HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

okamiueru

2,285 karma · joined December 10, 2011

submissionscomments
okamiueru··on The Absurdity of Income Tax
Let's not turn this political and insults. The parent commenter is absolutely right about how it is supposed to work, even though you seem to feel it has failed at that.

I live in Norway, and I honestly feel that the description above matches what I expect from governments, and its how I'd vote. It doesn't mean they reach the ideal, but your description of reality does not match my observations at all.

okamiueru··on C++ Coroutines
To more elegantly write code that is async in nature like IO/Web requests? Let stuff happen and just await where needed?

Seems like different type of concern than what you need multiprocessing for.

okamiueru··on How to build a super-slim smart mirror
I don't think Linux is user-unfriendly if you want to learn how computers work. Also, if you want computers for the use cases that a RaspberryPi is intended for, then what other OS choice is there? Heck, just having an OS is an overkill of luxury for most of those projects to begin with.

It's unfortunate that you had such a bad experience, but it sounds like you might have had unhelpful expectations.

okamiueru··on Steam now allows you to copy games over a local network to another PC
The only way steam is not itself a DRM is if copying installed steam files is a facsimile of everything the game needs and expects. I do not think that all "DRM-free" games in steam are excluded from making some kind of necessary system changes as part of its install process. Be that changes to registry, or the likes.

In other words, if the install process is necessary, then steam itself acts as a DRM, even for otherwise DRM free games, as you cannot easily copy the install files. Or, at least, not to my knowledge at least.

okamiueru··on Replacing my MacBook Air M1 with a ThinkPad T480
Indeed. I was being facetious
okamiueru··on Replacing my MacBook Air M1 with a ThinkPad T480
Well, you can still replace it. You just have to replace the parts attached to it as well.
okamiueru··on AMD ROCm: A Wasted Opportunity
NVIDIA did absolutely not "invent AI on GPU", that's a ridiculous statement. When programmable shaders became commonplace, shaders were used to do general computation. That was the birth of GPGPU. NVIDIA jumped on this and developed a lot of very good tooling around that. known as CUDA. Then they invested a lot to make that tooling standard in research departments.

Once GPGPU got more commonplace, researchers also doing AI, finding suitable GPGPU tasks, used the more user friendly and advanced tooling, which was CUDA.

So, "NVIDIA inventing AI on GPU" suggests you do not know much about the history of AI work on GPUs. But, feel free to correct me.

okamiueru··on AMD ROCm: A Wasted Opportunity
One player playing dirty does not imply the rest are saints?
okamiueru··on Steam now allows you to copy games over a local network to another PC
Hm, that is true. Good point. I suppose this is just a nice thing then :). Maybe OP wasn't aware that you could do this without steam complaining.
okamiueru··on Steam now allows you to copy games over a local network to another PC
I'm not OP. but, yes?

Steam is DRM. Before DRM, this process was solved very easily by copying over files.

What this adds is convenience. Which, I suppose is OK. But, in many ways, "buying games" used to come with some flexibility that we gave up for convenience.

I don't think OP suggest what valve is doing is a bad move. Just that, nostalgically, it used to be quite good. But, nothing stops us from buying games on GoG instead, and just copying over install files the "good old way" either.

okamiueru··on AMD ROCm: A Wasted Opportunity
I stopped believing in the well-intentions of NVIDIA a long time ago. Mind you, I didn't stop buying their products. But, they repeat the same shitty stuff all the time. I get why they do it, I get why it works, it's just annoying that people defend it as if it is altruistically motivated (not accusing you of this in particular, but in general).

And, as I said, AMD didn't, and still doesn't do a great job in the compute department. And, NVIDIA spent a lot of money developing good solutions with CUDA, their proprietary technology, cannot be anything but a good thing, right?

Invest money to "help" universities. Lock core software to your proprietary solutions. Jack up prices.

If they only did it in this instance, I'd perhaps give them the benefit of the doubt. But, off the top of my head:

- cuda - phys-x - gsync - Gameworks in general - rtx - dlss

There is really nothing uniquely special about any of these technologies, other than being (mostly) software solutions tied to NVIDIa hardware, and being pushed heavily onto both developers and researchers.

It's the same playbook as "give MatLab/<Any AutoDesk Product> for free to students". These good deeds are not altruistic, they are investments in market capture.

okamiueru··on AMD ROCm: A Wasted Opportunity
What on earth is your point? Let me make one thing clear, I could not care one bit about this team based mentality. Companies can be bad at each their thing.

NVIDIA delayed driver support for OpenCL deliberately, because they wanted the only viable alternative for their users to be CUDA. Pushing ML universities to invest resources into that.

