HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

okamiueru

2,285 karma · joined December 10, 2011

submissionscomments
okamiueru··on Congress Needs to Stop Day Trading, Says Sen. Mark Warner
I wish every time someone complained about a title, they included the title at the time. HN moderators are very quick to correct issues, and it leaves the comment and the rest wondering "what is wrong with it?"
okamiueru··on Apple execs: Let's take a 30% cut of Uber and Lyft's membership programs (2018)
Then it's all good :)

It's not uncommon to hear unrealistic praise of the M1 on HN.

okamiueru··on Apple execs: Let's take a 30% cut of Uber and Lyft's membership programs (2018)
> M1 completely obliterates the competition for laptops

IMO, you are both wrong. The M1 is fine as a laptop CPU, because what it needs to do well, it does very well - which is power efficiency. However, if what you need is computational power, and you don't particularly prioritize power consumption, then the M1 not only does not obliterate the competition, it significantly under-performs. And this is before you add in a dedicated GPU that solves some of those tasks much, much faster.

Take Cinebench R23, where M1 Pro (10+16) has about the same performance as the top contenders that do not have dedicated GPU cores, e.g. Ryzen 9 5900HX and Core i9-11980HK. Throw in a dedicated GPU for a work task that can properly utilize it, and the performance difference is at least 3x that of the M1.

Now, I'm not saying that the M1 is bad. It's just that.... "Completely obliterates the competition for laptops" is a strange way to describe "yeah, if both systems do very little, the M1 will use much less power!". For many, this results in it being the best laptop CPU for the tradeoffs they want, especially if the MacOS is an added positive.

However, that the M1 competes and outperforms in terms of computation performance, would be just wrong.

okamiueru··on 54% of adults in the United States have prose literacy below the 6th-grade level
An uneducated population is easier to persuade to vote against its own interests.
okamiueru··on Microsoft’s new Windows prompts try to stop people downloading Chrome
I see. I did not really follow the literal sense of "utopian". Such a high bar doesn't really exist for software. Just from a philosophical point of view, such a thing can arguably not exist. So I honestly didn't think anyone was actually taking that at face value.

But, to just focus on the arguments you had on Linux. Android is only a drop in the water in terms of Linux kernel usage. And we have every reason to believe they chose Linux based on its technical merits. It actually works pretty well for what an operating system needs to do. The top 500 supercomputers, worth billions (the fastest one alone cost 1 billion) don't pick Linux because it is cheaper. They pick it because it does what it needs to do, fairly decently. The NT kernel has a bag of decades old shit stinking up the place, so that's a no go. And MacOS forked Unix is not licensed to run on anything non-apple branded, not that that would matter, since there would be zero incentive to do so.

The argument presented that there is no open source software that is better than the commercial equivalent, is what I gave counter examples to. Which is demonstrably easy to argue against. Which I have done. You wouldn't want to use anything other than Linux for a supercomputer. AWS and GCP run their systems on Linux.

okamiueru··on Apple broke up with me
There are also pretty decent in-betweens based on AOSP like CalyxOS or /e/.

I'm pretty happy with the transition to CalyxOS. Everything works as before, but I can now limit internet access to apps, and there is a much more consumer friendly view of permissions. Not tying the whole phone to system-level user with google services feels great. Specifics that need it still gets it, like YouTube.

okamiueru··on Microsoft’s new Windows prompts try to stop people downloading Chrome
To clarify, when you say these are "non-utopian", it would help to know what that means to you.

I honestly think blender is a technical marvel that in many cases is better than its proprietary counterparts. The bar is quite high for these kinds of specialised and very expensive software. So, if blender is "bad", then perhaps the bar is set so high, that I don't think I can give a satisfactory answer.

"Utopian" in that there is nothing that could be better or improved is a higher bar than what I had in mind. But, just "better or equal than its proprietary counterparts", I do feel there are examples. Linux itself being a very clear one. There is a reason why it's the most used operating system by a mile (something like 90-98%). More contentiously I would also include it for desktop use. Hmm, perhaps AOSP also.

Out of the many tools you've mentioned, I've used most of them as well, and I don't consider any of them particularly great. But, what are the closed source alternatives that are better?

Perhaps also fish, as I cannot think of a better proprietary shell. Powershell and its windows integration is uaf.

