought is a matter of nature rather than nurture,” then PG is just wasting his readers’ time. This essay is a genuine clunker.

← PreviousPage 6 of 12Next →