2,285 karma · joined December 10, 2011
Your question as to who these people are, is still valid. So my objection is only to the extent that it being unknown doesn't mean it isn't likely.
But, if we accept a less restrictive/strict outcome, then unguided exploration is very likely a net positive. I think many well known "unorthodox" musicians did this, and also attributed it to exactly that. Though I cannot recall specific examples. So take it with a grain of salt. I'll look up who I suspect.
Edit: Searching for examples of largely self taught musicians, there are lots of examples. What this implies, probably varies wildly. So feel free to correct the examples I encountered: Chopin, Hendrix, Schubert, Uematsu, Bowie.
Would I be correct in assuming that you're tired of people not doing proper data engineering, and in general having a irresponsible disregard for it?
At least, "soul crushing to constantly be fixing problems that shouldn't have happened in the first place" resonates a lot. But I mostly see it as a result of the aforementioned.
So, not in reply to you, but the parent. It then seems entirely accurate to say they are not comparable.
Ffmpeg as workhorse is common. But what handbrake and losslesscut are in terms of (mostly) UI, they solve different problems, of which there isn't much to compare.
For example: You have a problem that is suitable for some message queue -> Apache Kafka. Now you have 7 new problems and the complexity warrants perhaps 3 other services, and on, and on.
> At Hack Club we're reimagining a new type of public education for technology. We believe people learn best by creating things they care about and sharing them with others. We build open source creative tools with young people all around the world. These tools are gateways to new subjects in technology like embedded systems, circuits or digital fabrication robotics. When teenagers build things with our tools we send them more creative materials for free.
> Our goal is to build a new type of library online that offers learners not just media to consume but tools to create. And it is free and open source to all. We're just getting started...
This is also great. But, I'm still confused by the name.
Shipping is usually referred to sending something through, well, ships originally, but postage in general this day. But, I don't think it has anything to do with that.
Am I missing something? Perhaps something lost in translation?
Edit: Aha. I just didn't read it correctly. The concept is that you contribute by sending materials to teenagers who are trying to learn this stuff? That's amazing!
I think everyone cares, whether they know it or not. Which sounds like an oxymoron. But my point is that inconsistent UX might not be glaringly noticeable, but it can still give a feeling of messiness and add to cognitive load.
"Native widgets" is just a way to achieve "consistent widgets". A good tradeoff IMO is to at handle as many things with native UX (e.g. window decorations, menus, etc.), as possible without compromising on function.
To avoid the latter, custom GUI is arguably necessary, as is the case with Blender, while OBS arguably doesn't need its own handling of the menu / window decoration.
These things matter very much to some people, as consistency affects how well certain accessibility tooling can understand the contents of applications. UI customization also matters for similar reasons. Certain things like scaling or theming, might rely on native GUI libraries.
To summarize, if the discussion is what is "best", and you don't have a functional reason to justify custom UX, and you disregard development cost, then the best solution is a consistent UX, i.e. native widgets.
When I want to do actual work, I stay at home.
If I couldn't decide how to best do my job, I'd have a chat with my manager, and change jobs if we couldn't agree on something so basic.
Compare it with
> - Don't like that apple's "Music" app pops up when you connect a Bluetooth headset? => Install an app
The only difference is that you add a puzzling self contradiction of "the problem isn't Apple, but that Apple has..."
This is entirely an Apple and MacOS thing, and most certainly not an issue on Linux. Though I don't know about Windows.
Heaven forbid the OS could let you chose what you want to happen... like launching Spotify instead, or simply nothing at all...
It's the headset doing something wrong. What a fascinating take. You wouldn't happen to be working at Apple R&D?
Maybe I missed the /s, it's just too on the nose, almost as if you're ridiculing it.
The answer to most "it's a bit dumb that MacOS doesn't let you / forces you to" is "install app X, Y, Z".
- Don't like that apple's "Music" app pops up when you connect a Bluetooth headset? => Install an app.
- Want to be able to "alt tab" through windows of the same program, or in general not be uselessly flawed? => Install an app
- Want to be able to move and resize windows without aiming at the exact edge pixels of the window? => Install an app.
- Want to move & resize windows to very common places and sizes on a screen? => Install an app.
- Want global hotkeys for whatever? => Install an app
- Want a software package management system a'la apt? => Install an app.
- Want to rebind keys or make things like Home/End not be dead keys... because apple keyboards don't have that, and they cannot be bothered with it. "you should be using "⌘ + →" anyways... or, I suppose it depends on the window"? => Install an app.
- etc....