Maybe some of my examples are skewed by the value I place on it not being controlled by corporate interests. That my usage isn't profiled, that I'm not exposed to dark patterns for KPIs at some board meeting.

okamiueru··on Microsoft’s new Windows prompts try to stop people downloading Chrome
I could not agree more. It's almost baffling to see the constant frustration of closed operating systems, and then outright rejecting Linux as an alternative, as if stuck one some preconception that it is bad. I've regularly used all three, and from my point of view, they are not even close to being equal. It's the only platform where I can start my day, and reliably get to work, without any unexpected fuckery wasting half my day.

The only thing that causes a comparatively bad experience on Linux is in part software availability or driver related, neither of which is the fault of the operating system itself.

okamiueru··on Microsoft’s new Windows prompts try to stop people downloading Chrome
> but I've never actually found a single piece of software, FOSS or not, that is anywhere close to "utopian" (or barely even "functioning").

Probably because of which fields you work in. But in software development, I'd say it is almost exclusively the case all over the board.

If you work in digital arts, then Blender is probably the best end-user application example I can think of.

okamiueru··on 3MF file format and why it’s great (2019)
There is a good reason for why one would want to store data the same way as when you work on it. It removes the need to process the data itself. A common approach is to follow it up with a fast compression algorithm when storage space is important.

The difference in post-processing when having to decode text is around two orders of magnitude, which is very significant. In the case of the 3MF format in question in this article, I find the tradeoff for human readable files to be a very strange one. The benefit of that at the cost of say waiting a minute to load a file that would otherwise take a second, is a puzzling one. But, it's all a tradeoff after all. If humans work with the files, it is a strong argument work with text. When software stores and loads files, it will likely be a poor choice to store data as text.

But, you are right. The file size consideration is not all that relevant. However, what was mostly discussed was the argument that serializing text that represents numbers is more space efficient. Which as I mentioned a few times, can only be the case when the straight serialization of the numbers is done poorly.

okamiueru··on 3MF file format and why it’s great (2019)
That is a good point. It is a good observation that just binary encoding numbers does not mean you have an efficient serialized representation. And, that sometimes that can be so bad that even encoding numbers as serialized text beats it out.

I think what threw me off was the context of this discussion, which was 3MF file format. For such cases, the usefulness of humans opening up the data in text editors is somewhat contrived. I believe that tradeoff for the 3MF format was a mistake, and will likely hinder broad adoption. I'm however mostly concerned with the extra processing required in order to decode the human readable files. We're talking a likely speedup of a factor of 50-100. For models that push this limit, imagine a file that takes 60 seconds to process. This isn't entirely unreasonable for a model with insane level of details. If they instead had gone for a binary file representation, the load time would likely be less than a second. Failing to recognize this tradeoff for human readable text... is unfortunate.

okamiueru··on 3MF file format and why it’s great (2019)
Seems we then spoke past each other. I did not focus on practical aspects or other such tradeoffs. Just, what is the most efficient way to represent numbers. If your argument is that for many practical applications, text is good enough. Then, I don't disagree.

But, if the argument was that text is a more efficient way to store numerical data. Then, there is no need to bring beliefs into this discussion. It is just not the case. Serialisation of numbers have been solved by engineers many decades ago, and there are many to chose from based on extra information on what the numbers should represent. One such representation is actually useful as a lookup table for text. But, to suggest that breaking up a single numerical value into individual lookup table values, is somehow more efficient than storing the original value with the right choice of encoding it... I don't know. I don't care all that much. But, surely you can see my argument?

The whole thing is a tautology. For the sake of silliness, if ascii encoding numbers somehow was the most efficient way of encoding numbers (it isn't, but, let's say it was) then it would only then be exactly as efficient as "choosing the best way to serialize a number". But, surely, whatevever that data was, would then be most efficiently represented by the ascii representation. So, we should store the ascii representation of the bytes that store the lookup table values, as encoded ascii values. Doesn't take more than a handful iterations before you run out of storage space available on the planet.

okamiueru··on 3MF file format and why it’s great (2019)
I too am curious. Not that it really matters. The statement itself is a tautology. There is no "opinion" here. Just straight logic and math. Text serialization is a way to serialize numbers. It's just a very poor and roundabout way made for human readable text. The idea that such a roundabout way of storing numbers as other numbers should somehow make things more efficient than storing the actual numbers... Is kinda silly.
okamiueru··on 3MF file format and why it’s great (2019)
That is of course true. My point was to highlight the kind of situations where straight serialization of text would be somewhat closer in required storage, when compared to similar serialization of number values. That serializations of such numbers would only encode a subset of the values it can represent, I would say, is besides the point. It is after all how number representations work.

