2,285 karma · joined December 10, 2011
> Dance Diffusion is also built on datasets composed entirely of copyright-free and voluntarily provided music and audio samples. Because diffusion models are prone to memorization and overfitting, releasing a model trained on copyrighted data could potentially result in legal issues. In honoring the intellectual property of artists while also complying to the best of their ability with the often strict copyright standards of the music industry, keeping any kind of copyrighted material out of training data was a must.
Reads very different to any statement made by Hugginface or the LION database regarding stable diffusion, which do not mention the concept of an artist or artist work a single time.
And Hugginface are the only ones open about it. Midjourney and Dall-E and Imagen most assuredly doing the same for their black boxes.
That said...
I get it. Huggingface are working on a diffusion based model for music. And guess what? It's extremely important for them to only use opt-in or commissioned training data. Why? Because the music industry, unlike artists on artstation and the likes, have a lot of lawyers and can protect their copyrighted works.
Why should it really be any different for visual arts? I honestly don't see why. That isn't to say I'm not going to keep on using stable diffusion, nor do I think there is anything that can be done to stop it. But, I do think artists should be compensated, and such models should not be based on the work of anyone, unless they want it to be.
But, it's also just a tool. That has to be used for the right reasons and the right circumstances.
One unexpected use for them is to implement the "right way" to do something as a unit test. Instead of having to remind them of what we agreed on, making a test is a great investment, and not the typical use case for tests.
COBRA is specific to the US? Related to extend some sort of private health care coverage they had under the employer?
And H1B are for non-Americans who were allowed to stay on the condition of having an employer?
Could you clarify what the conditions are for california? How many months of salary is covered? How immediate is the effect of termination in terms of "pack your bags". Etc
I'm saying that a decision should be made by weighing pros/cons by someone qualified to make them. If that's HN-y, then that sounds great.
It doesn't sound like how you described this process is anything short of incompetence or "phoning it in". Which, I'm sure is a valid explanation for how they ended up deciding it. But, I'm using the word "dumb" in not a literal sense. It covers both incompetence and laziness.
Also, if you are deciding on a font to be used widely. One of the key aspects is exactly the license. It describes the conditions for its use. If your job is to evaluate which fonts to use, and you don't consider the conditions for its use, then yes, you are incompetent in that decision. And its not "intricate", its the bare minimum expected.
It's not like this is a hard problem to solve more than adequately with open and more accessible alternatives.
I don't think there is a way to avoid this?
I found ChatGPT to be very useful in two areas:
1. where the problems are simple, and the question requires rudimentary knowledge, but of something very domain specific. Where, I would be 100% able to find a better answer myself by reading up on it, but I can get there 90% of the way, and figure out the 10% that is missing or wrong out of context.
If you don't have the ability to fix or identify that last 10%, you might suffer more for it. You'll get there more quickly, but you end up at slightly the wrong place.
2. When the questions are creative in nature. Suggest an imaginary setting, character, describe properties associated with, etc.
I don't see why this has to be the case. If unlikely conditions are correct for something unlikely to occur, then it's not longer unlikely to occur multiple times.
E.g. if you play around with chemical reactions and you hit the right conditions, it usually happens all over the place, and not just one molecule combining.
So here is my summary:
- The good: When you need inspiration, topics, creativity, suggestions. Exactly the things traditionally thought AI would be bad at. Turns out churning and mix-matching concepts is very close to human creativity.
- The bad: Anything, and I mean anything, that requires factual knowledge or accuracy, if the facts are important, then ChatGPT is terrible.
- The ugly: This is the same as the bad, but it's when used by people who do not understand that a confident wrong answer is worse than no answer at all. The world is already filled with vocal people on the wrong end of the Dunning-Kruger scale.
I asked it to explain simple multiplication (for example: "Explain 419 * 213", and it'll give you a page long answer and detailed step by step, with the conclusion "So, the product of 419 * 213 is equal to 8857.")
I asked it for the length of the titanic, and it happily adds how it sunk after hitting a polar bear.
Now, I've also asked it to group categories and materials associated with certain themes and topics. And those have been brilliant. So, it has it's use cases. But, producing useful final output based on any facts? Nah, haven't seen it.
A case of "brilliant coder wants to make game but don't know art well, so they create new complicated programming tasks instead", but, the brilliant coder part is still pretty relevant.
Reddit on the other hand went to being completely unusable. So much so, that I don't understand who and what motivates it to be the way it is. It's having on due to "old.reddit", but that too is a pain to use on mobile.
AMD is behind ROCm, and, development is active. So, maybe you can clarify what you mean by "abandoned"? I'm not feeling it.
However, the thought you had, and similar ones, are very much the intentional side-effect of the rules. The only way to win the game, as stated, is forcing your opponent to make the top engine move. Or, of course, correctly claim that your opponent made such a move (even though it wasn't forced). Or, having your opponent make the incorrect claim about your move.
So, it isn't necessarily "playing good chess". Though, I must say, I'm not qualified to have any good idea of what it would mean to be good at this game. It definitely helps to be good at chess, and have a good command of what are the correct engine moves. Especially since you lose if you incorrectly claim a position and opponent move was "the top engine line".
I suppose most would reduce this to leaving the opponent to only one legal move. In which case, the problem is is trivial. But, after move 2? You need to know most opening lines, and probably play intentionally bad in many situations.
Hm, this is cooler the more I think about it.
Imagine intentionally setting up material sacrifice with a resulting choice of multiple moves for the opponent to capitalize. If you can correctly evaluate the best computer move, you have a strong advantage. If it is not obvious, then the opponent might not dare to gamble the challenge.
Has Hikaru tried this in one of his streams? I'm certain he would have a blast.
The only thing about this that doesn't "spark joy" are the ambiguous practical implementations.
- Which engine? This matters a lot.
- How do you define the computational cut-off? CPU-minutes? Move depth? Etc. Not necessarily a simple problem.
- The rule "When multiple moves have the top score, they are all top moves". Needs a specific score evaluation delta for grouping "top moves".
All of these could rather simply be resolved if it isn't very important... might even add some uncertainty to it, for fun. Like, say: 1. Stockfish 15. 2. Allow the computer whatever resources it has available, 1 minute, and play some drum roll sample. 3. Pawn-evlauation of 0.05.
The user perception of OS is mostly third party software availability and driver support. I've used all three, and as far as "operating system" comes, Linux is the only thing that feels good to use.
But, I suppose the analogy isn't entirely inaccurate either. MJ is entirely owned by someone else, it can be removed at any time, including anyone's availability. While SD is flexible, allows a stable foundation to be built on, and you can extend it any way you want...
I couldn't have built a gRPC based wrapper around MJ, set up a bot that listens to prompts sent through telegram, and post back images. Hm.. or I suppose one could do the same with with MJ API... so, bad example :D