You don't get any of these annoyances with Linux / Gnome. "Why not use that if you hate MacOS so much?" I pretend to hear you say. First of all, because of anti-competitive reasons by Apple, I sort of have to. Secondly... something something angry old man yells at clouds.
They could have gone down the path of translating the windows UI APIs, though I think it's better that they left it as is. The bigger issue however, is that there are different systems depending on what it is you want to configure, and it's all ducktaped in an ancient registry that I'm just amazed only breaks as often as it does.
Not to mention that the thing Windows was supposed to always be better at, was driver support. On windows, you have to manually source them, and try as best to avoid all the bloatware that comes with. Windows itself might also decide to replace a driver with an older one (version, release date...). WiFi drivers didn't work last time I upgraded the mobo either.
As for Linux. Completely agree. Gnome is consistent, and gets out of the way often enough. There are some annoyances there too. I have my 90 y/o grandma use Linux/Gnome, because that's what Just Works these days.
The list of specific annoyances and bugs is likely in the 3 digits by now, and I've only used it for half a year.
The worst of all was getting the M2 soft-bricked by an update, because I had changed the display frame rate to 60Hz, because the tween duration when moving between desktops was for some reason tied to this refresh rate. About 2 second tween duration on 120 Hz until input control, and one second on 60 Hz. Impressive for such a thing to not be picked up by QA.
In my experience, incompetence has been the underlying cause for a lot that seems like malice or something more deliberate. Especially when combined with social aspects like not wanting to lose face, or having an ego.
I suppose that the transition between incompetence and malice isn't exactly black and white either, or mutually exclusive for that matter.
I've seen complacency too. People who know better, but instead of arguing that point, they go along the path of least resistance. "I get my paycheck either way"-kind of mindset.
I have yet to experience someone deliberately turning 70 lines of code into 3k lines. But, I've certainly seen that exact same thing happen. Almost surprising how similar it sounds. I should check how many lines it is, but if I would guess, it was 1k lines of code that could be done in 10. Which is what you get when you manually write a API client and objects, and you've split out the 10 lines of code into 4 separate micro-services (this isn't an exaggeration). I'm 99% sure that this was a case of not understanding why it was a terrible approach, and it being driven by consultants who are happy to explore some unsuited approach just for the CV-padding of it, if nothing else.
Deliberate feigned incompetence to make a problem worse, or job safety. I've yet to actually experience and confirm this for myself.
What you describe as "He knows! We've been found out!" might be entirely true, but it could also reflect being found out as in the impostor syndrome.. or "... that we have no clue", etc.
- If "sign with SSH instead of GPG", the answer is convenience.
- If "sign commits", the answer is authentication of the user of the commit.
Encryption part isn't relevant as you get that already regardless with https/ssh protocols when communicating with the git server.
As for why you want to authenticate the user, the better question to ask, is, why wouldn't you? No one can push any commit on your behalf. In some cases it is extremely important because certain branches might be protected due to automated CI/CD pipelines that contain secrets. Without enforcing verification of authenticity, a user might push a commit pretending to be a different user, which exposes those secrets. One might say "well, then you have a bigger problem in your organization", which leads to the restated question of "why not?". It just one of those things we do, like health care workers washing their hands.
So, what's the point of this? I was explaining things for your sake. You do not seem to care for it. So, just leave it be then?
... well, if you were offended by me linking the scientific method... it's because it might bridge the gap in why you think "that's the point".
It seem to me that, after all this, you still fail to understand the argument I've presented. I've made a lot of effort, in good faith, in trying to figure out why, and address it. The argument is also remarkably simple, as is the examples given. The argument wasn't so much physics, as didactics. But we got stuck on the physics part, because we don't share the same understanding of what logical inference requires. Hence... the aforementioned suggestion.
But, it has reached the point of just being silly. One can only lead the horse to the water. Doesn't seem productive to carry on with the spoon feeding.
> Stew on that.
I'm starting to get the impression that you don't really follow my arguments.
> > There is no "uncontroversial" series of arguments that will reach the logical conclusion "there are countless universes"
> Oh but there is. That's the point of the video. The arguments are laid bare if you care.
Yeah, I skimmed the video now. It's all related to the anthropic principle. Also, nothing is particularly complicated, and, it's exactly what I expected it to be. Hence my previous stated assumption "... is one way to explain the unlikeliness of the physical constants working out the way they "conveniently" do in our universe". I think I could get a a 10 year old to fully understand the fundamental concepts here, though certainly not by having them watch the video.
At 12:47 he states:
"The strong anthropic principle seems to make sense of the incredible fine tuning of our own universe. [Pause for effect] But does that fine tuning actually predict the multiverse? Well, this is a highly controversial point".