To reiterate my original point: It is never the case that serializing text that represents numbers is the most efficient representation. The posts here seem to either suggest or think this is the case. And this was only the size consideration. It is even worse in terms of processing. You need to do O(n) operations on the length of text data just in order to decode the values. A step that is entirely avoided with a correct binary format.

Just a anecdotal example here on the computational aspect. Maybe 10 years ago or so, I used an OBJ loading library that would straight up decode 3d models represented as ASCII text. I wrote a simple de/serialization program, just 70 lines of code, to both dump and read dumped data. The load speed for a complicated scene went from 38 to 0.7 seconds.

This isn't to say there aren't good use cases for text formats. However, it is always a tradeoff for human readable data, at the expense of efficiency (storage and computational). The former is much less so when using a simple compression step. Very often this tradeoff is acceptable.

okamiueru··on 3MF file format and why it’s great (2019)
Part of serialization is getting to pick how you encode numbers. And, one should do so with a good match on the range or required precision. I'm not sure double values are required here or necessary.

> Text compression of number data is extremely efficient

Of course it isn't. It is arguably one of the worst there is. It can only ever by more efficient when representing a very low subset of values and the alternative binary representation is exceedingly poor. But those constraint would make the whole discussion kinda silly.

Serializing text, is after all binary encoding data. If you follow this with compression algorithms, you'll likely not end up too far away in either case.

Just take the example you gave. "A 5 digit integer is 3 bytes less than the double to store it". Yes, true. However, a 5 digit integer can also be represented by 12 bits.

And you can even pack them if this is all you really care about (there is a good reason why you wouldn't want to do this, as word alignment is much more important, as you would be able to directly map data to memory allocations, but let's for argument sake say that storage was king). For each 5 digit numbers as a text file, you'll need another byte to encode the line break or delimiter. I.e. 6 bytes instead of 12 bits, or 4 times wasted space. For a million values, 5.7 MiB instead of 1.4 MiB.

okamiueru··on The Toit language is now open source
> I had to switch to a more powerful board though

And therein lies the rub. If you can throw more computational power and resources at your problem, then you should absolutely go for something with simpler abstractions that make better use of your time.

The problem is however not with C or C++, but rather inexperience in how to manage the control/flexibility these languages allow. You now have 50 ways to shoot yourself in the foot, instead of the otherwise handful. And, you also get the choice of a few bazookas.

> I have no idea how people write whole browsers and operating systems in this language.

They use best practices that avoid all of the aforementioned 50 ways.

okamiueru··on Simple Linux kernel memory corruption bug can lead to complete system compromise
I'm not sure to what extend you are being facetious, so I'll take it at face value. Rust doesn't particularly attract "crazies", and nor are software developers mostly crazies. So, I believe your criteria is exceptionally bad at filtering those kinds of developers out. Hiring good people is challenging enough as it is without doing the job poorly. My advice, unwarranted as it is, is to revise your preconceptions.
okamiueru··on Simple Linux kernel memory corruption bug can lead to complete system compromise
You are expressing widely different things though. You said you would consider out right rejecting someone and question their mental health for having rust on their resume.

Having a tool on a resume, or listing experience with tools, should certainly not be interpreted as someone being a rust zealot, evangelist, "pratting on endlessly", and all the rest of the examples you gave. So, maybe you initially wrote something different to what you actually meant.

okamiueru··on Simple Linux kernel memory corruption bug can lead to complete system compromise
I'm sure if that was the management attitude that would have welcomed them, it is a win-win situation.
okamiueru··on Pop OS – System76
I honestly don't remember any longer. I think one of the things was the windows-key behavior. I used to be able to just hit that, fuzzy search the app and hit enter. I might be entirely mistaken that this was one of the things though. Apologies for my lousy memory.
okamiueru··on Pop OS – System76
The first thing I do on a fresh Ubuntu is to purge away everything related to snap.

I tried PopOS at one point, to see what it was about. And, I honestly don't understand what it adds to the table. It felt like many minor things were changed to be different, but overall it had the same things I wanted. After being annoyed for a couple of days, I installed Ubuntu, removed snap, and everything is pleasant again.

okamiueru··on The climate disaster is here
Is anyone else struggling with staying positive about possibly adding a new generation to this world? Any tips on dealing with this? I've voted for the last decade to prioritize climate change issues, but it feels like a defeatist endeavour. I suppose I could do more. Cut out meat entirely, so maybe I'm just a hypocrite. Reading reports like this just confirms what we already know. So, why isn't more being done by global economies? "I've got mine"? Why do we keep on with such a wasteful way of life? Covid restrictions lift, and people immediately flock to airplanes to go on holidays. Maybe I just need to go for a walk.
okamiueru··on Firefox Now Sends Your Address Bar Keystrokes to Mozilla
What is the general opinion on Vivaldi?
okamiueru··on Mozilla to put ads in Firefox address bar suggestions
I've been using Vivaldi lately, and very happy with it.

