HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

okamiueru

2,285 karma · joined December 10, 2011

submissionscomments
okamiueru··on Inside the proton, the ‘most complicated thing you could possibly imagine’
You seem very hung up on my incorrect assumption as to what extent the video was about the anthropic principle or not. I have not watched it, nor do I intend to, and I am happy with being wrong about it. That said, it also isn't relevant to my dislike of PBS, or arguments presented. I just happened to click and take a peek at this particular video, to see if I could pinpoint the kind of stuff that I have come to associate with them. I didn't need to watch very long to find examples. Examples, that you can take at face value, in it's own isolated context, which makes it completely irrelevant what you are hung up on, and suggesting I am confused by.

So, I'll make it simple.

"LIFE = MULTIVERSE?", is... a very dumb statement. It can function as a clickbait, but I'm assuming that PBS wants to suggest a relationship of inference. Why start out with possibly giving someone a wrong idea/concept? Now, this isn't a big deal. I just took a peek, and the first thing I saw was rather dumb. So, that's what I'll mention.

Secondly is the sequence of statements, that are explicitly stated as "uncontroversial" in the inference between them.

They are:

"Life exists in our universe" ⇝ "Our universe is capable of producing and sustaining life" ⇝ "there are countless universes".

I'm taking these at face value. Third inference is invalid for more than one reason. Yet, it is presented as nothing but. You consider that OK. I can only think of two possible explanations for why: 1. You consider it OK to be incorrect and misleading when it is used as a literary device. 2. You do not understand why it is an invalid inference.

Either is fine by me. However, I'm not really confused. This... isn't very confusing. The only thing I've stated as a personal opinion here, is that I dislike PBS for being misleading and incorrect, as a literary device. You suggested that they weren't being misleading or incorrect, because there is a "hint hint, nudge nudge" that it might be ironic. So, my person opinion is: well, that's pretty fucking annoying. Hence my conclusion. Which is why I'll just stick to Derek and the likes who can manage to dumb things down to my level. Everyone is happy.

PS: .. and in case you might argue this; it also doesn't matter what they explain later on, if that's why you mentioned I should watch on. There is no "uncontroversial" series of arguments that will reach the logical conclusion "there are countless universes". It's just one of several ways to reason about why life, and the laws of physics, happen to allow something otherwise improbable. Which is what I'm assuming they will get to, but again, I have no intentions of watching it.

okamiueru··on Inside the proton, the ‘most complicated thing you could possibly imagine’
Sounds like we agree then.

The difference in opinion is that I don't consider literary devices to validate incorrect or misleading statements. Which is why I dislike PBS. You do, and that's fine. To each their own.

okamiueru··on Inside the proton, the ‘most complicated thing you could possibly imagine’
Are you sure you got the argument I'm presenting? You did quickly make an edit to avoid a rather rude remark.

My point is that their use of literary devices, as you put it, are often misleading if not flat out wrong. The listener needs to he able identify them as such, and I don't think that's a good way to communicate science.

It doesn't mean that PBS is bad. Note that I have made no such statement. I'm just saying that I dislike it, and tried to be constructive as to why. If this offended you, like your initial remark might suggest, perhaps you are reading too much into it.

okamiueru··on Inside the proton, the ‘most complicated thing you could possibly imagine’
I'm not convinced. When he talks about things I understand, he does so in a way that I still find frustratingly convoluted. In these cases, it's not for a lack of education. It probably just means that this style of presenting topics just isn't for me, which is completely fine. Diversity in free education is great and commendable.

But I think you touch on the part that I think is the reason why. Because PBS tries to dumb things down, but instead of doing it like Derek does, which adds clarity, PBS does it by "mystifying" it. Probably tickles someone's itch, but I find it annoying.

Take the video posted, for example. It starts out immediately with thumbnail "Life = Multiverse?". If it really was for the niche audience, that title is remarkably dumb, although understandable for the same reasons clickbait titles work. Perhaps PBS meant to present the question whether one leads to or suggests the other? "Life ⇝ Multiverse?" would better express that. Though, the thought process of how multiverse and the anthropic principle go together is: "Multiverse ⇝ Life?".

The video starts out by expressing three statements, related to the Anthropic Principle (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropic_principle). Had they instead worded those statements as to be correct, it would be a very nice way of introducing the topic.

This is how it is presented:

"Life exists in our universe" ⇝ "Our universe is capable of producing and sustaining life". Which is fine. We understand what producing and sustaining life is, because it is really just the first statement with some added anthropomorphism.

The next one, which is the whole point of the "hook" for the video, and is probably intended to be a little bit cheeky, except that he keeps a straight face, so, unless you know enough, it'll probably just misinform you.

"Okay. Let's try one final uncontroversial statement. Therefore, there are countless universes".

Well, no. Multiverse theory is one way to explain the unlikeliness of the physical constants working out the way they "conveniently" do in our universe. But this logical inference is not an "uncontroversial statement". It doesn't qualify, yet it is dumbed down to suggest it does. I'm sure that the following "Hm", and look to the side, is meant to express this. What do I know. But I'm not particularly amused or impressed.