Your point about AMD nok making something out of OpenCL isn't particularly fair... Maybe what you mean is that they should sponsor their own HPC labs at various universities? Is that "making something out of it"?

okamiueru··on AMD ROCm: A Wasted Opportunity
I'm not sure I agree with this. In my view the good alternative would have been OpenCL based machine learning libraries, no?

Nvidia deliberately undermined that at every turn, and pushed a proprietary solution, hard. Almost all gpgpu based machine learning used it, and, what is AMD left with? HIP, the "CUDA wrapper to make it work on ROCm".

What's the alternative here? Say that Nvidia shouldn't do anticompetitive things? That's been an exceedingly successful market strategy for them for quite some time.

okamiueru··on Android launches yet another way to spy on users with “Privacy Sandbox” beta
There are plenty of projects. They aren't main stream because people are more than willing to sell their privacy for convenience.

One such example is CalyxOS. Using it right now. It comes with both F-Droid and Aurora Store. The latter let's you download anonymously from the playstore.

okamiueru··on United States tells citizens: Leave Russia immediately
Do I understand it correctly, that the argument is that "it's a defensive war", because Putin in effect "called dibs, so it's ours, and we are defending it"?

So, more on how it is sold to the Russian people, rather, than there being anything technically correct about it, right? Because if it's the latter, then I suppose the closes would be "internationally accepted". And, none of the currently occupied regions, including Crimea, is recognized as such.

okamiueru··on Don’t watch ‘Star Trek: Picard’ season three, it’ll only encourage them
Maybe just avoid directors/writers such as JJ. He seems to have a knack for making absolute garbage movies of beloved established worlds, that fans and critics absolutely hate, but sell well enough that it keeps happening.
okamiueru··on ChatGPT lied to me and then tried to deny it
I see. I suppose what I mean is that it doesn't have a conceptual model of the what it knows and doesn't know. It doesn't try to improve upon that conceptual model because it knows that it needs to, it just maps sentences that typically require a follow up question, with a follow up question.
okamiueru··on ChatGPT lied to me and then tried to deny it
> I'll admit that I haven't even figured out what it means for anything to "know" something.

I think that a core part of what it means to "know" something, is also an understanding of "not knowing". If you provide ChatGPT with insufficient data, it doesn't ask you to clarify anything to fill in the dots or try to eliminate a possible misunderstanding. It just, as you nicely put it, completes the sentence as best it can.

Ask a curious human a logical question or puzzle, and they'll often reply with a bunch of follow ups to fix what they assume to be a lack of knowing.

okamiueru··on Stable Attribution
So, this is just a reverse image search, or does do anything more clever, like finding stronger matches in the latent space? For example the "style" could match, but a composition is completely different, etc.

So, even if it fails at correctly attributing source data. I'm wondering if it doesn't also fail at the concept of attribution. So far it just shows you some pictures with no attribution, and saying that whoever made those, made that.

Am I missing something? Why doesn't it know who the "human made sources" were made by?

okamiueru··on I use C when I believe in memory safety
Maybe it's controversial if I understood what the hell it means. Freedom? Destroy all semblance of individual thought? Authoritarian dystopia? ...

Am I dreaming?

The ability to write your own compiler for a language... that's related to the above?

okamiueru··on Cosmic DE update: System76's new Linux desktop environment
I was about to reply to you before reading your last sentence. I'd say that is very much the case. In fact, I tried pop! out of curiosity, and found that I liked it less than arch + gnome. At least overall, there was a little mix of pros and cons.
okamiueru··on I lost $209k of my own money trying to start a business
There are so many obvious pitfalls, and the lessons learned are not particularly good. It should have been summed up as:

> Discuss the core business product and idea with a technical person mostly capable of understanding the details it entails. Understand the market, end product you want to envision, and evaluate if there is a fit for it.

But then again, pick any "startups for dummies" book, and it'll explain exactly that.

A technical person should be able to give pointers on stuff you might be missing, and then knowing if there is a market for it... If you don't know, then, what's the point?

For example, "lesson #1" should be met with "<<cybercecurity isn't important for a digital market place>>... What do you mean? Of course it is. Also... what do you mean? Who's the middle man here?".

"Lesson #3": Build an mvp

"Lesson #4": If developing your MVP is 90%-95% development costs, you better know how to do this, or have deep enough pockets to not care.

"Lesson #5". What are you talking about?

"Lesson #6": See lesson 3.

"Lesson #7": See lesson 3, also, talk to potential customers, heck, even before mvp.

"Lesson #8": See lesson 7, i.e. lesson 3.