I really missed the old days of Opera, which for a long time was superior to Firefox and Chrome in so many ways. Up until they changed the web, and Opera dom/rendering engine couldn't keep up.

Vivaldi is the successor to Opera in many ways.

okamiueru··on The Apple A15 SoC Performance Review: Faster and More Efficient
> It trounces the majority of either of those - which something a revolutionary product would do.

This isn't even remotely true. Computers are really good at doing more than one thing at a time. I find it mind-boggling that there is such a focus on the performance of a single core. This hasn't been all that relevant for the last 15 years. As for what this matters, the difference for single core isn't all that big regardless (one M1 core performs about the same as one 5980HS thread). When you want to know how powerful the computing power of a CPU is, how about comparing .. you know... what it can do?

And, what it can do when it is asked to do everything it can, I can reiterate that the M1 is nowhere near the competition. The 5980HS mobile CPU will get the same multi-threaded job done in half the time, which is a huge difference. Which is why discussion threads like these feel... chilling. Like as if I stepped in to a cult meeting, where we praise normalcy as revolutionary. It's not even close to the last generation of CPUs in terms of compute power. It just a step up from the Intel CPUs apple used in the previous MBPs.

And, it's not that the M1 is a bad CPU. It's actually pretty good for what it does, and it is exceptionally good at power efficiency. The 5nm and low thread count does contribute significantly to the power performance, so it will be interesting to to see how future M1 processors perform.

Imagine if the M2 doubled core count, and thus doubled multi-core performance compared to the M1. It would then be just as powerful as the current 5980HS. Another revolution no doubt.

okamiueru··on Company That Routes Billions of Text Messages Quietly Says It Was Hacked
I believe the argument is that of "click bait". That it is deliberately being vague with "company that routers..." so that you have to click, and given the timing, in order to rid yourself of a wrong assumption.

So, it's not that the title is wrong. Just that it seems misleading.

okamiueru··on The Apple A15 SoC Performance Review: Faster and More Efficient
The reason why I asked was because you say x86, but you don't mean the competition of x86, but the older generation of apple's x86 based hardware. Also, three of those things you mention are arguably the same -- quieter, cooler and battery life are all tied to power efficiency, which the M1 excels at. So, it is kinda like with every discussion thread on the M1, everyone kinda suggesting it is a powerful CPU, while it is just power efficient. From a computational point of view, where it matters, it is far behind the competition. "Catching up to x86" in this regard makes very little sense, but you also explicitly omit computational power, which of course is accurate. I certainly would not think this was revolutionary for a CPU any sense of the word, but to each their own.

This discussion also comes up again and again on HN on the M1. People say weird things like that the never experienced such a jump in computational power from one generation to the next. And what they tend to mean is from older apple hardware to newer hardware.

okamiueru··on The Apple A15 SoC Performance Review: Faster and More Efficient
Here is what I find confusing. When people say the M1 is revolutionary, it really seems to suggest that the playing field is "available CPUs on the market". But, then some mean it to be "no, just compared to old CPUs in the previous generation of the same product".
okamiueru··on The Apple A15 SoC Performance Review: Faster and More Efficient
The power consumption is very impressive indeed. But, I think there are many compromises to be made when scaling up, so we'll see how the M2 performs in this regard. However, aside from power consumption, I find it interesting that people refer to it as such a revolution. Maybe I'm just imagining a unspoken "... for what is to come". Because as is, the only thing the M1 does better than it's competition is arguably the power consumption. The 5950x you mention, although an apples to oranges comparison will outperform highly parallelizable tasks by a factor of 4. Throw in a top end GPU and it becomes a factor of 14.

Now, power consumption may be the end all be all for some people. If your work tasks actually don't require a lot of computational power, then I can see it being much more valuable to have the flexibility of a cool laptop with a long battery life.

But, touting the M1 as revolutionary, because all that matters is power consumption, feels like a disconnect to me. I'm all for people liking stuff they like. But, I don't get what's revolutionary at all. I was interesting in hearing what people thought about it though.

okamiueru··on The Apple A15 SoC Performance Review: Faster and More Efficient
In which particular area are you suggesting that the M1 is ahead for x86 to catch up?
← PreviousPage 13 of 28Next →