So, so far, we've seen the thumbnail, and the first three sentences before the intro video rolls. And, it's been 1. Inaccurate information in thumbnail, 2. incorrect logical inference 3. false conclusion.

I can probably continue the video, but this is why I dislike PBS so much. It doesn't really try to dumb things down. It just IMO, fails to communicate science well.

okamiueru··on Inside the proton, the ‘most complicated thing you could possibly imagine’
I strongly dislike PBS Space Time, but I find it hard to explain why. I might also be just too dumb to get it. It's just the feeling of the goal not being the "listener gaining understanding", but rather "expressing how confusing and complicated it is".
okamiueru··on Apple has not fixed the macOS audio left/right balance bug for nearly 10 years
MacOS and Windows are, in my honest opinion, significantly less consistent experiences than Gnome. The list I have on MacOS UX annoyances, design inconsistencies and implementation bugs is in the hundreds.
okamiueru··on Apple has not fixed the macOS audio left/right balance bug for nearly 10 years
Even funnier is upgrading ventura could brick your Mx if you had changed the refresh rate on the display.
okamiueru··on 'Baby Bust': Why Fewer Young People Expect to Become Parents (2013)
Just be careful as to not collapse into a black hole.
okamiueru··on 'Baby Bust': Why Fewer Young People Expect to Become Parents (2013)
The expression "you can only lead a horse to water" doesn't really cut it. The horse is neck deep. We've been spoon feeding it. Tried IV hydration. Not even a bucket of water with apples made a difference. A sealion doesn't have to be self aware of the fact. I'm out.
okamiueru··on 'Baby Bust': Why Fewer Young People Expect to Become Parents (2013)
Why is it so hard for you to believe that Republicans are against contraception?

In the House, it was voted for by 100% of Democrats, and voted against by 96% of Republicans. The text, in full, if you want to read it is here: https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/117/hr8373/text

It's not very long. I've read it. It is the answer to what you want to know, straight from the horses mouth. There is no uncertainty or middle-man telling you how to interpret things. Just read it, and then consider that 96% of Republicans did not wish for that bill to go to congress.

You can then try to surmise what plausible reasoning they might have had to object. Just be somewhat critical, otherwise you'll just reaffirm what you already wanted to believe.

Don't know what else I can suggest on this matter.

okamiueru··on 'Baby Bust': Why Fewer Young People Expect to Become Parents (2013)
Did you see the link someone suggested: https://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/117-2022/h385 ?

A lot of things in politics can be murky. US republican votes on certain issues, is not one of them. If this stuff is obvious to me, and I don't even live there, I have to wonder how it is you can be so under-informed to genuinely think that Republican legislators are not against the restriction of contraception.

okamiueru··on 'Baby Bust': Why Fewer Young People Expect to Become Parents (2013)
Is... this sealioning? It's one of the easiest things to find endless examples of. I won't assume you are arguing in bad faith here, so, what have you done in an attempt to find the answer to that question?
okamiueru··on 'Baby Bust': Why Fewer Young People Expect to Become Parents (2013)
Why make procreation appealing through economic safety and optimism, when you can just make contraception and abortion harder to acquire or straight up illegal? Something, something, America.
okamiueru··on 46% of Americans didn't read a book in 2023
It very much contradicts what I said earlier. Don't remember the source. The only difference is that this also includes listening to audio-books. 53% in 2023, for 18-29 year-old, according to your source. Thanks for the correction.
okamiueru··on 46% of Americans didn't read a book in 2023
A lot higher than what I had thought. If only around 20% of Americans read a book, any book, within the ages 18-29, maybe the ranges outside of it make up for it?
okamiueru··on ZX – A tool for writing better scripts
> How am I supposed to put a script written using this tool in $PATH?

Separate file that invokes sh or bash and calls the script file with zx and the path to the mjs file.

Should do it.

Though I agree with your objection. The requirement for specific extension while also suggesting a shebang, breaks conventions and expectations. From what I can tell from comments made, it's done that way because they prefer it. Which... is a bit silly. But to each their own.

okamiueru··on ZX – A tool for writing better scripts
Extensions are predefined mapping to the executing program. There is no real concept of compatibility there. Useful for media files where you e.g. pick your image-viewer-of-choice, less useful when the script file already has a very strong opinion as to the expected executing binary. Compatibility can be hinted at, but really only determined on the application level.

If the script runtime binary then looks at the filename and does something differently based on it, it's likely not correct, and if it is done, it'd better be because of some necessity. The "we prefer it this way" is not a necessity. Plus it breaks conventions and expectations.

Enforcing file name extensions at execution, because you want to help an editor figure out how to lint or highlight the file, is also, arguably, letting a specific use case affect something it shouldn't.

okamiueru··on Tiny quadrotor learns to fly in 18 seconds
Excretion and simple movement from point to point, accurately describes most of my life.
okamiueru··on Goody-2, the world's most responsible AI model
Censoring LLMs is a fools errand. It is based on "topic" rather than substance. It also suggests that what it can talk about, is not harmful, when it's the personification of the left-side of Dunning-Kruger.