So, I suppose it's nice that you made me watch a bit more. Turns out I was right about what you convinced me I was wrong about (It's all tied to the anthropic principle, which includes details on the physical constants I referred to, and how the multiverse is a way to speculate as to why), and it also turns out PBS explicitly agrees with my objection. You know, the one about the initially stated inference being "totally uncontroversial". Telling me to watch the video to find out why, where they say the inference is controversial..... nice. But I have to ask then, did you watch it? That said, I did expect PBS to actually understand the topic. So it wasn't all that surprising that they would contradict the initial statement. After all, it was just a "literary device".
Have a great day.
PS: Regarding, "If only you'll watch the video to understand why it might in fact be a valid inference!". It's either a valid inference, or it isn't. (My point: It isn't, so it shouldn't be presented as if it is)
PPS: PBS is alright. It isn't for me, as it annoys me more often than not. I don't expect everyone to agree, nor is that my goal or desire. Heck, if PBS comes across this and thinks there are any take-aways, maybe that's all worth while. If nothing else, I do genuinely wish for you to have a nice day.
PPPS: Don't focus on the "predict" aspect. I suspect you might want to. But at some point I'd refer you to... maybe this is a good resource https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/scientific-method/
-----
For shits and giggles, I pasted this prompt into ChatGPT4: "Related to the anthropic principle, here are three statements, and a suggested inference between then. Can you point out any issues? They are all states as being totally uncontroversial: "Life exists in our universe" ⇝ "Our universe is capable of producing and sustaining life" ⇝ "there are countless universes"."
--- ChatGPT response start ---
""""
The three statements you've presented related to the anthropic principle and the suggested inference between them touch upon a range of complex issues in the philosophy of science, cosmology, and metaphysics. Here's a breakdown and analysis of each statement and the potential issues with the inference:
"Life exists in our universe" - This statement is indeed uncontroversial and supported by empirical evidence. We have direct evidence of life on Earth, and current scientific endeavors are exploring the possibility of life elsewhere in our universe.
"Our universe is capable of producing and sustaining life" - This follows logically from the first statement. Since life exists in our universe, it is a direct observation that our universe has the necessary conditions to produce and sustain life, at least in some regions like Earth.
"There are countless universes" (Multiverse Theory) - The leap to this statement from the previous ones introduces several controversial aspects:
- Lack of Direct Evidence: There is currently no direct empirical evidence for the existence of other universes, making this a speculative hypothesis rather than a well-established scientific theory.
- Inference from Fine-Tuning: The argument often used to support the multiverse concept is based on the fine-tuning of the constants and laws of physics that make life possible in our universe. The reasoning is that if there are countless universes, each with potentially different physical constants and laws, it wouldn't be surprising that at least one of them (ours) has the right conditions for life. However, this inference is a significant leap from the observational statements preceding it and rests on speculative physics and philosophical arguments rather than direct observation.
- Philosophical and Scientific Controversies: The multiverse hypothesis raises numerous philosophical questions about the nature of reality, the definition of a universe, and the limits of scientific knowledge. It also challenges the principle of parsimony or Occam's Razor, which suggests preferring simpler theories until more complex ones are necessitated by evidence.
Issues with the Inference: Non-Sequitur: The inference from the universe being life-sustaining to the existence of countless universes is a non-sequitur, meaning it does not logically follow from the previous statements. While the first two statements are grounded in observation, the leap to a multiverse requires additional assumptions not contained within the observational evidence.
Speculative Nature: The multiverse hypothesis, while a fascinating area of theoretical physics and cosmology, remains highly speculative and beyond the current reach of empirical verification.
Philosophical Implications: The argument touches on deep philosophical issues about the nature of existence and our ability to understand the universe. It also involves the anthropic principle, which has various formulations that can lead to different conclusions about the nature of the universe and the significance of human life within it.
In summary, while the first two statements are uncontroversial and empirically supported, the inference to the existence of countless universes introduces speculative elements that are not directly supported by the evidence cited."""
--- ChatGPT response end ---
Nice that ChatGPT and I seem to agree. Apologies for the formatting mess.
Here is a suggestion:
"Life exists in our universe" ⇝ "Our universe is capable of producing and sustaining life" ⇝ "The fundamental laws and constants of our universe are finely tuned to allow the existence of life" (aka the anthropic principle).
And then something like... "This fine-tuning can lead us to speculate that our universe might be just one of many, each with different laws and constants, in a vast multiverse". Or something along those lines.