"Lesson #9": I would argue a founder's job is to establish the business and product to a point where one can evaluate the extent it fits a market that was assumed to exist, then tested to exist, then proved to exist. None of this is necessarily related to sales, or cannot be handled by dedicated sales people.

In any case, kudos for writing a post mortem on this. Most would be too embarrassed by it.

okamiueru··on U.S. accuses Google of abusing monopoly in ad technology
I do not disagree at all with that. In fact, I also think I said, or implied at the least, that it was used incorrectly. However, for the sake of discussing the articles, every time this comes up, it would be more productive if people still understood that it isn't the monopoly part that is important, but the antitrust. Similar to what you were saying.
okamiueru··on U.S. accuses Google of abusing monopoly in ad technology
Aren't we arguing the same point? Or am I missing something?
okamiueru··on Show HN: I “wrote” a kid's book with ChatGPT and Midjourney
> stable diffusion

A bit tongue in cheek. But, that would be like saying a pencil knows the difference between them.

Which model in particular? 1.5, 2.1?

okamiueru··on U.S. accuses Google of abusing monopoly in ad technology
I'm just trying to help out here. I don't disagree with you, but it gets tiring that every single time some market position is abused, and the word "monopoly" gets used, there is at least one pedantic getting hung up on the "mono" part.

Android/iOS market share? Duopoly really. Call it a monopoly? "How is it a monopoly when..."

What they mean. What is always meant, is, you have a market position so significant, that you can use to get an unfair advantage on competition. That's what this is about, that is what all of these usually are about.

But, it gets sidetracked by misuse of words that should be understood from context.

Antitrust, isn't exclusively about monopolies abusing their market position. It doesn't care that much about whether it is one actor abusing it's position, or if it's two... Or three.

okamiueru··on U.S. accuses Google of abusing monopoly in ad technology
In every article about abusive "monopolies", just read it as "abusing market position".
okamiueru··on AI is in danger of being swallowed up by copyright law
I should mention that Stability.AI, Hugging Face and Stable Diffusion are tightly connected. It's all a bit muddy, and I didn't help by mixing them up. However, what I think is that Stability.AI is the company, "Hugging Face" is the community based website for sharing models and the likes, and "Stable Diffusion" is the implementation of the diffusion model developed in a university in Munich.

It's not really fair to take it all out on Stability.AI, as at the very least, they are sharing the technology and models with everyone (for the time being). And that open up some incredible possibilities.

It's much worse what DALL-E, Midjourney and others do, which is much the same, while they let people play with it, but it's all theirs, and they can take it away at any moment.

okamiueru··on AI is in danger of being swallowed up by copyright law
No, no, I agree about the insane lawsuits for similar sounding music. The popular music is mostly regurgitated stuff anyways. But the equivalent here would be "Penny Lane as if composed by Michael Jackson and sung by Taylor Swift". My example is bad, because I stopped following popular music a decade or two ago. But replace the deceased artists with living ones.

My point probably should be made clearer. You know how you can say "in the art style of X"? Well, it doesn't matter if Huggingface made that possible. You can, relatively easily, train that concept with a collection of paintings by X. Then you can go ahead an make art in their style.

Now, from a technology point of view, that is nothing short of amazing. I still cannot get my head around how absolutely ridiculously powerful it is. And, even the people who play with this, don't seem to fully grasp it either. The world will change in the next 4 years.

What I'm wondering, is, what should we, as a society, find acceptable? Why should someone be able to train "in the style of X" where X is a set of EVERYTHING, and make money of it, without the say of X, or even them getting anything for it? Have you checked the evaluation of Huggingface? It's in the order of 1-10 billion USD.

There is definitely the argument of anti-copyright. I get that part too. But there is definitely someone who will end up with the bigger stick, and it isn't the people holding the paint brushes who made it possible. That seems just a little bit unfair, and perhaps unwise.

Also, I'll end with a point that no one so far has brought up, even though I've followed the discussion both for and against AI. Which is "whitewashing" art. Now, the example I'm going to show isn't very good, but I also spent 5 minutes on this. Where would you draw the line on when Alexander Wild no longer has copyright over his photography?

https://imgur.com/a/cm6IrzG

okamiueru··on The contagious visual blandness of Netflix
There are a lot of reasons to not like an adaptation. I've watched Sandman, and I completely disagree with you. They did a great job. Even to the extent of doing certain scenes I didn't enjoy, but still thoroughly liked and respected. It was a breath of fresh air in an otherwise sea of "greatest common denominator appeal". Avatar, God of War, they all suffer from this.
← PreviousPage 8 of 28Next →