It's all bullshit that sounds like language and correct-ish for the context. Pretending some of it is harmful is putting a high bar on what it considers isn't.

Imagine you have a 10-year old, and you play a game of improv theater. The rules of the game are "You can only lose by admitting or suggesting that you don't know something. Making stuff up is OK. Contradicting yourself is OK".

This is more or less how I experience LLMs to be. I find it strange that some topics are "dangerous", when the danger is just assuming something said is factually correct.

Reminds me of a presentation on how to jailbreak LLMs, and you had your grandma tell you the ingredients and recipe for Napalm. Except, you can just google it. Unless the website contents was generated with LLMs, which is a troubling reality, it's likely to be correct. While the LLM side is just sentences that sound convincing. No requirement of the factual accuracy whatsoever.

okamiueru··on Drivers using Apple Vision Pro headsets prompt road safety concerns
> You can potentially use it as a distraction, or you can use it responsibly, just like anything else.

I lack the imagination for a responsible use case that isn't already covered by existing technology, and outweighs the risks related to a visual dependency strapped to your head running on battery.

Any suggestions? Otherwise, current assumption is that it's a case of wanting to make a point of owning something novel.

okamiueru··on Why is the mouse cursor slightly tilted and not straight?
I appreciate your responses. It seems to me that your uses are to a much larger degree interpretative and also somewhat creative.

LLMs are great here. My concerns are mostly that its ability for factual accuracy is confused with its own expressed confidence. Assessment of one's owns abilities is usually optimistic in humans. LLMs just model that language. Facts are baked in as linguistic patterns, rather than a knowledge machine. And, you can often invert its answer to a scary degree.

There was recently an article on Forbes, where the journalistic "source" was the output of Bard.

The most terrifying part about LLMs to me, is not that it's sometimes wrong. But that it's often enough right and excels at certain stuff, that we use it as a source of knowledge. It really isn't.

On the other hand, the creative part, or dialogues regarding creative processes. It's mind bogglingly amazing.

okamiueru··on Why is the mouse cursor slightly tilted and not straight?
How does it compare to ChatGPT 4? That's the only thing I've "vetted". It'll be subtly wrong about something, and if I point it out, I'll be "of course you are right!".

And, if you are wrong about what you said it was wrong about, it'll still almost always say how right you are.

okamiueru··on Why is the mouse cursor slightly tilted and not straight?
I hope we reach a collective maturity on this. LLMs have so far I've noticed, left a trail of mediocrity. I'll of course not notice the parts that are good, so there is some confirmation bias here.

And, I hate it. If not used appropriately, it's an automated output from left side on the Dunning-Kruger. Bullshit asymmetry has gotten more skewed, and it's tiresome.

okamiueru··on Learning Rust in 3 Attempts
Learning sole CS first is probably a good idea, but I don't agree with the reasoning. C++ exposes the underlying hardware to a large degree, and if you don't understand it, you'll be allowed to break stuff easily and before you know it. This is much harder to do in Rust. You don't need to know anything about function pointers, interrupts, registries, virtual tables, and what not, in order to follow the memory model. The unsafe parts, is a different story, so I suppose there is a limit. But Rust and C++ are fairly far apart imo.
okamiueru··on Outlook is Microsoft's new data collection service
If any ISP were to be caught doing this in the EU, it would be fairly big news.
okamiueru··on Outlook is Microsoft's new data collection service
Is it limiting tracking, or potentially exposing a untrusted middleman with knowledge of all your traffic, and who it belongs to?

What is the difference between the ISP knowing this and being a problem, but the VPN sitting with the exact same information, also knowing it?

okamiueru··on Outlook is Microsoft's new data collection service
You're wrong. I don't need more than one data point to make that conclusion.

I pay for protonmail, and I'm very happy with what I get. I can even use it as a client for receiving and sending email from my own domain. So, if ever I were to want to get away from it, my accounts won't be tied to the email provider.

okamiueru··on Apple now requires a judge's consent to hand over push notification data
Do you know how this relates to non-US customers in... non-US? I.e. everyone else, everywhere else? And, whatever applies to Apple in this sense, I assume also applies to Google.

If the US government knows when my laundry is done, because my local HomeAssistant instance uses google play services to send a push notification...

okamiueru··on Whisky: Wine supercharged with the power of Apple's game porting toolkit
Indeed. I think I only mentioned it because of the original reference to it not being a RTX 4090, with a somewhat adjusted perspective of what performance it is closer to.
okamiueru··on Whisky: Wine supercharged with the power of Apple's game porting toolkit
The graphics settings to ultra, and retina, you manage 25fps? With FSR perhaps? That's still very impressive if that's the case. I assumed the performance penalty would be severe

Edit: I saw your comment in parent thread.

← PreviousPage 4 of 28Next →